AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petition was filed by the Delhi High Court Bar Association, represented by its President Mr. Mohit Mathur and Honorary Secretary Mr. Abhijat, in public interest. The petition seeks a writ of mandamus directing respondents, including the States of Haryana and Uttar Pradesh, to allow unhindered movement of advocates residing in these States but practicing in Delhi courts. The petitioners requested this relief subject to the safeguards prescribed by the Union of India in its guidelines dated 01.05.2020, which were updated on 17.05.2020. The petition also sought consequential reliefs related to the primary request. The matter involves the regulation of inter-state movement of advocates during the COVID-19 pandemic, specifically concerning the issuance of e-passes for travel.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether advocates residing in Haryana and Uttar Pradesh but practicing in Delhi should be allowed unhindered movement between these States and Delhi subject to prescribed safeguards.
  2. Whether the issuance of weekly e-passes to advocates is a reasonable and effective method to regulate their movement while balancing public health concerns.
  3. Whether advocates should be allowed to travel on the basis of their Identity Cards alone without e-passes.

Arguments of the Parties

Arguments of the State of Haryana

  • A separate category for advocates has been created for issuance of weekly e-passes.
  • E-passes are issued routinely and promptly, usually within a few minutes to thirty minutes.
  • The purpose of regulating movement via e-passes is to enable contact tracing in case an individual tests positive for COVID-19.
  • Persons residing in containment zones are excluded from receiving e-passes.
  • It is sufficient for advocates to show the e-pass on their mobile phones along with their Identity Cards at checkpoints; printed copies are not mandatory.

Arguments of the Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi (GNCTD)

  • The GNCTD counsel shared his personal experience that e-passes for himself and his clerk were issued within minutes, indicating efficiency in the system.

Arguments of the Petitioners (Delhi High Court Bar Association)

  • Initially, the separate category for advocates for issuance of e-passes was not operational but has since become operational.
  • Advocates should be allowed to travel based solely on their Identity Cards without requiring e-passes.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court acknowledged that the Union of India’s guidelines for movement during the pandemic had been updated recently and that the State of Haryana had established a system for issuing weekly e-passes to advocates, which was functioning efficiently. The Court found the rationale behind e-pass issuance persuasive, as it serves the public health interest by enabling contact tracing and preventing the spread of COVID-19, while also allowing advocates to perform their essential services.

The Court rejected the petitioners’ submission that advocates should be allowed to travel solely on Identity Cards, reasoning that this could cause confusion and congestion at checkpoints, potentially leading to public disorder and delays. The Court emphasized that since the e-pass system was operational and effective, it was not appropriate to interfere with it at this stage.

Regarding Uttar Pradesh, the Court noted that some arrangements had been made between the Supreme Court Bar Association and local administrations, but directed the State to consider adopting a system similar to Haryana’s for issuing weekly e-passes to advocates, recognizing the importance of legal services as essential services that protect fundamental rights and livelihood.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition was allowed in part.

The Court permitted the continued operation of the weekly e-pass system for advocates traveling between Haryana and Delhi, finding it reasonable and necessary to balance public health concerns with the essential nature of legal services. The Court declined to permit travel on Identity Cards alone to avoid practical difficulties at checkpoints.

The Court directed the State of Uttar Pradesh to consider implementing a similar e-pass issuance system to facilitate advocates’ movement. The decision ensures advocates can continue to represent their clients and earn their livelihood with reasonable restrictions, without completely denying their right to practice.

No new legal precedent was established; the ruling primarily regulates the procedural aspects of inter-state movement of advocates during the pandemic.

    Delhi High Court Bar Association And Others v. Union Of India And Others

    1. Exemption allowed, subject to all just exceptions.

    2. The application stands disposed of.

    CM APPL. 10993/2020

    3. Exemption allowed, subject to all just exceptions.

    4. The Court Fees be filed within two weeks.

    5. The application stands disposed of.

    W.P. (C) 3163/2020 and CM APPL. 10991/2020

    6. Issue notice. Learned counsels accept notice on behalf of the respondents.

    7. The present writ petition has been preferred by the Delhi High Court Bar Association, its President Mr. Mohit Mathur and its Honorary Secretary Mr. Abhijat, in public interest, to seek a writ of mandamus to the respondents which, inter alia, include the State of Haryana and the State of Uttar Pradesh (UP), to allow unhindered movement of advocates - who are residing in the said two States but have their offices in Delhi and are practising in Delhi Courts, subject to safeguards laid down by the respondent No. 1/Union of India (UOI) in its guidelines dated 01.05.2020. At this stage itself, we may observe that the UOI has updated its guidelines only yesterday, i.e. 17.05.2020. Other consequential reliefs have also been sought in pursuance of the first relief in the writ petition.

    8. Mr. Anil Grover - learned counsel representing the State of Haryana, submits that in respect of advocates, a separate category has been included for issuance of e-passes on weekly basis, and the e-passes are routinely being issued without any delay, i.e. within a matter of few minutes - up to thirty minutes. He submits that the purpose of regulating entry to and fro, by issuing entry passes is to keep a track so that any person - who is later found to be Covid positive, and who may have travelled inter state, can be traced to prevent further spread of the viral infection. He further submits that the persons who are residing in Containment Zones are excluded from issuance of such like passes. Mr. Grover has also submitted that there is no insistence on the e-pass being shown in printed form at, and it is sufficient for the person concerned to show the e-pass on his mobile phone itself, apart from the Identity Card to establish the fact that the e-pass has been issued to the person actually travelling.

    9. Mr. Sameer Vashisht - learned counsel who appears for the GNCTD, has stated that he himself resides in Gurugram, and his experience is that when he applied for the e-passes today morning itself - for himself and his Clerk, the same were issued within a matter of few minutes.

    10. Mr. Mohit Mathur and Mr. Abhijat, firstly, submit that separate category for advocates was not operational till yesterday. It appears that the same has been made operational now. Since the same has been made operational while we are dealing with this petition, the said issue does not survive.

    11. Another submission of Mr. Mathur is that the advocates should be allowed entry & exit into, and out of Delhi, to the two States on the basis of their Identity Cards alone. We are not inclined to accept this submission for the reason that, in case, at the Border/Barrier, if the checking authorities find any reason not to accept the Identity Card, the same may lead to a fracas and congestion - which is best avoided in the present situation. The same may lead to slowing down the traffic and also congregation of persons at the Barrier - which cannot be permitted. Since the system of issuance of weekly e-passes is in place and has been made operational, we do not consider it proper to interfere with the same at this stage.

    12. So far as the State of Haryana is concerned, we are satisfied with the system in place, which shall continue to operate unless there is good reason to alter the same.

    13. So far as the State of UP is concerned, Mr. Diwakar submits that some arrangement has been entered between Supreme Court Bar Association and the local administration of Ghaziabad and Noida Districts. He seeks some time to take further instructions and report back.

    14. We find that movement of advocates between the said two States and the NCT of Delhi, in such like cases - where the advocates are residing in one or the other State, and working in the NCT of Delhi, should be permitted within reasonable limits, since legal services are essential services. The advocates represent their clients in cases to protect and advance their rights - including fundamental rights, which may be at stake, and to deny such litigants the right to avail of legal services through their engaged advocates, would be denial of such rights. The rights of such advocates to earn their livelihood - which is a facet of the Right to Life and Liberty, and their freedom to carry out the profession, are also at stake. The same cannot be completely denied and can only be regulated with reasonable restrictions. We, therefore, expect the State of UP to adopt the same method for issuance of e-passes on weekly basis, as has been evolved by the State of Haryana. The State of UP shall consider these aspects before the next date.

    15. To enable Mr. Diwakar to report instructions, list on 20.05.2020.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Delhi High Court Bar Association And Others v. Union Of India And Others
    (May 18, 2020)