Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellants, former employees in a work-charged establishment of the State of Uttarakhand, sought to have the period of their work-charged service counted as “qualifying service” for pension. The State Public Services Tribunal allowed their claim. The State’s writ petition (WP (S/B) No. 24 of 2007) against the Tribunal’s order was dismissed, and the State’s Special Leave Petition (SLP) challenging that dismissal was also rejected by the Supreme Court.

Subsequently, a Full Bench of the Uttarakhand High Court (2010 SCC OnLine Utt 3273) held that work-charged service could not be counted toward qualifying service. Relying on that Full Bench judgment, the High Court reviewed and reopened the earlier dismissal, ultimately holding on 26-5-2015 (2015 SCC OnLine Utt 2053) that work-charged service is not countable. The appellants challenged both the Full Bench judgment and the subsequent order by filing SLP (C) Nos. 11725 of 2015, 7434 of 2016 and 9991 of 2016. Delay in filing SLP 11725/2015 was condoned and leave was granted in all SLPs, converting them into civil appeals now decided by this order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the period of service rendered by employees in a work-charged establishment must be included when computing “qualifying service” for pension under Regulation 370 of the Civil Services Regulations applicable in Uttarakhand.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kesar Chand v. State of Punjab, 1988 SCC OnLine P&H 338; AIR 1988 P&H 265 Struck down Rule 3.17(ii) of the Punjab Civil Services Rules that excluded work-charged service from pensionable “qualifying service”. Cited as the foundational judgment eliminating the discriminatory exclusion of work-charged service.
State of Punjab v. Kesar Chand, (2009) 14 SCC 793 Supreme Court affirmed Kesar Chand and rejected the State’s challenge. Relied upon to show that the principle in Kesar Chand is binding nationwide.
Punjab SEB v. Narata Singh, (2010) 4 SCC 317 Re-affirmed that work-charged service must be counted for pension and approved the reasoning in Kesar Chand. Formed the immediate precedent for treating pari materia provisions as unconstitutional in effect.
Full Bench, Uttarakhand High Court, 2010 SCC OnLine Utt 3273; (2011) 98 AIC 950 Held that work-charged service could not be counted toward qualifying service under Regulation 370. Referenced as the view now reversed by the Supreme Court.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. Regulation 370 of the Civil Services Regulations excludes “service in a work-charged establishment” from qualifying service for pension. The Court observed that this provision is pari materia with Rule 3.17(ii) of the Punjab Civil Services Rules.

2. Rule 3.17(ii) had already been struck down in Kesar Chand, a decision affirmed first by the Supreme Court in (2009) 14 SCC 793 and reiterated in Punjab SEB v. Narata Singh (2010) 4 SCC 317. In Narata Singh, the Court expressly approved inclusion of work-charged service in qualifying service.

3. Because the operative language of Regulation 370 is indistinguishable from Rule 3.17(ii), the same constitutional reasoning applies. Excluding work-charged service would perpetuate an invalid classification already condemned by binding precedent.

4. Consequently, the Court found no justification for treating Uttarakhand employees differently and held that the appellants’ work-charged service must be reckoned for pension purposes.

Holding and Implications

Appeals Allowed. The impugned orders of the Uttarakhand High Court (including 2011 SCC OnLine Utt 60 and 2015 SCC OnLine Utt 2053) are set aside. The appellants’ period of work-charged service shall be counted toward their qualifying service for pension, and all consequential monetary and service benefits are to be granted forthwith by the State.

Implications: The decision restores pension eligibility for the appellants and effectively nullifies the contrary Full Bench view of the Uttarakhand High Court. While grounded on existing Supreme Court precedent rather than creating new law, the ruling reinforces that similar exclusions in other States with pari materia rules cannot withstand constitutional scrutiny.

    Habib Khan v. State Of Uttarakhand And Others

    Order

    1. Delay condoned in Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 11725 of 2015.

    2. Leave granted in all the special leave petitions.

    3. The period of service rendered by the appellants was directed to be counted for computing “qualifying service” for purposes of pension by the State Public Services Tribunal. Writ Petition No. 24 of 2007 filed by the State against the said order was dismissed WP (S/B) No. 24 of 2007. The petition for special leave to appeal filed by the State against the order of dismissal of the writ petition was also dismissed by this Court. In between, a Full Bench of the Uttaranchal High Court took the view 2010 SCC OnLine Utt 3273, (2011) 98 AIC 950 that the period of work-charged service cannot be counted for computation of the period of “qualifying service”. On the basis of the aforesaid decision of the Full Bench of the Uttaranchal High Court, review of the order dismissing Writ Petition No. 24 of 2007 was sought which was allowed by order dated 27-7-2012 2012 SCC OnLine Utt 1558. The said order dated 27-7-2012 2012 SCC OnLine Utt 1558 was challenged before this Court and was dismissed 2014 SCC OnLine SC 1766 as withdrawn. In the meantime, on the basis of the order passed in the review petition the matter was re-heard and the High Court by order dated 26-5-2015 2015 SCC OnLine Utt 2053 held that the period of work-charged service cannot be counted for reckoning of the period of “qualifying service”. While the order dated 26-5-2015 2015 SCC OnLine Utt 2053 is the subject-matter of challenge in appeal arising out of Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 7434 of 2016 and in appeal arising out of Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 9991 of 2016, the order of the Full Bench is the subject-matter of challenge in appeal arising out of Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 11725 of 2015.

    4. Having recalled the facts germane to a consideration of the case, the question of law arising may now be adverted to.

    5. The aforesaid question is no longer res integra in view of the facts enumerated herein after. The relevant provisions under which the period of work-charged service is not to be counted for computation of “qualifying service” in the State of Uttarakhand is Regulation 370 of the Civil Services Regulations which is extracted below:

    “370. Continuous temporary or officiating service under the Government of Uttar Pradesh followed without interruption by confirmation in the same or any other post shall qualify except—
    (i) periods of temporary or officiating service in a non-pensionable establishment;
    (ii) periods of service in a work-charged establishment; and
    (iii) periods of service in a post paid from contingencies.”

    6. The pari materia provision contained in Rule 3.17(ii) of the Punjab Civil Services Rules had been struck down by a Full Bench decision of the Punjab and Haryana High Court in Kesar Chand v. State of Punjab 1988 SCC OnLine P&H 338, AIR 1988 P&H 265, (1988) 5 SLR 27. The challenge by the State against the aforesaid decision of the Full Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High Court was negatived (2009) 14 SCC 793 by this Court. The matter came up for consideration before this Court, once again, in Punjab SEB v. Narata Singh (2010) 4 SCC 317. While dealing with the said question this Court in Para 25 of the report held that the Full Bench decision of the Punjab and Haryana High Court was perfectly justified in striking down Rule 3.17(ii) of the Punjab Civil Services Rules resulting in obliteration of the distinction made in the said Rules between “temporary and officiating service” and “work-charged service”. On the said basis, this Court took the view that the period of work-charged service should be reckoned for purposes of computation of “qualifying service” for grant of pension.

    7. As already observed, the provisions of Regulation 370 of the Civil Services Regulations applicable to the State of Uttarakhand are pari materia with the provisions of Rule 3.17(ii) of the Punjab Civil Services Rules, discussed above. If that is so, we do not see as to why the period of service rendered on work-charged basis by the appellants should not be counted for purposes of computation of “qualifying service” for grant of pension. The pari materia provisions of Rule 3.17(ii) of the Punjab Civil Services Rules having been interpreted and understood in the above manner by this Court in Narata Singh (2010) 4 SCC 317 we do not find any room for taking any other view except to hold that the appellants are entitled to reckon the period of work-charged service for purposes of computation of “qualifying service” for grant of pension. We order accordingly; allow these appeals and set aside the impugned orders 2011 SCC OnLine Utt 60, (2011) 128 FLR 910 passed by the High Court.

    8. All necessary and consequential benefit in terms of the present order will be paid and granted by the State to the appellants forthwith and without any delay.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Habib Khan v. State Of Uttarakhand And Others
    (Aug 23, 2017)