AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This writ petition challenges the action of the District Magistrate, Jamui, who confiscated a motorcycle bearing Registration No.53B 7198 seized in connection with Malaypur P.S. Case No.79C2/18 for violation of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016 (the Act). Previously, the petitioner had approached this Court in CWJC No.5277 of 2018 against a similar action, where this Court ordered the release of the vehicle on furnishing two surety bonds and certain undertakings pending the finalization of confiscation proceedings.

Following the earlier order, the District Magistrate conducted verification of the vehicle documents and imposed additional conditions for release, including a personal bond, bank guarantee, two sureties, and submission of vehicle details. The petitioner challenged these additional requirements as contrary to the Court’s earlier directions. The Court examined the statutory provisions under Section 56 of the Act, which governs confiscation, and issued notices to the Chief Secretary, Government of Bihar, and the Collector of Jamui District to show cause why the confiscation and similar proceedings should not be quashed and compensation granted.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the confiscation of a vehicle under the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016 is permissible solely on the ground that the driver was found in a drunken condition.
  2. Whether the additional conditions imposed by the District Magistrate for release of the vehicle, beyond furnishing two sureties as directed by this Court, are lawful.
  3. Whether all confiscation proceedings in cases where the only offence is driving in a drunken condition should be quashed and compensation awarded for wrongful confiscation and harassment.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed Section 56 of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016, which specifies the categories of things liable for confiscation when an offence under the Act is committed. These include intoxicants, apparatus used in offences, unlawfully handled liquor, packaging, conveyances used for carrying such liquor, and premises used for storing or manufacturing liquor.

The Court noted that mere driving of a vehicle in a drunken condition does not fall within the categories specified for confiscation under Section 56. It observed that the District Magistrate’s insistence on additional security measures beyond two sureties was contrary to the Court’s prior order and amounted to circumventing judicial directions.

The Court further recognized a pattern of illegal confiscation of vehicles in Bihar solely on the basis of drunken driving offences, which it deemed as harassment and beyond the statutory authority granted under the Act. Consequently, the Court issued notices to the State authorities to show cause why such confiscations should not be quashed and compensation granted to affected persons.

Holding and Implications

The Court held that confiscation of vehicles solely on the ground of drunken driving is not authorized under Section 56 of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016, and that the additional conditions imposed by the District Magistrate for release of the vehicle were unlawful and disapproved.

The direct effect of this decision is to restrain the State authorities from confiscating vehicles in cases where the only offence is drunken driving and to ensure compliance with this Court’s directions regarding vehicle release. The Court’s notice to the State authorities signals potential quashing of all such confiscation proceedings and possible compensation for wrongful confiscation and harassment. No new legal precedent beyond the interpretation of Section 56 and the procedural directions was established.

    Rajesh Kumar Pandit @ Rajesh Pandit v. State Of Bihar And Others

    Rajendra Menon, C.J. (Oral) - Challenging the action of the District Magistrate, Jamui, to confiscate a motorcycle bearing Registration No.53B 7198, which has been seized in connection with Malaypur P.S. Case No.79C2/18 for violation of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016 (hereinafter referred to as ''''the Act''''), this writ petition has been filed.

    2. Earlier also, when the same action was taken, the petitioner approached this Court in CWJC No.5277 of 2018 and we, by an order passed on 22.03.2018, as has been done in a large number of cases, directed for release of the vehicle pending finalization of the confiscation case on the petitioner furnishing two surety bonds to the satisfaction of the District Magistrate and further undertaking to produce the vehicle as and when directed by the authority concerned and not to alienate or deal with the vehicle in question or create a third party interest during the pendency of the confiscation proceedings.

    3. When the petitioner approached the District Magistrate for release of the vehicle, the District Magistrate has passed a detailed order and has issued the following directions:-

    4. The District Magistrate took note of the order passed by us in the writ petition, as is detailed hereinabove, and directed for verifying the documents of the vehicle. This was a reasonable approach of the District Magistrate and we approve the same.

    5. Thereafter, the District Magistrate has directed that personal bond of Rs. 42,000/-along with bank guarantee and two sureties and an affidavit be furnished by the petitioner. When we had directed for release of the vehicle on furnishing of two sureties, insistence upon by the Collector or the District Magistrate to submit a personal bond and a bank guarantee of Rs. 42,000/- is an act of circumventing and disobeying the directions issued by us in the writ petition. We do not approve the aforesaid act of the District Magistrate.

    6. That apart, the District Magistrate has also directed for submission of photograph of the registration number, chassis number of the vehicle and various other issues, may be in an anxiety to get security on behalf of the State, he has done so. For the present, we are not commenting upon the same, but at the same time, we may take note of the fact that the only allegation against the petitioner is that he along with a co-passenger was driving the vehicle in a drunken condition. Driving a vehicle in a drunken condition may be an offence under the Act. However, to initiate a confiscation proceeding or power of confiscation is available to the District Magistrate or the statutory authority only under Section 56 of the Act and Section 56 of the Act for the sake of brevity reads as under:

    "56. Things liable for confiscation.- Whenever an offence has been committed, which is punishable under this Act, following things shall be liable to confiscation, namely -

    (a) any intoxicant, liquor, material, still, utensil, implement, apparatus in respect of or by means of which such offence has been committed;

    (b) any intoxicant or liquor unlawfully imported, transported, manufactured, sold or brought along with or in addition to, any intoxicant, liable to confiscation under clause (a);

    (c) any receptacle, package, or covering in which anything liable to confiscation under clause (a) or clause (b), is found, and the other contents, if any, of such receptacle, package or covering;

    (d) any animal, vehicle, vessel or other conveyance used for carrying the same.

    (e) any premises or part thereof that may have been used for storing or manufacturing any liquor or intoxicant or for committing any other offence under this Act.

    Explanation : The word "premises" include the immoveable structure, all moveable items within the structure and the land on which the premises is situated."

    7. If we analyze the aforesaid provision, we find that whenever an offence has been committed under the Act and which is punishable, the things and items mentioned from sub-clause (a) to (e) are liable to be confiscated. Sub-clause (a) deals with intoxicant, liquor, material, still, untensil, implement, apparatus and other means which are used for committing of the offence. Clause (b) speaks about unlawful import, transportation, manufacturing and bringing, selling of intoxicant or liquor within the territory of the State in question. Clause (c) speaks about any receptacle, package or covering and any other item used for packaging or covering of the material. Clause (d) speaks about the animal, vehicle, vessel or other conveyance used for carrying the intoxicant, liquor and clause (e) deals with the premises or part thereof that may have been used for storing or manufacturing any liquor or intoxicant.

    8. If the provision of Section 56 of the Act, which is the only provision for confiscation under the Act, is analyzed, we find that only because a person is driving a vehicle or is found in a drunken condition, there is no provision for confiscation of the vehicle and proceeding against such an individual under Section 56 of the Act. We find that more than hundreds of cases have come to our notice where merely because the driver was found in a drunken condition, the vehicle has been seized, the confiscation has been held and in some cases even confiscation orders have been passed. Prima facie, in our considered opinion, all confiscation proceedings initiated and all confiscation done in the State of Bihar with regard to persons, who have only committed an offence of moving in a drunken condition, is an illegal act on the part of the State Government and the officers of the State Government. They are acting beyond the provisions of law and the citizens, who are found to have been committed an offence of driving a vehicle or moving in a drunken condition, are being harassed by confiscation of the vehicle and compelled to approach this Court challenging the confiscation.

    9. We, therefore, issue notice to the Chief Secretary, Government of Bihar, Patna and the Collector of the District concerned, i.e. Jamui to show cause as to why the entire confiscation proceedings in this case and all other cases of identical nature should not be quashed and compensation granted to the person concerned who has to take recourse to the remedy available of approaching this Court either for release of the vehicle or for challenging the confiscation proceedings. We direct the Chief Secretary, Government of Bihar, Patna, and the District Magistrate of the case in question to answer and to this show cause the aforesaid on or before 30th July, 2018.

    10. List on 31st July, 2018. On the said date, we will pass a detailed order including the orders for grant of compensation for the damage, loss or harassment caused to the person in case we are satisfied that the provisions of Section 56 of the Act will not apply in cases where the only allegation is that the person concerned was found in a drunken condition.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rajesh Kumar Pandit @ Rajesh Pandit v. State Of Bihar And Others
    (Jul 10, 2018)