AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner sought the release of a seized two-wheeler vehicle registered as BR01EQ4369, which was seized in connection with Pirbahor P.S. Case No. 182/2020 under Section 30(a) of the Bihar Excise & Prohibition Act, 2016. The petitioner prayed for directions to Respondent No. 2 to release the vehicle. The matter was heard with learned counsel for both parties present. The petitioner relied on prior orders passed in related writ petitions (CWJC Nos. 20598 of 2019, 17165 of 2019, and 2050 of 2020) for disposal of the petition. The State did not oppose the prayer for release of the vehicle.

The Court noted a continuing pattern of litigation and numerous writ petitions filed for release of vehicles seized under the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016. The Court observed that despite earlier orders directing authorities to initiate and conclude confiscation proceedings within specified time frames, the State had largely failed to comply, resulting in congested court dockets and prolonged detention of vehicles.

The Court referred extensively to earlier judgments and orders in similar matters, emphasizing the need for expeditious confiscation proceedings and proper application of Section 56 of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016, particularly in cases involving allegations of drunken driving without seizure of liquor or transportation of liquor.

The Court also highlighted the absence of a mechanism under the Act for safeguarding seized property, which leads to deterioration and loss, and noted the burden on litigants forced to approach the Court for release of vehicles due to administrative inaction.

In light of these circumstances, the Court disposed of the petition with directions for timely initiation and conclusion of confiscation proceedings and reserved liberty for the petitioner to seek damages or other remedies if the property is not liable to be confiscated.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the seized vehicle, used in connection with an offence under the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016, should be provisionally released pending confiscation proceedings.
  2. Whether the confiscating authority is required to apply Section 56 of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016, to determine if a vehicle used by a person in a drunken condition, but without seizure of liquor or transportation of liquor, is liable to be confiscated.
  3. What is the reasonable time frame within which confiscation proceedings under Section 58 of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016, must be initiated and concluded.
  4. What measures should be taken in cases of delay or non-initiation of confiscation proceedings, including the possibility of interim release of seized vehicles and claim for damages against erring officials.
  5. The appropriate forum and procedure for prosecuting officials accused of illegal seizure or false information in excise proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Md. Shaukat Ali v. The State of Bihar (CWJC No. 20598 of 2019) Directions on provisional release of vehicles seized under the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016, and application of Section 56 regarding vehicle confiscation. Followed and made applicable mutatis mutandis to the petitioner’s case for disposal and directions on confiscation proceedings.
Umesh Sah v. The State of Bihar (CWJC No. 17165 of 2019) Clarification that “reasonable delay” under Section 58 of the Act means not more than three months for adjudication of confiscation proceedings. Applied to set a time limit for initiation and conclusion of confiscation proceedings in the present matter.
Diwakar Kumar Singh v. The State of Bihar (CWJC No. 5049 of 2018) Mandatory application of Section 56 of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016, by confiscating authorities before ordering confiscation; prohibition of further proceedings without deciding this preliminary issue. Reiterated and emphasized to ensure confiscating authorities comply with statutory requirements before passing confiscation orders.
Shobha Devi v. The State of Bihar (CWJC No. 15003 of 2019) Competence of learned Special Judge, Excise to entertain petitions under Section 340 CrPC for false information; grant of compensation for illegal seizure of vehicle not liable for confiscation. Referenced for guidance on prosecuting officials responsible for illegal seizure and awarding compensation to vehicle owners.
Rajesh Kumar Pandit @ Rajesh Pandit v. The State of Bihar (CWJC No. 13162 of 2018) Provisional release of vehicles under certain conditions in excise-related offences. Referenced as part of a series of coordinate Bench decisions supporting provisional release practice.
Amar Kumar v. The State of Bihar (CWJC No. 14242 of 2018) Provisional release of vehicles in excise-related matters. Referenced as precedent supporting release subject to confiscation proceedings.
Mahendra Manjhi v. The State of Bihar (CWJC No. 2437 of 2018) Provisional release of vehicles seized under excise laws. Referenced as part of consistent judicial approach to vehicle release.
Laxman Das @ Lakshman Ravidas v. The State of Bihar (CWJC No. 2470 of 2018) Provisional vehicle release in excise cases. Referenced among coordinated Bench rulings.
Sanjay Kumar v. The State of Bihar (CWJC No. 13158 of 2017) Release of seized vehicles in excise-related offences. Referenced for consistent practice of provisional release.
Bikash Kumar v. The State of Bihar (CWJC No. 5528 of 2018) Provisional release of seized vehicles. Referenced twice for support of release practice.
Anandi Prasad v. The State of Bihar (CWJC No. 7755 of 2018) Provisional release of vehicles in excise offences. Included in list of supporting precedents.
Suraj Ram v. The State of Bihar (CWJC No. 7644 of 2018) Vehicle release in excise-related matters. Referenced as precedent supporting provisional release.
Kalesar Chaudhari v. The State of Bihar (CWJC No. 15435 of 2018) Provisional release of vehicles seized under excise laws. Part of consistent judicial approach cited.
Raushan Kumar @ Raushan Kumar Singh v. The State of Bihar (CWJC No. 1215 of 2019) Release of seized vehicles in excise cases. Referenced as part of coordinated Bench decisions.
Asharfi Kumar @ Rakesh Kumar v. The State of Bihar (CWJC No. 1620 of 2019) Provisional release of vehicles. Included in list of precedents.
Avinash Kumar v. The State of Bihar (CWJC No. 2380 of 2019) Vehicle release in excise-related offences. Referenced among coordinated Bench rulings.
Roshan Kumar v. The State of Bihar (CWJC No. 1648 of 2019) Provisional release of seized vehicles. Included in cited decisions.
Shanti Devi v. The State of Bihar (CWJC No. 1314 of 2019) Vehicle release and related excise law matters. Referenced as part of consistent judicial practice.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court observed a persistent failure by the State authorities to initiate and conclude confiscation proceedings under the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016, despite earlier judicial directives. This failure has led to a large backlog of cases and forced vehicle owners to approach the Court for release of their property.

Relying on previously established precedents, the Court reaffirmed that in cases involving drunken driving without seizure or transport of liquor, vehicles are generally not liable for confiscation. The Court emphasized the mandatory requirement for confiscating authorities to apply Section 56 of the Act as a preliminary issue before ordering confiscation.

The Court also underscored the importance of concluding confiscation proceedings expeditiously, setting a three-month outer limit for adjudication under Section 58 of the Act, and directing the authorities to act within this timeframe.

Further, the Court recognized the absence of a statutory mechanism to protect seized property, leading to loss and deterioration, and expressed concern over the administrative inertia causing undue hardship to vehicle owners.

Consequently, the Court disposed of the petition with directions to initiate confiscation proceedings within 15 days and conclude them within 30 days, allowing interim release of vehicles if proceedings are not timely completed. The Court also reserved the right for the petitioner to seek damages against erring officials if the vehicle is found not liable for confiscation.

The Court additionally directed the Chief Secretary, Government of Bihar, to file a personal affidavit detailing steps to ensure compliance with the Act and prevent litigants from being compelled to approach courts repeatedly for vehicle release.

Holding and Implications

The petition is disposed of with directions that the appropriate authority must initiate confiscation proceedings within 15 days and conclude them within 30 days. If proceedings cannot be completed within the stipulated time, the vehicle shall be released on such terms as deemed fit by the authority.

The petitioner is required to cooperate and appear before the authority as directed. If the vehicle is ultimately found not liable for confiscation, the petitioner may seek damages and initiate proceedings against responsible officials.

The Court clarified that the expression “reasonable delay” under Section 58 of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016, means no more than three months for adjudication of confiscation proceedings.

The Court reserved liberty for the petitioner to pursue other legal remedies if necessary and directed the State to communicate the order to all concerned authorities.

No new precedent was set; rather, the Court reinforced existing judicial practice and emphasized compliance with statutory timelines and procedural safeguards to prevent undue hardship and litigation.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Vishal Kumar Petitioner/S v. State Of Bihar Through The Principal Secretary And Another /S.

    Sanjay Karol, C.J.:— This matter was mentioned to be covered vide item No. IX of Notice-II dated 30 May, 2020 published in the Daily Cause List.

    2. Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and learned counsel for the State.

    3. Petitioner has prayed for the following reliefs:—

    “(i) For direction/order to the Respondent No. 2 to release the vehicle (Two Wheeler) bearing Registration No. BR01EQ4369, Chasis No. ME4JF49HMKW030244 and Engine No. JF49EW2089211 in favour of the petitioner, which had been seized in connection with Pirbahor P.S. Case No. 182/2020 registered under Section 30(a) of the Bihar Excise & Prohibition Act, 2016.

    (ii) Any other relief(s) as the petitioner may be found entitle by this Hon'ble Court under facts and circumstances of the case mentioned hereinbelow.”

    4. Learned counsel for the petitioner prays that the petition be disposed of in terms of order dated 9 January, 2020 passed in CWJC No. 20598 of 2019 titled as Md. Shaukat Ali v. The State of Bihar and subsequent order dated 14 January, 2020 passed in CWJC No. 17165 of 2019 titled as Umesh Sah v. the State of Bihar dated 29.01.2020 passed in CWJC No. 2050 of 2020 titled as Bunilal Sah @ Munilal Sah.

    5. Shri. Vikash Kumar, learned standing counsel for the respondents has no objection to the same.

    (In C.W.J.C. No. 20598 of 2019, order dated 9.1.2020)

    “The petition filed on 01.10.2019 is listed for hearing for the first time today before the Court.

    Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and learned counsel appearing on behalf of the State.

    With the consent of the learned counsel for the parties, the writ petition stands disposed of in the following terms.

    The petitioner prays for provisional release of Tata Indigo white vehicle bearing Registration No. BR 01CX 1796 which has been seized in connection with Kotwali P.S. Case No. 721 of 2019, for the offences punishable under Sections 427/279 of the Penal Code, 1860 and Section 37(b)(c) of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016.

    It is continued practice of this Court that in cases of drunken driving; no recovery from the vehicle; recovery of less than commercial quantity; where exfacie, vehicle is not liable to be confiscated; where there is inordinate delay in initiating proceedings for confiscation of the vehicle etc., this Court has been directing the State to provisionally release vehicle/property, subject to initiation/conclusion/finalisation of the confiscatory proceedings, as the case may be. Reference can be made to the judgments/orders passed by different coordinate Benches of this Court, viz:—

    (i) Judgement dated 22.03.2018 passed in CWJC No. 5049 of 2018, titled as Diwakar Kumar Singh v. The State of Bihar;

    (ii) order dated 31.07.2018 passed in CWJC No. 13162 of 2018 titled as Rajesh Kumar Pandit @ Rajesh Pandit v. The State of Bihar;

    (iii) order dated 31.07.2018 passed in CWJC No. 14242 of 2018 titled as Amar Kumar v. The State of Bihar;

    (iv) order dated 12.02.2018 passed in CWJC No. 2437 of 2018 titled as Mahendra Manjhi v. The State of Bihar;

    (v) judgement dated 12.02.2018 passed in CWJC No. 2470 of 2018 titled as Laxman Das @ Lakshman Ravidas v. The State of Bihar;

    (vi) order dated 11.09.2017 passed in CWJC No. 13158 of 2017 titled as Sanjay Kumar v. The State of Bihar;

    (vii) order dated 27.03.2018 passed in CWJC No. 5528 of 2018 titled as Bikash Kumar v. The State of Bihar;

    (viii) order dated 27.03.2018 passed in CWJC No. 5528 of 2018 titled as Bikash Kumar v. The State of Bihar;

    (ix) order dated 01.05.2018 passed in CWJC No. 7755 of 2018 titled as Anandi Prasad v. The State of Bihar;

    (x) order dated 01.05.2018 passed in CWJC No. 7644 of 2018 titled as Suraj Ram v. The State of Bihar;

    (xi) order dated 07.08.2018 passed in CWJC No. 15435 of 2018 titled as Kalesar Chaudhari v. the State of Bihar;

    (xii) judgement dated 18.01.2019 passed in CWJC No. 1215 of 2019 titled as Raushan Kumar @ Raushan Kumar Singh v. The State of Bihar;

    (xiii) judgement dated 29.01.2019 passed in CWJC No. 1620 of 2019 titled as Asharfi Kumar @ Rakesh Kumar v. the State of Bihar;

    (xiv) judgement dated 08.02.2019 passed in CWJC No. 2380 of 2019 titled as Avinash Kumar v. the State of Bihar;

    (xv) judgement dated 29.01.2019 passed in CWJC No. 1648 of 2019 titled as Roshan Kumar v. The State of Bihar; and

    (xvi) judgement dated 22.01.2019 passed in CWJC No. 1314 of 2019 titled as Shanti Devi v. The State of Bihar

    6. In fact, in CWJC No. 5049 of 2018 titled as Diwakar Kumar Singh v. The State of Bihar the Court issued the following directions:—

    “That apart, in the confiscation proceedings, the confiscating authority shall take note of the provisions of Section 56 of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016 and record a positive finding after hearing the petitioner as to whether when the petitioner is found or the vehicle is found to be used by a person in drunken condition and no liquor is seized from the vehicle or when the vehicle is not used for transportation of liquor, whether the provision of Section 56 of the Act will apply. It shall be mandatory for the confiscating authority to decide this issue before passing any order on the confiscation proceedings. The confiscating authority shall consider the provision of Section 56 of the Act, apply his mind and pass a speaking order with regard to confiscation initiated.

    Without deciding the aforesaid issue as a preliminary issue, further proceedings in the confiscation proceedings shall be prohibited.

    We further request the office of the Advocate General to communicate this order to all the District Magistrates in the State of Bihar, who would be mandated to pass an appropriate order in such cases where the vehicle has been confiscated under Section 56 of the Act only on the allegation that the vehicle was being driven in a drunken condition and no liquor was seized from the vehicle nor the vehicle used for transportation or carriage of liquor. The issue shall be decided by each and every District Magistrate before proceeding in the confiscation proceedings where the allegation is about the vehicle being driven in a drunken condition and no liquor was found from the possession of the vehicle.

    It shall be the duty of the Advocate General to communicate this order to each and every District Magistrate and inform the Registrar General of this Court. In spite thereof, if we find that the District Magistrates are passing confiscation order without addressing this issue first, we may consider initiating contempt proceedings against the concerned District Magistrate.”

    7. It is further seen that in CWJC No. 15003 of 2019 titled as Shobha Devi v. The State of Bihar the Court observed as under:—

    “6. On examination of aforesaid fact, particularly allegation of the petitioner that in a court proceeding before the learned Special Judge, Excise, a false information was given, we are of the opinion that the court of learned Special Judge, Excise would be competent court to pass an appropriate order, in view of provisions contained in Section 340 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.

    7. Accordingly, the petitioner is granted liberty to file appropriate petition before the learned Special Judge, Excise for prosecuting the concerned police official.

    8. So far as claim of compensation is concerned, obviously on going through the material on record, since there was no recovery of liquor from the vehicle and it was a case, in which, the occupants of the vehicle were alleged to be in drunken condition and were creating nuisance, though were liable to be arrested. In any event, the vehicle was not required to be seized, since it was not liable to be confiscated.

    9. In such situation, we are of the opinion that it is a fit case, in which, we may direct to pay adequate compensation to the petitioner, being owner of the vehicle, to the tune of Rs. 75,000/- (seventy five thousand), however, Sri. Kumar Manish, learned Standing Counsel - 5 requests for granting an opportunity for obtaining detailed instruction and filing counter affidavit in the matter. The request of Sri. Kumar Manish, S.C.-5 is allowed for filing counter affidavit so that final order may be passed.

    10. It goes without saying that before filing counter affidavit, the respondent no. 4/Superintendent of Police, Darbhanga may conduct a preliminary inquiry regarding the conduct of the police officer, who had seized the vehicle of the petitioner and state all those facts in its counter affidavit, which must be filed by 29 of November, 2019. The affidavit must be sworn by the Superintendent of Police himself.

    11. It further goes without saying that if after considering all the facts, including counter affidavit, which is proposed to be filed, the Court comes to the conclusion that the petitioner is entitled for claim of amount of compensation, which has been referred hereinabove, the said compensation amount must be recovered from the pocket of the police officer, who was responsible for such illegal seizure.”

    8. Despite the same, only before this Court, when matters of similar nature came up for hearing on 16of December, 2019, the learned Advocate General assisted by Shri. Vikash Kumar, learned Standing Counsel-11, and Shri. Vivek Prasad, learned Government Pleader-7, vehemently opposed the petitions for release of the vehicles.

    9. Consequently, the writ petitions were disposed of with the directions to the appropriate authorities to positively initiate/conclude confiscatory proceedings within a period of 30-45 days.

    10. Without adjudicating the petitioner's petition on merits, we are of the considered view that interest of justice would be best met, if the petition is disposed of in the following terms:—

    (a) Since the vehicle in question stands seized in relation to the FIR which stood registered long ago, in case confiscation proceeding has not been initiated, it must be initiated within a period of 15 days from today and that confiscation proceeding stands initiated, we direct the appropriate authority under the Act to forthwith ensure that such proceedings be concluded not later than 30 days.

    (b) The petitioner undertakes to make himself available in the office of the concerned appropriate authority empowered under Section 58 of the Act i.e. District Collector, in his/her office on 24.01.2020 at 10:30 A.M.

    (c) We further direct the appropriate authority to positively conclude the confiscation proceeding within next thirty days on appearance of the petitioner. If for whatever reason, such proceeding cannot be concluded, in that event it shall be open for the authority to take such measures, as are permissible in law, for release of the vehicle in question by way of interim measure, on such terms as may be deemed appropriate, considering the attending facts and circumstances of the case.

    (d) If eventually, the appropriate authority arrives at a conclusion that the property is not liable to be confiscated, it shall be open for the petitioner to seek damages in accordance with law and have appropriate proceedings initiated against the erring officials/officers.

    11. Learned counsel for the petitioner states that the certified copy of the order shall be made available to the concerned District Collector on the date so fixed.

    12. For future guidance, where parties have not approached this Court, we issue the following direction:—

    The expression “reasonable delay” used in Section 58 of Chapter VI of the Act, in our considered view, necessarily has to be within a reasonable time and with dispatch, which period, in our considered view, three months time is sufficient enough for any authority to adjudicate any issue, more so, when we are dealing with confiscatory proceedings.

    We clarify that we have not adjudicated the writ petition on merits and it shall be open for the parties to take all stand in the adjudicatory proceedings and wherever parties are aggrieved, it shall be open to them to initiate appropriate proceeding before the appellate authority.

    Learned counsel for the State also undertakes to communicate the order to the concerned appropriate authority i.e. District Magistrate, empowered under Section 58 of the Act.”

    (In C.W.J.C. No. 17165 of 2019, order dated 14.1.2020)

    “Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and learned counsel appearing on behalf of the State.

    Learned counsel for the petitioner invites our attention to our earlier order dated 09.01.2020 passed in CWJC No. 20598 of 2019, titled as Md. Shaukat Ali v. The State of Bihar, and wants the petition to be disposed of in terms thereof.

    With the consent of the learned counsel for the parties, the writ petition stands disposed of in the following terms.

    The petitioner prays for provisional release of Pick Up Van (Tata Motor/SFC-407 D-Van) bearing Registration No. BR-06G-4211 which has been seized in connection with Taukauliya P.S. Case No. 709 of 2018 for the offences punishable under Sections 272, 273, 34 of the Penal Code, 1860 and Sections 30(a), 38(1), 41(1) of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016.

    It is continued practice of this Court that in cases of drunken driving; no recovery from the vehicle; recovery of less than commercial quantity; where ex-facie, vehicle is not liable to be confiscated; where there is inordinate delay in initiating proceedings for confiscation of the vehicle etc., this Court has been directing the State to provisionally release vehicle/property, subject to initiation/conclusion/finalisation of the confiscatory proceedings, as the case may be. Reference can be made to the judgments/orders passed by different co-ordinate Benches of this Court, viz:—

    (i) Judgement dated 22.03.2018 passed in CWJC No. 5049 of 2018, titled as Diwakar Kumar Singh v. The State of Bihar;

    (ii) order dated 31.07.2018 passed in CWJC No. 13162 of 2018 titled as Rajesh Kumar Pandit @ Rajesh Pandit v. The State of Bihar;

    (iii) order dated 31.07.2018 passed in CWJC No. 14242 of 2018 titled as Amar Kumar v. The State of Bihar;

    (iv) order dated 12.02.2018 passed in CWJC No. 2437 of 2018 titled as Mahendra Manjhi v. The State of Bihar;

    (v) judgement dated 12.02.2018 passed in CWJC No. 2470 of 2018 titled as Laxman Das @ Lakshman Ravidas v. The State of Bihar;

    (vi) order dated 11.09.2017 passed in CWJC No. 13158 of 2017 titled as Sanjay Kumar v. The State of Bihar;

    (vii) order dated 27.03.2018 passed in CWJC No. 5528 of 2018 titled as Bikash Kumar v. The State of Bihar;

    (viii) order dated 27.03.2018 passed in CWJC No. 5528 of 2018 titled as Bikash Kumar v. The State of Bihar;

    (ix) order dated 01.05.2018 passed in CWJC No. 7755 of 2018 titled as Anandi Prasad v. The State of Bihar;

    (x) order dated 01.05.2018 passed in CWJC No. 7644 of 2018 titled as Suraj Ram v. The State of Bihar;

    (xi) order dated 07.08.2018 passed in CWJC No. 15435 of 2018 titled as Kalesar Chaudhari v. the State of Bihar;

    (xii) judgement dated 18.01.2019 passed in CWJC No. 1215 of 2019 titled as Raushan Kumar @ Raushan Kumar Singh v. The State of Bihar;

    (xiii) judgement dated 29.01.2019 passed in CWJC No. 1620 of 2019 titled as Asharfi Kumar @ Rakesh Kumar v. the State of Bihar;

    (xiv) judgement dated 08.02.2019 passed in CWJC No. 2380 of 2019 titled as Avinash Kumar v. the State of Bihar;

    (xv) judgement dated 29.01.2019 passed in CWJC No. 1648 of 2019 titled as Roshan Kumar v. The State of Bihar; and

    (xvi) judgement dated 22.01.2019 passed in CWJC No. 1314 of 2019 titled as Shanti Devi v. The State of Bihar

    13. In fact, in CWJC No. 5049 of 2018 titled as Diwakar Kumar Singh v. The State of Bihar the Court issued the following directions:—

    “That apart, in the confiscation proceedings, the confiscating authority shall take note of the provisions of Section 56 of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016 and record a positive finding after hearing the petitioner as to whether when the petitioner is found or the vehicle is found to be used by a person in drunken condition and no liquor is seized from the vehicle or when the vehicle is not used for transportation of liquor, whether the provision of Section 56 of the Act will apply. It shall be mandatory for the confiscating authority to decide this issue before passing any order on the confiscation proceedings. The confiscating authority shall consider the provision of Section 56 of the Act, apply his mind and pass a speaking order with regard to confiscation initiated.

    Without deciding the aforesaid issue as a preliminary issue, further proceedings in the confiscation proceedings shall be prohibited.

    We further request the office of the Advocate General to communicate this order to all the District Magistrates in the State of Bihar, who would be mandated to pass an appropriate order in such cases where the vehicle has been confiscated under Section 56 of the Act only on the allegation that the vehicle was being driven in a drunken condition and no liquor was seized from the vehicle nor the vehicle used for transportation or carriage of liquor. The issue shall be decided by each and every District Magistrate before proceeding in the confiscation proceedings where the allegation is about the vehicle being driven in a drunken condition and no liquor was found from the possession of the vehicle.

    It shall be the duty of the Advocate General to communicate this order to each and every District Magistrate and inform the Registrar General of this Court. In spite thereof, if we find that the District Magistrates are passing confiscation order without addressing this issue first, we may consider initiating contempt proceedings against the concerned District Magistrate.”

    14. It is further seen that in CWJC No. 15003 of 2019 titled as Shobha Devi v. The State of Bihar the Court observed as under:—

    “6. On examination of aforesaid fact, particularly allegation of the petitioner that in a court proceeding before the learned Special Judge, Excise, a false information was given, we are of the opinion that the court of learned Special Judge, Excise would be competent court to pass an appropriate order, in view of provisions contained in Section 340 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.

    7. Accordingly, the petitioner is granted liberty to file appropriate petition before the learned Special Judge, Excise for prosecuting the concerned police official.

    8. So far as claim of compensation is concerned, obviously on going through the material on record, since there was no recovery of liquor from the vehicle and it was a case, in which, the occupants of the vehicle were alleged to be in drunken condition and were creating nuisance, though were liable to be arrested. In any event, the vehicle was not required to be seized, since it was not liable to be confiscated.

    9. In such situation, we are of the opinion that it is a fit case, in which, we may direct to pay adequate compensation to the petitioner, being owner of the vehicle, to the tune of Rs. 75,000/- (seventy five thousand), however, Sri. Kumar Manish, learned Standing Counsel - 5 requests for granting an opportunity for obtaining detailed instruction and filing counter affidavit in the matter. The request of Sri. Kumar Manish, S.C.-5 is allowed for filing counter affidavit so that final order may be passed.

    10. It goes without saying that before filing counter affidavit, the respondent no. 4/Superintendent of Police, Darbhanga may conduct a preliminary inquiry regarding the conduct of the police officer, who had seized the vehicle of the petitioner and state all those facts in its counter affidavit, which must be filed by 29 of November, 2019. The affidavit must be sworn by the Superintendent of Police himself.

    11. It further goes without saying that if after considering all the facts, including counter affidavit, which is proposed to be filed, the Court comes to the conclusion that the petitioner is entitled for claim of amount of compensation, which has been referred hereinabove, the said compensation amount must be recovered from the pocket of the police officer, who was responsible for such illegal seizure.”

    15. Despite the same, only before this Court, when matters of similar nature came up for hearing on 16of December, 2019, the learned Advocate General assisted by Shri. Vikash Kumar, learned Standing Counsel-11, and Shri. Vivek Prasad, learned Government Pleader-7, vehemently opposed the petitions for release of the vehicles.

    16. Consequently, the writ petitions were disposed of with the directions to the appropriate authorities to positively initiate/conclude confiscatory proceedings within a period of 30-45 days.

    17. Without adjudicating the petitioner's petition on merits, we are of the considered view that interest of justice would be best met, if the petition is disposed of in the following terms:—

    (a) Since the vehicle in question stands seized in relation to the FIR which stood registered long ago, in case confiscation proceeding has not been initiated, it must be initiated within a period of 15 days from today and that confiscation proceeding stands initiated, we direct the appropriate authority under the Act to forthwith ensure that such proceedings be concluded not later than 30 days.

    (b) The petitioner undertakes to make himself available in the office of the concerned appropriate authority empowered under Section 58 of the Act i.e. District Collector, in his/her office on 24.01.2020 at 10:30 A.M.

    (c) We further direct the appropriate authority to positively conclude the confiscation proceeding within next thirty days on appearance of the petitioner. If for whatever reason, such proceeding cannot be concluded, in that event it shall be open for the authority to take such measures, as are permissible in law, for release of the vehicle in question by way of interim measure, on such terms as may be deemed appropriate, considering the attending facts and circumstances of the case.

    (d) If eventually, the appropriate authority arrives at a conclusion that the property is not liable to be confiscated, it shall be open for the petitioner to seek damages in accordance with law and have appropriate proceedings initiated against the erring officials/officers.

    18. Learned counsel for the petitioner states that the certified copy of the order shall be made available to the concerned District Collector on the date so fixed.

    19. For future guidance, where parties have not approached this Court, we issue the following direction:—

    The expression “reasonable delay” used in Section 58 of Chapter VI of the Act, in our considered view, necessarily has to be within a reasonable time and with dispatch, which period, in our considered view, three months time is sufficient enough for any authority to adjudicate any issue, more so, when we are dealing with confiscatory proceedings.

    We clarify that we have not adjudicated the writ petition on merits and it shall be open for the parties to take all stand in the adjudicatory proceedings and wherever parties are aggrieved, it shall be open to them to initiate appropriate proceeding before the appellate authority.

    Learned counsel for the State also undertakes to communicate the order to the concerned appropriate authority i.e. District Magistrate, empowered under Section 58 of the Act.”

    (Order dated 29.01.2020 passed in CWJC No. 2050 of 2020)

    20. It is seen that despite our order dated 9of January, 2020, passed in C.W.J.C. No. 20598 of 2019, titled as Md. Shaukat Ali v. The State of Bihar, and the order dated 14of January, 2020 passed in C.W.J.C. No. 17165 of 2019, titled as Umesh Sah v. The State of Bihar, the State has not initiated proceedings under the provisions of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016. It is a matter of record that this legislation has generated huge litigation. The docket of the Court, be it the trial court or the High Court, is now choked solely on account of such legislation. In the High Court itself, on an average, 400 bail applications are being filed every day, some of which are pertaining to the said Statute. Position in the lower courts is worse. Before the trial courts, i.e. the Sessions Courts, more than 1,75,000 challans stand filed in relation to the said Statute. Before this Court, on an average, more than 5000 writ petitions are being filed annually for release of vehicles/properties seized under the said Act. It has been the continued practice of this Court, since the year 2017, that in the writ petitions the vehicles, unless the situation so warrants, are normally being released subject to fulfilment of certain conditions. This, perhaps, is done only to protect the property from being destroyed, for there is no mechanism under the Statute or with the administration for protecting the property seized in relation to the crime registered under the said Statute. Property is left to the vagaries of weather, resulting into national loss. This we say for the reason that proceedings for confiscation, as envisaged under Section 58, were never initiated by the authority, which under the Act is the District Magistrate/Collector. It is only as a result of inaction on the part of such authorities that the owners of the vehicles/properties are constrained to approach this Court for its release. When the matter in C.W.J.C. No. 20598 of 2019 (Md. Shaukat Ali v. The State of Bihar) and in 17165 of 2019 (Umesh Sah v. The State of Bihar) (supra) was taken up for hearing, the State vehemently opposed the release of the vehicle and, as such, the following orders were passed:

    (in C.W.J.C. No. 20598 of 2019, order dated 9.1.2020)

    “The petition filed on 01.10.2019 is listed for hearing for the first time today before the Court.

    Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and learned counsel appearing on behalf of the State.

    With the consent of the learned counsel for the parties, the writ petition stands disposed of in the following terms.

    The petitioner prays for provisional release of Tata Indigo white vehicle bearing Registration No. BR 01CX 1796 which has been seized in connection with Kotwali P.S. Case No. 721 of 2019, for the offences punishable under Sections 427/279 of the Penal Code, 1860 and Section 37(b)(c) of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016.

    It is continued practice of this Court that in cases of drunken driving; no recovery from the vehicle; recovery of less than commercial quantity; where ex-facie, vehicle is not liable to be confiscated; where there is inordinate delay in initiating proceedings for confiscation of the vehicle etc., this Court has been directing the State to provisionally release vehicle/property, subject to initiation/conclusion/finalisation of the confiscatory proceedings, as the case may be. Reference can be made to the judgments/orders passed by different co-ordinate Benches of this Court, viz:—

    (i) Judgement dated 22.03.2018 passed in CWJC No. 5049 of 2018, titled as Diwakar Kumar Singh v. The State of Bihar;

    (ii) order dated 31.07.2018 passed in CWJC No. 13162 of 2018 titled as Rajesh Kumar Pandit @ Rajesh Pandit v. The State of Bihar;

    (iii) order dated 31.07.2018 passed in CWJC No. 14242 of 2018 titled as Amar Kumar v. The State of Bihar;

    (iv) order dated 12.02.2018 passed in CWJC No. 2437 of 2018 titled as Mahendra Manjhi v. The State of Bihar;

    (v) judgement dated 12.02.2018 passed in CWJC No. 2470 of 2018 titled as Laxman Das @ Lakshman Ravidas v. The State of Bihar;

    (vi) order dated 11.09.2017 passed in CWJC No. 13158 of 2017 titled as Sanjay Kumar v. The State of Bihar;

    (vii) order dated 27.03.2018 passed in CWJC No. 5528 of 2018 titled as Bikash Kumar v. The State of Bihar;

    (viii) order dated 27.03.2018 passed in CWJC No. 5528 of 2018 titled as Bikash Kumar v. The State of Bihar;

    (ix) order dated 01.05.2018 passed in CWJC No. 7755 of 2018 titled as Anandi Prasad v. The State of Bihar;

    (x) order dated 01.05.2018 passed in CWJC No. 7644 of 2018 titled as Suraj Ram v. The State of Bihar;

    (xi) order dated 07.08.2018 passed in CWJC No. 15435 of 2018 titled as Kalesar Chaudhari v. the State of Bihar;

    (xii) judgement dated 18.01.2019 passed in CWJC No. 1215 of 2019 titled as Raushan Kumar @ Raushan Kumar Singh v. The State of Bihar;

    (xiii) judgement dated 29.01.2019 passed in CWJC No. 1620 of 2019 titled as Asharfi Kumar @ Rakesh Kumar v. the State of Bihar;

    (xiv) judgement dated 08.02.2019 passed in CWJC No. 2380 of 2019 titled as Avinash Kumar v. the State of Bihar;

    (xv) judgement dated 29.01.2019 passed in CWJC No. 1648 of 2019 titled as Roshan Kumar v. The State of Bihar; and

    (xvi) judgement dated 22.01.2019 passed in CWJC No. 1314 of 2019 titled as Shanti Devi v. The State of Bihar

    21. In fact, in CWJC No. 5049 of 2018 titled as Diwakar Kumar Singh v. The State of Bihar the Court issued the following directions:—

    “That apart, in the confiscation proceedings, the confiscating authority shall take note of the provisions of Section 56 of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016 and record a positive finding after hearing the petitioner as to whether when the petitioner is found or the vehicle is found to be used by a person in drunken condition and no liquor is seized from the vehicle or when the vehicle is not used for transportation of liquor, whether the provision of Section 56 of the Act will apply. It shall be mandatory for the confiscating authority to decide this issue before passing any order on the confiscation proceedings. The confiscating authority shall consider the provision of Section 56 of the Act, apply his mind and pass a speaking order with regard to confiscation initiated.

    Without deciding the aforesaid issue as a preliminary issue, further proceedings in the confiscation proceedings shall be prohibited.

    We further request the office of the Advocate General to communicate this order to all the District Magistrates in the State of Bihar, who would be mandated to pass an appropriate order in such cases where the vehicle has been confiscated under Section 56 of the Act only on the allegation that the vehicle was being driven in a drunken condition and no liquor was seized from the vehicle nor the vehicle used for transportation or carriage of liquor. The issue shall be decided by each and every District Magistrate before proceeding in the confiscation proceedings where the allegation is about the vehicle being driven in a drunken condition and no liquor was found from the possession of the vehicle.

    It shall be the duty of the Advocate General to communicate this order to each and every District Magistrate and inform the Registrar General of this Court. In spite thereof, if we find that the District Magistrates are passing confiscation order without addressing this issue first, we may consider initiating contempt proceedings against the concerned District Magistrate.”

    22. It is further seen that in CWJC No. 15003 of 2019 titled as Shobha Devi v. The State of Bihar the Court observed as under:—

    “6. On examination of aforesaid fact, particularly allegation of the petitioner that in a court proceeding before the learned Special Judge, Excise, a false information was given, we are of the opinion that the court of learned Special Judge, Excise would be competent court to pass an appropriate order, in view of provisions contained in Section 340 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.

    7. Accordingly, the petitioner is granted liberty to file appropriate petition before the learned Special Judge, Excise for prosecuting the concerned police official.

    8. So far as claim of compensation is concerned, obviously on going through the material on record, since there was no recovery of liquor from the vehicle and it was a case, in which, the occupants of the vehicle were alleged to be in drunken condition and were creating nuisance, though were liable to be arrested. In any event, the vehicle was not required to be seized, since it was not liable to be confiscated.

    9. In such situation, we are of the opinion that it is a fit case, in which, we may direct to pay adequate compensation to the petitioner, being owner of the vehicle, to the tune of Rs. 75,000/- (seventy five thousand), however, Sri. Kumar Manish, learned Standing Counsel - 5 requests for granting an opportunity for obtaining detailed instruction and filing counter affidavit in the matter. The request of Sri. Kumar Manish, S.C.-5 is allowed for filing counter affidavit so that final order may be passed.

    10. It goes without saying that before filing counter affidavit, the respondent no. 4/Superintendent of Police, Darbhanga may conduct a preliminary inquiry regarding the conduct of the police officer, who had seized the vehicle of the petitioner and state all those facts in its counter affidavit, which must be filed by 29 of November, 2019. The affidavit must be sworn by the Superintendent of Police himself.

    11. It further goes without saying that if after considering all the facts, including counter affidavit, which is proposed to be filed, the Court comes to the conclusion that the petitioner is entitled for claim of amount of compensation, which has been referred hereinabove, the said compensation amount must be recovered from the pocket of the police officer, who was responsible for such illegal seizure.”

    23. Despite the same, only before this Court, when matters of similar nature came up for hearing on 16of December, 2019, the learned Advocate General assisted by Shri. Vikash Kumar, learned Standing Counsel-11, and Shri. Vivek Prasad, learned Government Pleader-7, vehemently opposed the petitions for release of the vehicles.

    24. Consequently, the writ petitions were disposed of with the directions to the appropriate authorities to positively initiate/conclude confiscatory proceedings within a period of 30-45 days.

    25. Without adjudicating the petitioner's petition on merits, we are of the considered view that interest of justice would be best met, if the petition is disposed of in the following terms:—

    (a) Since the vehicle in question stands seized in relation to the FIR which stood registered long ago, in case confiscation proceeding has not been initiated, it must be initiated within a period of 15 days from today and that confiscation proceeding stands initiated, we direct the appropriate authority under the Act to forthwith ensure that such proceedings be concluded not later than 30 days.

    (b) The petitioner undertakes to make himself available in the office of the concerned appropriate authority empowered under Section 58 of the Act i.e. District Collector, in his/her office on 24.01.2020 at 10:30 A.M.

    (c) We further direct the appropriate authority to positively conclude the confiscation proceeding within next thirty days on appearance of the petitioner. If for whatever reason, such proceeding cannot be concluded, in that event it shall be open for the authority to take such measures, as are permissible in law, for release of the vehicle in question by way of interim measure, on such terms as may be deemed appropriate, considering the attending facts and circumstances of the case.

    (d) If eventually, the appropriate authority arrives at a conclusion that the property is not liable to be confiscated, it shall be open for the petitioner to seek damages in accordance with law and have appropriate proceedings initiated against the erring officials/officers.

    26. Learned counsel for the petitioner states that the certified copy of the order shall be made available to the concerned District Collector on the date so fixed.

    27. For future guidance, where parties have not approached this Court, we issue the following direction:—

    The expression “reasonable delay” used in Section 58 of Chapter VI of the Act, in our considered view, necessarily has to be within a reasonable time and with dispatch, which period, in our considered view, three months time is sufficient enough for any authority to adjudicate any issue, more so, when we are dealing with confiscatory proceedings.

    We clarify that we have not adjudicated the writ petition on merits and it shall be open for the parties to take all stand in the adjudicatory proceedings and wherever parties are aggrieved, it shall be open to them to initiate appropriate proceeding before the appellate authority.

    Learned counsel for the State also undertakes to communicate the order to the concerned appropriate authority i.e. District Magistrate, empowered under Section 58 of the Act.”

    (in C.W.J.C. No. 20598 of 2019, order dated 9.1.2020)

    “The petition filed on 01.10.2019 is listed for hearing for the first time today before the Court.

    Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and learned counsel appearing on behalf of the State.

    With the consent of the learned counsel for the parties, the writ petition stands disposed of in the following terms.

    The petitioner prays for provisional release of Tata Indigo white vehicle bearing Registration No. BR 01CX 1796 which has been seized in connection with Kotwali P.S. Case No. 721 of 2019, for the offences punishable under Sections 427/279 of the Penal Code, 1860 and Section 37(b)(c) of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016.

    It is continued practice of this Court that in cases of drunken driving; no recovery from the vehicle; recovery of less than commercial quantity; where ex-facie, vehicle is not liable to be confiscated; where there is inordinate delay in initiating proceedings for confiscation of the vehicle etc., this Court has been directing the State to provisionally release vehicle/property, subject to initiation/conclusion/finalisation of the confiscatory proceedings, as the case may be. Reference can be made to the judgments/orders passed by different co-ordinate Benches of this Court, viz:—

    (i) Judgement dated 22.03.2018 passed in CWJC No. 5049 of 2018, titled as Diwakar Kumar Singh v. The State of Bihar;

    (ii) order dated 31.07.2018 passed in CWJC No. 13162 of 2018 titled as Rajesh Kumar Pandit @ Rajesh Pandit v. The State of Bihar;

    (iii) order dated 31.07.2018 passed in CWJC No. 14242 of 2018 titled as Amar Kumar v. The State of Bihar;

    (iv) order dated 12.02.2018 passed in CWJC No. 2437 of 2018 titled as Mahendra Manjhi v. The State of Bihar;

    (v) judgement dated 12.02.2018 passed in CWJC No. 2470 of 2018 titled as Laxman Das @ Lakshman Ravidas v. The State of Bihar;

    (vi) order dated 11.09.2017 passed in CWJC No. 13158 of 2017 titled as Sanjay Kumar v. The State of Bihar;

    (vii) order dated 27.03.2018 passed in CWJC No. 5528 of 2018 titled as Bikash Kumar v. The State of Bihar;

    (viii) order dated 27.03.2018 passed in CWJC No. 5528 of 2018 titled as Bikash Kumar v. The State of Bihar;

    (ix) order dated 01.05.2018 passed in CWJC No. 7755 of 2018 titled as Anandi Prasad v. The State of Bihar;

    (x) order dated 01.05.2018 passed in CWJC No. 7644 of 2018 titled as Suraj Ram v. The State of Bihar;

    (xi) order dated 07.08.2018 passed in CWJC No. 15435 of 2018 titled as Kalesar Chaudhari v. the State of Bihar;

    (xii) judgement dated 18.01.2019 passed in CWJC No. 1215 of 2019 titled as Raushan Kumar @ Raushan Kumar Singh v. The State of Bihar;

    (xiii) judgement dated 29.01.2019 passed in CWJC No. 1620 of 2019 titled as Asharfi Kumar @ Rakesh Kumar v. the State of Bihar;

    (xiv) judgement dated 08.02.2019 passed in CWJC No. 2380 of 2019 titled as Avinash Kumar v. the State of Bihar;

    (xv) judgement dated 29.01.2019 passed in CWJC No. 1648 of 2019 titled as Roshan Kumar v. The State of Bihar; and

    (xvi) judgement dated 22.01.2019 passed in CWJC No. 1314 of 2019 titled as Shanti Devi v. The State of Bihar

    28. In fact, in CWJC No. 5049 of 2018 titled as Diwakar Kumar Singh v. The State of Bihar the Court issued the following directions:—

    “That apart, in the confiscation proceedings, the confiscating authority shall take note of the provisions of Section 56 of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016 and record a positive finding after hearing the petitioner as to whether when the petitioner is found or the vehicle is found to be used by a person in drunken condition and no liquor is seized from the vehicle or when the vehicle is not used for transportation of liquor, whether the provision of Section 56 of the Act will apply. It shall be mandatory for the confiscating authority to decide this issue before passing any order on the confiscation proceedings. The confiscating authority shall consider the provision of Section 56 of the Act, apply his mind and pass a speaking order with regard to confiscation initiated.

    Without deciding the aforesaid issue as a preliminary issue, further proceedings in the confiscation proceedings shall be prohibited.

    We further request the office of the Advocate General to communicate this order to all the District Magistrates in the State of Bihar, who would be mandated to pass an appropriate order in such cases where the vehicle has been confiscated under Section 56 of the Act only on the allegation that the vehicle was being driven in a drunken condition and no liquor was seized from the vehicle nor the vehicle used for transportation or carriage of liquor. The issue shall be decided by each and every District Magistrate before proceeding in the confiscation proceedings where the allegation is about the vehicle being driven in a drunken condition and no liquor was found from the possession of the vehicle.

    It shall be the duty of the Advocate General to communicate this order to each and every District Magistrate and inform the Registrar General of this Court. In spite thereof, if we find that the District Magistrates are passing confiscation order without addressing this issue first, we may consider initiating contempt proceedings against the concerned District Magistrate.”

    29. It is further seen that in CWJC No. 15003 of 2019 titled as Shobha Devi v. The State of Bihar the Court observed as under:—

    “6. On examination of aforesaid fact, particularly allegation of the petitioner that in a court proceeding before the learned Special Judge, Excise, a false information was given, we are of the opinion that the court of learned Special Judge, Excise would be competent court to pass an appropriate order, in view of provisions contained in Section 340 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.

    7. Accordingly, the petitioner is granted liberty to file appropriate petition before the learned Special Judge, Excise for prosecuting the concerned police official.

    8. So far as claim of compensation is concerned, obviously on going through the material on record, since there was no recovery of liquor from the vehicle and it was a case, in which, the occupants of the vehicle were alleged to be in drunken condition and were creating nuisance, though were liable to be arrested. In any event, the vehicle was not required to be seized, since it was not liable to be confiscated.

    9. In such situation, we are of the opinion that it is a fit case, in which, we may direct to pay adequate compensation to the petitioner, being owner of the vehicle, to the tune of Rs. 75,000/- (seventy five thousand), however, Sri. Kumar Manish, learned Standing Counsel - 5 requests for granting an opportunity for obtaining detailed instruction and filing counter affidavit in the matter. The request of Sri. Kumar Manish, S.C.-5 is allowed for filing counter affidavit so that final order may be passed.

    10. It goes without saying that before filing counter affidavit, the respondent no. 4/Superintendent of Police, Darbhanga may conduct a preliminary inquiry regarding the conduct of the police officer, who had seized the vehicle of the petitioner and state all those facts in its counter affidavit, which must be filed by 29 of November, 2019. The affidavit must be sworn by the Superintendent of Police himself.

    11. It further goes without saying that if after considering all the facts, including counter affidavit, which is proposed to be filed, the Court comes to the conclusion that the petitioner is entitled for claim of amount of compensation, which has been referred hereinabove, the said compensation amount must be recovered from the pocket of the police officer, who was responsible for such illegal seizure.”

    30. Despite the same, only before this Court, when matters of similar nature came up for hearing on 16of December, 2019, the learned Advocate General assisted by Shri. Vikash Kumar, learned Standing Counsel-11, and Shri. Vivek Prasad, learned Government Pleader-7, vehemently opposed the petitions for release of the vehicles. Consequently, the writ petitions were disposed of with the directions to the appropriate authorities to positively initiate/conclude confiscatory proceedings within a period of 30-45 days.

    31. Without adjudicating the petitioner's petition on merits, we are of the considered view that interest of justice would be best met, if the petition is disposed of in the following terms:—

    (a) Since the vehicle in question stands seized in relation to the FIR which stood registered long ago, in case confiscation proceeding has not been initiated, it must be initiated within a period of 15 days from today and that confiscation proceeding stands initiated, we direct the appropriate authority under the Act to forthwith ensure that such proceedings be concluded not later than 30 days.

    (b) The petitioner undertakes to make himself available in the office of the concerned appropriate authority empowered under Section 58 of the Act i.e. District Collector, in his/her office on 24.01.2020 at 10:30 A.M.

    (c) We further direct the appropriate authority to positively conclude the confiscation proceeding within next thirty days on appearance of the petitioner. If for whatever reason, such proceeding cannot be concluded, in that event it shall be open for the authority to take such measures, as are permissible in law, for release of the vehicle in question by way of interim measure, on such terms as may be deemed appropriate, considering the attending facts and circumstances of the case.

    (d) If eventually, the appropriate authority arrives at a conclusion that the property is not liable to be confiscated, it shall be open for the petitioner to seek damages in accordance with law and have appropriate proceedings initiated against the erring officials/officers.

    32. Learned counsel for the petitioner states that the certified copy of the order shall be made available to the concerned District Collector on the date so fixed.

    33. For future guidance, where parties have not approached this Court, we issue the following direction:—

    The expression “reasonable delay” used in Section 58 of Chapter VI of the Act, in our considered view, necessarily has to be within a reasonable time and with dispatch, which period, in our considered view, three months time is sufficient enough for any authority to adjudicate any issue, more so, when we are dealing with confiscatory proceedings.

    We clarify that we have not adjudicated the writ petition on merits and it shall be open for the parties to take all stand in the adjudicatory proceedings and wherever parties are aggrieved, it shall be open to them to initiate appropriate proceeding before the appellate authority.

    Learned counsel for the State also undertakes to communicate the order to the concerned appropriate authority i.e. District Magistrate, empowered under Section 58 of the Act.”

    (In C.W.J.C. No. 17165 of 2019, order dated 14.1.2020)

    “Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and learned counsel appearing on behalf of the State.

    Learned counsel for the petitioner invites our attention to our earlier order dated 09.01.2020 passed in CWJC No. 20598 of 2019, titled as Md. Shaukat Ali v. The State of Bihar, and wants the petition to be disposed of in terms thereof.

    With the consent of the learned counsel for the parties, the writ petition stands disposed of in the following terms.

    The petitioner prays for provisional release of Pick Up Van (Tata Motor/SFC-407 D-Van) bearing Registration No. BR-06G-4211 which has been seized in connection with Taukauliya P.S. Case No. 709 of 2018 for the offences punishable under Sections 272, 273, 34 of the Penal Code, 1860 and Sections 30(a), 38(1), 41(1) of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016.

    It is continued practice of this Court that in cases of drunken driving; no recovery from the vehicle; recovery of less than commercial quantity; where ex-facie, vehicle is not liable to be confiscated; where there is inordinate delay in initiating proceedings for confiscation of the vehicle etc., this Court has been directing the State to provisionally release vehicle/property, subject to initiation/conclusion/finalisation of the confiscatory proceedings, as the case may be. Reference can be made to the judgments/orders passed by different co-ordinate Benches of this Court, viz:—

    (i) Judgement dated 22.03.2018 passed in CWJC No. 5049 of 2018, titled as Diwakar Kumar Singh v. The State of Bihar;

    (ii) order dated 31.07.2018 passed in CWJC No. 13162 of 2018 titled as Rajesh Kumar Pandit @ Rajesh Pandit v. The State of Bihar;

    (iii) order dated 31.07.2018 passed in CWJC No. 14242 of 2018 titled as Amar Kumar v. The State of Bihar;

    (iv) order dated 12.02.2018 passed in CWJC No. 2437 of 2018 titled as Mahendra Manjhi v. The State of Bihar;

    (v) judgement dated 12.02.2018 passed in CWJC No. 2470 of 2018 titled as Laxman Das @ Lakshman Ravidas v. The State of Bihar;

    (vi) order dated 11.09.2017 passed in CWJC No. 13158 of 2017 titled as Sanjay Kumar v. The State of Bihar;

    (vii) order dated 27.03.2018 passed in CWJC No. 5528 of 2018 titled as Bikash Kumar v. The State of Bihar;

    (viii) order dated 27.03.2018 passed in CWJC No. 5528 of 2018 titled as Bikash Kumar v. The State of Bihar;

    (ix) order dated 01.05.2018 passed in CWJC No. 7755 of 2018 titled as Anandi Prasad v. The State of Bihar;

    (x) order dated 01.05.2018 passed in CWJC No. 7644 of 2018 titled as Suraj Ram v. The State of Bihar;

    (xi) order dated 07.08.2018 passed in CWJC No. 15435 of 2018 titled as Kalesar Chaudhari v. the State of Bihar;

    (xii) judgement dated 18.01.2019 passed in CWJC No. 1215 of 2019 titled as Raushan Kumar @ Raushan Kumar Singh v. The State of Bihar;

    (xiii) judgement dated 29.01.2019 passed in CWJC No. 1620 of 2019 titled as Asharfi Kumar @ Rakesh Kumar v. the State of Bihar;

    (xiv) judgement dated 08.02.2019 passed in CWJC No. 2380 of 2019 titled as Avinash Kumar v. the State of Bihar;

    (xv) judgement dated 29.01.2019 passed in CWJC No. 1648 of 2019 titled as Roshan Kumar v. The State of Bihar; and

    (xvi) judgement dated 22.01.2019 passed in CWJC No. 1314 of 2019 titled as Shanti Devi v. The State of Bihar

    34. In fact, in CWJC No. 5049 of 2018 titled as Diwakar Kumar Singh v. The State of Bihar the Court issued the following directions:—

    “That apart, in the confiscation proceedings, the confiscating authority shall take note of the provisions of Section 56 of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016 and record a positive finding after hearing the petitioner as to whether when the petitioner is found or the vehicle is found to be used by a person in drunken condition and no liquor is seized from the vehicle or when the vehicle is not used for transportation of liquor, whether the provision of Section 56 of the Act will apply. It shall be mandatory for the confiscating authority to decide this issue before passing any order on the confiscation proceedings. The confiscating authority shall consider the provision of Section 56 of the Act, apply his mind and pass a speaking order with regard to confiscation initiated.

    Without deciding the aforesaid issue as a preliminary issue, further proceedings in the confiscation proceedings shall be prohibited.

    We further request the office of the Advocate General to communicate this order to all the District Magistrates in the State of Bihar, who would be mandated to pass an appropriate order in such cases where the vehicle has been confiscated under Section 56 of the Act only on the allegation that the vehicle was being driven in a drunken condition and no liquor was seized from the vehicle nor the vehicle used for transportation or carriage of liquor. The issue shall be decided by each and every District Magistrate before proceeding in the confiscation proceedings where the allegation is about the vehicle being driven in a drunken condition and no liquor was found from the possession of the vehicle.

    It shall be the duty of the Advocate General to communicate this order to each and every District Magistrate and inform the Registrar General of this Court. In spite thereof, if we find that the District Magistrates are passing confiscation order without addressing this issue first, we may consider initiating contempt proceedings against the concerned District Magistrate.”

    35. It is further seen that in CWJC No. 15003 of 2019 titled as Shobha Devi v. The State of Bihar the Court observed as under:—

    “6. On examination of aforesaid fact, particularly allegation of the petitioner that in a court proceeding before the learned Special Judge, Excise, a false information was given, we are of the opinion that the court of learned Special Judge, Excise would be competent court to pass an appropriate order, in view of provisions contained in Section 340 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.

    7. Accordingly, the petitioner is granted liberty to file appropriate petition before the learned Special Judge, Excise for prosecuting the concerned police official.

    8. So far as claim of compensation is concerned, obviously on going through the material on record, since there was no recovery of liquor from the vehicle and it was a case, in which, the occupants of the vehicle were alleged to be in drunken condition and were creating nuisance, though were liable to be arrested. In any event, the vehicle was not required to be seized, since it was not liable to be confiscated.

    9. In such situation, we are of the opinion that it is a fit case, in which, we may direct to pay adequate compensation to the petitioner, being owner of the vehicle, to the tune of Rs. 75,000/- (seventy five thousand), however, Sri. Kumar Manish, learned Standing Counsel - 5 requests for granting an opportunity for obtaining detailed instruction and filing counter affidavit in the matter. The request of Sri. Kumar Manish, S.C.-5 is allowed for filing counter affidavit so that final order may be passed.

    10. It goes without saying that before filing counter affidavit, the respondent no. 4/Superintendent of Police, Darbhanga may conduct a preliminary inquiry regarding the conduct of the police officer, who had seized the vehicle of the petitioner and state all those facts in its counter affidavit, which must be filed by 29 of November, 2019. The affidavit must be sworn by the Superintendent of Police himself.

    11. It further goes without saying that if after considering all the facts, including counter affidavit, which is proposed to be filed, the Court comes to the conclusion that the petitioner is entitled for claim of amount of compensation, which has been referred hereinabove, the said compensation amount must be recovered from the pocket of the police officer, who was responsible for such illegal seizure.”

    36. Despite the same, only before this Court, when matters of similar nature came up for hearing on 16of December, 2019, the learned Advocate General assisted by Shri. Vikash Kumar, learned Standing Counsel-11, and Shri. Vivek Prasad, learned Government Pleader-7, vehemently opposed the petitions for release of the vehicles. Consequently, the writ petitions were disposed of with the directions to the appropriate authorities to positively initiate/conclude confiscatory proceedings within a period of 30-45 days.

    37. Without adjudicating the petitioner's petition on merits, we are of the considered view that interest of justice would be best met, if the petition is disposed of in the following terms:—

    (a) Since the vehicle in question stands seized in relation to the FIR which stood registered long ago, in case confiscation proceeding has not been initiated, it must be initiated within a period of 15 days from today and that confiscation proceeding stands initiated, we direct the appropriate authority under the Act to forthwith ensure that such proceedings be concluded not later than 30 days.

    (b) The petitioner undertakes to make himself available in the office of the concerned appropriate authority empowered under Section 58 of the Act i.e. District Collector, in his/her office on 04.02.2020 at 10:30 A.M.

    (c) We further direct the appropriate authority to positively conclude the confiscation proceeding within next thirty days on appearance of the petitioner. If for whatever reason, such proceeding cannot be concluded, in that event it shall be open for the authority to take such measures, as are permissible in law, for release of the vehicle in question by way of interim measure, on such terms as may be deemed appropriate, considering the attending facts and circumstances of the case.

    (d) If eventually, the appropriate authority arrives at a conclusion that the property is not liable to be confiscated, it shall be open for the petitioner to seek damages in accordance with law and have appropriate proceedings initiated against the erring officials/officers.

    38. Learned counsel for the petitioner states that the certified copy of the order shall be made available to the concerned District Collector on the date so fixed.

    39. For future guidance, where parties have not approached this Court, we issue the following direction:—

    The expression “reasonable delay” used in Section 58 of Chapter VI of the Act, in our considered view, necessarily has to be within a reasonable time and with dispatch, which period, in our considered view, three months time is sufficient enough for any authority to adjudicate any issue, more so, when we are dealing with confiscatory proceedings.

    We clarify that we have not adjudicated the writ petition on merits and it shall be open for the parties to take all stand in the adjudicatory proceedings and wherever parties are aggrieved, it shall be open to them to initiate appropriate proceeding before the appellate authority.

    Learned counsel for the State also undertakes to communicate the order to the concerned appropriate authority i.e. District Magistrate, empowered under Section 58 of the Act.”

    40. In Umesh Sah (supra), this Court had clarified that the expression “reasonable delay” under Section 58 of Chapter 6 of the Act has to be construed to be ‘not more than three months’.

    It is seen that despite our observations, the appropriate authorities have not taken any action in initiating the proceedings for confiscation of the property under the Act. The litigants are, thus, forced to approach this Court by way of filing separate petitions.

    Thus, today we are left with two options; either to initiate proceedings for contempt under the provisions of Contempt of Courts Act or under Article 215 of the Constitution of India or ask the Chief Secretary, Government of Bihar, to evolve a mechanism, self serving in nature, so as to ensure that the provisions of the Act are implemented in letter and spirit, expeditiously, without any delay and with reasonable dispatch.

    Why is it that the owners of the property are forced to approach this Court for release of the vehicles or property? Is it that there is no mechanism under the Act for initiating confiscatory proceedings at the earliest? Is it that there is insufficient infrastructure with the State Government for ensuring implementation of the provisions of the Act?

    Illustratively, in the weekly list dated 27.1.2020, we notice that more than 75cases stand filed and listed despite our order dated 9of January, 2020. In the instant case, seizure is of the year 2019 and no proceedings of confiscation have commenced.

    We are of the considered view that nonimplementation of the Act is generally having a very serious adverse consequence on the dispensation of administration of justice. And, peculiarly, it is only when the matter was taken up by the Bench hearing the petition bearing C.W.J.C. No. 25266 of 2019 (Vikki Kumar v. The State of Bihar) on 17.12.2019at the State vehemently opposed release of the vehicle, contrary to the practice adopted hitherto before.

    Be that as it may, at this point in time, we refrain from passing any order under the contempt jurisdiction, but direct the Chief Secretary, Government of Bihar, to file his personal affidavit dealing with each one of the issues highlighted (supra) as also elaborately indicating the mechanism which the State has or desires to evolve so as to prevent the litigants from directly approaching the Court for release of the vehicle and also ensuring early completion of the proceedings, be it confiscatory in nature or in an appellate jurisdiction, under the provisions of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016.

    Let an affidavit in that regard be positively filed within one week.

    List this case on 6.2.2020.”

    41. In the aforesaid decisions, we have already laid down the time-schedule within which all proceedings are necessarily required to be concluded and the outer limit is three months from the date on which this Court has directed the party to make himself available before the appropriate authority.

    42. We clarify that petitioner undertakes to fully cooperate in the proceedings and we further clarify that in case the authorities are not able to conclude the proceedings within the time bound period, the vehicle shall be allowed to be released on such conditions as the appropriate authority may deem fit and proper.

    43. As such, petition is disposed of making the directions contained in the orders referred to supra, applicable mutatis mutandis, insofar as applicable and possible, to the petitioner case.

    44. Petitioner through learned counsel undertakes to make himself available on 15 June, 2020 at 10:30 A.M. before the Collector, Patna in his office.

    45. We only hope and expect that the authorities under the Act shall take appropriate action at the earliest in accordance with law and within the time schedule fixed, failing which the vehicle shall be allowed to be released.

    46. Liberty reserved to the petitioner to take recourse to such remedies as are otherwise available in accordance with law if the need so arises.

    47. Petition stands disposed of with the aforesaid observations/directions.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Vishal Kumar Petitioner/S v. State Of Bihar Through The Principal Secretary And Another /S.
    (Jun 4, 2020)