Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 308, 323 and 504 I.P.C., Police Station
  • Section 504 I.P.C.22. Appellant-Bablu
  • Sections 308 and 504 I.P.C.23.
  • Section 323, 504 and 308 I.P.C.
  • Section 308 I.P.C.17.
  • Section 504 I.P.C.15.
  • Section 313 Cr.P.C.
  • Section 323 I.P.C.
  • Section 308 I.P.C.
  • Section 504 I.P.C.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 308, 323 and 504 I.P.C., Police Station
  • Section 504 I.P.C.22. Appellant-Bablu
  • Sections 308 and 504 I.P.C.23.
  • Section 323, 504 and 308 I.P.C.
  • Section 308 I.P.C.17.
  • Section 504 I.P.C.15.
  • Section 313 Cr.P.C.
  • Section 323 I.P.C.
  • Section 308 I.P.C.
  • Section 504 I.P.C.
Smart Summary

Judicial Opinion Summary — Aniruddha Singh, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from convictions in S.T. No. 445 of 2013 (Case Crime No. 356 of 2011, Police Station Panki, District Kanpur Nagar). An FIR alleged that on 22.6.2011, appellants Bablu @ Shankar Lal and Shekhar @ Chandra Shekhar assaulted Shanti Devi in front of her house. Medical observations recorded four injuries (including a lacerated wound on the left parietal region and contusion/swelling) and opined they were simple injuries caused by a hard and blunt object; one head injury was kept under observation and a CT scan and emergency admission were noted.

A charge-sheet was submitted under Sections 323, 504 and 308 IPC. The trial court (Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 4, Kanpur Nagar) convicted the appellants on 29.9.2016 under Sections 308, 323 and 504 IPC and sentenced them to varying terms and fines, with sentences to run concurrently. The appellants appealed. The present judgment records hearing of counsel for appellants and the State and disposes of the appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the convictions of the appellants under Section 308 IPC (attempt to commit culpable homicide) and Section 323 IPC (voluntarily causing hurt) were sustainable on the evidence.
  2. Whether the conviction under Section 504 IPC (intentional insult with intent to provoke breach of the peace) was proved.
  3. Appropriate sentencing, including whether a lenient view should be taken having regard to culpability, period of detention already undergone and the nature of injuries.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • No motive existed to cause grievous injury; injuries resulted from a scuffle and fall, not from a deliberate assault.
  • Nobody saw the incident (contention that there was lack of direct observation by independent witnesses).
  • Although a chapar (sharp-edged weapon) was allegedly in appellant Bablu's hand, no sharp-edged weapon injury appeared on the injured; therefore there was no intention to kill or to cause grievous harm that would sustain a conviction under Section 308 IPC.
  • Defence witnesses (D.W.-1 and D.W.-2) stated the injury was received in a scuffle by throwing on the surface, supporting lack of intent.
  • Offence under Section 504 IPC was not made out: no specific words were used to intentionally insult or provoke the injured to breach the public peace.
  • On sentencing: both appellants had no prior criminal history, belonged to poor families, the incident happened in 2011 (several years earlier), and a lenient sentence (period already undergone and fine) should be imposed.

Prosecution / State Case (as presented at trial)

  • Prosecution relied on six witnesses (P.W.-1 Shanti Devi - injured witness; P.W.-2 Ram Awatar - eye witness; P.W.-3 Dr. Pawan Agarwal; P.W.-4 Dr. R.C. Bhatt; P.W.-5 S.I. Virendra Kumar Rai; P.W.-6 Constable Sarvesh Singh) and relevant medical and formal documents.
  • Prosecution case alleged that Shekhar came armed with a 'danda' and Bablu with a 'chapar' and assaulted the injured, causing head and shoulder injuries including a fracture on the head.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jarnail Sing v. State of Punjab, 2009 (6) Supreme 526 Deposition of an injured witness should be relied upon unless there are strong grounds for rejection based on major contradictions and discrepancies, because presence on scene and suffering injuries establishes reliability. The court relied on the principle to treat P.W.-1 Shanti Devi's testimony as sufficient unless strong grounds for rejection existed; P.W.-1's evidence was held sufficient to prove the offence(s) in part.
Maqsoodan v. State of U.P., (1983) 1 SCC 218 Presence of injured witnesses at time and place of occurrence cannot be doubted when they received injuries during the incident and such witnesses should normally not be disbelieved. The court referenced this authority to support reliance on the injured witness(es) (P.W.-1 and corroboration by P.W.-2) in assessing the prosecution case.
Rudappa Ramappa Jainpur v. State of Karnataka, (2004) 7 SCC 422 Where a prosecution story is developed after thought or shows improvement, that circumstance may be relevant in deciding the credibility and in particular in determining whether an offence like attempt to commit culpable homicide (Section 308 IPC) is sustainably proved. The court applied this principle to conclude that the prosecution's story that a chapar was used (ascribed to appellant Bablu) appeared to be a developed/improved story; on this basis the court found it would not be proper to convict Bablu under Section 308 IPC.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the totality of evidence: the injured witness (P.W.-1 Shanti Devi) gave an account that she was assaulted and received injuries; an eye witness (P.W.-2 Ram Awatar) corroborated P.W.-1 without major contradictions. Medical reports and doctors' testimony established a head injury, including a fracture, and described at least one injury as grievous in nature. Defence witnesses admitted that an occurrence took place but stated the injury resulted from a scuffle and falling.

The court found the scuffle/fall explanation improbable for the multiplicity and character of injuries recorded; the medical evidence indicated that the injuries were not consistent with simple falling. Consequently, the court accepted the prosecution's version insofar as an assault occurred and that Shekhar struck the injured with a danda, causing the head fracture.

Regarding Section 504 IPC, the court noted there was no evidence of specific words used to intentionally insult or provoke the injured to breach the peace; accordingly, the court concluded the ingredients of Section 504 were not proved and acquitted the appellants on that count.

Concerning Section 308 IPC and appellant Bablu: although a chapar was admitted to have been in Bablu's hand, no injury attributable to a sharp-edged weapon was found on the injured. The court observed that the prosecution's assertion that the chapar was used (from the opposite side) appeared to be a later-developed story. Applying the principle from Rudappa (improvement in story weakens reliability for a charge of attempt to commit culpable homicide), the court held that Bablu lacked the requisite intention or knowledge to attempt culpable homicide; conviction under Section 308 was therefore not proper for Bablu.

As to co-accused Shekhar, the medical evidence corroborated that a danda-inflicted blow caused the head injury and fracture; the court found Shekhar's culpability for the grievous injury established beyond reasonable doubt.

On sentencing, the court considered mitigating factors advanced by defence (first offence, poor socio-economic status, lapse of time since the incident) and took a lenient approach for Bablu given the absence of intention to cause grievous harm; Shekhar received substantive sentences consistent with his proven culpability.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The appeal is partly allowed; the impugned judgment and order dated 29.9.2016 is set aside in part and modified as follows.

Disposition and Sentences:

  • Appellant-Shekhar: Convicted under Section 323 IPC and sentenced to one year rigorous imprisonment and fine of Rs. 500; convicted under Section 308 IPC and sentenced to two years rigorous imprisonment and fine of Rs. 3,000. Both sentences to run concurrently. In default of fine, specified simple imprisonment terms apply. Acquitted under Section 504 IPC.
  • Appellant-Bablu: Acquitted of Sections 308 and 504 IPC. Sentenced under Section 323 IPC to the period already undergone and a fine of Rs. 1,000 (with a specified default simple imprisonment term).

Implications for the parties: The direct effect is modification of convictions and sentences — Shekhar remains convicted for causing hurt and attempt to commit culpable homicide with the stated concurrent sentences; Bablu is acquitted of the more serious charge under Section 308 IPC and of Section 504 IPC and is given the benefit of time already served for the Section 323 conviction. The court ordered transmission of this order and lower court record to the concerned court with a compliance report within one month.

The opinion does not purport to establish any new legal precedent beyond application of cited authorities to the facts of this case.

Administrative direction: Office to send a copy of this order along with lower court record to the concerned court immediately; compliance report within one month.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Bablu And Another v. State Of U.P. .

    Aniruddha Singh, J.:— Heard Sri. Anil Kumar Savita, learned counsel for the appellants and Sri. Sanjeev Kumar Tripathi (Brief Holder) appearing for the State.

    2. This criminal appeal has been preferred by Bablu @ Shankar Lal and Shekhar @ Chandra Shekhar against the impugned judgment and order dated 29.9.2016 passed by learned Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 4, Kanpur Nagar in S.T. No. 445 of 2013, arising out of Case Crime No. 356 of 2011, under Sections 308, 323 and 504 I.P.C., Police Station Panki, District Kanpur Nagar whereby the appellants were convicted and sentenced under Section 308 I.P.C. for a period of four years R.I. each with fine of Rs. 3,000/- each and in case of default of payment of fine, they shall undergo further additional rigorous imprisonment of two months R.I. each, under Section 323 I.P.C. for one year R.I. each with fine of Rs. 500/- each and in case of default of payment of fine, they shall undergo further additional rigorous imprisonment of one month each and under Section 504 I.P.C. for one year R.I. each and fine of Rs. 500/- each and in case of default of payment of fine, they shall undergo further additional rigorous imprisonment of one month each. All the sentences shall run concurrently and 50% of the fine deposited by the appellants was directed to be paid to Shanti Devi and the period of detention spent by the appellants in jail shall be adjusted.

    3. In nutshell, the case of the prosecution is that an F.I.R. was lodged against Bablu @ Shankar Lal and Shekhar @ Chandra Shekhar at Police Station Panki, District Kanpur Nagar alleging therein that on 22.6.2011 in front of the house of the complainant, they assaulted to Shanti Devi. She received four injuries, which are quoted below:—

    1 Lacerated wound 3.5 cm. × 1 cm. muscle deep on left parietal region of scalp 10 cm above to left mastoid (KUO).

    2. Contusion swelling 5 cm. × 4 cm. on left parietal region of scalp on around the injury no. 1.

    3. Complaint of pain on all over back region.

    4. Nausea and vomiting episodes present.

    Opinion-

    All the above injuries were simple in nature caused by hard and blunt object.

    Injury no. 1 was kept under observation.

    C.T. Scan Head and admission in emergency.

    4. N.C.R. was lodged. Later on, charge sheet was submitted under Section 323, 504 and 308 I.P.C. and charges were framed against the appellants to which they pleaded to be not guilty.

    5. In order to prove its case, the prosecution examined six witnesses, namely, P.W.-1 Shanti Devi (injured), P.W.-2 Ram Awatar, P.W.-3 Dr. Pawan Agarwal, P.W.4-Dr. R.C. Bhatt, P.W.-5 S.I. Virendra Kumar Rai and P.W.-6 Constable Sarvesh Singh. From the side of appellants, D.W.-1 Shafi Mohd and D.W.-2 Chhotey were also examined.

    6. Statements of the accused appellants were recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C. in which he denied the charges levelled against him.

    7. After hearing learned counsel for both the parties, the impugned judgment and order was passed. Hence this appeal.

    8. Learned counsel for the appellants submitted that there was no motive to cause injury to injured. The injury was received by the injured in scuffle only. Story narrated by the prosecution is unnatural. Nobody had seen the incident. No injury of sharped edged weapon (Chapar) was found on the body of the injured but in the hand of appellant-Babllu, injury of Chaper was assigned. Hence, there was no intention of Bablu to kill or cause injury to injured otherwise he had option to assault the injured by Chapar, which is sharp edged weapon, and caused grievous injury to injured and it may cause death also. Hence, Bablu is entitled to be acquitted under Section 308 I.P.C. as D.W.-1 and D.W.-2 have clearly stated that injured had received injury in scuffle by throwing on surface.

    9. From perusal of the record, it transpires that P.W.-1 Shanti Devi, who is injured witness of the case, who was also the family member of accused. Shekhar came armed with ‘danda’ and Bablu came armed with Chapar and assaulted her. She had received injuries on head and shoulder.

    10. The statement of P.W.-1 Shanti Devi, who is injured witness, is sufficient to prove the offence. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of injured witness has observed as under:

    “In the case of Jarnail Sing v. State of Punjab, 2009 (6) Supreme 526, the Court has held that deposition of an injured witness should be relied upon unless there are strong grounds for rejection of his evidence on the basis of major contradictions and discrepancies for the reason that his presence on the scene of incident established in the case and it is proved that he suffered the injuries during the said incident.

    In the case of Maqsoodan v. State of U.P., (1983) 1 SCC 218, the Apex Court has held that presence of the injured witnesses at the time and place of the occurrence cannot be doubted as they had received injuries during the course of incident and they should normally be not disbelieved.”

    11. P.W.-2 Ram Awatar, who is the eye witness, has corroborated the statement of P.W.-1 Shanti Devi without major contradiction.

    12. From perusal of the record, it transpires that fracture was found on the head of P.W.-1 Shanti Devi. D.W.-1 Shafi Mohd. and D.W.-2 Chhotey have also admitted the occurrence, but they stated that injury was received by the injured in scuffle and by throwing. From perusal of injury report, it is very clear that it is not possible to receive four injuries as was found on the body of the injured by fallen, hence story of the appellants is not believable. From perusal of medical report and the statements given by the doctors, it is very clear that one head injury was found on the body of the injured and that was grievous in nature. Other formal witnesses were also proved relevant documents produced by the prosecution were exhibited.

    13. Learned counsel for the appellants further submitted that offence under Section 504 I.P.C. is not proved against the appellants and have been convicted wrongly without considering evidence. Even in chief-examination of the witnesses of fact, nothing has been stated to prove that accused intentionally insulted the injured and given provocation to injured intending or knowing it to be likely that such provocation will cause him to break the public peace or commit any other offence. Hence the appellants are liable to be acquitted.

    14. From perusal of the record, this Court finds that the argument raised by the learned counsel for the appellants on this point is correct. No specific word has been used to provoke the person intentionally or to insult the injured. Hence, this Court finds that appellants are liable to be acquitted under Section 504 I.P.C.

    15. From perusal of the record, it transpires that it is admitted fact that in the hand of appellant-Bablu, there was Chapar (sharp edged weapon) but no injury was found on the body of the injured caused by sharp edged weapon. Hence, it is very clear that there was no intention to cause injury to injured but attempt to commit culpable homicide. There was no intention or knowledge of the appellant Bablu to assault the injured or attempt to commit culpable homicide. The case of the prosecution is that Chapar was used by the appellant from opposite side is not believable and that story was developed later on. After perusal of injury report, it transpires that the said story was developed after thought and with due legal consultation and its come within the purview of improvement and on the basis of improvement, it will not be proper to convict the appellants under Section 308 I.P.C. as it was held by the Apex Court in the Case of Rudappa Ramappa Jainpur v. State of Karnataka, reported in (2004) 7 SCC 422.

    16. The argument of learned counsel for the appellants has force on this issue and this Court finds that appellant-Bablu is liable to be acquitted under Section 308 I.P.C.

    17. From perusal of the record, it appears that Shekhar had assaulted by ‘danda’ on the head of injured and due to said assault the injurerd received injury and fracture was found on head, hence offence against co-accused Shekhar is proved beyond reasonable doubt.

    18. Learned counsel for the appellants further submitted that on the point of sentence, there is no criminal history against the appellants. This is the first offence. The incident is of the year 2011 since then more than seven years have been elapsed. Both the appellants belong to poor family. Financial and social status of the appellants are very poor.

    19. According to prosecution case, both the parties belong to same family. Hence, a lenient view may be taken and the appellants may be sentenced to the period already undergone and fine only. He further submitted that at the time when impugned judgment was passed, they were in jail for several days.

    20. From perusal of the record, this Court finds that a lenient view may be taken in favour of the appellant-Bablu because he had no intention to cause any grievous injury to injured or to attempt to commit culpable homicide or murder. Hence, ends of justice would be served, if the appellant-Bablu is sentenced to the period already undergone with fine of Rs. 1,000/- only under Section 323 I.P.C. So far as appellant-Shekhar is concerned, he has committed an offence under Section 308 I.P.C. and assaulted by ‘danda’, and the same has been corroborated by the injury report, ends of justice would be served if the appellant-Shekhar is sentenced under Section 308 I.P.C. for a period of two years rigorous imprisonment and fine of Rs. 3,000/-. Appeal is liable to be allowed partly, accordingly.

    21. The appeal is partly allowed. The impugned judgment and order dated 29.9.2016 passed by learned Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 4, Kanpur Nagar is set aside. Appellant-Shekhar is convicted under Section 323 I.P.C. and sentenced to undergo one year rigorous imprisonment and fine of Rs. 500/- and under Section 308 I.P.C. he shall undergo two years rigorous imprisonment and fine of Rs. 3,000/-. Both the sentences shall run concurrently. In case of default of fine, he shall undergo one month and three months simple imprisonment independently. He is acquitted for the offence under Section 504 I.P.C.

    22. Appellant-Bablu is also sentenced to the period already undergone under Section 323 I.P.C. and fine of Rs. 1,000/-. In case of default of payment of fine, he shall undergo one month simple imprisonment separately. He is acquitted for the offence under Sections 308 and 504 I.P.C.

    23. Office is directed to send a copy of this order along with lower court record to the concerned court immediately for information and compliance. Compliance report be submitted within one month.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bablu And Another v. State Of U.P. .
    (Jan 4, 2019)