Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2022 KER 71542
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2022 KER 71542
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This writ petition challenges the report (Exhibit P4) issued by the Internal Complaints Committee (3rd respondent) concerning allegations of sexual harassment made by the 4th respondent against the petitioner, who is the Head of the Department of Engineering and Maintenance at the Malabar Cancer Centre (2nd respondent). The complaint (Exhibit P1) was submitted on 18.01.2019, alleging that the petitioner molested the 4th respondent on 23.10.2019, among other instances of misconduct. The petitioner filed a detailed reply (Exhibit P3) denying the specific incident on 23.10.2019 and contesting the allegations. The Internal Complaints Committee conducted an enquiry, considered evidence and testimonies, and submitted a report recommending disciplinary action against the petitioner. The petitioner seeks to quash this report and restrain any further action based on it.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Internal Complaints Committee had the authority to recommend disciplinary action against the petitioner despite the specific allegation of molestation on 23.10.2019 not being proved.
  2. Whether the findings of the Committee that the petitioner engaged in sexual harassment and created a hostile work environment justify the recommendation for disciplinary action.
  3. The extent to which the provisions of the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013 apply to the disciplinary process following the Committee's findings.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner denies the specific incident of molestation alleged to have occurred on 23.10.2019, supported by a detailed reply and evidence that he was attending a meeting at the relevant time.
  • The petitioner contends that the allegations could not be proved before the Internal Complaints Committee, and thus the Committee had no authority to issue recommendations for disciplinary action.
  • Reliance was placed on the decision in K.P. Anil Rajagopal v. State of Kerala [2017 (5) KHC 217], asserting that where no sexual harassment complaint is found proved, no disciplinary recommendation can be made.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The 2nd respondent states that the Committee found specific allegations of sexual harassment and creation of a hostile work environment against the petitioner, justifying the disciplinary recommendations.
  • The 4th respondent highlights that the complaint included allegations of continuous misconduct from 2010 onwards, not limited to the incident of 23.10.2019, and that the Committee found three out of four issues framed against the petitioner proved.
  • It is submitted that the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace Act contemplates disciplinary action subject to due process, including notice and opportunity to be heard, which will be followed.
  • The respondents contend that the petitioner’s reliance on K.P. Anil Rajagopal is misplaced because, unlike that case, here the Committee found the petitioner guilty of sexual harassment on multiple counts after enquiry.
  • The respondents also submit that merits of the case cannot be re-examined by this Court under Article 226, as there is a statutory appeal mechanism under Section 18 of the Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
K.P. Anil Rajagopal v. State of Kerala [2017 (5) KHC 217] Where no sexual harassment complaint is found proved by the Committee, no recommendation for disciplinary action can be made. The Court distinguished this precedent by noting that in the present case the Committee found multiple allegations of sexual harassment proved, thus justifying the recommendation for disciplinary action.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the complaint and the Internal Complaints Committee's report in detail. It noted that the complaint included allegations of ongoing misconduct from 2010 onwards and not merely the specific incident on 23.10.2019. The Committee framed four issues, out of which three were found against the petitioner, including findings that the petitioner engaged in sexual harassment and created a hostile work environment, impairing the 4th respondent’s ability to work peacefully. Although the specific incident of molestation on 23.10.2019 was not proved, the Committee’s overall findings were sufficient to justify disciplinary recommendations. The Court rejected the petitioner’s contention that absence of proof on one incident invalidated the entire report. It distinguished the petitioner’s reliance on the precedent in K.P. Anil Rajagopal by emphasizing the difference in factual findings. The Court also noted the statutory framework under the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013, which provides procedural safeguards and a right of appeal, limiting the scope of judicial interference at this stage.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is dismissed.

The Court upheld the validity of the Internal Complaints Committee’s report and its recommendation for disciplinary action against the petitioner. The petitioner’s challenge to the report failed as the Committee had found sufficient evidence of sexual harassment and hostile work environment. The decision leaves open the petitioner’s right to contest the merits in appropriate disciplinary or appellate proceedings. No new precedent was set by this ruling; it primarily affirms the applicability of the statutory scheme and the limited scope of judicial review in such matters.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    SUDEEP.K.T v. STATE OF KERALA

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

    PRESENT

    THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN

    WEDNESDAY, THE 23RD DAY OF NOVEMBER 2022 / 2ND AGRAHAYANA, 1944

    WP(C) NO. 2468 OF 2021

    PETITIONER:

    SUDEEP.K.T

    AGED 44 YEARS

    S/O C.V.AMBU MASTER, PRATHEEKSHA, ONAKKUNNU, KARIVELLUR P.O.KANNUR-670 521, WORKING HOD (DEPARTMENT OF

    ENGINEERING AND MAINTENANCE) (UNDER SUSPENSION) MALABAR

    CANCER CENTRE P.O.MOOZHIKKARA, THALASSERY KANNUR-670

    103.

    BY ADVS.

    K.P.PRADEEP

    SMT.T.THASMI

    RESPONDENTS:

    1 STATE OF KERALA

    REPRESENTED BY ITS HOME DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT

    SECRETARIAT, THIRUANANTHAPURAM-695 001.

    2 MALABAR CANCER CENTRE,

    P.O. MOOZHIKKARA, THALASSERY, KANNUR-670 103,

    REPRESENTED BY ITS THE DIRECTOR.

    3 INTERNAL COMPLAINT COMMITTEE,

    THE SEXUAL HARASSMENT OF WOMEN AT WORK PLACE,

    COMMITTEE, MALABAR CANCER CENTRE, THALASSERY, KANNUR-

    670 103, REPRESENTED BY ITS THE CHAIRPERSON

    4 REENA P.C

    ELECTRICAL SUPERVISOR, MALABAR CANCER CENTRE,

    P.O.MOOZHIKKARA, THALASSERY, KANNUR-670 103.

    BY ADVS.

    SHRI.P.SREEKUMAR, SC, MALABAR CANCER CENTRE

    TITUS MANI

    BINNY THOMAS

    P.A.JACOB

    BY SRI.V..K.SUNIL-SR.GP

    THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON

    23.11.2022, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

    1

    2

    JUDGMENT

    Dated this the 23rd day of November, 2022

    This writ petition is filed challenging Ext.P4 report issued by the 3rdrespondent and seeking interdiction of all further actions therein.

    2. Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and the learned Standing Counsel appearing for the respondents 2 and 3 as well as the learned counsel for the 4threspondent.

    3. It is submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the petitioner is an Engineer holding the post of Head of the Department of Engineering & Maintenance in the 2ndrespondent. It is submitted that on 18.01.2019, the 4th respondent who is the Supervisor (Electrical) in the petitioner's department submitted Exhibit P1 complaint against the petitioner. It was alleged that on 23.10.2019, the 4threspondent had been molested by the petitioner. It is submitted that the

    3

    petitioner had submitted Exhibit P3 detailed reply stating that there was no inspection of the medical gas work in the newly constructed Pediatric Block on 23.10.2019, as mentioned in the complaint and that the petitioner was attending the Administrative Committee meeting at the relevant time. In the hearing conducted by the Internal Complaints Committee, the 4threspondent had stated that the examination of the medical gas work had been completed and that she did not remember the exact date on which the alleged incident took place. It is contended by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the allegations made by the 4threspondent could not be proved before the 3rd respondent Committee. However, without such allegations being proved, a report has been submitted recommending disciplinary action against the petitioner which is under challenge in

    4

    the writ petition.

    4. The learned counsel for the petitioner would contend that since the specific allegation of sexual harassment that had been raised by the 4th respondent against the petitioner could not be proved, the Committee had no power to issue any recommendations, especially the recommendation directing the conduct of a disciplinary enquiry against the petitioner. Learned counsel would also place reliance on a decision of this Court in

    K.P. Anil Rajagopal v. State Of Kerala.

    [2017 (5) KHC 217] to contend that where no sexual harassment complaint has been found by the Committee, there can be no recommendation by the Committee to take any action against the alleged offender.

    5. A statement has been filed by the 2nd respondent, specifically stating that a reading of

    5

    Exhibit P4 would show that the allegations of sexual harassment and creating a hostile atmosphere in the workplace had been specifically found by the Committee and it was on the basis of the said finding that the recommendations had been issued by the Committee. It is submitted that only the specific allegation raised about the molestation which occurred on 23.10.2019 could not be proved in the enquiry and that in the light of the other findings, the action of the 3rdrespondent in having recommended action against the petitioner is perfectly justified. It is further contended that the provisions of the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013 contemplate disciplinary action in terms of the Rules and that such disciplinary action will be taken only after issuance of due notices to the petitioner and the

    6

    petitioner will get a further opportunity to explain his conduct and to submit objections against the proposed action.

    6. A counter affidavit has been placed on record by the 4threspondent as well. It is specifically stated that a reading of Exhibit P1 would show that the 4threspondent had raised specific allegations not only of an incident which occurred on 23.10.2019, but also of the molestation and bad behavior on the part of the petitioner from the very date of his joining the institution. It is submitted that 4 issues had been framed by the ICC as is evident from Exhibit P4 report as well and that 3 of such issues had been found against the petitioner. The ICC had found that there was behavior which amounted to sexual harassment in the workplace on the part of the petitioner and that the 4threspondent was unable

    7

    to work peacefully in the office on account of the behaviour and attitude of the petitioner. It is submitted that it was on those findings that the recommendations as per Exhibit P4 are issued and that there is absolutely nothing illegal in the said report. It is further contended that an appeal is provided against such a report under Section 18 of the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013 and that the contentions, if any, on merits cannot be considered by this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. It is further submitted that the reliance placed on the decision of this Court in K.P.Anil Rajagopal (supra) is misconceived since the instant case is one where the allegations of sexual harassment raised by the 4threspondent has been specifically found to be true by the 3rdrespondent after conduct of the

    8

    enquiry.

    7. Having considered the contentions advanced in detail, Exhibit P1 complaint submitted by the 4threspondent, refers not only to an incident which occurred on 23.10.2019, but specifically refers to the attitude and behaviour of the petitioner from 2010 onwards. The incident which occurred on 23.10.2019, is specifically referred to an as an instance of the behaviour of the petitioner towards the 4threspondent. Allegations have also been raised with regard the general attitude of the petitioner as against other employees as well. It is submitted that the petitioner had been put on notice and Exhibit P3 detailed reply had been submitted by the petitioner. The petitioner had raised specific contentions with regard to the allegations raised by the 4threspondent. The matter was considered by

    9

    the 3rdrespondent quite in extenso and all the allegations raised on both sides were considered. Evidence was taken by the Committee and the statements of the petitioner, the 4threspondent as well as other persons working in the Department and eye witnesses to the various instances of molestation alleged by the 4threspondent were recorded. Thereafter, 4 issues were raised, out of which one was with regard to the allegation of the incident which occurred on 23.10.2019. Thereafter, findings were rendered in issues raised and three of such issues were found against the petitioner. It is only with regard to the incident which occurred on 23.10.2019 that the Committee found that the 4threspondent was unable to prove the specific instance of molestation which occurred on the said date. 3 of the 4 issues raised were found against the petitioner that the employer was

    10

    required to take disciplinary action against the petitioner in Exhibit P4.

    Provisions of the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013, defines sexual harassment as follows:

    "S.2(n)'sexual harassment' includes any one or more of the following unwelcome acts or behaviour (whether directly or by implication) namely:-

    (i) physical contact and advances; or

    (ii) a demand or request for sexual favours; or

    (iii) making sexually coloured remarks; or

    (iv) showing pornography; or

    (v) any other unwelcome physical, verbal or non- verbal conduct of sexual nature."

    In the above factual situation, I am of the opinion that since the complaint raised by the 4th respondent had been specifically considered by the Committee with notice to all concerned and findings had been rendered as against the petitioner, the contention that there was no finding of sexual harassment and therefore, no recommendation can be issued by the Committee,

    11

    cannot be accepted. The decision of this Court in

    K.P.Anil Rajagopal (supra) was rendered in a case where the allegation of sexual harassment was found not proved, where the complaint raised by the 4threspondent contains specific allegations of sexual harassment and findings were returned that the petitioner had been guilty of such harassment against the 4threspondent and that he had created a hostile working atmosphere where the 4threspondent could not work in peace. In the above view of the matter, I am of the opinion that the challenge raised against Exhibit P4 has been failed and the writ petition is, accordingly, dismissed, leaving open the contentions on merits of the petitioner to be agitated in appropriate proceedings.

    Sd/-

    ANU SIVARAMAN

    JUDGE

    SSK/23/11

    12

    APPENDIX

    PETITIONER EXHIBITS

    EXHIBIT P1 TRUE COPY OF THE COMPLAINT DATED 18.1.2019

    SUBMITTED BY THE 4TH RESPONDENT AGAINST THE

    PETITIONER BEFORE THE 2ND RESPONDENT

    EXHIBIT P2 TRUE COPY OF THE SHOW CAUSE NOTICE DATED

    23.11.2019 ISSUED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT TO THE

    PETITIONER

    EXHIBIT P3 TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY DATED 7.3.2020 GIVEN BY

    THE PETITIONER WITH RESPECT TO EXT P1 COMPLAINT

    BEFORE THE 3RD RESPONDENT

    EXHIBIT P4 TRUE COPY OF THE REPORT BY THE INTERNAL

    COMPLAINTS COMMITTEE DATED 6/11/2020 SSK //TRUE COPY// PA TO JUDGE

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    SUDEEP.K.T v. STATE OF KERALA
    (Nov 23, 2022)