ORDER
The present petitioner was accused in C.C.No.85/2010, in the Court of the learned Civil and J.M.F.C., Aluru, (hereinafter for brevity referred to as the
"trial Court"). By its judgment dated 14.09.2012, the trial Court convicted the accused for the offence punishable under Section 138 of Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (hereinafter for brevity referred to as `N.I.Act') and was sentenced accordingly.
2. The summary of the case of the complainant in the trial Court was that accused was a friend of the complainant. The complainant was running a juice stall
2
behind BSNL Office, at Hassan. The accused was a customer of the said shop since about three to four years prior to the date of filing of the complaint, thus, their intimacy developed. Since the accused requested for a loan of a sum of `1,25,000/-, the complainant gave him the said loan amount on the date 04.09.2009. Stating that the loan would be repaid to the complainant within a month, the accused had also issued a cheque bearing No.273244, for a sum of `1,25,000/-, drawn on Canara Bank, Hassan Branch, in favour of the complainant. The said cheque when presented for encashment by the complainant, it returned on 23.10.2009 with the Banker's endorsement `insufficient funds' in the account of the drawer. Thereafter, the complainant issued a legal notice to the accused demanding the payment of the cheque amount. Since the accused did not pay the cheque amount, the complainant was constrained to institute a criminal case against the accused in the trial Court for the offence punishable under Section 138 of N.I.Act.
3
3. Since the accused pleaded not guilty, charges were framed against the accused for the alleged offences.
4. The complainant in order to prove his case, got himself examined as PW-1 and got marked six documents from Exs.P-1 to P-6. On behalf of the accused, the accused got himself examined as DW-1, however, no documents were marked.
5. After hearing both side, the trial Court by its impugned judgment dated 14.09.2012, convicted the accused for the offence punishable under Section 138 of N.I.Act and sentenced him accordingly.
6. Challenging the said order, the accused has preferred an appeal in Criminal Appeal No.132/2012 before the learned Addl.Sessions Judge and Presiding Officer, Fast Track Court-I, at Hassan, (hereinafter for brevity referred to as `Sessions Judge's Court), which by its judgment dated 28.01.2013, dismissed the appeal by confirming the judgment of conviction passed by the trial Court. It is
4
against these judgments of conviction, the accused has preferred this revision petition.
7. In spite of granting sufficient opportunities, learned counsel for the respondent has neither appeared nor addressed his arguments in the matter.
8. Heard the arguments of learned counsel for the petitioner. Perused the trial Court records and materials placed before this Court.
9. For the sake of convenience, the parties would be henceforth referred to as per their rankings before the trial Court.
10. After hearing, the only point that arises for my consideration is,-
"Whether the impugned judgments suffer from perversity, illegality, impropriety warranting any interference at the hands of this Court".
5
11. The complainant who got himself examined as PW-1 has reiterated the contentions taken up by him in his complaint. In support of his contention of alleged loan transaction, the complainant got marked dishonoured cheque at Ex.P-1, Banker's endorsement at Ex.P-2, copy of the legal notice at Ex.P-3, Certificate of Posting at Ex.P-4, the returned postal cover at Ex.P-5 and a postal receipt at Ex.P-6. The accused in the cross-examination of PW-1 has not denied or disputed these exhibits, however, his contention was that cheque was not given to the complainant, but, it was given to one Nagaraj, the brother of the complainant, but, the same was got misused by the complainant. The accused who got himself examined as DW-1 has reiterated the same in his very brief examination-in-chief.
Thus, the undisputed cheque at Ex.P-1, which shows the payee's name as that of the complainant and Banker's endorsement at Ex.P-2 showing that there was insufficiency of funds in the account of the drawer and the copy of the
6
legal notice at Ex.P-3, which after mentioning about the issuance and dishonour of the cheque, has demanded the payment of the cheque amount from the accused and the Certificate of Posting at Ex.P-4, would go to show that even after issuance of legal notice, the accused did not pay the cheque amount. Thus, prima facie a presumption about the existence of legally enforceable debt forms in favour of the complainant under Section 139 of N.I.Act. However, the said presumption is rebuttable.
12. In order to rebut the presumption formed in favour of the complainant, though the accused has denied the loan transaction by making suggestions to that effect in the cross-examination of PW-1, as well himself entering into the witness box and getting himself examined as DW-1, but, primarily he has taken a contention about the territorial jurisdiction of the trial Court which has entertained the criminal case instituted by the complainant in C.C.No.85/2010.
7
It is the specific contention of the accused that at no point of time, the complainant was the resident of a place called Aluru in Hassan District. It is his specific contention that throughout the complainant has been the resident of Hassan, so also, the accused. It is in that regard, suggestions were made to PW-1 in his cross-examination from the accused side. The complainant as PW-1, no doubt in his cross-examination has admitted that the cheque at Ex.P-1 is drawn on a Bank at Hassan and that it was presented by the complainant through his Banker at Hassan. He also admitted a suggestion that an alleged transaction between the parties was also taken place at Hassan, but, denied that he (complainant) was residing at Hassan and that it was only the competent Court at Hassan, which has got territorial jurisdiction to try the case.
13. A perusal of Exs.P-1 and P-2 would go to show that the dishonoured cheque was drawn on a bank at its Hassan Branch. The said cheque was presented by the complainant through his Banker i.e., State Bank of
8
Hyderabad at its Branch at Hassan only. Thus, the collecting banker and drawee banker both were at Hassan only. Undisputedly, the place of residence of accused was at Hassan. Though the complainant contends that he was at that particular point of time residing at Aluru, but, admittedly has not produced any material in that regard. No doubt, in the legal notice at Ex.P-3, the complainant has shown his place of residence as a place called Aluru town, however, the accused has specifically taken a contention that at no point of time, the complainant was a resident at Aluru. The said notice showing the place of residence of the complainant as Aluru has been issued by an advocate from Hassan.
In the cross-examination of PW-1, it was specifically elicited from PW-1 with respect to his alleged residence at Aluru in the house belonging to one Sri Rangaswamy, however, the complainant has not produced any documents. The complainant as PW-1 has admitted in his cross-examination that he has not produced the Lease
9
Agreement with said Sri Rangaswamy to show that he was residing as a lessee in the house of said Sri Rangaswamy. It was also specifically suggested to the witness that it was only to file the complaint before the Aluru Court, he has shown his house wrongly as a resident of Aluru.
14. Admittedly, the complainant was running a juice stall at Hassan and according to the complainant himself, the accused was a regular customer to the juice stall, as such, the accused came into his acquaintance. Thus, when admittedly the complainant was pursuing his avocation at Hassan and his bank account is also at Hassan Branch and admittedly, the accused was also a resident of Hassan and when the complainant claims that he was residing at Aluru in a house under lease with one Sri Rangaswamy, necessarily the complainant should have some documents to show about his place of residence as at Aluru. Though generally the said ascertainment of residence was not required, but, in the instant case, since when admittedly the drawer and drawee bank were at Hassan only, so also,
10
the avocation of the complainant was also at Hassan and more particularly, when the territorial jurisdiction of Aluru Court to try criminal case in C.C.No.85/2010 was seriously challenged, it was required of the complainant to satisfy the Court that the said Court had jurisdiction. In that regard, when admittedly the complainant claims to have possessing documents, including the rental agreement, with him, he was required to produce the same to overcome the contention of the accused. However, for the reasons best known to him, the complainant did not produce any material in that regard.
15. The Hon'ble Apex Court in M/s.Harman Electronics (P) Ltd., -vs- M/s.National Panasonic India Ltd., reported in AIR 2009 SC 1168, at Paragraph-25 of its judgment was pleased to observe as below :
" 25. We cannot, as things stand today, be oblivious of the fact that a banking institution holding several cheques signed by the same borrower cannot only present the cheque for its encashment at four different places but also may serve notices from four
11
different places so as to enable it to file four complaint cases at four different places. This only causes grave harassment to the accused. It is, therefore, necessary in a case of this nature to strike a balance between the right of the complainant and the right of an accused vis-a-vis the provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure."
Subsequently, the Hon'ble Apex Court in Dashrath Rupsingh Rathod -vs- State of Maharashtra and another,
reported in (2014) 9 SCC 129, in Paragraph-58.7 of its judgment was pleased to observe as below :
" The general rule stipulated under Section 177 of Cr.P.C applies to cases under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. Prosecution in such cases can, therefore, be launched against the drawer of the cheque only before the Court within whose jurisdiction the dishonour takes place except in situations where the offence of dishonour of the cheque punishable under Section 138 is committed along with other offences in a single transaction within the meaning of Section 220(1) read with Section 184 of the Code of Criminal Procedure or is covered by the provisions of Section 182(1) read with Sections 184 and 220 thereof."
12
16. Thus, the complainant should have to approach the appropriate jurisdictional Court to try his case, that too, when in fact, he could not able to establish that he was the resident of Aluru village. However, both the trial Court and the Sessions Judge's Court though considered the said contention of the accused about the absence of territorial jurisdiction, still, did not gave any reasons for the trial Court to proceed further in the trial of C.C.No.85/2010, but, only observed that since in the legal notice, the complainant has shown his place of residence as Aluru, the trial Court has got territorial jurisdiction. The said reasoning now having been shown to be not convincing and in view of the analyses made above, the impugned judgment passed by the trial Court has to be necessarily held that the trial Court has passed the same having no territorial jurisdiction to try the case. As such, the impugned judgment passed by the trial Court deserves to be set aside. Consequently, the judgment of Sessions Judge's Court which has tried the appeal, which is also
13
challenged in this revision petition, also deserves to be set aside.
17. Accordingly, I proceed to pass the following order:
ORDER
[i] The Criminal Revision Petition stands
allowed in-part. [ii] The judgment of conviction and order on sentence passed by the learned Civil Judge & J.M.F.C., Aluru, in C.C.No.85/2010, dated 14.09.2012, which was further confirmed by the learned Addl.Sessions Judge and Presiding officer, Fast Track Court-I, Hassan, in Criminal Appeal No.132/2012, dated 28.01.2013, stands set aside.
[iii] The complaint of the complainant stands returned to him for its presentation before the appropriate Court having territorial jurisdiction and in accordance with law.
14
Registry to transmit a copy of this order to both the trial Court and also to the Sessions Judge's Court and transmit the records to the concerned trial Court forthwith.
Sd/-
JUDGE
bk/
15