ORDER (ORAL)
Hon'ble Mr. Tarun Shridhar, Member (A) By virtue of the instant M.A., the applicant seeks execution of the order passed in O.A. No. 416/2021. The subject of the said O.A. was request of the applicant for transfer on the ground that her spouse was posted at a different station and the policy of the department required the husband and the wife to be posted at the same station if possible.
2. While disposing of the aforesaid O.A. on 19.03.2021 this Tribunal had passed the following order:-
"6. We, therefore, dispose of the OA, directing that the case of the applicant shall be considered in the general transfers, as and when they take place, and the relevant guidelines shall be applied in this behalf.
There shall be no order as to costs."
3. Thereafter, the applicant filed a Review Application and the order was amended to the limited extent as follows:-
"We make it clear that what was meant in the order was that the request of the applicant for transfer on the spouse ground, shall be considered as and when the general transfer takes place. We make this aspect clear and dispose of the RA. There shall be no order as to costs"
3
4. Drawing attention to the order passed by the respondents pursuant to these directions on 16.12.2021. Learned counsels submits that while disposing of the Review Application this Tribunal had given a categorical direction that the transfer be not considered as a routine transfer but as transfer on spouse ground. He points out that the rules and instructions governing transfer on spouse ground are distinct from the guidelines governing routine transfers. Therefore the order passed on 16.12.2021 is neither compliant of the letter nor the spirit of the order passed by this Tribunal.
5. We have heard the learned counsels for the applicant and also gone through the documents on record. In our view, the order passed by the Competent Authority of the respondents on 16.12.2021 is a detailed order which has examined not only the judgment passed by the Tribunal in the O.A. but also in the R.A. The order specifically makes a mention of the request of the applicant for transfer on spouse ground and has adequately dealt with the aforesaid issue.
6. We are, accordingly satisfied that the directions of this Tribunal passed in the aforesaid OA and RA have been complied with by the respondents in accordance of the rules and regulations. In our view,
4
nothing survives in the present M.A. which is accordingly dismissed. However, liberty is accorded to the applicant to agitate her grievances if any still survive in accordance with law.
(Tarun Shridhar) (R. N. Singh)
Member (A) Member (J)
/kk/sb/