Vandana Kasrekar, J.:— This revision preferred under Section 397 read with Section 401 of Cr.P.C. calls in question the legality, propriety and correctness of order dated 12/12/2018 passed by the learned II Additional Sessions Judge, West Nimar, Mandleshwar, District-Khargone in ST. No. 150/2018 whereby charge under Section 302/34 of IPC has been framed against the petitioners.
2. Case of the prosecution is that on 25/12/2015, the complainant-Rameshwar gave an intimation at P.S.-Kasrawad disclosing that his agricultural field is situated at ‘Ota Road Kasrawad’ and adjoining to his field, field of Ghanshyam is situated. When, complainant was on his way to his agricultural field, he saw Gopal was lying down in a tank situated in the agricultural field of Ghanshyam. He immediately informed to Ghanshyam and Balram. Other villagers of local residents also gathered on the spot and took the dead-body of the deceased to Kasrawad Hospital and merg No. 94/2015 was registered under Section 174 of Cr.P.C. During the course of merg inquiry statements of family members of the deceased were recorded and they apprehended that deceased was killed by the petitioners. On the basis of said suspicion, statements of petitioners were also recorded. It was disclosed by the petitioners that a night before the alleged incident, petitioners and deceased had consumed liquor and thereafter, the deceased was left on the agricultural filed. It was also stated by them that the deceased was a heavy drinker and due to said habit, he must have died due to drowning. Doctor who conducted the postmortem stating that the deceased was died due to drowning and liquor was found in his body. No external injury was found, therefore, no case was registered against the present petitioners.
3. Being dissatisfied with the action of police, a complaint was filed by Bhawana (wife of the deceased) under Section 156 (3) of Cr.P.C. against the petitioners before the trial Court and vide order dated 23/04/2016, the learned trial Court passed an order directing to register FIR under Section 302 of the IPC against the petitioners. Being aggrieved by the said order, criminal revision was preferred by the State of M.P., which was dismissed. Thereafter, FIR at crime No. 145/2016 was registered against the petitioners. After due investigation, charge-sheet was filed and the learned trial Court framed the charges under Section 302/34 of IPC.
4. Referring to a number of decisions rendered by Hon'ble Apex Court as well as by this Court, learned Counsel for the petitioners has contended that even if the entire prosecution story is accepted as such, still prima-facie case for committing death is not made out against the petitioners because what is alleged against the petitioners is by itself cannot amount to murder. The contention is that to constitute a case of murder within the meaning of Section 302 of IPC, there must be active encouragement, persuasion or instigation for committing murder which is not there in the present case. Lastly, it is submitted that the learned Trial Court while framing the charge has not examined all these aspects and has mechanically framed the charge; therefore, the impugned order is not sustainable in the eyes of law.
5. Per contra, it is submitted by the learned Public Prosecutor that the learned Trial Court on due consideration of material on record has framed the charge under Section 302 of IPC against the petitioners and from the record it is clear that the deceased was murdered by the petitioners, therefore, prima facie a case for committing death of the deceased is made out.
6. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
7. “302. Punishment for murder.—Whoever commits murder shall be punished with death, or 1[imprisonment for life], and shall also be liable to fine.”
8. The Supreme Court has held in the case of Niranjan Singh Karam Singh v. Jitendra Bhimaraj Bijje, (1990) 4 SCC 76 : AIR 1990 SC 1962 that it is well settled that at the stage of Sections 227 and 228 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, that is the stage of framing of charge, the Court is required to evaluate the material and documents on record with a view to finding out if the facts emerging therefrom taken at their face-value, discloses the existence of all the ingredients constituting the alleged offence. The Court may for this limited purpose sift the evidence as it cannot be expected even at that initial stage to accept all that the prosecution states as gospel truth even if it is opposed to common sense or the broad probabilities of the case.
9. In the case of Union of India v. Prafulla Kumar Samal, (1979) 3 SCC 4 : AIR 1979 SUPREME COURT 366 the Supreme Court held that in exercising his jurisdiction under Section 227 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the Judge, which under the present Code is a senior and experienced Court, cannot act merely as a Post-Office or a mouthpiece of the prosecution, but has to consider the broad probabilities of the case, the total effect of the evidence and the documents produced before the Court, and any basic infirmities appearing in the case and so on. The Supreme Court; however, cautioned that this does not mean that the Judge should make a roving inquiry into the pros and cons of the matter and weigh the evidence as if he was conducting a trial.
10. In the case of State of Madhya Pradesh v. S.B. Johari, (2000) 2 SCC 57 : AIR 2000 SC 665, the Supreme Court held that the Court would not be justified in appreciating material produced by the prosecution at the stage of framing of the charge. At the stage of framing of charge, the trial Court is not required to marshal the material on record but only has to prima facie consider whether there is sufficient material against the accused.
11. This High Court in the case of Anil @ Noni Panda v. State of M.P. as reported in 2012 (2) M.P.H.T. 515 wherein the ratio of the judgment is that though the Court deciding to frame charges is not required to record reasons or pass a speaking order either under law or under principles of natural justice, but in vulnerable cases, as for example under Section 306 or 307 of IPC because of non-application of mind trial Courts are framing charges resulting in bulk of revisions before the High Court, has held that trial Court should apply judicial mind and should give reasons in concise manner for framing charges in such cases like under Section 306 or 307 of IPC.
12. After going through the evidence and the law laid down by Hon'ble the Supreme Court as well as by this Court, it is apparent that trial Judge while framing charge under Section 302 of IPC is required to apply his mind to the facts and circumstances of the case, therefore, this Court is of the opinion that trial Court has failed to apply its mind while framing charge under Section 302/34 of IPC, and therefore, charge under Section 302/34 of IPC deserves to be quashed.
13. Resultantly, the present petition is hereby allowed. The order dated 12/12/2018 passed by the learned II Additional Sessions Judge, West Nimar, Mandleshwar, District-Khargone in S.T. No. 150/2018 whereby charge under Section 302/34 of IPC has been framed against the petitioners are hereby quashed and petitioners are discharged.
14. C.C. as per rules.