AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 146 PATENTS ACT 1970
  • Order XI Rules 3 and 5 of the CPC
  • Order XI Rules 3 and 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (in short, 'CPC'),
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 146 PATENTS ACT 1970
  • Order XI Rules 3 and 5 of the CPC
  • Order XI Rules 3 and 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (in short, 'CPC'),
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The defendant no.2 filed an application under Order XI Rules 3 and 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, seeking production of various documents from the plaintiff. These documents include license agreements with multiple parties, declarations of essentiality to ETSI, statements of working filed under the Patents Act, agreements with chipset manufacturers, and agreements with telecom network service providers. The plaintiff had earlier produced some license agreements under a Confidentiality Club arrangement but was challenged for not producing all relevant documents. The suit itself involves claims of patent infringement relating to AMR, EDGE, and 3G technologies, seeking permanent injunctions, damages, and delivery up of infringing products.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiff is obligated to produce the complete set of license agreements, including those with entities similarly placed to the defendant no.2, for inspection by the defendant.
  2. Whether the plaintiff must produce declarations of essentiality made to ETSI and statements of working filed under Section 146 of the Patents Act.
  3. Whether the plaintiff must disclose agreements and negotiations with chipset manufacturers and telecom network service providers.
  4. The extent to which discovery of documents should be allowed without enabling a fishing and roving expedition by the defendant.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant No.2's Arguments

  • The plaintiff claims to support FRAND licensing and has over 100 global license agreements, but has produced only 70, of which only a few pertain to Indian entities.
  • The plaintiff produced only 37 distinct license agreements, with many being amendments or outdated, and some not involving companies in the same trade as the defendant no.2.
  • License agreements with companies like HTC, LG, Apple, Samsung, Huawei, ZTE, and CoolPad are necessary to determine FRAND terms and should be produced.
  • Declarations of essentiality made to ETSI regarding the suit patents are relevant and should be produced.
  • Statements of working filed under Section 146 of the Patents Act prior to 2010 should be produced.
  • Agreements and negotiations with chipset manufacturers Qualcomm and Mediatek are relevant to compare licensing terms and should be produced.
  • Agreements with telecom network service providers supplying equipment to government and private operators are relevant to assess FRAND compliance and should be produced.
  • Relied on the judgment in M. Sivasamy v. Vestergaard Frandsen A/S & Ors to emphasize the importance of production of relevant documents for fair trial.

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The defendant's request is a fishing and roving expedition intended to delay proceedings; the documents sought are neither relevant nor material.
  • Relied on a prior order in Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson (Publ) v. Xiaomi Technology & Ors where similar requests were dismissed, and the Supreme Court dismissed the Special Leave Petition against that order.
  • The plaintiff has produced comparable license agreements selected by its economic expert, including those with Indian entities.
  • The defendant itself denied the relevance of all 100 license agreements in its written statement.
  • The plaintiff will produce only agreements with relevant and comparable third parties; the defendant must show comparability.
  • Declarations of essentiality to ETSI are publicly available and copies of licensing declarations have been placed on record.
  • Statements of working under Section 146 of the Patents Act are publicly accessible via the Controller of Patents website.
  • The plaintiff has not entered into license agreements with chipset manufacturers like Mediatek and Qualcomm for the last 10-15 years, except for a limited agreement with Qualcomm related to CDMA applications, a copy of which has been shared.
  • Agreements with telecom network service providers are not relevant as the defendant does not deal in network or infrastructure equipment.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Anil Rishi v. Gurbaksh Singh, (2006) 5 SCC 558 Burden of proof lies on the plaintiff in a civil suit. The court reiterated that the plaintiff must prove its case and the defendant may seek adverse inference for non-production of relevant documents.
M. Sivasamy v. Vestergaard Frandsen A/S & Ors, 2009 (113) DRJ 820 (DB) Inspection/discovery of documents must assist parties in assessing the strengths and weaknesses of their cases for fair disposal. The court accepted the defendant's submission that production of documents would assist in just disposal of claims.
Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson (Publ) v. Xiaomi Technology & Ors., CS(COMM) 434 of 2016 License agreements with telecom network providers and chipset manufacturers are not necessarily relevant for production. The court relied on this order to reject the production of certain agreements as irrelevant at this stage.
Dolby International AB & Anr. v. GDN Enterprises Private Limited & Ors, CS(COMM) 1425 of 2016 Before ordering production of documents, the court must be satisfied of their relevance and necessity for proving claims or defenses. The court held that if the opposing party suffers for non-production, the application may still be refused with liberty to take advantage later.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court emphasized the settled principle that the burden of proof lies with the plaintiff in civil suits and that the defendant can seek adverse inference if relevant documents are not produced. It recognized that discovery is limited to documents material and relevant to the party's own case, not for enabling a fishing expedition. The court considered the plaintiff's assertion that it has produced all license agreements with similarly situated entities and that declarations of essentiality and statements of working are publicly available or already filed. The plaintiff’s denial of license agreements with chipset manufacturers except for one limited agreement was noted. The court held that the defendant must demonstrate comparability of entities before compelling production of agreements related to those entities. The defendant's application for production of additional documents was thus limited, allowing only an affidavit from the plaintiff confirming production of all relevant license agreements with similarly placed entities. The court declined to order production of agreements with entities claimed by the defendant without proof of comparability, reserving the defendant’s right to take advantage of non-production at trial. The court also noted that the production of certain documents is not presently warranted given the plaintiff’s submissions and public availability of some documents.

Holding and Implications

The application filed by defendant no.2 for production of additional documents is disposed of with directions that the plaintiff shall file an affidavit confirming production of all license agreements with entities similarly placed to the defendant no.2, subject to the Confidentiality Club arrangement.

The court’s decision limits discovery to relevant and comparable documents, preventing fishing expeditions and preserving procedural fairness. The defendant retains the right to challenge the sufficiency of documents during trial and seek adverse inferences if warranted. No broad new precedent was established; the ruling affirms existing principles on relevance and proportionality in document production in patent litigation.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Telefonaktiebolaget Lm Ericsson v. Gionee Communication Equipment Co. Ltd.

    * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI Reserved on: 18.07.2022

    Date of decision: 18.08.2022

    + CS(COMM) 1533/2016 & CC(COMM) 15/2021, IAs 8904/2018, 17513/2018, 2473/2019, 5937/2021, 10238/2021, 2634/2022

    TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON(PUBL)

    ..... Plaintiff

    Through: Mr.Sajan Poovayya, Sr. Adv. with Ms.Saya Choudhary Kapur,

    Mr.Ashutosh Kumar, Mr.Vinod

    Chauhan, Ms.Vrinda, Mr.Raksha Agarwal, Mr.Abhishek Kakkar,

    Ms.Alvia Ahmed, Ms.Pragya

    Agarwal, Advs.

    Versus

    GIONEE COMMUNICATION EQUIPMENT CO LTD & ANR ..... Defendants

    Through: Mr. Mudit Sharma and Ms. Snigdha Sharma, Advocates for D-2.

    CORAM:

    HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NAVIN CHAWLA

    NAVIN CHAWLA, J.

    I.A. 2473/2019

    1. This is an application filed by the defendant no.2/applicant under Order XI Rules 3 and 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (in short, 'CPC'), as applicable to commercial disputes, praying for the production of the following documents by the plaintiff/non-applicant:

    "a. License Agreements entered into by the Plaintiff with various parties in the same trade as

    1

    Defendant No.2 more particularly HTC, LG, Apple, Samsung, Huawei, ZTE, CoolPad etc b. 100 global license agreements entered into by the Plaintiff in relation to its portfolio of alleged Standard Essential Patents from most recent to the date of filing the Suit; and c. Declarations of Essentiality made by the Plaintiff to ETSI in respect of the eight suit patents. d. All licensing agreements the Plaintiff has entered into with entities in India with respect to the suit patents and all statements of working filed by Plaintiff under section 146 of the Patents Act with respect to the suit patents.

    e. Complete agreements between Plaintiff and Qualcomm and all documents relating to any offers made, negotiations held or agreements entered into any time by and between the Plaintiff and manufacturers of Radio Frequency Baseband Processors ("chipsets") anywhere in the world more particularly with respect to Qualcomm and MediaTek. All documents related to any offers made, negotiations held or agreements entered into at any time by and between Plaintiff and component manufacturers (as distinguished from end product manufacturers) anywhere in the world.

    f. Agreements entered into between telecom network service providers and Plaintiff under which equipment as supplied to government and private operators."

    Submissions on behalf of the defendant

    2. In support of the application, the learned counsel for the defendant no.2/applicant has drawn my attention to the contents of paragraph 18 of the plaint, wherein the plaintiff/non-applicant asserts that it supports Fair,

    2

    Reasonable and Non-Discriminatory (in short, 'FRAND') licensing and has over 100 Global License Agreements with vendors in the telecom industry. The defendants had earlier filed an I.A. No. 11833 of 2016 under Order XI Rules 3 and 5 of the CPC seeking production of similar documents, whereafter, owing to the confidential nature of the documents the Confidentiality Club was created. The learned counsel for the defendant no.2/applicant submits that the plaintiff/non-applicant has produced only seventy Global Patent License Agreements, in a sealed cover, pursuant to the Confidentiality Club created vide the order of this Court dated 04.04.2018. Of these, only five License Agreements pertain to Indian entities. He submits that the plaintiff/non-applicant has effectively filed only thirty-seven License Agreements with different entities, both Indian and Global, and, the remaining thirty-three agreements are either amendments or executed with the same entities on different dates; thirty-six of the License Agreements as produced by the plaintiff/non-applicant are not even valid and subsisting as on date and no renewed or latest License Agreements have been produced by the plaintiff/non-applicant to prove their validity; some of the License Agreements do not even pertain to the companies which are in the same business or trade as that of the defendant no.2. He submits that the plaintiff/non-applicant, therefore, having asserted itself that it has over

    100 Global License Agreements, must produce the copies thereof.

    3. The learned counsel for the defendant no.2/applicant further submits that the License Agreements entered into by the plaintiff/non- applicant with various similarly-placed parties in the same trade, more particularly HTC, LG, Apple, Samsung, Huawei, ZTE, CoolPad, to name

    3

    a few, are necessary and essential for the determination of FRAND license terms and rates. The same should also be produced by the plaintiff/non-applicant.

    4. The learned counsel for the defendant no.2/applicant further submits that the plaintiff/non-applicant, in paragraph 22 of the plaint, states that the plaintiff's suit patents are essential for various versions of the European Telecommunications Standards Institute (in short, 'ETSI') standards. The details of some of the ETSI standards that correspond to the suit patents related to AMR, EDGE and 3G have been provided in the plaint. He submits that the plaintiff/non-applicant should, therefore, be directed to place on record all the declarations made by the /non- applicant to the ETSI with respect to the suit patents for the standards which, according to the plaintiff/non-applicant, are covered by the suit patents. He submits that these documents are also relevant since they go to the root of the plaintiff's claim of the suit patents (related to AMR, EDGE and 3G technologies) being essential patents and its allegations of infringement against the defendants.

    5. The learned counsel for the defendant no.2/applicant further submits that the plaintiff/non-applicant has also stated the details of its various patents in paragraph 19 of the plaint. The plaintiff/non-applicant must therefore, produce all the 'statements of working of patents' for the period prior to the year 2010, filed by the plaintiff/non-applicant under Section 146 of the Patents Act, 1970 (in short, 'the Act') before the Controller General of Patents, Designs & Trade Marks (hereinafter referred to as the 'Controller of Patents').

    4

    6. The learned counsel for the defendant no.2/applicant further submits that the efforts made, negotiations held, or agreements entered into by the plaintiff/non-applicant and the chipset manufacturers, that is Qualcomm and Mediatek, have not been supplied by the plaintiff/non- applicant. He submits that the production of the said Agreements would be relevant to the Suit as they would shed light on the terms offered by the plaintiff/non-applicant, if at all, to a component manufacturer and the basis of such terms. This would facilitate a comparison of the said terms to the terms offered by the plaintiff/non-applicant to a handset manufacturer. These should also therefore, be produced by the plaintiff/non-applicant.

    7. Lastly, the learned counsel for the defendant no.2/applicant submits that the agreements entered into between telecom network service providers and the plaintiff/non-applicant, under which equipment is supplied to the Government and the private operators, as they are also crucial to comprehend which technologies/patents have been licensed by the said Agreement and for the rates for such license, should be produced by the plaintiff/non-applicant. These documents would be essential for accessing compliance of the FRAND obligations by the plaintiff/non- applicant.

    8. In support of his submissions, the learned counsel for the defendant no.2/applicant has placed reliance on the judgment of this Court in M.Sivasamy v. Vestergaard Frandsen A/S & Ors. 2009 (113) DRJ 820 (DB), to submit that the inspection/discovery of documents is to provide parties with the relevant documents which would assist them in appraising the strength and weakness of their respectively cases, thereby

    5

    leading to a fair disposal of the proceedings before the trial. He submits that in the present case, the production of the above documents would, therefore, assist this Court in a just disposal of the claims made by the plaintiff/non-applicant.

    Submissions on behalf of the plaintiff

    9. On the other hand, the learned senior counsel for the plaintiff/non- applicant submits that the request for documents sought for by the defendant no.2/applicant is only a fishing and roving expedition with the sole intent to delay the proceedings. The documents sought for are neither relevant nor material to the dispute raised.

    10. Placing reliance on the order dated 08.03.2018 passed by a Co- ordinate Bench of this Court in Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson (Publ)

    v. Xiaomi Technology & Ors., CS(COMM) 434 of 2016, he submits that a similar application by the defendant therein, being I.A. No. 12541 of 2016, was dismissed by this Court inter alia observing that the License Agreements with the telecom network providers are not relevant enough to be produced; so was the finding with respect to the Agreement with the chipset manufacturers, that is Qualcomm and Mediatek.

    11. He submits that a Special Leave Petition against the said order being SLP(C) No.023383 of 2018, has been dismissed by the Supreme Court vide the order dated 06.12.2018.

    12. In support of his submission, the learned senior counsel for the plaintiff/non-applicant has also placed reliance on the judgment/order dated 18.05.2017 passed by a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in

    6

    CS(COMM) 1425 of 2016 titled Dolby Inernational AB & Anr. v. GDN Enterprises Private Limited & Ors.

    13. On merit, he submits that the plaintiff/non-applicant has already produced comparable License Agreements executed with the third parties as selected by its extrinsic economic expert, including the Agreements executed by the plaintiff/non-applicant with Indian entities. In fact, the defendant no. 2/applicant has itself denied the relevance of all the 100 License Agreements entered into between the plaintiff/non-applicant and the third parties by stating in the written statement to the suit that such Agreements are of no consequence.

    14. As far as the Agreements with the entities like HTC, LG, Apple, Samsung, Huawei, ZTE and CoolPad are concerned, the learned senior counsel for the plaintiff/non-applicant reiterates that the only Agreements with relevant third parties which are comparable in nature are to be produced. It is for the defendant no.2/applicant to show how these companies are comparable to it and in the absence thereof, a direction to produce such Agreements cannot be issued.

    15. As far as the declaration of 'essentiality' made by the plaintiff/non- applicant to the ETSI in respect of eight suit patents are concerned, the learned senior counsel for the plaintiff/non-applicant submits that this information is available in the public domain and is not in the sole custody and possession of the plaintiff/non-applicant. In any case, the plaintiff/non-applicant has placed on record the copies of the IPR Information Statement and Licencing Declarations qua the patent finalisation of the suit patents, which have been submitted by the plaintiff/non-applicant to the ETSI.

    7

    16. As with regard to the demand of all the 'statements of working of patents' filed by the plaintiff/non-applicant under Section 146 of the Act with respect to the suit patents, he reiterates that these are documents that are available in the public domain, that can be easily accessed on the website of the Controller of Patents, operated by the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade, Government of India, which has a window for 'Public Search for granted Patents'. These documents are not in the sole custody or possession of the plaintiff/non-applicant. He submits that the plaintiff/non-applicant has duly filed all 'statements of working of patents' pertaining to the suit patents along with existing License Agreements executed by it with the parties who are actively selling their products/device in India.

    17. On the claim of the defendant no.2/applicant regarding the license efforts made, negotiations held, or agreements entered into by the plaintiff/non-applicant and chipset manufacturers, more particularly Qualcomm and Mediatek, is concerned, the learned senior counsel for the plaintiff/non-applicant submits that the plaintiff/non-applicant has not entered into License Agreements with chipset-manufacturing companies like Mediatek and Qualcomm for the last 10-15 years. An exception was made for Qualcomm Inc. and the Agreement entered into with it by the plaintiff/non-applicant was a part of a much bigger business Arrangement whereby the plaintiff/non-applicant granted limited rights under its 3G SEP for CDMA applications only. Though the defendant no.2/applicant is not similarly situated, the plaintiff/non-applicant has shared a copy of Exhibit.C, detailing the Agreement entered into between the plaintiff/non-applicant and Qualcomm Inc.

    8

    18. On the claim regarding the production of the Agreement between the plaintiff/non-applicant and the telecom network service providers, the learned senior counsel for the plaintiff/non-applicant reiterates that these are not relevant for the adjudication of the issues involved in the instant case, as the defendant no.2/applicant is not dealing in any network/infrastructure equipment.

    Findings of the Court

    19. I have considered the submissions made by the learned senior counsel for the plaintiff/non-applicant and the learned counsel for the defendant no. 2/applicant.

    20. The plaintiff/non-applicant has filed the present suit inter alia seeking following reliefs:

    i. A decree of Permanent Injunction be passed in favour of the Plaintiff and against the Defendants, their officers, Directors, Agents, Distributors and restraining them Customers from

    manufacturing/assembling, importing, selling, offering for sale, advertising including through their and third party websites, products (telephone instruments, mobile handsets, tablets, hand held devices, dongles etc.), including the models mentioned in paragraph 6 of the plaint and any future or other devices or models, that include the AMR, 3G and EDGE

    technology/devices/apparatus as patented by the Plaintiff in suit patents IN 203034, IN 203036, IN

    234157, IN 203686, 213723 (THE AMR

    PATENTS), IN 229632, IN 240471 (THE 3G

    PATENTS) AND IN 241747 (THE EDGE

    PATENT), so as to result in infringement of the

    9

    said suit patents, until the Defendant(s) have procured appropriate licenses therefor from Plaintiff;

    ii. A decree of damages of at least Rs.3,00,00,000/- (Three Crores) be passed in favour of the Plaintiff and against the Defendant nos. 1&2 and the said Defendants be also directed to render sales accounts qua the mobile handsets sold by them in India that incorporated the Plaintiff's patented technology. The Plaintiff submits that the valuation of damages is in approximate figures and on the complete disclosure of the revenues earned by the Defendants, the Plaintiff undertakes to pay further court fee as may be determined by this Hon'ble Court.

    iii. An order for delivery up of infringing components/elements,semi-manufactured products/ parts, products manufactured using the patented technology/devices/apparatus including packaging, labels, brochures and other printed material for the purposes of destruction;"

    21. It is well-settled that the burden of proof in a civil suit lies with the plaintiff. [Ref: Anil Rishi v. Gurbaksh Singh ., (2006) 5 SCC 558]. It is for the plaintiff to prove its case in trial. The defendant shall be entitled to take advantage of any deficiency in the documents of the plaintiff/non- applicant, by calling upon the Court to drawn an adverse inference against the plaintiff/non-applicant in case a relevant and material document is not filed on record by the plaintiff/non-applicant.

    22. In Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson (Publ)(supra), this Court has held as under:-

    10

    "11. It is settled proposition of law that a fundamental limitation on the right to production of document is a party is entitled to the production of only such material, facts and documents as relate to its own case and is not entitled merely to enable him to disprove or pry his adversary's case."

    23. In Dolby International AB (supra), this Court has held that before a direction for production of the documents is issued, the Court has to be satisfied with the relevance and of the need thereof for the applicant to prove its claim/defence. Once the applicant states that the opposite party will suffer for non-production, and the opposite party opposes the production, the application will not be allowed at the risk and cost of the opposing party and with the liberty to the applicant to take advantage thereof.

    24. The plaintiff/non-applicant asserts that all License Agreements of similarly-situated entities have been produced by them. It would be open for the defendant no.2/applicant to claim deficiencies in the License Agreements so produced at the relevant stage and to request the Court to draw an adverse inference against the plaintiff/non-applicant, in the event such a case of non-production is made out. However, at this stage, the defendant no.2/applicant cannot be permitted to go on a fishing and roving expedition.

    25. Therefore, as far as the prayer by the defendant no.2/applicant for the remaining License Agreements to be produced, the same is disposed of directing the plaintiff/non-applicant to file an affidavit stating that it has produced the License Agreements with all those entities which are similarly placed with the defendant no.2/applicant for the inspection of

    11

    the defendant no.2/applicant in terms of the Confidentiality Club constituted vide the order of this Court dated 04.04.2018.

    26. As far as the License Agreements between the plaintiff/non- applicant and the entities like HTC, LG, Apple, Samsung, Huawei, ZTE and CoolPad, are concerned, again in view of the statement made by the learned senior counsel for the plaintiff/non-applicant that these parties are not similarly situated, it is for the defendant no.2/applicant to disprove this assertion in the trial and if it succeeds in doing so, the defendant no. 2/applicant can take advantage of non-production of these Agreements during the adjudication of the suit. However, at this stage, the plaintiff/non-applicant cannot be directed to produce such License Agreements on a mere assertion of the defendant no.2/applicant, claiming such parties to be comparable to the defendant no.2/applicant.

    27. With respect to the declarations of 'essentiality', the plaintiff/non- applicant has submitted that without prejudice to its case that these documents are available in the public domain, it has filed the same. The learned counsel for the defendant no.2/applicant has submitted that there are certain deficiencies in the documents filed. It would again be for the defendant no.2/applicant to take advantage of such deficiencies, if they exist, during the trial and subject to the condition that these are not otherwise publically available documents. The same also goes for the 'statements of working of patent' filed by the plaintiff/non-applicant under Section 146 of the Act with respect to its suit patents.

    28. As far as the Agreements between the plaintiff/non-applicant and chipset manufacturers, more particularly Qualcomm and Mediatek, as well as Agreements between the plaintiff/non-applicant and telecom

    12

    service providers are concerned, it would again be for the defendant no.2/applicnat to show in the trial that these are comparable entities to that of the defendant no.2/applicant; and in case it succeeds in doing so, take advantage thereof in the final adjudication of the suit. At the present stage, the prayer, in view of the stand taken by the plaintiff/non- applicant, cannot be granted.

    Relief

    29. In view of the above, the present application is, therefore, disposed of with the above observations. There shall be no order as to costs.

    CS(COMM) 1533/2016 & CC(COMM) 15/2021, IAs 8904/2018, 17513/2018, 5937/2021, 10238/2021, 2634/2022

    30. List before Court on 11thOctober, 2022.

    NAVIN CHAWLA, J

    AUGUST 18, 2022

    RN/AB/DJ

    13

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Telefonaktiebolaget Lm Ericsson v. Gionee Communication Equipment Co. Ltd.
    (Aug 18, 2022)