Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2020 INSC 244
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Article 136 of the Constitution of India
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2020 INSC 244
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Article 136 of the Constitution of India
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 1 December 2005, at approximately 4–5 a.m. in Village Hinotiya Gird, Bal Kishan (son of Bhagwan Singh) was killed in a cattle shed allegedly by five accused: Bal Kishan (Accused 1) armed with an axe and Accused 2-5 armed with lathis. The prosecution’s case rested principally on the testimony of the deceased’s mother, Mullo Bai (PW-8), who stated that she witnessed the incident when she awoke to barking dogs and observed the assailants in torchlight.

The trial court convicted all five accused for offences punishable under Section 302 read with Section 149 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and Section 450 IPC. Accused 2-5 appealed (Criminal Appeal No. 574 of 2006), and Accused 1 filed a separate appeal. On 19 April 2018, the High Court of Madhya Pradesh at Gwalior dismissed both appeals, affirming the convictions (Bal Kishan v. State of M.P., 2018 SCC OnLine MP 1614). A Special Leave Petition by Accused 1 was later dismissed by the Supreme Court. Accused 2-5 thereafter sought relief before the Supreme Court, resulting in the present judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the conviction of Accused 2-5 can be sustained solely on the testimony of the single eyewitness (PW-8) in light of alleged material contradictions, omissions and improvements in her statements.
  2. Whether, in the absence of reliable evidence establishing a common object, Accused 2-5 could be held liable for murder under Section 302 with the aid of Section 149 IPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants – Accused 2-5

  • The trial court and High Court relied exclusively on PW-8, whose testimony contained material contradictions and improvements, rendering it unreliable.
  • Identification was impossible because the murder occurred on an “Amavasya” (moonless) night; PW-8 alternately cited torchlight and chimney light, and no torch was recovered.
  • PW-8’s deposition in court introduced new assertions—such as Accused Santosh and Rakesh holding the deceased—that were absent from her Section 161 CrPC statement.
  • The High Court improperly treated the Section 161 statement (inadmissible in evidence) to conclude that Accused 2-5 carried lathis.
  • No cogent evidence established a common object; therefore, Section 149 IPC could not be invoked.
  • Prior enmity between the families suggested possible false implication.
  • The case against Accused 2-5 was distinguishable from that of Accused 1, whose conviction rested on consistent testimony and recovery of the murder weapon.

Respondent – State of Madhya Pradesh

  • Both lower courts recorded concurrent findings of fact based on proper appreciation of evidence, which should not be disturbed under Article 136 of the Constitution.
  • Conviction can legally rest on the testimony of a single eyewitness if that witness is reliable; PW-8’s presence at the scene was natural and her testimony trustworthy.
  • PW-8 identified the appellants not only visually but also by their voices.
  • The Supreme Court’s affirmation of Accused 1’s conviction on the same testimony reinforced PW-8’s credibility.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bal Kishan v. State of M.P., 2018 SCC OnLine MP 1614 (High Court judgment under appeal) Concurrent confirmation of conviction based on sole eyewitness testimony Reviewed and set aside to the extent it pertained to Accused 2-5

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court acknowledged that a conviction may legally rest on a solitary eyewitness, but only if that testimony is “trustworthy and reliable” and free from material discrepancies. It undertook a detailed comparison of PW-8’s Section 161 CrPC statement with her deposition:

  • Contradictory identification conditions: PW-8 first claimed torchlight illumination yet later introduced a chimney light; no torch was recovered.
  • New elements at trial: The assertion that Accused Santosh and Rakesh held the deceased did not appear in the earlier statement.
  • Use of Section 161 statement by High Court: The High Court’s reliance on that statement to establish that Accused 2-5 carried lathis was impermissible because such statements are inadmissible except for proving contradictions.
  • Lack of corroboration: No other eyewitness supported the prosecution, and named witnesses PW-1 and PW-2 turned hostile.
  • Common object unproved: The evidence did not demonstrate shared intent among Accused 2-5 sufficient to attract liability under Section 149 IPC.
  • Distinguishing Accused 1: PW-8’s statements concerning Accused 1 were consistent and corroborated by recovery of the axe, circumstances absent for Accused 2-5.

Given these “material contradictions, omissions and improvements,” the Court held it unsafe to base a conviction of Accused 2-5 solely on PW-8’s testimony and extended to them the benefit of doubt.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed – Accused 2-5 Acquitted.

The Supreme Court quashed the convictions under Section 302 read with Section 149 IPC and ordered the immediate release of Accused 2-5 unless required in another case. The decision affects only the parties involved; it sets no new precedent beyond reaffirming the principle that sole-witness testimony must be free of material infirmities to sustain a conviction.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Parvat Singh And Others v. State Of Madhya Pradesh .

    M.R. Shah, J.— Leave granted. Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the impugned judgment and order dated 19-4-2018 passed by the High Court of Madhya Pradesh at Gwalior in Bal Kishan v. State of M.P. 2018 SCC OnLine MP 1614 by which the High Court has confirmed the conviction of the appellants herein — original Accused 2 to 5 for the offences punishable under Section 302 r/w Section 149 IPC, 1860 the original Accused 2 to 5 have preferred the present appeal.

    2. All the accused including the appellants came to be tried by the learned trial court for the offences under Section 302 r/w Section 149 IPC for having killed one Bal Kishan, son of the informant Mullo Bai on 1-12-2005 around 4-5 a.m. in the morning at Village Hinotiya Gird.

    3. According to the case of the prosecution, the informant Mullo Bai — PW 8 was sleeping in the cattle shed. At that time, the appellants and one another accused named Bal Kishan, s/o Diman Singh while sharing common object caused murder of Bal Kishan, s/o Bhagwan Singh. According to the informant there was a dispute going on between the parties. As per the case of the prosecution and according to the informant, when she was sleeping in the cattle shed in the house, around 4-5 a.m. in the morning due to the barking of the dogs she woke up and in the light of torch, she saw that in the cattle shed, accused Bal Kishan with an axe and other original Accused 2 to 5 herein with sticks/lathis in their hands were standing. Thereafter, accused Bal Kishan entered in the cattle shed and with an intention to kill her son Bal Kishan gave a blow of axe. She shouted and the other members of the family and nearby house came there and all the accused ran away from the spot. Investigation was carried out by one Mahesh Sharma, Investigating Officer — PW 12. He recorded the statements of witnesses concerned. The IO also obtained the relevant evidences including the medical evidence and also the post-mortem report. That all the accused were charge-sheeted for the offences punishable under Section 302 r/w Section 149 and Section 450 IPC. The case was committed to the Court of Session. All the accused pleaded not guilty, therefore, all the accused came to be tried by the learned trial court for the aforesaid offences.

    4. To prove the case against the accused, the prosecution examined in all 12 witnesses including PW 8 Mullo Bai, informant — mother of the deceased who was the sole eyewitness. At this stage, it is required to be noted that mother of the deceased Mullo Bai was the sole eyewitness. At this stage, it is required to be noted that the axe used in the commission of the offence by the original Accused 1 was recovered at the instance of Accused 1 himself. Ratan Singh — PW 1 and Pahalwan Singh — PW 2 did not support the prosecution and therefore, they were declared as hostile by the prosecution. In support of the defence two witnesses were examined by the defence to bring home the theory of alibi in respect of original Accused 1 — Bal Kishan.

    5. After perusing the evidence led by the parties and solely relying upon the evidence of Mullo Bai — PW 8 the sole eyewitness, the learned trial court convicted all the accused for the offences under Section 302 r/w Section 149 IPC.

    6. Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the judgment and order of conviction by the learned trial court, the appellants herein — original Accused 2 to 5 preferred Criminal Appeal No. 574 of 2006 before the High Court. Original Accused 1 also preferred one separate appeal. By the impugned judgment and order 2018 SCC OnLine MP 1614, the High Court has dismissed the appeal preferred by Accused 2 to 5 — appellants herein. The High Court also dismissed the appeal preferred by Accused 1 — Bal Kishan. It is reported that the SLP against the judgment and order of conviction of the original Accused 1 — Bal Kishan is dismissed by this Court. Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the impugned judgment passed by the High Court, the original Accused 2 to 5 have preferred the present appeal.

    7. Shri A.K. Srivastava, learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of all the appellants — original Accused 2 to 5 has vehemently submitted that in the facts and circumstances of the case, the High Court has materially erred in dismissing the appeal and confirming the judgment and order of conviction passed by the learned trial court and convicting them for the offences under Section 302 r/w Section 149 IPC.

    7.1. It is vehemently submitted by Mr Srivastava, learned Senior Advocate that the High Court has not properly appreciated the fact that the trial court convicted the appellants solely relying upon the evidence/deposition of Mullo Bai — PW 8.

    7.2. It is submitted that the High Court has not properly appreciated the fact that so far as the evidence/deposition of PW 8 is concerned, it is full of material contradiction and improvements.

    7.3. It is further submitted by the learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of the appellants that the High Court has not properly appreciated the fact that it was a black night when the incident took place, there was a dark, and it was not possible for Mullo Bai to recognise/identify the accused — the appellants herein.

    7.4. It is further submitted that as such there was material contradiction in the deposition of the PW 8 insofar as identifying/recognising the appellants in the light of torch or from the chimney light. It is further submitted by the learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of the appellants that the testimony of Mullo Bai — PW 8 suffers from material omissions, which amounts to contradictions as well as material improvements in her statement in court as regards place of incident where she was sleeping. It is submitted that it was for the first time in the court that she has stated that accused Santosh and Rakesh caught hold the deceased and that Bal Kishan inflicted axe injury over his neck.

    7.5. It is further submitted that in fact there is no recovery of any torch from the place of incident.

    7.6. It is further submitted that even the observations made by the High Court that the appellants herein went with the lathis is contrary to the evidence on record. It is submitted that in the deposition of PW 8 — Mullo Bai, she has not stated anything that the appellants herein were carrying the lathis. It is submitted that in her statement recorded under Section 161 CrPC she has stated that the appellants were having lathis, but the statement under Section 161 CrPC is not admissible in evidence and therefore the High Court has committed a grave error in observing that the appellants were having lathis, solely relying upon the statement of PW 8 recorded under Section 161 CrPC.

    7.7. It is further submitted by the learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of the appellants that as such there is no cogent material and/or evidence with respect to the common object and/or conspiracy hatched amongst the accused persons to kill the deceased. It is submitted that the appellants are convicted with the aid of Section 149 IPC. It is submitted that, therefore, in absence of theory of common intention/object, the appellants could not have been convicted for the offences under Section 302 IPC with the aid of Section 149 IPC.

    7.8. It is further submitted by the learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of the appellants that even as per the deposition of Mullo Bai — PW 8 the dispute was going on between the parties. It is submitted that therefore the false implication of the appellants cannot be ruled out. It is submitted that therefore conviction of the accused is solely based upon the evidence — deposition of PW 8 and no other independent witness supports the case of the prosecution and that the evidence — deposition of PW 8 is full of contradictions, omissions and improvements, it is not safe to convict the appellants solely relying upon the evidence/deposition of PW 8.

    7.9. It is further submitted by the learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of the appellants — original Accused 2 to 5 that the case of the original Accused 2 to 5 is clearly distinguishable on facts, from that of original Accused 1. It is further submitted that there are not much contradictions and/or improvements in the case so far as original Accused 1 is concerned. It is submitted that so far as Accused 1 is concerned, it can be seen that PW 8 is consistent with her statement under Section 161 CrPC as well as her deposition before the court. It is submitted that even there was a recovery of axe used in the commission of the offence at the instance of the original Accused 1. It is submitted that therefore the dismissal of SLP qua original Accused 1 would not come in the way of appeal. It is further submitted that even otherwise, the SLP was dismissed in limine and therefore it is prayed to consider the present appeal on its own merits.

    8. Making the above submissions it is prayed to allow the present appeal.

    9. The present appeal is vehemently opposed by Ms Madhurima Mridul, learned advocate appearing on behalf of the respondent State.

    10. It is vehemently submitted by the learned advocate appearing on behalf of the State that there are a concurrent finding of facts recorded by both the courts below while convicting the appellants for the offences under Section 302 r/w Section 149 IPC. It is submitted that the findings recorded by the learned trial court and the High Court are on appreciation of evidence and therefore the same are not required to be interfered with by this Court in exercise of powers under Article 136 of the Constitution of India.

    10.1. It is further submitted by the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the State that in the present case though the conviction of the appellants is solely based upon the deposition of PW 8 — Mullo Bai, however there is no rule that there cannot be any conviction relying upon the sole witness, more particularly an eyewitness. It is submitted that PW 8 is a reliable and trustworthy witness. It is submitted that her presence on the spot is natural as the incident has taken place in her house and near the place where she was sleeping. It is submitted that as she is the sole eyewitness to the incident, both the courts are justified in convicting the accused relying upon the deposition/evidence of PW 8 — Mullo Bai.

    10.2. It is further submitted by the learned counsel on behalf of the State that in the present case the presence of appellants herein, original Accused 2 to 5 on the spot has been established and proved by the prosecution by examining PW 8 who is the eyewitness. It is submitted that presence on the spot at the time of incident and that too between 4-5 a.m. early morning is sufficient to convict the accused for the offence under Section 302 IPC with the aid of Section 149 IPC.

    10.3. It is further submitted by the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the State that even the accused were recognised and identified by PW 8 — Mullo Bai even from their voice, so stated by PW 8 in her deposition.

    10.4. It is further submitted by the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the State that the original Accused 1 also came to be convicted solely relying upon the deposition of PW 8. It is submitted that the conviction of original Accused 1 has been confirmed up to this Court. It is submitted that therefore there is no reason not to believe PW 8 so far as the appellants, original Accused 2 to 5 are concerned. It is submitted that therefore both the courts below have rightly convicted the appellants herein for the offences under Section 302 r/w Section 149 IPC. Making the above submissions, it is prayed to dismiss the present appeal.

    11. Heard the learned counsel for the respective parties at length. We have gone through and considered in detail the entire evidence recorded by the learned trial court as well as the High Court. We have also considered in detail the evidence on record more particularly the statement of PW 8 — Mullo Bai recorded under Section 161 CrPC as well as her deposition before the court.

    12. At the outset, it is required to be noted that the appellants herein — original Accused 2 to 5 are convicted by the learned trial court and the High Court solely relying upon the evidence/deposition of PW 8 — Mullo Bai. It cannot be disputed that there can be a conviction relying upon the evidence/deposition of the sole witness. However, at the same time, the evidence/deposition of the sole witness can be relied upon, provided it is found to be trustworthy and reliable and there are no material contradictions and/or omissions and/or improvements in the case of the prosecution. Therefore, the question which is posed for consideration of this Court is whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, can the appellants herein, original Accused 2 to 5 be convicted relying upon the deposition of the sole witness — PW 8 and whether PW 8 is a reliable and trustworthy witness to convict the appellants herein, original Accused 2 to 5?

    13. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the respective parties and considering the evidence on record, we are of the opinion that the evidence/deposition of PW 8 is full of material contradictions, omissions and improvements.

    13.1. It is required to be noted that it was a black night (Amavasya) at the time of incident. It was a dark night as the incident has happened between 4-5 a.m. PW 8 in her statement recorded under Section 161 CrPC has stated that she has seen all the accused in the light of the torch. She has stated that Bal Kishan — original Accused 1 was having an axe and other four were armed with lathis. She had also stated in her statement under Section 161 CrPC that Bal Kishan — original Accused 1 gave the axe-blow on the neck of the deceased due to the enmity and earlier dispute and other accused were telling to run away immediately and thereafter all the five accused ran away from behind the cattle shed/house. She stated that she had identified all the accused in the light of the torch and also by voice. According to her after she shouted, other persons came. However, there is material improvement in her deposition before the court. In her deposition, she has stated that accused Santosh and Rakesh caught hold of Bal Kishan — deceased. In her deposition, she has also stated that there was a chimney light in the cattle shed. She has also stated in her deposition that the accused ran away from the nearby agricultural field of sugarcane. Therefore, the deposition of PW 8 is full of material contradictions and improvements so far as original Accused 2 to 5 is concerned. It is required to be noted that no other independent witness even named by PW 8 has supported the case of the prosecution. Though, according to PW 8, she identified the accused in the light of the torch, there is no recovery of torch. There is material improvement so far as the chimney light is concerned. In her deposition, she has not stated anything that the appellants — original Accused 2 to 5 were having the lathis, though she has stated this in her statement under Section 161 CrPC. The High Court has observed relying upon her statement recorded under Section 161 CrPC that the appellants herein — Accused 2 to 5 were having lathis. However, as per the settled proposition of law a statement recorded under Section 161 CrPC is inadmissible in evidence and cannot be relied upon or used to convict the accused. As per the settled proposition of law, the statement recorded under Section 161 CrPC can be used only to prove the contradictions and/or omissions. Therefore, as such, the High Court has erred in relying upon the statement of PW 8 recorded under Section 161 CrPC while observing that the appellants were having the lathis.

    13.2. As observed hereinabove in her statement under Section 161 CrPC, she has never stated that accused Santosh and Rakesh caught hold of Bal Kishan, but stated that the appellants herein told to run away as other persons have woken. In the facts and circumstances of the case, there are material contradictions, omissions and/or improvements so far as the appellants herein — original Accused 2 to 5 are concerned and therefore we are of the opinion that it is not safe to convict the appellants on the evidence of the sole witness of PW 8. The benefit of material contradictions, omissions and improvements must go in favour of the appellants herein. Therefore, as such the appellants are entitled to be given benefit of doubt.

    13.3. Now, so far as the submission on behalf of the State that relying upon the deposition of PW 8, the original Accused 1 was convicted and his conviction has been confirmed up to this Court and therefore to dismiss the present appeal qua other accused is concerned from the evidence on record and having observed hereinabove the case of the appellants — original Accused 2 to 5, is distinguishable on facts. There are material contradictions and omissions so far as the appellants — original Accused 2 to 5 are concerned. So far as the original Accused 1 is concerned, PW 8 is consistent in her statement under Section 161 CrPC as well as in her deposition before the court. There was a recovery of axe used in commission of the offence by Accused 1 at the instance of Accused 1. Under the circumstances, the case of the original Accused 2 to 5 is clearly distinguishable to that of original Accused 1.

    14. For the reasons stated hereinabove, we are of the firm opinion that in view of the material contradictions, omissions and improvements in the statement of PW 8 recorded under Section 161 CrPC as well as deposition before the court qua the appellants — Accused 2 to 5 and that there was a prior enmity and no other independent witness has supported the case of the prosecution, we are of the opinion that the appellants herein — original Accused 2 to 5 are entitled to be given the benefit of doubt.

    15. Under the circumstances, the present appeal is allowed. The impugned judgment and order of conviction passed by the learned trial court and confirmed by the High Court convicting the appellants herein — Accused 2 to 5 for the offence under Section 302 r/w Section 149 IPC are hereby quashed and set aside and the appellants herein — original Accused 2 to 5 are acquitted of the charges for which they were tried. The appellants herein — Accused 2 to 5 be released forthwith, if not required in any other case.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Parvat Singh And Others v. State Of Madhya Pradesh .
    (Mar 2, 2020)