ADDITIONAL SMALL CAUSES JUDGE AND XXXI A.C.M.M., BANGALORE IN C.C.NO.24373/2016 AND ETC. THIS PETITION COMING ON FOR ADMISSION THIS DAY, THE COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING: ORDER This petition is filed under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. praying this Court to quash the order dated 05.09.2018 passed by the VI Additional Small Causes Judge and XXXI Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate in CC.No.24373/2016. Being aggrieved by the order the Crl.R.P.No.686/2018 is filed and the same is also dismissed. Hence, the present petition is filed for quashing both the order.
2. The respondent has initiated proceedings under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instrument Act, 1881 against the petitioner through General Power of Attorneyholder one Sri.Dharmappa D. The said Dharmappa has filed the affidavit before the Magistrate but he could not be present before the Court for cross- examination. At this juncture, an application was filed seeking permission to substitute the General Power of Attorneyholder and re-open the stage for evidence of the Complainant Witness No.1 i.e General Power of Attorneyholder and take the original Special Power of Attorney dated 19.06.2018. The same is allowed by the Magistrate.
3. Learned Magistrate while considering the said application passed an order that General Power of Attorneyholder who filed the petition was a permanent resident of Sagar Taluk and he was unable to present before the Court due to illness of his father, since his father was bed ridden. The reasons assigned in the application has been accepted. The same has been questioned in the Revisional Court. The Revisional Court also in its order dated 25.04.2019 in paragraph 12 of the judgment comes to the conclusion that the substituted power of attorney holder of the complainant has no personal knowledge to represent the present case, which has to be elicited at the time of trial. The findings of the trial Court required no interference since the power of attorney holder of complainant has got personal knowledge to represent the case of the complainant before the Trial Court. Hence, there are no sufficient grounds.
4. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner referring to the judgment of the Honble Apex Court in the case of A.C.NARAYANAN VS. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER reported in 2015 (12) SCC 203 brought to the notice of this Court paragraph 15 of the judgment and contend that no reasons are assigned in the application as to whether the new General Power of Attorney holder is having the knowledge in respect of the transaction.
5. Having heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and on perusal of the application except stating that the General Power of Attorney holder who has been examined before the Court is unable to come to depose before the Court, nothing is averred that the new General Power of Attorney holder who is going to be substituted is having any knowledge with regard to transaction.
6. The Revisional Court has come to the conclusion that the findings of the Trial Court are not required any interference as the General Power of Attorney holder of the complainant has got personal knowledge to represent the case of the complainant before the Trial Court. There is no doubt with regard to whether he is having any knowledge or not and the same is required to be elicited at the time of trial.
7. At this juncture, learned counsel for the petitioner brought to notice of this Court that the complainant has filed the affidavit stating that the new General Power of Attorney holder is having the personal knowledge with regard to the transaction. The contention of the petitioners counsel that there would have been averment in the complaint that whether he has got knowledge or not. The very argument of the petitioners counsel cannot be accepted. This is only a changed circumstances and during the pendency of the matter, the new General Power of Attorney holder is introduced. Hence, the question of making averments in the complaint does not arise. The affidavit is filed after filing of the objections by the petitioner mentioning that he is having personal knowledge. Hence, such being the case, the revision Court has rightly come to the conclusion that it is the matter of trial whether he is having knowledge or not. The revision Court while dismissing the revision petition also made an observation that the General Power of Attorney holder has having knowledge. This Court cannot find fault with the allowing the application filed by the complainant.
8. Having considered the materials on record and also reasons assigned by both the Magistrate and revisional Court, it is not a fit case to exercise the power under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. The principles laid down in the judgment of the Honble Apex court in A.C.Narayanans case (stated supra), are not applicable to the case on hand and it is only under the changed circumstances. The substitution is sought and also filed affidavit stating that he is having personal knowledge. Such being the case, it is a matter of trial.
10. In view of the discussions made above, I pass the following order: :ORDER: Petition is dismissed. However the grounds urged by the petitioner is kept open. Sd/- JUDGE