Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order 41 Rule 27 of Code of Civil Procedure.
  • Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Section 100 of Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order 18 Rule 17 CPC
  • Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order 41 Rule 27 C.P.C.
  • Order 41 Rule 27 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order 41 Rule 27 of Code of Civil Procedure.
  • Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Section 100 of Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order 18 Rule 17 CPC
  • Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order 41 Rule 27 C.P.C.
  • Order 41 Rule 27 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Regular Second Appeal (Order 41 Rule 27 issues)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff (now appellant) sued in respect of 2 biswas of land and a house on part of Khasra No. 409/283 in village Jagatkhana, Tehsil Nirmand, District Kullu, H.P., claiming ownership by virtue of an agreement to sell and alternatively by a gift said to have been executed by the original owner Sh. Parmi. The plaintiff alleged that defendants Nos. 1–3 (who claimed through their late father Sh. Rattan Dass) interfered with her peaceful possession and obstructed rent payments by tenants (defendants Nos. 4–6); she sought, inter alia, permanent prohibitory injunctions restraining defendants from interference and from collecting rent.

The trial court framed several issues and, after evidence from both sides (oral and documentary), answered Issue No. 1 and 5 in the negative, Issues No. 2–4 in the affirmative and held Issue No. 6 as not pressed; the suit was dismissed by judgment and decree dated 30.09.2005. The plaintiff appealed under Section 96 CPC to the District Judge (Civil Appeal No. 48 of 2005), but the District Judge dismissed the appeal by judgment and decree dated 05.11.2007.

The plaintiff filed the present Regular Second Appeal under Section 100 CPC. This Court admitted the appeal on 29.12.2007 on four substantial questions of law, which included whether the lower appellate court had properly considered an application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC (and related procedural matters concerning additional evidence and other ancillary applications).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC filed by the appellant was not considered and decided by the learned District Judge, and whether that omission amounted to a failure to exercise jurisdiction properly such that the findings are liable to be set aside.
  2. Whether the application under Order 18 Rule 17 CPC for recall of PW‑7 (as filed by the appellant) was wrongly rejected and whether that constituted an improper exercise of jurisdiction.
  3. Whether the appellant's receipt of compensation for damage to her house (supported by certificates Ex. PW‑2/A and Ex. PW‑2/B) and the electricity connections in her name (Ex. PW‑7/A, Mark A and Mark B) were not considered by the courts below and, if considered, would have entitled the appellant to decree of the suit.
  4. Whether the agreement for sale (Ex. PW‑3/A) and the writing of gift (Ex. PW‑3/B) proved on record could not have been excluded from consideration and, at least for the purpose of grant of injunction, should have been taken into account.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jatinder Singh v. Mehar Singh, (2009) 17 SCC 465 : AIR 2009 SC 354 The duty of an appellate court (High Court) to take notice of and decide an application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC for admission of additional evidence; if such an application is filed the court must deal with it on merits and failure to do so is a jurisdictional lapse requiring setting aside and remittal. The Court relied on this authority to conclude that the District Judge's failure to adjudicate the application under Order 41 Rule 27 (filed before the appellate court and left undecided when the appeal was decided) amounted to a refusal to exercise jurisdiction and warranted setting aside the impugned judgment and remitting the matter for fresh decision including adjudication of that application.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the lower appellate record and observed that the appellant had filed an application under Order 41 Rule 27 read with Section 151 CPC for adducing additional evidence before the District Judge. That application had been replied to by respondents and the appeal was repeatedly adjourned, but the application remained pending and was not decided either separately or along with the appeal before the District Judge proceeded to decide the appeal on 05.11.2007.

The opinion notes the settled procedural position that there is no absolute right to adduce additional evidence at the appellate stage; nonetheless, the appellate court has the power to permit additional evidence subject to the restrictions of Order 41 Rule 27 CPC. Allowing additional evidence can, in appropriate circumstances, change the outcome of a case. The Court reasoned that because the appellant had a right to have that application decided, the absence of adjudication amounted to a refusal to exercise jurisdiction vested in the lower appellate court and had the potential to prejudice the appellant.

The Court relied upon the decision in Jatinder Singh v. Mehar Singh, where the Supreme Court held that when an application under Order 41 Rule 27 is filed the court hearing the appeal must deal with it on merits and that failure to do so requires setting aside and remittal. Applying that principle to the instant record, the Court concluded that the impugned judgment ought to be set aside and the matter remitted for fresh consideration by the District Judge with directions to decide the appeal along with the pending application under Order 41 Rule 27 read with Section 151 CPC.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court set aside the impugned judgment and decree dated 05.11.2007 passed by the learned District Judge, Kinnaur, in Civil Appeal No. 48 of 2005. The appeal is allowed to the extent of setting aside that judgment and remanding the matter to the District Judge for fresh decision in the appeal along with the application under Order 41 Rule 27 read with Section 151 CPC filed by the plaintiff.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the District Judge must hear and decide the pending application under Order 41 Rule 27 read with Section 151 CPC and thereafter decide the appeal afresh; the previous appellate judgment is set aside.
  • The Court recorded "No order as to costs."
  • The opinion, as rendered, follows the Supreme Court authority cited and remits for fresh adjudication; it does not purport to lay down any new principle beyond applying the existing precedent to the facts of this case.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Mani Devi v. Suresh Chand And Others

    Satyen Vaidya, J.:— By way of present appeal, the appellant has assailed the judgment and decree dated 05.11.2007, passed by learned District Judge, Kinnaur at Rampur Bushahr, H.P. in Civil Appeal No. 48 of 2005, arising out of judgment and decree dated 30 September, 2005 passed by learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), Anni, District Kullu in Civil Suit No. 14-1 of 2004.

    2. Appellant herein was plaintiff before the Trial Court and respondents herein were defendants. The parties hereafter shall be referred to by the same status, which they held before the learned Trial Court.

    3. Plaintiff filed the suit in respect of 2 biswas of land and house constructed thereon comprised in part of Khasra No. 409/283 in mauja/Phati Thachwa in village Jagatkhana, Tehsil Nirmand, District Kullu, H.P. (for short “suit property”). Plaintiff claimed the suit property as owner thereof by virtue of agreement to sell and alternatively under a gift executed by one Sh. Parmi, who was the original owner of the land comprised in Khasra No. 409/283. She alleged that defendants No. 1 to 3 were strangers to the suit property and defendants No. 4 to 6 were her tenants. As per plaintiff, defendants were sons of Sh. Rattan Dass, who had lived as husband of plaintiff for considerable long period. It was contended by plaintiff that after the death of Sh. Rattan Dass, defendants No. 1 to 3 illegally started claiming their rights over the suit property on the pretext that it belonged to their father. The peaceful possession of plaintiff was alleged to be disturbed by defendants No. 1 to 3. It was also alleged that defendants No. 1 to 3 obstructed defendants No. 4 to 6 from paying rent to the plaintiff on the above noted averments relief in the following terms was prayed for:—

    “It is, therefore, prayed that defendant Nos. 1 to 3 and their family members, agents, persons, servants or whosoever acts for and on their behalf may kindly be restrained from causing any sort of interference directly or indirectly into the possession of the plaintiff and her tenants in the double storey house comprising two rooms and kitchen on the ground floor and two rooms with separate kitchen, latrine and bathroom on the Ist floor of the house along with vacant space in front and right side of the house and they be also restrained from collecting rent from defendants Nos. 4 to 6 and further defendant Nos. 4 to 6 may kindly be restrained to make any kind of payment of rent to defendant Nos. 1 to 3 and further defendant Nos. 1 to 6 may kindly be restrained from causing any sort of nuisance, acts and deeds in peaceful enjoyment of the property situated over Khasra No. 409/283 in mouza Tachwa by the plaintiff. Any other relief the Court deems just and proper may kindly be passed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants in the interest of justice.”

    4. Suit was contested by all the defendants. Defendants No. 1 to 3 denied the claim of plaintiff on the ground that their father late Sh. Rattan Dass had purchased the land measuring two biswas in Khasra No. 409/283 from Sh. Ratti Ram, who was son of Sh. Parmi. According to defendants No. 1 to 3, the house was constructed by their father and plaintiff was one of his tenants. They specifically denied any relationship between their father and plaintiff.

    5. Defendants No. 4 to 6 acknowledged that suit property belonged to Sh. Rattan Dass and they were inducted tenants by him. Defendants No. 4 to 6 maintained that they had been paying rent earlier to Sh. Rattan Dass and after his death to defendants No. 1 to 3.

    6. The learned Trial Court on the basis of the pleadings of the parties had framed followings issues:—

    1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the relief of permanent prohibitory injunction, as prayed? OPP.

    2. Whether the plaintiff has no cause of action to file the present suit against the defendants? OPD.

    3. Whether the suit is not maintainable in the present form? OPD.

    4. Whether the plaintiff has no locus standi to file this suit against the defendants? OPD.

    5. Whether the suit is not properly valued for the purpose of court fee and jurisdiction? OPD.

    6. Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties? OPD.

    7. Relief.

    7. Parties to the suit availed opportunities to lead evidence. Oral as well as documentary evidence was produced on record by both the parties. The learned Trial Court answered issues No. 1 and 5 in negative, issues No. 2 to 4 in affirmative and issue No. 6 as not pressed. The suit of the plaintiff was accordingly dismissed vide judgment and decree dated 30.09.2005 passed by learned Trial Court.

    8. Aggrieved against the judgment and decree dated 30.09.2005, passed by learned Trial Court, plaintiff filed appeal under Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure before learned District Judge, Kinnaur at Rampur Bushahr, which came to be registered as Civil Appeal No. 48 of 2005. Learned District Judge, Kinnaur at Rampur Bushahr dismissed the above noted appeal vide judgment and decree dated 5.11.2007 and thereby affirmed the judgment and decree passed by learned Trial Court.

    9. The plaintiff has approached this Court by way of Regular Second Appeal under Section 100 of Code of Civil Procedure against above noted judgment and decree dated 05.11.2007, passed by learned District Judge, Kinnaur at Rampur Bushahr in Civil Appeal No. 48/2005.

    10. On 29.12.2007, the instant appeal was admitted for hearing on following substantial questions of law:—

    1. Whether the application under Order 41 Rule 27 C.P.C. having been filed by appellant has not been considered and decided by the learned District Judge, therefore, the jurisdiction has not been exercised properly and findings are liable to be set-aside.

    2. Whether the application under Order 18 Rule 17 CPC as filed by the appellant for recall of PW-7 has wrongly been rejected and thus the jurisdiction has not been exercised in accordance with law.

    3. Whether the appellant having received the amount of compensation due to damage to her house in the suit by the Tehsildar, Nirmand in support of which certificates Ex.PW-2/A and Ex. PW-2/B have been brought on record, but effect thereof on the claim of the appellant has not been considered by both the courts below and similarly the factum of electricity connections in the name of appellant as per Ex.PW-7/A, Mark A and Mark B, the suit was required to be decreed.

    4. Whether the agreement for sale Ex. PW-3/A and writing of gift Ex. PW-3/B having been proved on record, therefore, the same could not be excluded from consideration and in any case for decree of injunction, these documents could be considered.

    11. Learned counsel for appellant at the time of hearing of the appeal, in the first instance, addressed arguments on substantial question No. 1. He drew the attention of the Court towards the relevant portion of the record of learned District Judge Kinnuar at Rampur in Civil Appeal No. 48 of 2005.

    12. Perusal of “zimni” order dated 31.05.2007 revealed that the plaintiff on the said date had filed an application under Order 41 Rule 27 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure for adducing additional evidence. On 20.06.2007, reply on behalf of the respondents was filed to the said application and the main appeal was ordered to be listed for arguments along with application under Order 41 Rule 27 of Code of Civil Procedure. Thereafter, the appeal came to be adjourned on various occasions due to one or other reason. Finally, the appeal came to be decided on 05.11.2007. The record further reveals that the application under Order 41 Rule 27 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure filed by plaintiff before lower Appellate Court remained pending throughout and was not decided either separately or along with the appeal.

    13. There is no absolute right granted by Code of Civil Procedure to adduce additional evidence at the appellate stage. Nonetheless, the Court hearing appeal has power to allow a party to adduce additional evidence subject, however, to the interdict provided in Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The allowance of the prayer to adduce additional evidence, in the given circumstances of the case, may have the effect of changing the outcome of the case.

    14. Undisputedly, plaintiff had right to invite a decision, on her prayer to adduce additional evidence, from Lower Appellate Court. The absence of adjudication on application under Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure amounts to refusal of exercise of jurisdiction vested in Lower Appellate Court, which has potential to cause prejudice to the plaintiff.

    15. In Jatinder Singh v. Mehar Singh, (2009) 17 SCC 465 : AIR 2009 SC 354, Hon'ble Apex Court has held as under:—

    “4. While deciding the second appeal, however, the High Court had failed to take notice of the application under Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure and decide whether additional evidence could be permitted to be admitted into evidence. In our view, when an application for acceptance of additional evidence under Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure was filed by the appellants, it was the duty of the High Court to deal with the same on merits. That being the admitted position, we have no other alternative but to set aside the judgment of High Court and remit the appeal back to it for a decision afresh in the second appeal along with the application for acceptance of additional evidence in accordance with law.”

    16. In the light of above discussion, impugned judgment and decree passed by learned District Judge, Kinnaur, dated 05.11.2007, in Civil Appeal No. 48 of 2005 in case titled Smt. Mani Devi v. Sh. Suresh Chand is set aside. The appeal, thus is allowed to the extent indicated above and the matter is remanded to learned District Judge, Kinnaur at Rampur Bushahr, H.P. for decision afresh in the appeal alongwith application under Order 41 Rule 27 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure filed on behalf of plaintiff.

    17. No order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mani Devi v. Suresh Chand And Others
    (Aug 27, 2021)