Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 2 of the Epidemic Disease Act, 1897, issued G.O.Ms. No.152,
  • Section 144 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.(ix)
  • Section 2 of the Epidemic Disease Act, 1897. Due
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 2 of the Epidemic Disease Act, 1897, issued G.O.Ms. No.152,
  • Section 144 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.(ix)
  • Section 2 of the Epidemic Disease Act, 1897. Due
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Writ Petition Challenging Press Release No.265 dated 12.04.2020

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition is a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking issuance of writs (certiorari and mandamus) calling for the records of Press Release No.265 dated 12.04.2020 issued by the fifth respondent and quashing that press release. The petitioner also sought a direction forbidding respondents from interfering with the petitioner’s public welfare activities, including the distribution of cooked food, food items, food grains, groceries, vegetables, medical kits and so on to needy persons within Tamil Nadu during the COVID-19 lockdown.

The petitioner is the Organising Secretary of Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK). The factual backdrop includes: the WHO declaration regarding COVID-19; state lockdown orders issued under Section 2 of the Epidemic Disease Act, 1897; initial restrictions and later permissions for delivery of food by aggregators; severe hardship to daily wage earners, migrant workers and others leading to charitable distributions by the petitioner party and others; and a press release dated 12.04.2020 by the fifth respondent prescribing regulatory measures for distribution of food and other items during the lockdown, including requirements for handing over items to specified government officials and obtaining prior permission.

The petition challenges those regulatory conditions as unreasonable and unlawful; the case proceeded on oral arguments by senior counsel for the petitioner and the Advocate General for the State. The court heard the parties and issued a considered order disposing of the writ petition subject to specified directions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Press Release No.265 dated 12.04.2020 (issued by the fifth respondent) imposing regulatory measures on distribution of food and essential items during the COVID-19 lockdown is legally valid and liable to be quashed.
  2. Whether the State may, consistent with the objective of preventing spread of COVID-19, require prior permission/intimation and other conditions for charitable distribution of food and essential items, including whether a requirement to hand over distributed items to designated government officers is permissible.
  3. What regulatory measures (if any) are constitutionally permissible to ensure public health while permitting charitable food distribution during the lockdown?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (Senior Counsel Mr. Wilson)

  • The conditions imposed by the State (in particular, requiring prior permission from District authorities and the requirement to hand over food to certain government officers) are unreasonable, arbitrary and illegal.
  • The petitioner party has observed and will continue to observe social distancing and other health norms during distribution; local police maintained vigil during such distributions.
  • Obtaining prior permission from the District authority is unnecessary and causes undue hardship because many people are starving and need timely distribution of food and essentials.
  • Timely serving of food and essential commodities is an inevitable charitable measure; regulations that unduly restrict it ought to be struck down by the Court.

State's Arguments (Advocate General)

  • The State is combating an infectious disease and must take measures to curb its spread; unregulated gatherings during distribution of food can cause disease transmission.
  • Instances exist where organisers have gathered large crowds at distributions, increasing the risk of spreading COVID-19; therefore regulation of such activities is justified to prevent further infections.
  • The measures in the press release are regulatory (to ensure compliance with health norms) rather than prohibitory of charitable distribution; the State bears vicarious responsibility for controlling spread and thus must impose reasonable conditions.
  • Given the magnitude and contagion risk, certain stringent measures are inevitable and in public interest; the restrictions are reasonable and the petition should be dismissed.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by acknowledging the unprecedented public health crisis caused by COVID-19 and the consequential lockdown measures invoked under Section 2 of the Epidemic Disease Act, 1897. It recognized the severe hardship faced by daily wage earners, migrant workers and persons below the poverty line, and acknowledged the important role of volunteers, NGOs and political organisations in feeding the needy.

The court explained the State's legitimate concern that unregulated distribution of food and essential items could defeat the object of the lockdown by causing crowding and leading to spread of the virus. The press release of 12.04.2020 was evaluated against this backdrop: the court accepted that the State was entitled to impose conditions to prevent the spread of infection.

The court performed a focused analysis of specific conditions imposed by the press release. It found the requirement of prior intimation/permission to District authorities to be reasonable and not arbitrary in the circumstances, as such regulation would assist authorities to ensure compliance with health and safety norms and to control potential crowding. By contrast, the court held that the particular condition that charitable distributors must hand over food/groceries to the Commissioner or other government instrumentalities before distribution was "not well founded" and therefore unacceptable.

On balance, the court considered measures necessary to reconcile two competing public interests: (1) enabling charitable distribution to the needy during an acute crisis, and (2) preventing gatherings that could accelerate the spread of COVID-19. To achieve that balance, the court formulated detailed directions grounded in public-health regulatory concerns rather than an absolute prohibition on charitable distributions.

The court explicitly limited distribution in certain ways (e.g., prohibiting distribution in government-identified hot spots, confining activity to specified local zones) and imposed administrative safeguards (e.g., 48-hour prior intimation, food-safety inspection, sanitation, limits on the number of organisers and vehicle occupants, adherence to social distancing and Section 144 preventive measures). It also allowed District authorities discretion to impose further reasonable conditions.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF

Holding (core ruling): The writ petition is disposed of subject to the court's observations and directions. The court upheld the State's power to impose reasonable regulatory conditions to prevent spread of COVID-19 but struck down the specific condition requiring handing over of food to designated government officers. Instead, the court mandated a set of procedural and safety measures which, if complied with, permit organised distribution of food and essentials.

Immediate consequences for the parties:

  • The petitioner organisation and similar entities are permitted to distribute food and other materials provided they comply with the court's directions (including 48-hour prior intimation and food-safety inspection, restrictions on areas such as government-designated hot spots, time limits, sanitation, limits on organisers present, and strict observance of social distancing).
  • The State may continue to regulate and, where reasonable, impose additional conditions to ensure distributions do not contribute to spread of the virus; District authorities have discretion to impose further reasonable conditions and to extend distribution time by one or two hours in appropriate cases.
  • The specific condition in the press release requiring handing over of items to government officers before distribution has been rejected by the court as not well founded.
  • No order as to costs; connected miscellaneous petitions closed.

Broader implications: The opinion balances public-health regulatory authority with the need to permit charitable relief during an emergency. The text does not state that a new legal precedent is being laid down; rather, it sets case-specific directions for how charitable distributions may be conducted during the present emergency.

    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam rep. by its Organising Secretary R.S. Bharathi "Anna Arivalayam" Chennai v. The State of Tamil Nadu rep. by its Chief Secretary to Government Secretariat, Chennai & Others

    (Prayer: Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of The Constitution of India praying to issue a Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus calling for the records of the fifth respondent pertaining to Press Release No.265 dated 12.04.2020 and quash the same, and consequently forbear the respondents from in any way interfering with the public welfare measures of the Petitioner including distribution of cooked food, food items, food grains, groceries, vegetables, medical kits and so on and so forth to the needy within the State of Tamil Nadu during the lockdown period due to COVID-19.)

    The petitioner has filed this writ petition questioning the legality and/or validity of the Press Release No.265 dated 12.04.2020 issued by the first respondent and quash the same, and consequently forbear the respondents from in any way interfering with the public welfare measures carried out by the Petitioner, including distribution of cooked food, food items, food grains, groceries, vegetables, medical kits and so on and so forth to the needy within the State of Tamil Nadu during the lock down period due to COVID-19.

    2. The petitioner is the Organising Secretary of Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam, a major political party founded in the year 1949. The Petitioner party is the principal opposition party in the legislative assembly of Tamil Nadu and playing a constructive role in safeguarding the interests of the people of the State. According to the petitioner, the World Health Organisation (WHO) declared the recent COVID-19 epidemic affecting 114 Countries in the World, including India, as a Public Health Emergency of International Concern (PHEIC) and has also characterised it as a controllable pandemic. Pursuant to the WHO warning, the Country has observed one day self-imposed quarantine on 22.03.2020 and on 23.03.2020, the second respondent, invoking the powers under Section 2 of the Epidemic Disease Act, 1897, issued G.O.Ms. No.152, dated 23.03.2020 imposing restrictions within the territorial jurisdiction of the State of Tamil Nadu from 24.03.2020 to 01.04.2020. However, during such lock down, the State permitted commercial and private establishments dealing with food and other essential commodities to function. However, home delivery of food items through aggregators like Swiggy, Zomato, Uber Eats etc., were prohibited.

    3. It is the further case of the petitioner party that the Government subsequently passed various orders extending the period of lock down for 21 days from 25.03.2020. However, on 27.03.2020, orders were issued permitting the delivery of food items through aggregators like Swiggy, Zomato, Uber Eats etc., fixing the time of operation between 7 am to 9.30 am and 12.00 noon to 2.30 pm from 29.03.2020, thus the delivery of cooked food was allowed by the State. As the lock down was in force from 25.03.2020, many of the people belonging to lower strata of the society, back ward and oppressed classes, migrant workers, labourers, workers in the unorganised sectors were badly hit as they could not eke out their livelihood and consequently, they were made to starve. It is in this context, the petitioner party had undertaken various philanthropic measures such as distribution of food to the needy, personal preventive equipment such as hand gloves, sanitizers etc., through their party workers. Further, tens of thousands of people requested the petitioner party to supply daily rations, food, medicines etc., Therefore, the petitioner party had distributed food, groceries, vegetables etc., While so, according to the petitioner party, the restrictions imposed by the State to obtain prior permission from the District authorities concerned before effecting distribution of food to the poor and needy is unwarranted as it is causing immense hardship to them and therefore the present writ petition is filed.

    4. Mr. Wilson, learned Senior counsel for the petitioner would vehemently contend that the restrictions imposed by the State in effecting distribution of food, groceries and vegetable to the poor and needy is unreasonable, arbitrary and illegal. It is his contention that the petitioner party, during the distribution of food and other essential items have always maintained social distancing norms and will continue to do so. Further, during such distribution of food by the petitioner party, the local police always maintained a vigil and there was no occasion for the petitioner party to flout any of the norms. At the same time, obtaining prior permission from the District authority before effecting distribution of food is unwarranted, especially when there were several people who are starving due to nonavailability of food. It is his contention that timely serving of food and other essential commodities is one of the inevitable measures undertaken by the petitioner party and any restriction in the guise of regulating the distribution of food by the State has to be interfered with by this Court.

    5. Opposing the prayer sought for by the petitioner party, the learned Advocate General would contend that the State is fighting against an invisible enemy and taking several measures to curb the spread of the disease any further. The learned Advocate General cited several instances where the organisers gather huge crowd during the distribution of food and other items and submitted that there is every likelihood that such crowd could lead to spread of the disease. Therefore, the Government thought it fit to impose certain restrictions or regulations in the matter of distribution of food and it cannot be construed as the one to prevent the distribution of food to the poor and needy. The restrictions imposed by the State has to be scrupulously followed by every one so that the spread of the disease can be curtailed. Even if one person in the crowd is infected with the virus, he or she can inflict several others and in such event, the Government will find it very difficult to quarantine each and every one in their effort to curb the disease. In that event, it is the State which has to be made vicariously liable for the spread of the disease and the organisers who served food cannot be made liable. The learned Advocate General also would contend that the charitable activities done by the philanthropists during the natural calamity witnessed by the State earlier in the form of flood and cyclone have not been curbed or curtailed in any manner. However, taking note of the magnitude of the spread of the Virus, certain stringent measures are inevitable in the present situation. The learned Advocate General also would contend that the Government, in the best interest of the citizens as a whole has imposed certain restrictions with an avowed object of preventing the further spread of the virus. If the distribution of food goes unregulated or unrestricted, it is likely that the virus will spread from one person to another like a wild fire and in such event, the very purpose and object of lock down imposed by the Government will be defeated. Thus, it is submitted by the learned Advocate General that the restrictions imposed by the State are reasonable and he prayed for dismissal of this writ petition.

    6. We have heard the learned Senior counsel for the petitioner and the learned Advocate General appearing for the respondents.

    7. The State is witnessing an unprecedented situation due to spread of a malevolent disease called COVID-19 - Corona Virus. In order to curb the spread of such disease, the State Government, as directed by the Central Government, has imposed a lock down by invoking Section 2 of the Epidemic Disease Act, 1897. Due to such lock down, it is no doubt true that number of citizens could not eke out their livelihood by stepping out of their home. Several thousands were rendered jobless, particularly the daily wage earners, contract labourers, migrant workers etc., are the worst affected. The citizens who are living below the poverty line find it difficult to get a square meal a day. In this grim situation, public spirited persons have taken up the task of feeding the poor by engaging them in charitable activities. It is no doubt true that the Government cannot feed the entire masses during this extreme situation and the support of the Volunteers, Non-governmental Organisation, individuals is inevitable. However, the Government apprehends that such poor feeding or distribution of food packets should not defeat the very object of the lock down imposed by the Government as a measure of combating the dreaded virus. It is in this direction that a press release dated 12.04.2020 was issued by the fifth respondent by which certain regulatory measures were issued. As per the press statement, the political parties or charitable organisations should not distribute food, groceries, vegetables or other such items to the public directly and it has to be handed over to the Corporation Commissioner or President or Executive Officers or Block Development Officer of the Town Panchayats. Such a condition, according to the petitioner, is unreasonable, arbitrary and illegal.

    8. It is the contention of the learned Senior counsel for the petitioner that the petitioner party is ready and willing to intimate the local police or authorities about the distribution of the food, grocery or vegetables in advance, however, the requirement to obtain prior permission from the authorities concerned is not necessary. This is countered by the learned Advocate General appearing for the State by contending that the State has a vicarious responsibility to prevent the spread of Virus. According to the learned Advocate General, the State is not preventing any individual or group of individuals from distributing food, vegetables or groceries, but it has to be regulated by requiring the individual or group of individuals from adhering to certain norms to ensure that there is no further spread of the Virus. It is also his contention that if there is no regulation and the distribution of food, vegetables and groceries goes unchecked or unregulated, certainly, the huge crowd that gathers for receipt of the freebies will be prone to spread of virus. Therefore, the learned Advocate General justifies the conditions imposed by the State with an intention to regulate the distribution of freebies and they are not meant to prevent it.

    9. Having considered the above submissions, we are of the view that in the course of distribution of food or other items, the State is wholly justified in imposing certain conditions. We also do not see any irrationality or arbitrariness in requiring the individual or group of individuals from seeking prior permission from the authorities concerned. At the same time, the requirement to handover the food items to the Commissioner or other instrumentalities of the Government is not well founded. Having regard to the magnitude of the situation, which the State is presently combating, it is very much essential that the organisers or the beneficiaries must strictly adhere to certain norms with a view to regulate the distribution of food and other items. Such a condition was issued only to ensure that there will not be any further spread of the malevolent disease. In the light of the above, we issue the following directions:-

    (i) The petitioner organisation or other similar organisation, nongovernmental organisations, individuals or group of individuals shall intimate the District authorities concerned, as already notified by the government, 48 hours in advance prior to distribution of food and other materials to the poor

    (ii) As far as distribution of food is concerned, on receipt of such intimation, the Food Safety Officer concerned shall cause an inspection of the place where the food is likely to be distributed with respect to the health condition of the person (s) who is/are engaged in preparation of the food as well as the quality of the food to be served. After the Food Safety Officer is satisfied with the above norms, the petitioner party can proceed with the distribution of food

    (iii) It is made clear that the preparation and distribution of food has to be effected within the zone, in respect of Corporation limits and within the police Station limits in rural areas. However, there shall not be any distribution of food within the areas earmarked as 'hot spots' by the Government.

    (iv) It is further made clear that the distribution of the food has to be completed within a time to be specified. However, in case, if the distribution of food could not be completed within the time, the District authorities can consider extending the time on their discretion by one or two hours.

    (v) The place where the food is likely to be served has to be sanitised by the authorities concerned prior to effecting distribution so that it will be fit for such distribution of food

    (vi) The State can deploy police officials to regulate the recipient of food

    (vii) The State shall permit three organisers, excluding the driver, who organise the distribution of food, along with an elected representative, to be present at the venue

    (viii) More than three persons shall not travel in one vehicle to carry the food items to the place of distribution and they shall strictly adhere to the preventive measures announced by the Government in exercise of powers under Section 144 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

    (ix) The petitioner organisation or other similar organisation, nongovernmental organisations, individuals or group of individuals shall strictly ensure that social distancing norm is followed during distribution of food and there is no deviation, whatsoever

    �(x) It is well open to the District authorities to impose such other condition (s) that may be reasonable to ensure that the distribution of food is effected without deviation of any of the norms.

    10. Subject to the above observation, the writ petition is disposed of. No costs. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dravida Munnetra Kaz... v. The State of Tamil N...
    (Apr 16, 2020)