Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion by Rekha Borana, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal challenges an award dated 06.09.2007 of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Jaitaran, District Pali. The Tribunal originally awarded Rs. 3,06,500/- to the claimants (parents, wife and five minor children of the deceased) but deducted 30% of the awarded amount on account of contributory negligence attributed to the deceased, resulting in an award of Rs. 2,14,500/-. The present proceedings concern the contention that the Tribunal's finding of contributory negligence is contrary to the record and should be set aside, and also challenges aspects of the Tribunal's assessment of quantum (including denial of future prospects and loss of consortium). Respondent No.1 (driver) and Respondent No.2 (owner of the jeep) did not appear despite service. The insurer (respondent) opposed the appeal, relying on the site plan and other contentions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the finding of contributory negligence against the deceased (leading to 30% deduction) can be sustained on the basis of the site plan and the record.
  2. Whether the absence of a valid driving licence of the deceased can, by itself, be a ground to hold the deceased contributorily negligent.
  3. Whether the learned Tribunal erred in denying compensation for future prospects and loss of consortium.
  4. What is the correct computation of compensation (income, future prospects, multiplier, heads of damage) in the present case following applicable precedent.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The learned Tribunal's finding of contributory negligence is contrary to the record and must be set aside.
  • No respondent (owner/insurer) produced evidence to prove contributory negligence of the motorcyclist; the insurer did not lead any evidence on this aspect.
  • The Tribunal's conclusion rests solely (or primarily) on the site plan, which cannot be treated as substantive evidence to establish contributory negligence.
  • The deceased's lack of a valid driving licence cannot be the sole ground to find contributory negligence.
  • The Tribunal wrongly denied future prospects and compensation for loss of consortium; reliance placed on Pranay Sethi and Rajwati @ Rajjo for correct principles on future prospects and related heads.
  • Relied on precedents: Mangla Ram v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.; New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Somwati; Sushila v. Mohan Singh; United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sugni Devi; Shanti Lal v. Ramesh Chandra; and decisions concerning future prospects (Pranay Sethi, Rajwati @ Rajjo).

Respondent-Insurance Company's Arguments

  • The Tribunal's findings are in conformity with the site plan and other material on record; the site plan shows facts consistent with contributory negligence by the motorcyclist.
  • The jeep driver held licence to drive a light motor vehicle only and was not entitled to drive a commercial vehicle; this amounted to a breach of insurance policy conditions, rendering insurer not liable.
  • Where a collision occurs in the middle of the road, both drivers may be equally responsible; reliance placed on prior judgments to that effect.
  • The site plan was a document prepared by police in discharge of official duty and is admissible in evidence without formal proof; reliance placed on United India Insurance Co. v. Hamu Ram and other authorities.
  • Relied on precedents including National Insurance Company v. Kusum Rai, Oriental Insurance Co. v. Mohan Kanwar and related decisions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mangla Ram v. Oriental Insurance Company [2018 ACJ 1300] The finding of contributory negligence cannot be based solely on the site map; absence of evidence about negligent driving cannot be assumed; lack of a valid driving licence is of no significance to establish contributory negligence. The court relied on this authority extensively and quoted its reasoning to hold that contributory negligence could not be sustained merely on site map evidence and that absence of licence was not determinative. This authority supported setting aside the 30% deduction.
The New India Assurance Company Limited v. Somwati [(2020) 9 SCC 644] Referenced as an authority relevant to computation/recomputation of awards (cited by parties). The court directed recomputation of the award in light of judgments of Somwati and Pranay Sethi (the opinion calls for recomputation "in light of judgments of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the cases of Somwati and Pranay Sethi").
Sushila v. Mohan Singh [2015 (2) R.A.R. 564 (Raj.)] Holds that the site plan cannot be treated as substantive evidence for concluding contributory negligence in motor accident claims. The court cited this state-court authority to reinforce that the site plan alone is not sufficient to fix contributory negligence and used it to support overturning the Tribunal's finding.
United India Insurance Company Ltd. v. Smt. Sugni Devi [2013 R.A.R. 21 (Raj.)] Also stands for the principle that a site plan is not a substantive piece of evidence for concluding contributory negligence. The court cited this authority in support of the proposition that the Tribunal erred in relying on the site plan to attribute contributory negligence to the deceased.
Shanti Lal v. Ramesh Chandra [2019 (4) DNJ (Raj.) 1597] Establishes that mere lack of a valid driving licence of a rider is not a ground to saddle the rider with contributory negligence or liability. The court relied on this decision (along with Mangla Ram) to hold that the deceased's lack of licence was of no significance to sustain contributory negligence.
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi [2017 ACJ 2700 (SC)] Constitution Bench standard for future prospects: addition of 40% of established income where deceased was below 40 years; 25% where deceased was between 40 and 50 years. The court applied the Pranay Sethi standard (40% addition) for computing future prospects for a 30-year-old deceased and held that denial of future prospects by the Tribunal was erroneous.
Rajwati @ Rajjo v. United India Insurance Company Ltd. [2022 Supreme (SC) 1231] Cited by appellant in relation to quantum/future prospects (recent apex-court pronouncement referenced by counsel). The court noted reliance upon this authority by the appellants; the court's recomputation referenced applicable apex-court precedents including this decision as part of quantum principles (the opinion groups it with other apex decisions relied upon by counsel).
National Insurance Company v. Kusum Rai [(2006) 4 SCC 250 : AIR 2006 SC 3440] Relied upon by insurer to support the proposition that a breach of policy conditions (driver not entitled to drive the vehicle) can relieve insurer of liability. The respondent-insurer invoked this authority to contend breach of insurance conditions; the court recorded the reliance but examined contributory negligence and evidence on record in its analysis. The eventual order directed respondents to pay an enhanced amount (see Holding) — the opinion records the insurer's contention and the precedent relied upon.
Oriental Insurance Co. v. Mohan Kanwar (S.B. Civil Misc. Appeal Nos. 702 & 714 of 1998 of this Court, decided 28.03.2006) Authority cited in support of the proposition that when collision occurs in the middle of the road both drivers may be equally responsible. The insurer relied on this decision; the court, after analyzing the site report, concluded that the site report did not support equal responsibility in this case.
Shivaji Waman Eodase v. Chandrapati Ishwarsingh Dahiya (F.A. Nos. 246 to 251 of 1987, Bombay High Court, decided 20.04.2006) Also cited for the principle that collisions in the middle of the road may render both drivers equally responsible. The insurer relied on this authority; the court's factual analysis of the site report led it to reject the Tribunal's finding of equal or contributory negligence on the part of the deceased.
United India Insurance Co. v. Hamu Ram (2004 RAR 308, decided 21.03.2003) Relied upon to support the admissibility of site plans prepared by police in discharge of official duty (argument that such documents are admissible without formal proof). The insurer relied on this case to validate the Tribunal's reliance on the site plan. The court nonetheless examined the site report's contents and concluded that the site report supported the appellants' contention rather than the Tribunal's finding of contributory negligence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reviewed the Tribunal's factual findings, the site report (Exhibit-4), the testimony on record, and the precedents cited by the parties. The analysis proceeded in the following steps:

  1. Examination of Tribunal's finding: The Tribunal had found that the collision occurred at the center of the road on a curve, rendering the vehicles not visible to each other, and held that where vehicles collide head-on, fault cannot be attributed to a single driver; it also noted the deceased lacked a driving licence and concluded contributory negligence, reducing the award by 30%.
  2. Close reading of the site report: The court analyzed the site report and found that the mapped positions (marks A, B, C, X and broken glass placements) indicate the jeep was ultimately on the extreme right (mark 'C') after hitting the motorcycle at mark 'A', whereas the motorcycle was found at mark 'B' on the extreme right and the deceased's body at mark 'X' between A and B. The court interpreted the site report to mean that the jeep moved to the wrong side and struck the motorcycle which had been in the correct lane. On this factual reading, the site report undermined — rather than supported — the Tribunal's attribution of contributory negligence to the deceased.
  3. Legal principle on the weight of site plans: The court reiterated settled principles (citing Sushila, Sugni Devi and Mangla Ram) that a site plan alone is not a substantive piece of evidence sufficient to conclude contributory negligence; physical position of vehicles after collision cannot be presumptively taken as the position in which the vehicle was being driven at the time of collision.
  4. Lack of evidential foundation by respondents: The court noted that the insurer and other respondents did not lead evidence to prove contributory negligence of the deceased. Even during cross-examination of claimant witnesses, the insurer did not suggest the deceased was negligent; no substantive proof was produced to support the defense plea of contributory negligence.
  5. Effect of lack of driving licence: The court applied the principle in Mangla Ram and Shanti Lal that absence of a valid driving licence, by itself, is not sufficient to establish contributory negligence and cannot be assumed to prove negligent driving.
  6. Conclusion on contributory negligence: Combining the factual reading of the site report, the absence of contrary evidence by the respondents, and authoritative precedent, the court concluded that the Tribunal's finding that the deceased was contributorily negligent (and the consequent 30% deduction) could not be affirmed and set that part of the award aside.
  7. Future prospects and quantum: The Tribunal had refused future prospects, reasoning that the witness made false statements and no evidence on future prospects was led. The court rejected that approach: following Pranay Sethi (Constitution Bench), future prospects is an essential component in computing the income of a deceased and is not dependent on separate evidence being led for that head. The court applied the Pranay Sethi benchmark of 40% addition to established income for a deceased below 40 years of age.
  8. Income and recomputation: The Tribunal's finding of monthly income Rs. 1,800/- (based on deposition of PW2 that the deceased earned Rs. 50-60 per day as construction labour) was affirmed. The court computed future prospects (40% of Rs. 1,800 = Rs. 720), arrived at a monthly total after dependents' deduction (resulting in annual income of Rs. 24,192), applied multiplier 17 for age 30, and aggregated heads of damage (loss of dependency, loss of estate, spousal and parental consortium, funeral expenses) to reach a recomputed total. The court set aside the Tribunal's deduction and recomputed the award accordingly.
  9. Resulting directions: The court ordered enhancement of the award and fixed interest and timeline for payment (see Holding).

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is partly allowed. The court set aside the Tribunal's finding of contributory negligence against the deceased (and the consequent 30% deduction) and directed recomputation of the award. After recomputation, the court directed that the respondents pay an enhanced amount of Rs. 5,47,000/- to the appellants (in addition to the award already paid by the learned Tribunal), within two months. The enhanced amount shall carry interest @ 6% per annum from the date of filing of the claim petition. The appeal is disposed of in these terms; the stay petition is also disposed of and the record of the Tribunal is to be sent back forthwith.

Implications for the parties:

  • The Tribunal's attribution of 30% contributory negligence to the deceased has been set aside; the appellants obtain a substantially enhanced monetary award (enhancement quantified in the order).
  • The respondents (including the insurer) are directed to pay Rs. 5,47,000/- within two months, with interest at 6% per annum from the date of filing of the claim petition.
  • The Tribunal's denial of future prospects and some heads of consortium was found to be legally unsound; the award was recomputed applying the Pranay Sethi standard for future prospects.

Broader precedent: The court applied and relied upon existing case law (including apex-court decisions) to reach its conclusions. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent beyond applying and reconciling the cited authorities to the facts of this case.

This summary is strictly confined to and derived from the contents of the provided judicial opinion. No additional facts or inferences beyond the text of the opinion have been introduced.

    Suresh Devi And Others v. Pukhraj And Others

    Rekha Borana, J.:— The present appeal has been filed against the award dated 06.09.2007 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Jaitaran, District Pali (hereinafter referred to as ‘the learned Tribunal’) whereby although an award of Rs. 3,06,500/- has been passed in favour of the claimants but holding the contributory negligence of the deceased, 30% of the awarded amount has been directed to be deducted qua the contributory negligence. Therefore, after deduction as aforementioned, a claim of Rs. 2,14,500/- has been awarded in favour of the claimants who are the parents, wife and the five minor children of the deceased.

    2. Learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the finding of the learned Tribunal regarding the contributory negligence of the deceased is totally contrary to the record and therefore, liable to be set aside. He submitted that it was not even the case of the respondent owner or the insurer of the vehicle that the motorcyclist was negligent and the accident occurred due to his contributory negligence. No evidence qua the said fact was led by any of the respondents and therefore, the finding as arrived by the learned Tribunal cannot be upheld. In support of his contention, learned counsel relied upon the judgment passed by Hon'ble Apex Court in the cases of Mangla Ram v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. [2018 ACJ 1300] and The New India Assurance Company Limited v. Somwati [(2020) 9 SCC 644].

    3. Learned counsel further submitted that the finding of the learned Tribunal is based solely on the site plan which cannot be treated to be a substantive piece of evidence. He submitted that even if the same is taken into consideration, the conclusion as arrived by the learned Tribunal proves to be totally contrary even to the site plan. In support of his contention, learned counsel relied upon the judgments passed by this Court in Sushila v. Mohan Singh [2015 (2) R.A.R. 564 (Raj.)] and United India Insurance Company Ltd. v. Smt. Sugni Devi [2013 R.A.R. 21 (Raj.)].

    4. Learned counsel for the appellants further submitted that the learned Tribunal has held the deceased to be guilty of contributory negligence, also because of the fact that he did not have a valid driving licence. He submitted that this cannot be a ground for holding a driver to be negligent. In support of his contention, learned counsel relied upon the judgment passed by this Court in the case of Shanti Lal v. Ramesh Chandra [2019 (4) DNJ (Raj.) 1597].

    5. Arguing upon the quantum of compensation, learned counsel submitted that the future prospects as well as the compensation qua the loss of consortium have wrongly not been granted by the learned Tribunal to the claimants. In support, he relied upon the latest pronouncements of the Hon'ble Apex Court in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi [2017 ACJ 2700 (SC)] and Rajwati @ Rajjo v. United India Insurance Company Ltd. [2022 Supreme(SC) 1231].

    6. Despite service, none has put in appearance on behalf of respondent No. 1 Driver as well as respondent No. 2-Owner of the Jeep involved in the accident.

    7. Learned counsel for the respondent-Insurance company submitted that the findings as arrived by the learned Tribunal are totally in conformity with the site plan as well as the material which was available on record. Learned counsel submitted that a bare perusal of the site plan makes it clear that the deceased-motorcyclist was equally responsible for the accident as he drove in a negligent manner. Learned counsel submitted that the driver of the vehicle in question i.e. Jeep was possessing a license to drive light motor vehicle only and was not entitled to drive a commercial vehicle. Therefore, there was a specific breach of condition of the insurance policy and the insurer was therefore, not liable to pay the compensation. In support of his contention learned counsel relied upon the Hon'ble Supreme Court judgment passed in the case of National Insurance Company v. Kusum Rai ((2006) 4 SCC 250 : AIR 2006 SC 3440). In support of his contention that where a collision of two vehicles take place in the middle of the road, both the drivers would be equally responsible, learned counsel relied upon the judgments passed in the cases of Oriental Insurance Co. v. Mohan Kanwar; S.B. Civil Misc. Appeal Nos. 702 and 714 of 1998 of this Court decided on 28.03.2006 and Shivaji Waman Eodase v. Chandrapati Ishwarsingh Dahiya F.A. Nos. 246 to 251 of 1987 of the Bombay High Court decided on 20.04.2006.

    8. So far as the reliance of the learned Tribunal upon the site plan is concerned, learned counsel submitted that the same was validly relied upon by the Tribunal as the site plan was a document prepared by the police officer while discharging his official duty and the same is admissible in evidence without there being a formal proof. In support of his contention learned counsel relied upon the judgment passed in the case of United India Insurance Co. v. Hamu Ram, 2004 RAR 308, decided on (21.03.2003).

    9. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material available on record.

    10. The learned Tribunal has reached to a finding that the accident between the two vehicles i.e. the motor cycle and the jeep occurred in the center of the road and that too at a place where there was a curve in the road. Because of the curve, the vehicles were not visible to each other and therefore, they collided. Learned Tribunal has found that where the vehicles collide head on, it cannot be because of negligence of any one of the driver. Further, the deceased who was driving the motor cycle did not even have a valid driving licence. It was therefore, concluded that the accident occurred due to negligence of both the vehicles and hence the contributory negligence of the deceased was held to be proved on record. The said conclusion of the learned Tribunal is based on the site report Exhibit-4.

    11. In the opinion of this Court, the site report rather proves to the contrary. According to the site report, the jeep was placed at mark ‘C’ after hitting the motor cycle at mark ‘A’. A bare perusal makes it clear that mark ‘C’ is on the right side of the road and admittedly, the jeep was supposed to be driven on the left side of the road. Meaning thereby, the jeep which was supposed to be on the left side, moved towards the right, hit the motor cycle towards the center of the road and because of the high speed, after hitting, reached to the extreme corner of the road towards right and halted there. As per the site report, the motor cycle is shown to be lying at mark ‘B’ which is also on the extreme right of the road. The pieces of broken glass have also been shown to be between mark ‘A’ to ‘B’. The body of the deceased has been shown to be placed at mark ‘X’ which is somewhere between mark ‘A’ to ‘B’. The only conclusion which can be drawn from the site report is that the jeep came to the wrong side and hit the motor cycle. The motor cycle clearly was in the correct lane and on the correct side and therefore, by any stretch of imagination, it cannot be concluded that the motor cycle driver i.e. the deceased was also negligent. The finding of the learned Tribunal is therefore, contrary to the site report even on facts and therefore, cannot be affirmed.

    12. Further, as held in the cases of Sushila v. Mohan Singh, 2015 (2) RAR 564 (Raj.) and United India Insurance v. Sugni Devi, 2013 RAR 21 (Raj.), in the matter of motor accident claims, the site plan cannot be held to be substantive piece of evidence for conclusion of contributory negligence.

    13. Further, a perusal of the evidence as led by the parties makes it clear that no evidence regarding any contributory negligence of the deceased was led by the Insurance Company. Even while cross-examining the claimant witnesses, no suggestion whatsoever, to suggest that the deceased was also negligent has been put to them by the Insurance Company. Just a cursory plea in the reply regarding the negligence of the deceased has been taken but no evidence to prove the said averment has been led by the Insurance Company. Therefore, the finding of the learned Tribunal cannot be affirmed even on the count that there was no evidence available on record to suggest that the deceased was also negligent.

    14. In Mangla Ram v. Oriental Insurance Company, 2018 ACJ 1300, while dealing with a similar issue-whether the finding qua the contributory negligence can be reached only on the basis of the site map, the Hon'ble Apex Court specifically held as under:

    “23. Be that as it may, the next question is whether the Tribunal was justified in concluding that the Appellant was also negligent and had contributed equally, which finding rests only on the site map (Exh. 2) indicating the spot where the motorcycle was lying after the accident? We find substance in the criticism of the Appellant that the spot where the motor vehicle was found lying after the accident cannot be the basis to assume that it was driven in or around that spot at the relevant time. It can be safely inferred that after the accident of this nature in which the Appellant suffered severe injuries necessitating amputation of his right leg above the knee level, the motorcycle would be pushed forward after the collision and being hit by a high speeding jeep. Neither the Tribunal nor the High Court has found that the spot noted in the site map, one foot wrong side on the middle of the road was the spot where the accident actually occurred. However, the finding is that as per the site map, the motorcycle was found lying at that spot. That cannot be the basis to assume that the Appellant was driving the motorcycle on the wrong side of the road at the relevant time.

    Further, the Respondents did not produce any contra evidence to indicate that the motorcycle was being driven on the wrong side of the road at the time when the offending vehicle dashed it. In this view of the matter, the finding of the Tribunal that the Appellant contributed to the occurrence of the accident by driving the motorcycle on the wrong side of the road, is manifestly wrong and cannot be sustained. The High Court has not expressed any opinion on this issue, having already answered the issue about the non-involvement of the offending vehicle in favour of Respondent Nos. 2 & 3.

    24. In other words, we are inclined to hold that there is no title of evidence about the motorcycle being driven negligently by the Appellant at the time of accident. The Respondents did not produce any such evidence. That fact, therefore, cannot be assumed. Resultantly, the argument of the Respondents that the Appellant did not possess a valid motorcycle driving licence at the time of accident, will be of no significance. Thus, we hold that there is no legal evidence to answer the issue of contributory negligence against the Appellant.”

    15. In view of above observations of the Hon'ble Apex Court also, it can be safely concluded that the factum of contributory negligence cannot be based solely on the site map in absence of any evidence being led by the respondents and further that the deceased was not having a valid driving licence at the time of accident will be of no significance. The said principle has also been reiterated in the case of Shanti Lal v. Ramesh Chandra, 2019 (4) DNJ (Raj.) 1597, wherein it has been held that merely because the rider of the motor cycle was not having a valid driving licence, the same cannot be a ground to saddle any contributory negligence or liability.

    16. In the overall analysis of the facts of the present case and the precedential law, this Court is of the specific opinion that the finding of the learned Tribunal holding the deceased also to be negligent for the accident and thereby deducting 30% of the award amount qua contributory negligence cannot be affirmed and the same is hereby set aside.

    17. So far as the quantum of compensation is concerned, the learned Tribunal has declined to grant any compensation qua future prospects on the ground that the witness has made false statements and no evidence qua future prospects has been led. In the specific opinion of this court, the consideration of the income qua future prospects is not on the basis of the evidence being led qua the said issue but is an essential corollary while computing the income of a deceased. The compensation qua future prospects is a natural consequence based on the rationale that a person who is self-employed is bound to garner his resources and raise his income for a better living. Further, computation of compensation keeping into consideration, the future prospects is a mandate and not a discretion. In National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi, 2017 ACJ 2700 (SC), the Constitution Bench while deciding on the issue of future prospects devised a fixed standard for granting future prospects and held as under:

    “Taking into consideration the cumulative factors, namely, passage of time, the changing society, escalation of price, the change in price index, the human attitude to follow a particular pattern of life, etc., an addition of 40 per cent of the established income of the deceased towards future prospects where the deceased was below 40 years and an addition of 25 per cent where the deceased was between the age of 40 and 50 years would be reasonable.”

    18. In view of the ratio as laid down in Pranay Sethi's case, denial of compensation qua future prospects by the learned Tribunal is also held to be bad and the finding qua the said issue is also set aside.

    19. So far as the computation of the income is concerned, the learned Tribunal has computed the same to be Rs. 1,800/- per month on the basis of the statements of PW2 Bhunda Ram who has deposed that the deceased was earning Rs. 50-60 per day as he was a construction labour. The said finding of the learned Tribunal cannot be interfered with being based on the evidence available on record and the same is affirmed.

    20. In view of above observations, the award requires recomputation in light of judgments of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the cases of Somwati and Pranay Sethi (supra).

    For future prospects:

    Income per month Rs. 1800 Future prospects (40% of income) Rs. 720 Total Rs. 2520 Deduction (more than 6 dependents) Rs. 504 Income per month Rs. 2016 Income per annum Rs. 24,192

    21. The age of the deceased was 30 years, therefore, a multiplier of 17 will be applied.

    (I) Compensation due to death (Loss of dependency) 24,192 × 17 Rs. 4,11,264/- (II) Loss of Estate 15,000 Rs. 15,000/- (III) Loss of spousal consortium 40,000 Rs. 40,000/- (IV) Loss of parental consortium to each of the 5 children 40,000 × 5 Rs. 2,00,000/- (V) Loss of consortium to parents 40,000 × 2 Rs. 80,000/- (VI) Funeral Expenses 15,000 Rs. 15,000/- Total Rs. 7,61,264/- Amount awarded by learned Tribunal vide award dated 06.09.2007 Rs. 2,14,550/- Enhanced amount Rs. 5,46,714/- Round off Rs. 5,47,000/-

    22. Accordingly, the appeal is partly allowed. In view of the recomputation of the award done, the respondents are directed to pay an enhanced amount of Rs. 5,47,000/- to the appellants-claimants in addition to award already awarded by the learned Tribunal within a period of two months from today. The said enhanced amount shall carry an interest @6% per annum from the date of filing of the claim petition.

    23. The appeal is disposed of in the above terms.

    24. The stay petition also stands disposed of.

    25. The record of the learned Tribunal be sent back forthwith.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Suresh Devi And Others v. Pukhraj And Others
    (Feb 21, 2023)