Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner entered into a contract with the respondents for the upgradation and renewal of Uslapur-Daija Road. The petitioner claims to have substantially completed the work except for some minor portions, which remain unfinished due to administrative obstacles caused by the respondent State. The petitioner seeks directions for the finalization and closure of the contract and for the settlement of bills related to the executed work. Correspondence and preliminary enquiries have already taken place between the parties regarding these issues. The matter is presently under consideration by the respondents.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to a direction for the finalization and closure of the contract with the respondents.
  2. Whether the petitioner can obtain a final settlement of bills for the work executed.
  3. Whether the petitioner must first avail the arbitration mechanism provided under Clause 28 of the agreement before the respondents take a final decision on the petitioner's request.
  4. How to address the penalty clauses imposed for delay in execution, considering the petitioner attributes the delay to administrative hurdles caused by the respondents.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner has substantially completed the contract work except for minor portions.
  • The minor unfinished work was due to administrative reasons beyond the petitioner’s control.
  • The petitioner seeks finalization and closure of the contract and settlement of bills after verification of completed work.
  • The petitioner contests penalty clauses imposed for delay, arguing the delay was caused by hurdles on the respondents' part, not by the petitioner.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Correspondence and preliminary enquiries have already occurred regarding the contract closure and bill settlement.
  • Clause 28 of the contract agreement provides for arbitration as the prescribed mechanism to resolve disputes, which the petitioner must first invoke before any final decision is taken.
  • Extensions of time have already been granted to the petitioner, and issues related to penalties should be addressed in the representation to be made by the petitioner.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted that the petitioner has substantially completed the contractual work except for minor portions impeded by administrative reasons attributable to the respondents. Recognizing that the matter is already under consideration by the respondents, the Court directed the petitioner to submit a fresh application to respondents no. 4 and 5 for contract closure and final bill settlement. The Court emphasized the requirement under Clause 28 of the agreement that disputes should first be addressed through arbitration before a final decision can be made by the respondents. Regarding the penalty clauses related to delay, the Court left the issue open for the petitioner to raise in the forthcoming representation, noting that extensions of time have already been granted. The Court’s approach balances procedural propriety with the factual matrix, ensuring the petitioner’s claims are addressed through the prescribed contractual dispute resolution mechanism and administrative process.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is DISPOSED OF with directions that the petitioner shall move a fresh application to respondents no. 4 and 5 within three weeks for closure of the contract and final settlement of bills. The respondents are directed to verify the claim and take an appropriate decision preferably within 60 days from receipt of the representation. The Court refrained from adjudicating on penalty clauses or arbitration at this stage, leaving these issues to be resolved through the contractually prescribed mechanisms. This decision resolves the immediate procedural impasse without setting a new precedent, requiring the parties to follow the existing contractual and administrative processes for dispute resolution.

    D.a. Enterprises, Through Its Proprietor Shri Dinesh Kumar Mishra v. State Of Chhattisgarh, Through The Secretary, Public Works Department And Others

    P. Sam Koshy, J.:— The limited relief sought for by the petitioner in the present writ petition is for appropriate direction to the respondent no. 4 & 5 for finalising and closing of the contract entered into between the petitioner with respondents and for final settlement of bills qua the work that has been executed by the petitioner.

    2. Matter relates to the work for upgradation and renewal of Uslapur-Daija Road.

    3. Contention of petitioner is that except for some minor works, the substantial work has already been executed by the petitioner. That the non completion of minor work was on account of administrative reasons and petitioner as such was not responsible or could not have done unless the respondent State would have made the execution of the work free from all disputes and hurdles.

    4. Learned counsel for the petitioner therefore submits in the given factual backdrop where he has substantially concluded the work except for some minor work which was left to be done carried out at that point of time, the petitioner wants tender to be finalized and settled after due verification of actual works completed by the petitioner.

    5. Learned State counsel submits that there seems to be already correspondence being made by the petitioner with respondents in this regard and certain preliminary enquiry, discussions have already been taken place as would be evident from the documents enclosed with the writ petition.

    6. Learned Additional AG further submits that Clause 28 of the agreement also speaks of availing arbitration clause for resolving the dispute, wherein certain mechanism available is prescribed in the said agreement itself which the petitioner has to avail first before respondents could take a decision finally on the request so made by the petitioner.

    7. Considering the nature of dispute that petitioner has with the respondents and nature of relief that he seeks, this Court is of the opinion that since the matter is already under process and under consideration by the respondents in this regard, let petitioner once again approach respondent no. 4 & 5 in this regard by moving an appropriate fresh application in respect of closure and settlement of Contract and for also final settlement of bills unpaid, if any.

    8. Let petitioner move an appropriate application to respondent no. 4 & 5 within a period of three weeks in addition to the representations which he has already made. The respondent no. 4 & 5 in turn shall scrutinize the said claim and after due verification of facts shall take an appropriate decision for closure of contract as also for the settlement of final bills itself at the earliest preferably within a further period of 60 days from the date petitioner makes the representation to the respondent no. 4 & 5.

    9. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that there are certain penalty clause which the respondents have imposed while granting extension of time. However, those extensions were sought by the petitioner because of the hurdles that had arisen on the part of the respondents and that it was not the fault on the part of the petitioners in execution of work which had caused the delay but were all because of administrative reasons.

    10. Given the fact that extension of time has already been granted by the respondents, it would be more appropriate for leaving that issue open for the petitioner to raise it before respondent no. 4 & 5 in the representation that he is suppose to make.

    11. The writ petition therefore stands disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    D.a. Enterprises, Th... v. State Of Chhattisgar...
    (Nov 21, 2022)