AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petitions were filed by MBBS-qualified doctors seeking to appear for the Institute of National Importance Combined Admission Test (INI CET) for admission to Post Graduate courses for the July 2021 session in AIIMS units, PGIMER Chandigarh, JIPMER Puducherry, and NIMHANS Bengaluru. The petitions challenged Notice No. 81/2021 dated 27.05.2021 issued by the AIIMS Examination Centre, which rescheduled the INI CET for the July 2021 session to 16.06.2021.

The court disposed of the writ petitions by setting aside the impugned notice and directing postponement of the examination. Separately, in W.P.(Civil) No. 631 of 2021, counsel stated that the petitioners would not press Prayer No. 1, and the court issued notice to the Union of India and the Medical Council returnable by 18.06.2021, permitting dasti service and indicating that the Union of India may be served through the Solicitor General of India’s office.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether AIIMS’s decision to reschedule INI CET 2021 to 16.06.2021 on short notice was arbitrary, unfair, and discriminatory in the circumstances pleaded, warranting judicial interference.
  2. Whether the examination date should be postponed to mitigate alleged prejudice to candidates (including those serving at COVID hospitals) and practical impediments arising from lockdowns and COVID-19-related risks.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The decision to conduct INI CET on 16.06.2021 was described as “hasty” and seriously prejudicial to aspirants, many of whom were serving in COVID hospitals and posted far from their chosen examination centres.
  • Conducting the examination at short notice was alleged to be arbitrary and unfair, causing “gross injustice” because candidates had very little time to prepare; the petitioners claimed doctors had been assured sufficient time (at least a month) to prepare.
  • Counsel highlighted the scale and importance of the examination: approximately 850 MD/MS seats across specified institutions, with about 80,000 MBBS doctors expected to appear.
  • The petitioners contrasted INI CET with NEET-PG (for other medical colleges), stating NEET-PG had been postponed beyond 31.08.2021.
  • It was argued that other examinations (including the Civil Services Examination) had been postponed due to the pandemic, and there was uncertainty about whether some examinations (including Board examinations) would be held.
  • Reference was made to reported lockdown extensions in multiple states (including Odisha till 16.06.2021, and Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh, and Kolkata till 15.06.2021), making it extremely difficult for candidates to travel to exam centres.
  • The petitioners contended that many doctors faced exposure risk, potential infection, and consequent isolation/quarantine, and that holding INI CET on 16.06.2021 could contribute to virus spread and increased COVID-19 cases.
  • On these circumstances, fixing the exam on 16.06.2021 was claimed to be arbitrary and discriminatory, especially since other important examinations (including Joint Entrance Examinations and Board examinations) were postponed.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court recorded the circumstances pleaded by the petitioners regarding the short-notice scheduling of INI CET during the COVID-19 pandemic, including the fact that many candidates were serving in COVID hospitals, travel difficulties due to extended lockdowns in various states, the risks of infection and quarantine, and the potential public health impact of holding the examination on the scheduled date.

Having regard to these pleaded circumstances, the court concluded that fixing INI CET on 16.06.2021 was arbitrary and discriminatory (particularly in light of postponement of other examinations), and therefore judicially set aside the rescheduling notice and directed postponement by at least one month.

In W.P.(Civil) No. 631 of 2021, the court noted counsel’s statement that the petitioners would not press Prayer No. 1, and proceeded to issue notice to the Union of India and the Medical Council with directions regarding service and returnability.

Holding and Implications

SET ASIDE AND DISPOSED OF: The impugned Notice No. 81/2021 dated 27.05.2021 rescheduling INI CET to 16.06.2021 was set aside. The court directed that INI CET be postponed by at least one month from 16.06.2021, and that AIIMS fix a convenient date at least one month after 16.06.2021. The writ petitions and any pending applications were disposed of with these observations.

The direct effect was to compel postponement of INI CET and require AIIMS to announce a new date meeting the minimum one-month deferral. The opinion, as provided, does not indicate that any broader legal precedent was set beyond the relief granted in these petitions.

FURTHER PROCEDURAL DIRECTIONS (W.P.(Civil) No. 631 of 2021): The petitioners did not press Prayer No. 1. Notice was issued to the Union of India and the Medical Council, returnable by 18.06.2021; dasti service was permitted, and service on the Union of India could be effected through the Solicitor General of India’s office.

    Poulami Mondal And Others Petitioner(S) v. All India Institute Of Medical Sciences And Others (S).

    1. These Writ Petitions have been filed by doctors with an MBBS degree, aspiring to appear for the Institute of National Importance Combined Admission Test (INI CET) for admission to the Post Graduate courses for the July 2021 session in the units of AIIMS (All India Institute of Medical Sciences), PGIMER Chandigarh, JIPMER Puducherry and NIMHANS Bengaluru. The Writ Petitions are directed against Notice No. 81/2021 dated 27.05.2021 issued by the AIIMS Examination Centre, rescheduling the INI CET for the July, 2021 session to 16 June, 2021.

    2. It is submitted that the hasty decision taken by AIIMS to conduct INI CET 2021 on 16 June, 2021 has seriously prejudiced innumerable aspirants for admission to Post Graduate courses of the institutions of national importance, who are serving in Covid hospitals in various parts of the country. Many of them have been rendering services at Covid Centres located far away from the examination centres for which they have opted.

    3. The Petitioners contend that conducting the INI CET at such short notice is arbitrary, unfair on the aspirants for the INI CET and will cause gross injustice, as the aspirants have got very short time to prepare. According to the petitioners the concerned doctors had been assured that they would be given sufficient time, atleast a month, to prepare for the admission test.

    4. Mr. Datar, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the Petitioners pointed out that the INI CET is being conducted to fill up 850 MD and MS seats in 6 units of AIIMS, PGIMER Chandigarh, JIPMER Puducherry and NIMHANS Bengalure. About 80,000 doctors with the MBBS degree are expected to take the INI CET. Post Graduate courses of medical colleges, other than those mentioned above are through the NEET-PG, which according to the Petitioners has been postponed beyond 31 August, 2021.

    5. Mr. Datar argued that different examination have been postponed on account of the pandemic including the Civil Services Examination. It is not clear whether some examinations including Board examinations for this year, will at all be held.

    6. The attention of the court has also been drawn to news reports of extensions of lock down, in many States. It is reported that in Odisha lock down has been extended till 16 June, 2021. In Maharashtra and Andhra Pradesh and also in Kolkata, the lock down has been extended till 15 June, 2021. It would be extremely difficult, if not virtually impossible for many candidates for the INI CET to reach their examination centres from their places of duty. Many of the doctors are exposed to and are running the risk of contracting Covid 19 and they may have to isolate and/or quarantine themselves. Even otherwise holding the INICET on 16 June, 2021 will result in spread of the virus and increase in Covid 19 cases.

    7. Having regard to the circumstances, pleaded, fixing of the INI CET on 16.06.2021 is arbitrary and discriminatory, more so since other important examinations including Joint Entrance Examinations, Board Examinations etc. have been postponed.

    8. The impugned notice is, therefore, set aside. The INI CET is directed to be postponed by at least a month from 16 June, 2021.

    9. The AIIMS shall fix a convenient date for the INI CET at least one month after 16 June, 2021.

    10. With the aforesaid observations, the Writ Petitions are disposed of.

    11. Pending application, if any, stands disposed of.

    IN W. P.(Civil) No(s). 631 of 2021

    12. Mr. Sanjay R. Hegde, learned senior counsel, on instructions, submits that the Petitioners shall not press the first prayer i.e. Prayer No. 1.

    13. Issue Notice to the Union of India and to the Medical Council, returnable by 18 June, 2021.

    14. Dasti service, in addition, is permitted.

    15. Union of India may be served through the office of the Solicitor General of India.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Poulami Mondal And Others Petitioner(S) v. All India Institute Of Medical Sciences And Others (S).
    (Jun 11, 2021)