Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The First Respondent, employed as a Lecturer in the Computer Science and Engineering Department of the Petitioner’s Educational Institution since 09.07.2001, resigned on 18.01.2013 and requested payment of gratuity under Section 7(1) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 on multiple occasions (20.07.2016, 23.06.2017, and 25.01.2018). The Petitioner refused these requests. Subsequently, the First Respondent filed an application under Section 7(4) of the Act before the Second Respondent, along with a petition (P.G.I.A. No. 29 of 2018) seeking condonation of a delay of 1875 days in filing the application. The Petitioner appeared on 14.06.2018 and sought time to file a Counter-Affidavit. The Second Respondent condoned the delay by order dated 02.07.2018 due to the absence of a Counter-Affidavit at that time. The Petitioner later applied on 19.11.2018 to set aside the ex parte order, which was dismissed on 08.01.2019. Aggrieved, the Petitioner filed this Writ Petition under Article 226 challenging the order dated 02.07.2018 and seeking direction to consider the Counter-Affidavit and decide the matter on merits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the period of limitation prescribed under Rule 10 of the Tamil Nadu Payment of Gratuity Rules, 1973, for filing an application before the Controlling Authority is valid after the amendments to the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, particularly post-1987 amendments?
  2. Whether the condonation of delay in filing the gratuity application was necessary or warranted given the statutory provisions of the Act?
  3. Whether the Petitioner’s Counter-Affidavit ought to have been considered despite the delay?
  4. What is the proper interpretation of the employer’s obligation to pay gratuity and the employee’s right to apply for gratuity under the amended statutory scheme?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The Petitioner contended that the delay in filing the application for gratuity was not condoned properly and sought to file a Counter-Affidavit which was not considered before the delay was condoned.
  • The Petitioner relied on the procedural requirement under Rule 10 for condonation of delay and argued that the Second Respondent should have awaited the Counter-Affidavit before condoning the delay.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The Respondent relied on the Rules framed under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, which prescribe limitation periods and condonation procedures for delay in filing applications.
  • The Respondent argued that the limitation prescribed in the Rules was applicable and that the delay should not be condoned beyond the prescribed period.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bharat Barrel and Drum Mfg. Co. Ltd. v. ESI Corpn., (1971) 2 SCC 860 Subordinate legislation inconsistent with parent enactment is ultra vires and invalid. Court held Rule 10’s limitation period was inconsistent with the Act’s provisions and thus not applicable.
M.Vairamuthu v. Regional Labour Commissioner, W.P.(MD) No. 10377 of 2007 Delay and laches in moving authority under Payment of Gratuity Act not fatal to claim; limitation by rules beyond rule-making power. Supported the view that limitation prescribed by Rules cannot defeat substantive rights under the Act.
H. Jayarama Shetty v. Sangli Bank Ltd., (2005) 3 LLJ 637 (Bom) Non-payment of gratuity is a continuing wrong; limitation does not bar application; employer’s obligation to pay gratuity and interest. Reinforced the principle that employer must pay gratuity and interest irrespective of delay in application.
H. Gangahanume Gowda v. Karnataka Agro Industries Corpn Ltd., 2003 I CLR 705 Employer’s statutory obligation to pay gratuity and interest on delayed payment; no discretion to exempt employer. Confirmed no discretion to relieve employer from interest liability on delayed gratuity payment.
Sitaram v. M.N. Nagrashana, AIR 1960 SC 260 Explanation of delay must cover entire period; analogy with Limitation Act for condonation of delay. Referenced in context of condonation principles for delay in statutory claims.
Gurunath Vithal Tamse v. National Textile Corporation, 2002 I CLR 809 No specific limitation period prescribed for moving Controlling Authority under Payment of Gratuity Act. Supported the position that limitation under Rules cannot override Act’s provisions.
M.C.D. v. Nand Kishore, 2003 (97) FLR 158 (Delhi HC) Nonpayment of gratuity constitutes continuing wrong; delay in approaching Controlling Authority not applicable. Reinforced continuing wrong principle negating limitation defense.
Neelakandan v. State of Kerala, 2001 II CLR 448 (Kerala HC) Rules cannot override Section 7(2) of the Act; employer’s duty to pay gratuity independent of application. Supported liberal interpretation in favor of employee’s rights under Act.
General Secretary, Vokkaligara Sangha, Bangalore v. R. Chandramouli, 2002 II CLR 1070 (Karnataka HC) Rule 7(5) permits entertaining late applications on sufficient cause; claim not invalid solely for delay. Confirmed procedural flexibility for late applications consistent with Act.
Madura Coats Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner of Labour, (1993) 3 LLJ 923 (Mad) Application to condone delay must be decided before main gratuity application. Noted as earlier precedent; however, inconsistency with amended Act not considered then.
M. Devarajulu v. Assistant Commissioner of Labour, (1995) 1 LLJ 348 (Mad) Approved Madura Coats Ltd. view on condonation application. Referenced for procedural sequencing; subject to limitations discussed in current opinion.
State of Orissa v. Sudhansu Sekhar Misra, AIR 1968 SC 647 Precedent binds only on what is actually decided, not logical extensions. Clarified limits of precedential authority in interpreting earlier decisions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the statutory scheme of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, particularly focusing on the amendments made by Acts 25 of 1984 and 22 of 1987. It noted that the employer’s obligation to determine and pay gratuity arises irrespective of whether the employee has applied, and that the employer must pay the gratuity within thirty days of it becoming payable, failing which statutory interest is payable. The Court observed that the Act does not prescribe any limitation period for an employee to apply to the Controlling Authority under Section 7(4)(b), though the Rules framed prior to the amendments do prescribe limitation periods and condonation procedures. The Court held that such subordinate legislation (the Rules) cannot override or limit the substantive rights and obligations created by the parent enactment, citing the Supreme Court’s ruling in Bharat Barrel and Drum Mfg. Co. Ltd. The Court further relied on various High Court and Supreme Court decisions emphasizing that non-payment of gratuity is a continuing wrong and that limitation cannot be a defense to defeat the employee’s just entitlement. It concluded that the condonation of delay under Rule 10 was not warranted in the present case because the limitation prescribed therein is inconsistent with the Act post-amendment. The Court also clarified that earlier precedents approving the procedural requirement to decide condonation applications before the main gratuity claim did not consider the amendments and thus have limited applicability. Finally, the Court directed that the matter be heard on merits with the Petitioner’s Counter-Affidavit considered, ensuring adherence to natural justice and statutory provisions.

Holding and Implications

The Writ Petition is dismissed with clarifications. The Court upheld the order of the Second Respondent condoning the delay in filing the gratuity application, but clarified that the limitation period prescribed under Rule 10 of the Tamil Nadu Payment of Gratuity Rules is not applicable post the 1987 amendment of the Act. The Petitioner is directed to file its Counter-Affidavit and the matter is to be decided on merits by the Second Respondent. The Court emphasized the employer’s statutory obligation to pay gratuity and interest irrespective of employee delay in application. No new precedent was set; rather, the Court reinforced the existing legal position that limitation cannot defeat substantive rights under beneficial social welfare legislation. The connected Miscellaneous Petitions are closed with no costs.

    Sri Muthukumaran Institute of Technology, Represented by Principal, Chennai & Others v. J. Rajalakshmi & Others

    (Prayer: Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying to issue a Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus, calling for the records of the Second Respondent in its Order dated 2.7.2018 in P.G.I.A. No. 29 of 2018, quash the same and consequentially, direct the Second Respondent to consider the Counter Affidavit filed by the Petitioner and decide the application on merits after hearing the arguments.)

    (through video conference)

    1. Heard Mr. T.Sundar Rajan, Learned Counsel for the Petitioner, Mr. K.S.L.Narain, Learned Counsel for the Second Respondent and Mr. D.Sathyaraj, Learned Special Government Pleader appearing for the Second to Fourth Respondents and perused the materials placed on record, apart from the pleadings of the parties.

    2. The First Respondent, who had been employed as Lecturer in the Computer Science and Engineering Department in the Educational Institution of the Petitioner from 09.07.2001 onwards, claims that she had resigned from service on 18.01.2013 and had made a request in writing for payment of gratuity under Section 7(1) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (hereinafter referred to as the 'Act' for short) on 20.07.2016, 23.06.2017 and 25.01.2018 to the Petitioner, who had refused to entertain the same. Thereafter, the First Respondent made an application under Section 7(4) of the Act before the Second Respondent along with a petition in P.G.I.A. No. 29 of 2018 to condone the delay of 1875 days in filing the same. The Petitioner, who had entered appearance on 14.06.2018 in the said proceedings, had sought time for filing Counter-Affidavit in the said petition to condone delay. According to the Petitioner, the Second Respondent had condoned the delay in filing the application for gratuity by order dated 02.07.2018 as no Counter had been filed by the Petitioner till that date. The Petitioner thereafter claims to have made an application on 19.11.2018 to set aside the exparte order in the petition for condoning the delay in filing the application for gratuity, and by order dated 08.01.2019, it was dismissed by the Second Respondent. Aggrieved thereby, the Petitioner has filed this Writ Petition challenging the order dated 02.07.2018 in P.G.I.A. No. 29 of 2018 and to consider the Counter-Affidavit filed by the Petitioner and consequentially decide the matter on merits.

    3. It must, at once, be pointed out here that when the Act came into force on 16.09.1972, an employee could make an application for payment of gratuity under the Explanation to Section 7(4)(a) of the Act only after requiring the employer to deposit the gratuity amount and the employer has failed to do so. In that backdrop, Rule 10 of the Tamil Nadu Payment of Gratuity Rules, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as the 'Rules' for short), which were made in the exercise of powers under Section 15(1) of the Act, provides as follows:-

    “10. Application to controlling authority for direction:-

    (1) If an employer:-

    (i) refuses to accept a nomination or to entertain an application sought to be filed under rule 7, or

    (ii) issues a notice under sub-rule (1) of rule 8 either specifying an amount of gratuity which is considered by the applicant less than what is payable or rejecting eligibility to payment of gratuity, or

    (iii) having received an application under rule 7 fails to issue any notice as required under rule 8 within the time specified therein,

    the claimant employee, nominee or legal heir, as the case may be, may, within ninety days of the occurrence of the cause for the application, apply in Form ‘N’ to the controlling authority for issuing a direction under sub-section (4) of section 7 with as many extra copies as are the opposite parties:

    Provided that the controlling authority may accept any application under this sub-rule, on sufficient cause being shown by the applicant, after the expiry of the specified period.

    (2) Application under sub-rule (1) and other documents relevant to such an application shall be presented in person to the controlling authority or shall be sent by registered post acknowledgement due.”

    However, amendments have been made by Act 25 of 1984 with effect from 01.07.1984 and Act 22 of 1987 with effect from 01.10.1987 by which the Act provides in Section 7(4)(b) that an employee may straight away make an application for payment of gratuity to the Controlling Authority for deciding the dispute arising out of the matter specified in clause (a) thereto, which includes non-payment of gratuity by the employer within the time limit after it had fallen due. In order to have a better understanding of the effect of those statutory amendments, a comparative study may be made to the provisions of clause (1) to (4) of Section 7 of the Act as it stood at the time of commencement of the Act and the subsequent amendments made in the self-explanatory tabular statement below:-

    Provisions of Section 7 as it stood at the time of commencement of the Act on 16.09.1972Provisions of Section 7 after the amendment made by Act 22 of 1987 with effect from 01.10.1987
    7. Determination of the amount of Gratuity:-7. Determination of the amount of Gratuity:-(1) A person who is eligible for payment of

    gratuity under this Act or any person authorised, in writing, to act on his behalf shall send a written application to the employer, within such time and in such form, as may be prescribed, for payment of such gratuity.

    (2) As soon as gratuity becomes payable, the employer shall, whether an application referred to in sub-section (1) has been made or not, determine the amount of gratuity and give notice in writing to the person to whom the gratuity is payable and also to the Controlling Authority specifying the amount gratuity so determined.

    (3) The employer shall arrange to pay the amount of gratuity, within such time as may be prescribed, to the person to whom the gratuity is payable.

    (4) (a) If there is any dispute as to the amount of gratuity payable to an employee under this Act or as to the admissibility of any claim of, or in relation to, an employee for payment of gratuity, or as to the person entitled to receive the gratuity, the employer shall deposit with the Controlling Authority such amount as he admits to be payable by him as gratuity.

    Explanation:- Where there is a dispute with regard to any matter or matters specified in this clause the employee may make an application to the Controlling Authority for taking such action as is specified in clause (b).

    (b) The Controlling Authority shall, after due inquiry and after giving the parties to the dispute a reasonable opportunity of being heard, determine the amount of gratuity payable to an employee, and if as a result of such inquiry any amount in excess of the amount deposited by the employer is found to be payable, the Controlling Authority shall direct the employer to pay such amount as is in excess of the amount deposited by him.

    (c) The Controlling Authority shall pay the amount deposited, including the excess amount, if any, deposited by the employer, to the person entitled thereto.

    (d) As soon as may be after a deposit is made under Clause (a), the Controlling Authority shall pay the amount of the deposit-

    (i) to the applicant where he is the employee; or

    (ii) where the applicant is not the employee, to the nominee or heir of the employee if the Controlling Authority is satisfied that there is no dispute as to the right of the applicant to receive the amount of gratuity.

    7. Determination of the amount of Gratuity:-(1) A person who is eligible for payment of gratuity under this Act or any person authorised, in writing, to act on his behalf shall send a written application to the employer, within such time and in such form, as may be prescribed, for payment of such gratuity.(2) As soon as gratuity becomes payable, the employer shall, whether an application referred to in sub-section (1) has been made or not, determine the amount of gratuity and give notice in writing to the person to whom the gratuity is payable and also to the Controlling Authority specifying the amount gratuity so determined.

    (3) The employer shall arrange to pay the amount of gratuity within thirty days from the date it becomes payable to the person to whom the gratuity is payable.

    (3-A) If the amount of gratuity payable under sub-section (3) is not paid by the employer within the period specified in sub-section (3) the employer shall pay, from the date on which the gratuity becomes payable to the date on which it is paid, simple interest at such rate, not exceeding the rate notified by the Central Government from time to time for repayment of long term deposits, as that Government may, by notification specify:

    Provided that no such interest shall be payable if the delay in the payment is due to the fault of the employee and the employer has obtained permission in writing from the Controlling Authority for the delayed payment on this ground.

    (4) (a) If there is any dispute as to the amount of gratuity payable to an employee under this Act or as to the admissibility of any claim of, or in relation to, an employee for payment of gratuity, or as to the person entitled to receive the gratuity, the employer shall deposit with the Controlling Authority such amount as he admits to be payable by him as gratuity.

    (b) Where there is a dispute with regard to any matter or matters specified in Clause (a), the employer or employee or any other person raising the dispute may make an application to the Controlling Authority for deciding the dispute.

    (c) The Controlling Authority shall, after due inquiry and after giving the parties to the dispute a reasonable opportunity of being heard, determine the matter or matters in dispute and, if, as a result of such inquiry any amount is found to be payable to the employee, the Controlling Authority shall direct the employer to pay such amount or, as the case may be, such amount as reduced by the amount already deposited by the employer.

    (d) The Controlling Authority shall pay the amount deposited, including the excess amount, if any, deposited by the employer, to the person entitled thereto.

    (e) As soon as may be after a deposit is made under Clause (a), the Controlling Authority shall pay the amount of the deposit-

    (i) to the applicant where he is the employee; or

    (ii) where the applicant is not the employee, to the nominee or, as the case may be, the guardian of such nominee or heir of the employee if the Controlling Authority is satisfied that there is no dispute as to the right of the applicant to receive the amount of gratuity.

    �It could be noticed from reading together of clauses (2) and (3) of Section 7 of the Act that the employer has to make payment of the admitted amount of gratuity to the employee within a period of thirty days from the date on which it falls due, irrespective of whether the employee has made such claim. Further Section 7(3-A) of the Act fastens liability on the employer to pay simple interest thereon at such rate not exceeding the rate notified by the Central Government from time to time for repayment of long-term deposits, as that Government may, by notification specify. When the employer fails to make or there is shortfall in payment of gratuity, the employee is entitled to make an application for payment of gratuity to the Controlling Authority under Section 7(4)(b) of the Act. The scheme of the Act as per the amended provisions clearly reveal that there is no period of limitation restricting the right of the employee to make such application to the Controlling Authority.

    4. The legal position is well settled that a provision for limitation cannot be made by way of subordinate legislation when the parent enactment does not contemplate the same as held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Bharat Barrel and Drum Mfg. Co. Ltd., v. ESI Corpn., [(1971) 2 SCC 860]. Further, it is trite law that the subordinate legislation which is inconsistent with the parent enactment would be ultra vires and cannot have any effect.

    5. It becomes evident that after the amendments made to the Act with effect from 01.10.1987, the period of limitation prescribed in Rule 10 of the Rules is in derogation of clauses (2), (3), (3-A) and (4) of Section 7 of the Act. As a consequence thereof, it would necessarily follow that though the First Respondent condoned the delay in filing the application for payment of gratuity in terms of Rule 10 of the Rules, resort to that procedure was not actually warranted. This view is fortified by the decision of this Court in M.Vairamuthu -vs- Regional Labour Commissioner (Order dated 21.10.2010 in W.P. (MD) No. 10377 of 2007 etc., batch), where it has been held as follows:-

    “7. Though initially the IRE Limited wanted to contend delay and laches on the part of the workmen in moving the authority under the Payment of Gratuity Act, however, no serious submissions were made on that score. Hence it is unnecessary to deal with the issue elaborately except when dealing with W.P.(MD)No.10377 of 2007. Even otherwise, this court has already held that if there is unpaid gratuity, the workmen can move the authority and the prescription of limitation by rules is beyond the power conferred on the rule making authority.”

    6. The Bombay High Court in H.Jayarama Shetty -vs- Sangli Bank Ltd., [(2005) 3 LLJ 637 (Bom)] has elaborately discussed this aspect of the matter as follows:-

    “5. The second reason which weighed with the Appellate Authority was that the claim of the Petitioner for payment of gratuity was barred by limitation. The Petitioner submitted in his application that the breach on the part of the employer was of a continuous and recurring nature. The Petitioner, however, submitted that if the authority came to the conclusion that there was a delay, he would crave leave to file a separate application for the condonation. Counsel for the Petitioner has made a statement before the Court on instructions that there was no separate application for condonation.

    6. Section 4 of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 provides that gratuity shall be payable to an employee on the termination of his employment after he has rendered continuous service for not less than five years, on superannuation or, as the case may be, on retirement, resignation, death or disablement. Sub-section (1) of Section 7 provides that a person who is eligible for the payment of gratuity shall send a written application to the employer, within such time and in such form, as may be prescribed, for the payment of gratuity. Sub-section (2), however, lays down that irrespective of whether an application as provided in sub-section (1) has been made or not, the employer shall as soon as gratuity becomes payable, determine the amount of gratuity and give a notice in writing to the person to whom the gratuity is payable and to the Controlling Authority specifying the amount of gratuity so determined. Subsections (3) and (3A) of Section 7 were substituted by Amending Act 22 of 1987 with effect from 1st October 1987. Sub-section (3) provides that the employer shall arrange to pay the amount of gratuity within thirty days from the date on which it becomes payable to the person to whom gratuity is payable. Sub-section (3A) stipulates that if the amount of gratuity that is payable is not paid by the employer as specified in sub-section (3), the employer shall pay simple interest at such rate, not exceeding the rate notified by the Central Government from time to time for repayment of long term deposits. No interest is, however, payable if the delay in payment is due to the fault of the employee and the employer has obtained permission in writing from the Controlling Authority for delayed payment on that ground. Payment of interest on delayed payment of gratuity is the statutory norm and even if delay is due to the employee, the employer has to obtain permission of the Controlling Authority in writing on this ground without which gratuity must carry statutory interest. Sub-section (4)(a) then provides that if there is any dispute as to the amount of gratuity payable to an employee under the Act, or as to the admissibility of any claim of, or in relation to, an employee for payment of gratuity or as to the person entitled to receive the gratuity, the employer must deposit with the Controlling Authority such amount as he admits to be payable. Sub-section (4)(b) provides that upon there being a dispute with regard to any matter specified in clause (4)(a), the employer or employee or any other person raising the dispute may make an application to the Controlling Authority for deciding the dispute. The Controlling Authority has thereupon been empowered to adjudicate upon the dispute.

    7. These provisions of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 provide a statutory elucidation of the nature of gratuity as a terminal benefit. Under Section 4 of the Act, payment of gratuity to an employee is a mandate of the statute, on the termination of employment after continuous service for not less than five years. This mandate is subject to the limited exception which is carved out in sub-section (6) of Section 4 to which a reference would be made shortly hereafter. The employer is under a mandate and an obligation to determine the amount of gratuity that is payable as soon as gratuity becomes payable. The employer is under an obligation to arrange for the payment of the amount of gratuity within 30 days from the date on which it becomes payable to the person to whom is payable. After the amendment of 1987, a statutory provision has been made for the payment of interest. The employer can avoid that obligation to pay interest only if the delay in payment is due to a fault of the employee and if employer is granted permission in writing by the Controlling Authority for the delayed payment on that ground. These provisions emphasise that the determination of the amount and the payment of gratuity is the obligation of the employer. The employer has to make a determination of the gratuity which is payable whether or not an application has been made by the employee. The employer has to arrange payment.

    8. These provisions have been interpreted by the Supreme Court in H. Gangahanume Gowda -vs- Karnataka Agro Industries Corpn Ltd., [2003 I CLR 705], where the Court held as follows:

    "From the provisions made in Section 7, a clear command can be seen mandating the employer to pay the gratuity within the specified time and to pay interest on the delayed payment of gratuity. No discretion is available to exempt or relieve the employer from payment of gratuity with or without interest as the case may be. ... Payment of gratuity with or without interest as the case may be does not lie in the domain of discretion but it is a statutory compulsion. Specific benefits expressly given in a social beneficial legislation cannot be ordinarily denied."

    The Supreme Court held that in view of the clear mandate of Section 7, no residual discretion vested in the High Court to relieve the obligation imposed on the employer of paying interest on account of the delayed payment of gratuity.

    9. On behalf of the Respondent, however, reliance was sought to be placed on the rules framed under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. These Rules, it must be noted at the outset, were framed prior to the Amending Acts of 1984 and 1987. The Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, it may be noted, has made no provision for a specified period for the submission of an application to the Controlling Authority in Section 7(4)(b) of the Act. As contradistinguished from this, Section 7(7) provides for a specific period of limitation of sixty days for preferring an appeal to the appropriate Government against the decision of the Controlling Authority under Section 7(4). In Sitaram -vs- M.N.Nagrashana (AIR 1960 SC 260), the Supreme Court considered Section 10 of the Workmen's Compensation Act which provided a period of limitation to make a claim for compensation to the Commissioner but empowered the latter to condone delay for sufficient cause. This provision of the Act was held by the Supreme Court to be similar to Section 5 of the Limitation Act and the Court held that the explanation must cover the whole period of delay. In Gurunath Vithal Tamse -vs- National Textile Corporation [2002 I CLR 809] this Court held that significantly, the legislature had advisedly not specified any particular period of limitation for moving the Controlling Authority under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. But the submission before the Court now on behalf of the the Respondent, is that the limitation which has been provided for in Rules 7 and 10 of the Rules framed under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 was not brought to the attention of the Court in that case. Before dealing with this submission on first principle, it would be necessary to note that at least three High Courts have had occasion to consider the question. The Delhi High Court, in M.C.D. -vs- Nand Kishore [2003 (97) FLR 158], dealt with the submission that the Controlling Authority had not taken into consideration the delay of the employee in filing an application under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. The Delhi High Court held that "the grievance of the appellant is misconceived as the nonpayment of gratuity due to the Respondent was a continuing wrong and there was no question of any delay in approaching the Controlling Authority. A Learned Single Judge of the Kerala High Court in Neelakandan -vs- State of Kerala [2001 II CLR 448] adverted to the provisions of Section 7 of the Act as amended and held that while Rule 7 of the Gratuity Rules provides that an application be filed within a prescribed time, these provisions under the Rules "cannot of course, be taken as over reaching the provision of Section 7(2) of the Act". The Court held that perhaps the impact of the Amending Acts of 1984 and 1987 had not been taken notice of by the rule making body. Upon the amendment of Section 7, it has now unambiguously been laid down that an employer has a duty to pay gratuity whether or not an application is filed. The Payment of Gratuity Act is a piece of beneficial legislation and a liberal interpretation would have to be adopted since an employee, it was held, may not at times be aware of his rights. The Act imposes an obligation on the employer and it would not be open to the employer to benefit from a delay in making an application for the payment of gratuity. The Karnataka High Court in General Secretary, Vokkaligara Sangha, Bangalore -vs- R. Chandramouli [2002 II CLR 1070] noted that Rule 7(5) permits the entertainment of the applications for payment of gratuity after the expiry of the period specified and claim shall not be invalid merely because the claimant failed to present the application within the specified period.

    10. The Rules framed under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 provide for two separate periods of time in relation to the making of an application. The first under Rule 7 is an application to the employer within 30 days from the date on which gratuity becomes payable. Rule 7(5), however, provides that an application for payment of gratuity filed after the expiry of the period specified shall also be entertained by the employer if the applicant adduces sufficient cause for delay and no claim for gratuity shall be invalid merely because the claimant failed to present his application within the specified period. This must be in a juxtaposed with Section 7(2) which requires the employer to make a determination of gratuity payable and to furnish a notice to the employee and to the Controlling Authority as soon as gratuity becomes payable whether or not an application under Section 7(1) has been made. Clearly therefore, the employer cannot set up limitation as a defence on the ground that the application to him was not presented within thirty days. The clear answer to such a defence, if it is set up is that the employer is obliged to determine and make arrangement to pay gratuity whether or not an application is made. The second time period that is prescribed is under Rule 10. Rule 10 inter alia provides a period of 90 days for making an application before the Controlling Authority upon the employer failing to issue a notice as required under Rule 8 upon the receipt of an application from the employee under Rule 7. The delay under Rule 10 can be condoned by the Controlling Authority on sufficient cause being shown.

    11. The rules which were framed in 1972 must be read in a manner which is consistent with the statutory provisions of Section 7 particularly after the amendments that were introduced by Amending Act 25 of 1984 (with effect from 1st April 1984) and by Amending Act 22 of 1987 (with effect from 1st October 1987). The provisions of Section 7 emphasise that the obligation is that of the employer to determine and to make arrangements for the payment of gratuity and upon his failure to do so, to pay interest at the rate which is statutorily prescribed. Even if the period that is prescribed in the Rules is taken into consideration, the Rules themselves lay down that the delay on the part of the employer, if any, can be condoned if sufficient cause is shown. A breach of the employer to comply with his obligation under section 7 provides a recurring and continuous cause of action. The Act is a piece of social welfare legislation and the employer cannot be permitted by reason of his own default in complying with his obligation to defeat the just entitlement of the employee. Finally, it may be noted that the employer has to determine and pay gratuity whether or not an application is filed to him. The filing of an application before the employer is not a condition precedent. Rule 7 makes procedural provisions for such an application. On receipt of an application under Rule 7, the employer has to issue a notice under Rule 8 either admitting the claim or to specify the reasons why he holds the claim inadmissible. It is thereafter that time is prescribed in Rule 10 for an application to the Controlling Authority. The making of an application under Rule 7 therefore invokes a chain of events in Rules 8 and 10. Once the making of an application to the employer is not mandatory under the provisions of Section 7(2) of the substantive provisions of the act, the limitation under the Rules which is triggered upon the filing of the application under Rule 7 can obviously not defeat the claim of the employee.”

    This Court is in agreement with the aforesaid views expressed.

    7. At the same time, it also requires to be mentioned here that in an earlier decision in Madura Coats Ltd., -vs- Assistant Commissioner of Labour [(1993) 3 LLJ 923 Mad], it had been held that an application to condone delay would have to be first decided before the main application for gratuity is taken up for hearing and the said view taken has been approved in M.Devarajulu -vs- Assistant Commissioner of Labour [(1995) 1 LLJ 348 Mad] by the Division Bench of this Court. However, on a perusal of the said decisions, it is evident that the apparent inconsistency of Rule 10 of the Rules with Section 7 of the Act after the amendments made to the Act with effect from 01.10.1987 had neither been raised nor brought to the notice of the Court while deciding those cases. It is needless to recapitulate in this context that a precedent can be an authority only for what has been actually decided and not what may logically flow from it, as explained by the Constitution Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in State of Orissa -vs- Sudhansu Sekhar Misra (AIR 1968 SC 647).

    8. In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court does not find any justification to interfere with the impugned order. The matter shall be listed for hearing before the Second Respondent on 17.02.2021, and the Petitioner and the First Respondent shall appear through their respective Counsel on that date, and the Petitioner shall file its Counter-Affidavit on the merits of the claim in the application for gratuity filed by the First Respondent without fail. If the Second Respondent is not in a position to take up the matter for hearing on that date, it shall inform to all parties concerned of the date of hearing to which it is adjourned in the prescribed manner. The Second Respondent shall afford full opportunity of hearing to all parties concerned following the prescribed procedure in consonance with the principles of natural justice and pass reasoned orders dealing with each of the contentions raised by them on merits and in accordance with law.

    9. In the result, the Writ Petition is dismissed with the aforesaid clarifications. Consequently, the connected Miscellaneous Petitions are closed. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sri Muthukumaran Ins... v. J. Rajalakshmi & Others
    (Oct 1, 2020)