AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2020 INSC 173
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order 41 Rule 31 CPC, Article 54 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act
  • Section 96 read with Order 41 Rule 31 of the Code
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Story on Constitution (of United States), Vol. 2, Article 1762
  • Article 54 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act, 1963
  • Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
  • Story on Constitution (of United States), Vol. 2, Article 1761
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2020 INSC 173
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order 41 Rule 31 CPC, Article 54 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act
  • Section 96 read with Order 41 Rule 31 of the Code
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Story on Constitution (of United States), Vol. 2, Article 1762
  • Article 54 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act, 1963
  • Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
  • Story on Constitution (of United States), Vol. 2, Article 1761
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant–plaintiff filed OS No. 32 of 2005 seeking specific performance of an agreement to sell dated 30-3-2000. The contract contemplated execution of the sale deed within three years, conditioned on the defendants performing certain obligations. Defendant 1 admitted execution of the agreement but asserted that (i) the suit was time-barred and (ii) the plaintiff lacked readiness and willingness to perform. The trial court framed issues on execution, readiness and willingness, limitation, and relief, ultimately dismissing the suit on the grounds of limitation and lack of readiness/willingness. The High Court of Karnataka affirmed that dismissal on 9-2-2012. The plaintiff appealed to the Supreme Court; delay was condoned and leave granted.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court, as the first appellate court under Section 96 CPC, erred by issuing a cryptic judgment that failed to comply with the requirements of Order 41 Rule 31 CPC.
  2. Consequent to the above, whether the decree confirming dismissal of the suit for specific performance—on grounds of limitation and the plaintiff’s alleged lack of readiness and willingness—could stand.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The High Court’s judgment is cursory and does not undertake the mandatory re-appraisal of evidence required in a first appeal; it ignores the guidelines of Order 41 Rule 31 CPC.
  • Under Article 54 of the Limitation Act, the suit filed on 28-1-2005 was within the three-year period from the contractual deadline; therefore, the finding of limitation is erroneous.
  • The High Court rendered no independent finding on the plaintiff’s readiness and willingness to perform.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hari Shankar v. Rao Girdhari Lal Chowdhury, AIR 1963 SC 698 Right of appeal includes rehearing on law and fact. Reinforces that the High Court had to re-examine evidence as a first appellate court.
Shankar Ramchandra Abhyankar v. Krishnaji Dattatreya Bapat, (1969) 2 SCC 74 Defines appellate jurisdiction as revisional and corrective. Used to underscore the corrective role neglected by the High Court.
Santosh Hazari v. Purushottam Tiwari, (2001) 3 SCC 179 First appellate court must give reasoned findings on all issues. Cited to highlight mandatory duty under Order 41 Rule 31 CPC.
Madhukar v. Sangram, (2001) 4 SCC 756 Same principle: necessity of reasoned judgment in first appeal. Supports the conclusion that the High Court’s order is infirm.
B.M. Narayana Gowda v. Shanthamma, (2011) 15 SCC 476 Requirement of conscious application of mind in first appeal. Illustrates standards the High Court failed to meet.
H.K.N. Swami v. Irshad Basith, (2005) 10 SCC 243 Value of first appeal as a full rehearing. Used to stress the High Court’s omission.
Sri Raja Lakshmi Dyeing Works v. Rangaswamy Chettiar, (1980) 4 SCC 259 First appellate court’s duty to address all issues. Further authority for remand.
Vinod Kumar v. Gangadhar, (2015) 1 SCC 391 Reiterates principles governing first appeals. Cited as recent affirmation of the standard.
B.V. Nagesh v. H.V. Sreenivasa Murthy, (2010) 13 SCC 530 Obligation to formulate points for determination. Shows procedural lapse by the High Court.
Shasidhar v. Ashwini Uma Mathad, (2015) 11 SCC 269 Failure to observe Order 41 Rule 31 prejudices parties. Provides direct basis for setting aside the judgment.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court observed that a first appeal under Section 96 CPC is a continuation of the suit, requiring the appellate court to re-appreciate evidence and address both factual and legal issues. Order 41 Rule 31 mandates the judgment to (a) frame points for determination, (b) decide those points, and (c) state reasons. Reviewing the High Court’s single-paragraph dismissal, the Court found:

  • No formulation of points for determination.
  • No discussion or re-appraisal of evidence concerning limitation or readiness and willingness.
  • No independent reasoning justifying concurrence with the trial court.

Such non-compliance constitutes a substantial procedural infirmity. While the Supreme Court acknowledged that an appellate court need not restate all evidence if concurring with the trial court, it must still demonstrate conscious application of mind. Because these standards were not met, the High Court judgment could not stand.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed in part; the High Court’s judgment dated 9-2-2012 is set aside, and the matter is remanded to the High Court for fresh disposal in accordance with law.

Implications: The decision does not decide the merits of the specific-performance suit but reinforces procedural discipline for first appellate courts, mandating compliance with Order 41 Rule 31 CPC. The parties retain the right to agitate all issues before the High Court on remand; no new substantive precedent is created, but existing principles on appellate duties are reaffirmed.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Malluru Mallappa (Dead) Through Legal Representatives v. Kuruvathappa And Others

    S. Abdul Nazeer, J.— Delay condoned. Leave granted. This is the plaintiff's appeal challenging the judgment and decree in Malluru Mallappa v. Kuruvathappa 2012 SCC OnLine Kar 2487 dated 9-2-2012 passed by the High Court of Karnataka at Bangalore, whereby the High Court has confirmed the judgment and decree passed by the trial court in OS No. 32 of 2005 dated 9-6-2006.

    2. The plaintiff filed the above suit against the respondent-defendants for specific performance of the agreement to sell dated 30-3-2000. The agreement provided that the sale was to be executed within three years from the date of the agreement, subject to the defendants fulfilling certain obligations.

    3. Defendant 1 filed the written statement and the other defendants filed a memo adopting the same as their written statement. Defendant 1 admitted the execution of the agreement to sell in favour of the plaintiff. However, the defendant pleaded that the suit was barred by limitation. It was further contended that the plaintiff was not ready and willing to perform his part of the contract.

    4. Based upon the rival pleadings of the parties, the trial court framed the following issues:

    “1. Whether the plaintiff proves that, Defendants 1 and 2 their father have executed an agreement to sell on 30-3-2000 for Rs 2,00,000 in favour of the plaintiff after receiving Rs 1,50,000 as earnest money?
    2. Whether the plaintiff proves that, he is always ready and willing to perform his part of contract?
    3. Whether the suit of the plaintiff is barred by limitation?
    4. What order or decree?”

    5. The plaintiff got himself examined as PW 1 and Exts. P-1, P-1(a) to (c) were marked in his evidence. Defendant 1 was examined as DW 1 and three other witnesses were examined as DWs 2 to 4. On appreciation of the evidence on record, the trial court held that the suit was barred by time. It was also held that the plaintiff was not ready and willing to perform his part of the contract. The suit was accordingly dismissed.

    6. As noticed above, the High Court has confirmed the said decree of the trial court.

    7. We have heard Shri S.N. Bhat, learned counsel for the appellant-plaintiff. Though notice was served on the respondents, no one has entered appearance on their behalf.

    8. Shri Bhat, learned counsel, has made twofold submissions. Firstly, he submits that the High Court has passed a cryptic judgment without reappreciating the evidence on record. It was argued that the first appeal filed by the plaintiff under Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short “CPC”) was a continuation of the suit and it was incumbent upon the High Court to reassess the entire evidence on record. It was argued that the High Court as an appellate court has failed to follow the guidelines provided under Order 41 Rule 31 CPC while deciding the appeal. Secondly, it was argued that the agreement to sell was dated 30-3-2000, providing for three years' time from the date of the agreement to complete the execution of the sale deed. The suit was filed on 28-1-2005 which was well within time. Referring to Article 54 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act, 1963 (for short “the Limitation Act”) it was submitted that when a date is fixed for performance of the contract, the period of limitation for filing the suit is three years from the date fixed for the performance. It was further argued that there is no finding by the High Court as to the readiness and willingness of the plaintiff to perform his part of the contract.

    9. We have carefully considered the submission of the learned counsel made at the Bar and perused the materials placed on record.

    10. Section 96 CPC provides for filing of an appeal from the decree passed by any court exercising original jurisdiction to the court authorised to hear the appeals from the decisions of such courts. In the instant case, the appeal from the decree passed by the trial court lies to the High Court. The expression “appeal” has not been defined in CPC. Black's Law Dictionary (7th Edn.) defines an appeal as “a proceeding undertaken to have a decision reconsidered by bringing it to a higher authority”. It is a judicial examination of the decision by a higher court of the decision of a subordinate court to rectify any possible error in the order under appeal. The law provides the remedy of an appeal because of the recognition that those manning the judicial tiers too commit errors.

    11. In Hari Shankar v. Rao Girdhari Lal Chowdhury AIR 1963 SC 698 it was held that a right of appeal carries with it a right of rehearing on law as well as on fact, unless the statute conferring a right of appeal limits the rehearing in some way as has been done in second appeal arising under CPC.

    12. In Shankar Ramchandra Abhyankar v. Krishnaji Dattatreya Bapat (1969) 2 SCC 74 it was held thus :

    “5. … In the well-known work of Story on Constitution (of United States), Vol. 2, Article 1761, it is stated that the essential criterion of appellate jurisdiction is that it revises and corrects the proceedings in a cause already instituted and does not create that cause. The appellate jurisdiction may be exercised in a variety of forms and, indeed, in any form in which the legislature may choose to prescribe. According to Article 1762, the most usual modes of exercising appellate jurisdiction, at least those which are most known in the United States, are by a writ of error, or by an appeal, or by some process of removal of a suit from an inferior tribunal. An appeal is a process of civil law origin and removes a cause, entirely subjecting the fact as well as the law, to a review and a retrial.”

    13. It is a settled position of law that an appeal is a continuation of the proceedings of the original court. Ordinarily, the appellate jurisdiction involves a rehearing on law as well as on fact and is invoked by an aggrieved person. The first appeal is a valuable right of the appellant and therein all questions of fact and law decided by the trial court are open for reconsideration. Therefore, the first appellate court is required to address itself to all the issues and decide the case by giving reasons. The court of first appeal must record its findings only after dealing with all issues of law as well as fact and with the evidence, oral as well as documentary, led by the parties. The judgment of the first appellate court must display conscious application of mind and record findings supported by reasons on all issues and contentions [see : Santosh Hazari v. Purushottam Tiwari (2001) 3 SCC 179, Madhukar v. Sangram (2001) 4 SCC 756, B.M. Narayana Gowda v. Shanthamma (2011) 15 SCC 476, H.K.N. Swami v. Irshad Basith (2005) 10 SCC 243 and Sri Raja Lakshmi Dyeing Works v. Rangaswamy Chettiar (1980) 4 SCC 259].

    14. A first appeal under Section 96 CPC is entirely different from a second appeal under Section 100. Section 100 expressly bars second appeal unless a question of law is involved in a case and the question of law so involved is substantial in nature.

    15. Order 41 Rule 31 CPC provides the guidelines for the appellate court to decide the matter. For ready reference Order 41 Rule 31 CPC is as under:

    “31. Contents, date and signature of judgment.—The judgment of the appellate court shall be in writing and shall state—
    (a) the points for determination;
    (b) the decision thereon;
    (c) the reasons for the decision; and
    (d) where the decree appealed from is reversed or varied, the relief to which the appellant is entitled;
    and shall at the time that it is pronounced be signed and dated by the Judge or by the Judges concurring therein.”

    16. In Vinod Kumar v. Gangadhar (2015) 1 SCC 391 this Court has reiterated the principles to be borne in mind while disposing of a first appeal, as under :

    “15. Again in B.V. Nagesh v. H.V. Sreenivasa Murthy (2010) 13 SCC 530, this Court taking note of all the earlier judgments of this Court reiterated the aforementioned principle with these words :
    ‘3. How the regular first appeal is to be disposed of by the appellate court/High Court has been considered by this Court in various decisions. Order 41 CPC deals with appeals from original decrees. Among the various rules, Rule 31 mandates that the judgment of the appellate court shall state:
    (a) the points for determination;
    (b) the decision thereon;
    (c) the reasons for the decision; and
    (d) where the decree appealed from is reversed or varied, the relief to which the appellant is entitled.
    4. The appellate court has jurisdiction to reverse or affirm the findings of the trial court. The first appeal is a valuable right of the parties and unless restricted by law, the whole case is therein open for rehearing both on questions of fact and law. The judgment of the appellate court must, therefore, reflect its conscious application of mind and record findings supported by reasons, on all the issues arising along with the contentions put forth, and pressed by the parties for decision of the appellate court. Sitting as a court of first appeal, it was the duty of the High Court 2008 SCC OnLine Kar 837 to deal with all the issues and the evidence led by the parties before recording its findings. The first appeal is a valuable right and the parties have a right to be heard both on questions of law and on facts and the judgment in the first appeal must address itself to all the issues of law and fact and decide it by giving reasons in support of the findings. (Vide Santosh Hazari v. Purushottam Tiwari (2001) 3 SCC 179 and Madhukar v. Sangram (2001) 4 SCC 756)’”

    17. In Shasidhar v. Ashwini Uma Mathad (2015) 11 SCC 269, it was held as under :

    “21. Being the first appellate court, it was, therefore, the duty of the High Court 2012 SCC OnLine Kar 8774 to decide the first appeal keeping in view the scope and powers conferred on it under Section 96 read with Order 41 Rule 31 of the Code mentioned above. It was unfortunately not done, thereby, causing prejudice to the appellants whose valuable right to prosecute the first appeal on facts and law was adversely affected which, in turn, deprived them of a hearing in the appeal in accordance with law.”

    18. It is clear from the above provisions and the decisions of this Court that the judgment of the first appellate court has to set out points for determination, record the decision thereon and give its own reasons. Even when the first appellate court affirms the judgment of the trial court, it is required to comply with the requirement of Order 41 Rule 31 and non-observance of this requirement leads to infirmity in the judgment of the first appellate court. No doubt, when the appellate court agrees with the views of the trial court on evidence, it need not restate effect of evidence or reiterate reasons given by the trial court. Expression of a general agreement with the reasons given by the trial court would ordinarily suffice.

    19. Keeping in mind the above principles, let us examine the present case. As stated above, the issue relating to readiness and willingness of the plaintiff to perform his part of the contract and issue relating to limitation were held against the plaintiff and the suit was accordingly dismissed. The appeal before the High Court involved both disputed questions of law and fact. The High Court without examination of any of these aspects has dismissed the appeal by a cryptic order. The court below has neither reappreciated the evidence of the parties, nor it has passed a reasoned order. The High Court has failed to follow the provisions of Order 41 Rule 31 CPC while deciding the appeal. Mr Bhat has argued that the suit was well within time under Article 54 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act. Even this question has not been examined in its proper perspective.

    20. In the result, the appeal succeeds and is accordingly allowed in part. The judgment and decree of the High Court in Malluru Mallappa v. Kuruvathappa 2012 SCC OnLine Kar 2487 dated 9-2-2012, is set aside and the matter is remanded to the High Court for fresh disposal in accordance with law.

    21. All the contentions of the parties are left open. There will be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Malluru Mallappa (Dead) Through Legal Representatives v. Kuruvathappa And Others
    (Feb 12, 2020)