Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • the amended Constitution in terms of the order of this Court dated 4-12-2017
  • the Constitution (unamended)
  • The Sports Code
  • Article 19, Article 33 of the Constitution
  • Nsdci (National Sports Development Code)
  • National Sports Development Code of India, 2011
  • Constitution of AAI
  • Administrator's Constitution (with amendments dated 4-12-2017)
  • Constitution (as amended by him)
  • The National Sports Code
  • Constitution of the World Archery
  • National Sports Code on specified matters
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • The Constitution as amended in terms of order dated 4-12-2017, SCC OnLine SC 1850
  • National Sports Development Code, 2011 (Nsdci)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • the amended Constitution in terms of the order of this Court dated 4-12-2017
  • the Constitution (unamended)
  • The Sports Code
  • Article 19, Article 33 of the Constitution
  • Nsdci (National Sports Development Code)
  • National Sports Development Code of India, 2011
  • Constitution of AAI
  • Administrator's Constitution (with amendments dated 4-12-2017)
  • Constitution (as amended by him)
  • The National Sports Code
  • Constitution of the World Archery
  • National Sports Code on specified matters
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • The Constitution as amended in terms of order dated 4-12-2017, SCC OnLine SC 1850
  • National Sports Development Code, 2011 (Nsdci)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Respondent 1 filed Public Interest Litigation No. 195 of 2010 in the Delhi High Court seeking transparency in the governance of the Archery Association of India (“AAI”). On 10 August 2017, the High Court placed AAI under an Administrator (Mr. S. Y. Quraishi) and directed him to (i) prepare an electoral college, (ii) conduct elections, and (iii) ensure compliance with the National Sports Development Code of India, 2011 (“Sports Code”).

Multiple appeals (SLP (C) Diary Nos. 28788, 29202, 29577 of 2017) were lodged before the Supreme Court by AAI and its State affiliates. On 4 December 2017, the Supreme Court:

  • Approved only four specific amendments to AAI’s constitution identified by the Union Government as inconsistent with the Sports Code;
  • Ordered those four amendments to be “incorporated … as an order of the Court” within one week; and
  • Directed Mr. Quraishi to supervise fresh elections within four weeks.

Instead of following those parameters, the Administrator unilaterally introduced several further amendments (“Administrator’s Constitution”) and conducted elections on 22 December 2018. Numerous applications were then filed by AAI, its State units, the Union of India and the Indian Olympic Association challenging the validity of the amended constitution and the election process. The present judgment resolves those challenges.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Administrator was authorised, under the Supreme Court’s order dated 4 December 2017, to introduce amendments beyond the four specifically approved by the Court.
  2. Whether the elections held on 22 December 2018, based on the “Administrator’s Constitution”, are valid in law.
  3. The consequential status of the additional amendments and of the elected body constituted pursuant to those elections.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments (AAI, MAA, KSAA)

  • The Administrator exceeded the limited mandate of the Supreme Court by unilaterally inserting numerous extra amendments without stakeholder consultation or Court approval.
  • Such action violated members’ rights and prevented eligible representatives from contesting the 2018 elections.
  • All steps taken on the basis of the unauthorized constitution, including the elections, should be declared null and void.
  • Reliance was placed on DDA v. Skipper Construction, Anita International v. Tungabadra Sugar Works Mazdoor Sangh, and Bihari Lal v. Shankar Das to emphasise that acts in disobedience of a court order are void.

Union of India’s Arguments

  • Even after certain amendments, AAI’s constitution still deviated from mandatory provisions of the Sports Code, inter alia regarding secret ballot, delegate strength, affiliation criteria, and honorary life presidents.
  • Sought rectification of these deviations before recognition could be restored to AAI.

Administrator’s Position

  • Contended that the liberty granted in para 6 of the 4 December 2017 order authorised him to ensure full conformity with the Sports Code and therefore to make additional amendments before conducting elections.

Respondent 1 (PIL Petitioner)

  • Supported the Administrator’s efforts as steps towards sports reforms and alignment with the Sports Code.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
DDA v. Skipper Construction Co. (P) Ltd. (1996) 4 SCC 622 Acts done in defiance of a court order are void and non est. Used to support the declaration that the Administrator’s ultra vires amendments and resultant elections are null and void.
Anita International v. Tungabadra Sugar Works Mazdoor Sangh (2016) 9 SCC 44 Illegality of actions contrary to judicial direction. Further foundation for annulling steps taken beyond the Court’s mandate.
Bihari Lal v. Shankar Das, AIR 1925 Lah 309 Consequences of exceeding authorised jurisdiction. Cited to underline that unauthorised acts have no legal effect.
Damyanti Naranga v. Union of India (1971) 1 SCC 678 Right to form and continue an association includes freedom from compulsory alteration of its composition. Relied on to hold that unilateral amendments violated members’ associational rights.
O.K. Ghosh v. E.X. Joseph, 1963 Supp (1) SCR 789 Conditions that impermissibly curtail the right to associate are unconstitutional. Quoted (via Damyanti) to stress that membership rights cannot be restricted by unauthorised rules.
BCCI v. Cricket Association of Bihar (2016) 8 SCC 535 & (2015) 3 SCC 251 Guidelines for sports-body reforms and judicial oversight. Referred to illustrate possible approaches but distinguished, noting cricket is outside the Sports Code schedule.
Sheela Barse v. Union of India (1988) 4 SCC 226;
K. Murugan v. Fencing Association of India (1991) 2 SCC 412
High Court’s powers in public interest litigation over sports governance. Guidance for the Delhi High Court in continuing oversight of the AAI matter.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court analysed the scope of its 4 December 2017 order and held that:

  • The order specifically approved only four amendments and imposed a stringent five-week timeline for elections; it did not authorise any further constitutional changes by the Administrator.
  • Liberty granted to the Administrator (“to see that the Constitution … is strictly in accordance with the Code”) was conditional: any doubts or additional changes had to be brought back to the Court for permission.
  • The Administrator failed to seek such clarification, introduced numerous extra amendments unilaterally, did not circulate them to stakeholders, and conducted elections long after the Court-prescribed schedule.
  • Such actions infringed members’ associational rights as recognised in Damyanti Naranga and O.K. Ghosh and were contrary to the High Court’s and Supreme Court’s directions.
  • Because the Administrator acted under a mistaken belief rather than wilful defiance, no contempt finding was necessary, but legality still required annulment of his acts.

Holding and Implications

HELD: The appeals are allowed.

  • Only the four amendments specified in the Supreme Court’s 4 December 2017 order stand incorporated; all other amendments made by the Administrator are declared “null and void and non est”.
  • The elections conducted on 22 December 2018 and every action based on the Administrator’s Constitution are likewise null and void.
  • The parties revert to the position prevailing on 4 December 2017 after incorporation of the four approved amendments.
  • The High Court–appointed Administrator is relieved; the erstwhile elected body will function as a Committee of Administrators limited to routine affairs until fresh elections are completed within four weeks.
  • The newly elected body may thereafter process any further constitutional amendments following due procedure and National Sports Code requirements, subject to oversight by the Delhi High Court where the PIL remains pending.

Implications: Immediate re-elections must be held under the Court-approved constitution, restoring participatory rights of all recognised State units. The judgment reinforces that court-appointed administrators cannot exceed expressly defined mandates and that sports federations must follow due process and the Sports Code before altering governance structures.

    Maharashtra Archery Association v. Rahul Mehra And Others

    A.M. Khanwilkar, J.— Leave granted. Respondent 1 has filed a public interest litigation before the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi, being Writ Petition (Civil) No. 195 of 2010, raising issues of transparency in governance and functioning of the Archery Association of India (for short “AAI”). Several interim orders came to be passed in the said writ petition which are not relevant for answering the controversy in the present proceedings. The present special leave petitions emanate from the order dated 10-8-2017 2017 SCC OnLine Del 9747 passed by the High Court in CM No. 10461 of 2017 filed by Respondent 1 (writ petitioner) inter alia for appointment of Administrator/Returning Officer including to conduct elections of AAI in compliance with the High Court's order dated 15-12-2016 2016 SCC OnLine Del 6610, as well as stay of notice dated 2-3-2017 of AAI, calling for an emergency meeting of the General Council on 15-3-2017 and, in the alternative, to stay the outcome of such meeting if held, till the Court appoints an Administrator/Returning Officer.

    2. The High Court after hearing the parties passed the following order : (Rahul Mehra case 2017 SCC OnLine Del 9747, SCC OnLine Del paras 20-23)

    “20. In the circumstances, the court deems it appropriate that the affairs of the Archery Association of India (AAI) be brought under the supervision of an Administrator till its Constitution is amended and elections are held in terms of this Court's order dated 15-12-2016 2016 SCC OnLine Del 6610. The court also deems it appropriate that for the present, the affairs and elections of AAI be conducted by a person of public eminence with significant experience in sports affairs and administration and elections. We are of the opinion that Mr S.Y. Quraishi, Former Chief Election Commissioner of India, who has also served as Secretary in the Ministry of Youth Affairs and Sports, Government of India would be a suitable person to be appointed as the Administrator-cum-Returning Officer for discharge of the following functions :
    (i) To resolve the issue of disaffiliation of such members/units of AAI as on 15-12-2016, within a month from today by giving them two weeks' notice and if their membership can be regularised in terms of the “unamended” Constitution, it shall be so regularised;
    (ii) The Electoral College of AAI shall be prepared and elections shall be held in six weeks thereafter. This elected body shall carry out the amendments to the Constitution to bring it in conformity with the National Sports Code.
    (iii) Thereafter, a fresh round of elections, shall be carried out as per the amended Constitution and in terms of the National Sports Code, to ensure that age and tenure restrictions and due representation of the sports persons are strictly complied with. The entire exercise shall be carried out within a period of 4 months from today.
    (iv) AAI shall make available to the Administrator an appropriate office space and facilities for the discharge of the aforesaid directions and make available such staff and personnel as the Administrator may express the need for. Alternatively, the Administrator may appoint such personnel to assist him in the aforesaid matter and expenses towards the same shall be borne by AAI.
    (v) Till the elections are conducted and results declared in consonance of the National Sports Code and in compliance with the preceding directions, AAI shall not make any new financial commitments except with the prior approval of the Administrator. Routine expenses of AAI too shall be defrayed, with the due prior approval of the Administrator.
    21. The applicant and AAI shall seek consent of Mr S.Y. Quraishi, of his acceptance of the aforementioned responsibility.
    22. The court would consider fixing an honorarium for the Administrator's assignment at a later date.
    23. The application is disposed of in the above terms.”

    3. This decision is assailed by way of an appeal [arising out of SLP (C) Diary No. 29577 of 2017] filed by Maharashtra Archery Association (for short “MAA”), appeal [arising out of SLP (C) Diary No. 28788 of 2017] filed by the Archery Association of India (for short “AAI”), and the appeal [arising out of SLP (C) Diary No. 29202 of 2017] filed by Kerala State Archery Association (for short “KSAA”). When these special leave petitions came up for hearing on 18-9-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1848, the Court recorded the submission of the appellant(s) that the Constitution of AAI stood amended in accordance with the National Sports Development Code of India, 2011 (for short “the Sports Code”). The counsel appearing for Union of India prayed for time to verify the said position. Later, this Court directed 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1849 the Ministry of Sports to file an affidavit regarding compliance, on or before 26-10-2017. Eventually, the affidavit of the competent officer of the Ministry of Youth Affairs and Sports, Government of India, came to be filed. It is not necessary for us to dilate on the contents of the said affidavit. For, the matters were heard on 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850 whence, after hearing the parties, the Court proceeded to pass the following order : (Maharashtra Archery Assn. case 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850, SCC OnLine SC paras 1-7)

    “1. Heard Mr Sunil Gupta, learned Senior Counsel and Mr Salwan, learned counsel for the petitioners; Mr Narasimha, learned Additional Solicitor General for the Union of India and Mr Rahul Mehra, respondent appearing in person.
    2. It is submitted by Mr Narasimha, learned Additional Solicitor General that though certain amendments have been carried out in the Constitution, yet they are not in consonance with the National Sports Development Code, 2011 (Nsdci) of the MYAS. In the affidavit filed by the Union of India, certain deviations have been pointed out. They read as follows:
    ‘(i) Nsdci provides that the election of office-bearer of an NSF shall be conducted in accordance with the Model Election Bye-laws of Nsdci, copy whereof is annexed herewith and marked Annexure R/3 [pp. 12 to 51]. As per the provisions of the said election bye-laws, the Office-Bearer and Members of the Managing Committee shall be elected by secret ballot. However, the Constitution of AAI provides that election of office-bearers of AAI shall be held as per the rules and regulations which may be adopted by the General Council, and there is no mention in the Constitution of AAI that such election shall be held by secret ballot.
    (ii) As per the principles underlying Nsdci, an affiliated member of a National Sports Federation (NSF) i.e. a full member of NSF, should be represented by two delegates in the General Council (by whatever name called). The Constitution of AAI shows each State Association has been given representation of three delegates in the General Council i.e. one representative over and above the minimum of two representatives.
    (iii) Nsdci provides that an NSF shall give affiliation as a full member to a State Association if such State Association has at least 50% of the district units functioning in that State as per Para 3.10 and Para 3.19 of Annexure II of the Code. But no such stipulation is found in the eligibility conditions for affiliation of State Associations as members of AAI.
    (iv) The Constitution of AAI also makes a provision that up to three persons may be bestowed the title of Honorary Life President of AAI, without voting rights, in recognition of the services rendered by past Presidents of AAI. Nsdci is silent on the matter.’
    3. Mr Gupta, learned Senior Counsel and Mr Salwan, learned counsel for the petitioners fairly stated that the amendment shall be carried out keeping in view the said deviations within a week hence.
    4. In view of the aforesaid, it is directed that amendment shall be incorporated by treating it as an order of the Court. After the Constitution comes into force, election shall be held under the supervision of Mr S.Y. Quraishi who has been appointed as the Administrator by the High Court, within four weeks therefrom. Mr Quraishi is requested to see that the election takes place in accordance with the amended Constitution which stands amended by incorporation by virtue of order passed by this Court, as agreed to by learned counsel for the parties.
    5. The amended Constitution shall be filed before this Court and a copy whereof be supplied to Mr Narasimha, learned Additional Solicitor General and Mr Rahul Mehra, respondent-in-person. But the filing of the amended Constitution will not postpone the election, as directed hereinabove. To elaborate, amendment shall be incorporated stating the same as an order of the Court within a week hence and thereafter Mr Quraishi shall proceed to hold the election in accordance with the Constitution which will come into existence by virtue of the order passed today.
    6. Mr Quraishi shall be at liberty to see that the Constitution of the Association is strictly in accordance with the Code and thereafter proceed with the election. If he has any reservation, he is at liberty to move this Court.
    7. List after eight weeks.”
    (emphasis supplied)

    4. As a matter of fact, the contentious issues regarding the relevant amendment carried out to the Constitution of AAI stood resolved in terms of this order. Further, this Court issued certain peremptory directions to the Administrator to ensure compliance thereof within the timeline specified in the order. The appeals could have been disposed of in terms of the said order 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850 itself, but the same were kept pending with a sanguine hope that the directions given therein would be complied with within the time-frame specified in the order and that the compliance report would be submitted by the Administrator in that regard. The appellant (AAI) filed an application before this Court on 11-12-2017, being IA No. 135882 of 2017 and placed on record the final amended Constitution in terms of the order of this Court dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850. The appellant (AAI) then filed a separate IA No. 132436 of 2018 on 13-9-2018, seeking directions to hold elections as per the Court approved Constitution.

    5. The Administrator, Mr S.Y. Quraishi, appointed by the High Court finally filed a compliance report in the Registry of this Court on 24-9-2018, being Document No. 139081 of 2018 in appeal arising from SLP (C) Diary No. 29577 of 2017, together with the new Constitution (for short “Administrator's Constitution”). Be it noted that, admittedly, the Constitution filed by the Administrator contained several other amendments than the permitted or approved amendments in terms of the order of this Court dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850. It is also not in dispute that no formal application has been moved by the Administrator (appointed by the High Court) before this Court seeking liberty to amend the Constitution beyond the amendments referred to in the order of this Court dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850. Further, no direction was sought from this Court to permit the Administrator to conduct elections on the basis of the amendments incorporated by him in the new Constitution. The grievance of the appellants is that this amended Administrator's Constitution was not even circulated to the constituent members until it came to be filed in this Court.

    6. Thus, the grievance of the appellant(s) is that the Administrator had carried out amendments beyond what was permitted and approved by this Court in terms of the order dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850, that too without any discussion with the members and stakeholders. That Constitution however, came to be notified for the first time on 4-10-2018, through e-mail to the members — State Association(s) along with a notice for election for the office-bearers of AAI to be conducted by the Administrator on 22-12-2018, at 11.00 a.m.

    7. The appellant (AAI) immediately rushed to this Court by way of IA No. 15611 of 2018, seeking directions to the Administrator to conduct elections in conformity with the Court approved Constitution and seeking further directions to the Union of India to restore recognition of AAI which was de-recognised on 17-12-2012. That application was moved for passing suitable directions by this Court on 19-11-2018 2018 SCC OnLine SC 3303, when the Court, after hearing the parties, passed the following order : (Maharashtra Archery Assn. case 2018 SCC OnLine SC 3303, SCC OnLine SC paras 1-4)

    “1. Since the election programme has already commenced in terms of notice dated 4-10-2018, the same should proceed as per law uninterrupted.
    2. We clarify that the result of the election will be subject to the outcome of this application.
    3. The grievance made in this application inter alia about improper amendments to the Constitution can be considered at a later stage.
    4. List this application in the second week of February 2019.”
    (emphasis supplied)

    8. Resultantly, the election process was concluded in accordance with the Administrator's Constitution and not as per the amended Constitution in terms of the order of this Court dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850. As a result, the representatives of the appellant Association(s) could not contest the election due to the restrictions prescribed in the Administrator's Constitution.

    9. The Union of India has also filed a separate application being IA No. 15103 of 2019 on 24-1-2019, raising objections to the Administrator's Constitution being in violation of the Sports Code. Even the Indian Olympic Association (for short “IOA”) has filed Document No. 24274 of 2018 on 8-2-2019, objecting to the Administrator's Constitution being in violation of the Sports Code and the Constitution of the World Archery. Another application has been filed by Kerala State Archery Association (“KSAA”), being IA No. 30011 of 2019 on 18-2-2019, for directions to declare that the elections conducted by the Administrator on the basis of the Administrator's Constitution, is null and void and to appoint a new Returning Officer to hold fresh elections in consonance with the Court approved Constitution, in terms of the order dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850. The appellant (MAA) has also filed an application on 1-3-2019, being IA No. 3792 of 2019 seeking a direction to declare the Administrator's Constitution as void ab initio and to appoint a Returning Officer/Observer to conduct fresh election for AAI in terms of the Court approved Constitution as per order dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850. The Union of India, as per the liberty given by this Court, has filed an affidavit on 5-3-2019 highlighting the deviations in the Administrator's Constitution and the Sports Code.

    10. During the course of hearing of these matters, before closing the matter for judgment, the Court called upon the Administrator, appointed by the High Court, to submit a flowchart pointing out the steps taken by him from 4-12-2017 till 22-12-2018, until the election of the new body. The Administrator has accordingly filed a compilation giving details about the follow-up steps taken by him in that regard.

    11. We have heard Mr K.M. Natarajan, learned Additional Solicitor General appearing for Union of India, Mr Shyam Divan, Mr Sunil Gupta, Mr Siddharth Dave, Mr Shekhar Naphade, Mr Gopal Sankaranarayanan, learned counsel appearing for the respective parties and Mr Rahul Mehra, Respondent 1 appearing-in-person.

    12. The core issue to be answered in these proceedings is about the purport of the order passed by this Court on 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850. The background in which the said order came to be passed after hearing the parties, leaves no manner of doubt that it had modified the impugned order of the High Court dated 10-8-2017 2017 SCC OnLine Del 9747. Further, the contentious issues regarding the proposed amendment in the Constitution stood answered to that extent. In that, this Court passed a peremptory order not only for approving the proposed amendments, as noted in the order dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850, but also directed the Administrator to conduct elections in consonance thereto within a period of four weeks, after incorporating the amendments within one week from the date of the order. That was the limited mandate given to the Administrator. Indeed, this Court had given liberty to the Administrator to seek clarification or directions if and when necessary. That liberty, however, by no stretch of imagination could be mistaken as authorising the Administrator to carry out amendments in the Constitution beyond the four amendments referred to in the order dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850, much less to do so unilaterally without any prior notice to all the stakeholders and due deliberations with them as mandated by the Constitution of AAI. In any case, any further amendments to the Constitution could be incorporated only after taking prior permission of this Court which was still in seisin of the matter. The Administrator was also ill-advised not to seek extension of time for completion of election process, which was to be completed not later than five weeks from 4-12-2017.

    13. The stand taken by the Administrator is that the order dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850 gave him liberty to ensure that the Constitution of the Association is strictly in accordance with the Sports Code and only thereafter to proceed with the election. Indeed, liberty was given to the Administrator in the last paragraph of the order dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850. However, the order if read as a whole and keeping in mind the spirit of the order, it had directed the Administrator to ensure timely completion of election within five weeks from the date of the order on the basis of four amendments approved by the Court, which were required to be incorporated by the Administrator within one week from the date of the order. No more and no less. For any other doubt or deviation, the Administrator was obliged to seek clarification and appropriate directions from this Court, before the expiry of the timeline given in the order dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850. The Administrator, however, merely filed a compliance report on 24-9-2018, in the Registry of this Court without attempting even once to invite the attention of this Court thereto. The Administrator has also filed a further report in terms of the order dated 28-3-2019 2019 SCC OnLine SC 730. On perusal of the said reports, we may hasten to accept the plea that the steps taken by the Administrator were under a mistaken belief — that he had the authority to proceed in the manner that he did and including to amend the Constitution beyond the four amendments referred to in the order dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850. It is not a case of defiance or disobedience of the Court's order as such.

    14. The appellant(s) would contend that even if it is not a case of intentional disobedience of the order of this Court by the Administrator, however, since steps taken by him are not in conformity with the spirit of the directions given by the Court, the same be declared as null and void and non est. For, his actions had caused serious prejudice owing to the unilateral, unauthorised action taken by him, including of having deprived the members of the appellant Association(s) from representing and participating in the election process of the apex body, which they were otherwise entitled to under the Constitution, as approved by this Court in terms of the order dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850. All this having been done by the Court appointed Administrator, in the guise of an order of this Court, the Court must step in and nullify all the actions taken by the Administrator which are beyond the scope of the order dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850. To buttress this submission, reliance has been placed on DDA v. Skipper Construction Co. (P) Ltd. (1996) 4 SCC 622, Anita International v. Tungabadra Sugar Works Mazdoor Sangh (2016) 9 SCC 44 and Bihari Lal v. Shankar Das AIR 1925 Lah 309 (2), 1924 SCC OnLine Lah 378.

    15. We are in agreement with the stand taken by the appellant(s) that the Administrator could have taken only such steps as were permitted by this Court vide order dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850, in their letter and spirit. Indisputably, the additional amendments incorporated by the Administrator have resulted in denial of right to represent in and contest elections of AAI for the existing members. Notably, even the direction given by the High Court whilst appointing the Administrator vide the impugned judgment 2017 SCC OnLine Del 9747, in no way gave authority to the Administrator to amend the Constitution, but was limited to conduct elections on the basis of the Constitution as it stood then. As ordered by the High Court, it was for the newly elected body to take steps in the right earnest to amend the Constitution to bring it in line with the National Sports Code on specified matters and then to conduct fresh elections on the basis of such amended Constitution. In other words, the Constitution could be amended only in accordance with law, which means by the elected body after interacting with all the stakeholders and members. The Administrator had no power to amend the Constitution, much less unilaterally, except for the four amendments approved by this Court, for which no further formality was required to be undertaken. The Administrator was obliged to conduct elections on the basis of such amended Constitution in terms of the order of this Court dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850. No more and no less.

    16. The appellants have rightly invited our attention to the decision of the Constitution Bench of this Court in Damyanti Naranga v. Union of India (1971) 1 SCC 678, which had approved the exposition in O.K. Ghosh v. E.X. Joseph 1963 Supp (1) SCR 789, AIR 1963 SC 812. In that case, this Court had held that the right to form an Association was conditioned by the existence of the recognition of the said Association by the Government. In that case the Court had held : (O.K. Ghosh case 1963 Supp (1) SCR 789, AIR 1963 SC 812, AIR p. 815, para 11)

    “11. It is not disputed that the Fundamental Rights guaranteed by Article 19 can be claimed by government servants. Article 33 which confers power on the Parliament to modify the rights in their application to the Armed Forces, clearly brings out the fact that all citizens, including government servants, are entitled to claim the rights guaranteed by Article 19. Thus, the validity of the impugned rule has to be judged on the basis that the respondent and his co-employees are entitled to form associations or unions. It is clear that Rule 4-B imposes a restriction on this right. It virtually compels a government servant to withdraw his membership of the Service Association of government servants as soon as recognition accorded to the said association is withdraw or if, after the association is formed, no recognition is accorded to it within six months. In other words, the right to form an association is conditioned by the existence of the recognition of the said association by the Government. If the association obtains the recognition and continues to enjoy it, government servants can become members of the said association; if the association does not secure recognition from the Government or recognition granted to it is withdrawn, government servants must cease to be the members of the said association. That is the plain effect of the impugned rule.”

    17. This dictum in O.K. Ghosh case 1963 Supp (1) SCR 789, AIR 1963 SC 812 was quoted with approval by the Constitution Bench in Damyanti Naranga (1971) 1 SCC 678 to conclude that the right to form an Association included the right to its continuance and any law altering the composition of the Association compulsorily will be a breach of the right to form the Association. Thus understood, the steps taken by the Administrator beyond the scope of the authority bestowed upon him in terms of the order of this Court dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850, cannot be validated by the Court but must be treated as non est in law. It would have been a different matter if the Administrator had presented the additional amendments before this Court and invited this Court to approve the same after hearing the parties concerned.

    18. Be that as it may, the question as to whether the amendments incorporated by the Administrator are justified and proper or, so to speak, essential as per the exposition of this Court in BCCI v. Cricket Assn. of Bihar (2016) 8 SCC 535, need not detain us. For, the further amendments to the Constitution could be effected only in the manner provided by the Constitution of AAI including in terms of the order dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850. It is thus not necessary for us to examine as to whether, in fact, there is any deviation or not from the dispensation predicated in the National Sports Code, as contended by the respondents and the counsel appearing for the Administrator.

    19. For the time being, without any hesitation, we are of the considered opinion that all steps taken by the Administrator, including the elections conducted by him on the basis of the Constitution (as amended by him), will have to be treated as null and void and non est in law. The parties will have to be relegated to the position as on 4-12-2017, consequent to incorporation of the four amendments approved in terms of the same order. After carrying out those four amendments in the Constitution, the election will have to be conducted to constitute the new body, which would then take steps to introduce further amendments to the Constitution, if so required, to bring it in line with the National Sports Code, after giving an opportunity to all concerned. Only after the amendments are accepted and approved, fresh elections be conducted for constituting a new body in conformity with such duly amended Constitution.

    20. In reference to certain apprehensions expressed by the respondents due to reactions of the World Archery body, we must observe that the controversy cannot be adjudicated on the basis of perception of the World Archery body. Similarly, we do not wish to expand the scope of the present proceedings as the main writ petition is still pending before the High Court of Delhi, where all issues can be deliberated and answered appropriately. While doing so, the High Court, no doubt, would be guided by the exposition in Sheela Barse v. Union of India (1988) 4 SCC 226, K. Murugan v. Fencing Assn. of India (1991) 2 SCC 412 and BCCI v. Cricket Assn. of Bihar (2015) 3 SCC 251, on which reliance has been placed by the counsel representing the newly elected body of AAI and the respondents, for issuing appropriate directions in a public interest litigation. In other words, the High Court will examine all aspects of the matter on their own merits in accordance with law.

    21. We make it clear that the High Court may also consider the stand taken by the appellant(s) and Union of India that the decision of this Court in BCCI (2016) 8 SCC 535 will be of no avail to the present case, because the National Sports Code takes within its fold fifty-two disciplines of sports and Cricket is not one of the scheduled sports. In other words, the dispensation to be followed must be in conformity with the National Sports Code insofar as AAI is concerned. We keep this issue open to be considered at the appropriate stage.

    22. In view of the above, we dispose of these appeals and all the applications on the following basis:

    22.1. We declare that the Constitution of AAI is amended only to the extent of four amendments referred to in the order dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850, treating it as amended by an order of this Court, without requiring to comply with any other formality. Rest of the amendments are declared as null and void and non est in law. The same, at best, may be pursued as a proposal to be considered after the newly elected body initiates a procedure for carrying out further amendments to the Constitution of AAI as per law.

    22.2. We further declare that all steps taken by the Administrator on the basis of the Administrator's Constitution, including the elections conducted on 22-12-2018, are null and void and non est in law.

    22.3. All parties concerned are relegated to the position as it stood after the incorporation of the four amendments referred to in the order dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850. Further, the High Court-appointed Administrator stands relieved in terms of this order. The elected body, in office, would continue to function hereafter as a Committee of Administrators appointed in terms of this order. We deem it appropriate to allow this Committee to continue in office as nothing adverse has been brought to our notice for their continuation until the newly elected body takes over. However, the Committee shall discharge only routine and day-to-day activities and shall not take any policy decision or create new financial liability, until the newly elected body takes over.

    22.4. The election for constituting the new elected body be completed by the aforementioned Committee appointed by this Court within four weeks from today and the election process must be conducted strictly in accordance with the Constitution as amended in terms of order dated 4-12-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1850.

    22.5. The newly elected body, after taking over the office, shall move a proposal for further amendment of the Constitution to bring it in line with the National Sports Code and that process be taken to its logical end expeditiously.

    22.6. Any issue arising from such amendment may be raised before the High Court where the main matter i.e. Writ Petition (Civil) No. 195 of 2010 is pending. That writ petition be decided on its own merits and in accordance with law.

    22.7. The Committee shall submit a compliance report before the High Court immediately after the newly elected body takes over the office but not later than six weeks from today. Issues concerning the said report may also be considered by the High Court on their own merits in accordance with law.

    23. The appeals are allowed in the aforementioned terms. All the applications are disposed of.

    24. While parting, we place on record our word of appreciation for the services rendered by the High Court appointed Administrator Mr S.Y. Quraishi. We also appreciate the sincere effort of Respondent 1 for the cause of sports and for introducing reforms in the functioning of the apex body (AAI).

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Maharashtra Archery Association v. Rahul Mehra And Others
    (May 1, 2019)