Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Rule 227A of the Rajasthan Rajasthan Panchayati Raj Rules, 1994 (the Rules of 1994)
  • provisions of Rule 227A of the Rules of 1994
  • Clause (vi) of Rule 227A of the Rules of 1994
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Rule 227A of the Rajasthan Rajasthan Panchayati Raj Rules, 1994 (the Rules of 1994)
  • provisions of Rule 227A of the Rules of 1994
  • Clause (vi) of Rule 227A of the Rules of 1994
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners filed a writ petition seeking a declaration that the waiting list be issued against vacancies arising due to non-joining of selected candidates pursuant to a revised advertisement dated 11.9.2017. Appointments were made based on select lists, but several selected candidates did not join. The petitioners alleged that the respondents failed to comply with Rule 227A of the Rajasthan Panchayati Raj Rules, 1994, which mandates issuance of a waiting list and appointments from it. The respondents contested the petition, arguing it was based on assumptions regarding vacancies and non-joining candidates. The Court considered these submissions and relevant materials on record.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondents are obligated under Rule 227A of the Rajasthan Panchayati Raj Rules, 1994, to issue and operate a waiting (reserve) list in respect of vacancies caused by non-joining of selected candidates pursuant to the advertisement dated 11.9.2017.
  2. Whether the provisions of Rule 227A, particularly Clause (vi), require the Authorized Agency and concerned Zila Parishads to publish and act upon the reserve list within six months from forwarding the original list.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners relied on the judgment in Bhushan Kumar Pandya v. State of Rajasthan, which interpreted Rule 227A, emphasizing the mandatory nature of issuing and operating a reserve list to fill vacancies.
  • They asserted that despite vacancies arising from non-joining candidates, the respondents failed to comply with Rule 227A's requirement to issue the waiting list and make appointments from it.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents contended that the petition was based on assumptions regarding vacancies and non-joining candidates without sufficient proof.
  • They argued that the provision to "keep" names on the reserve list under Rule 227A is directory and does not mandate publication or appointment from the reserve list.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bhushan Kumar Pandya v. State of Rajasthan (S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 14505/2018, decided on 25.10.2018) Interpretation of Rule 227A of the Rajasthan Panchayati Raj Rules, 1994, particularly the obligation to prepare, publish, and operate a reserve list to fill vacancies. The Court relied on this precedent to hold that the Authorized Agency must upload the reserve list and the Zila Parishads must act upon it within six months to fill vacancies from the reserve list.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the provisions of Rule 227A, specifically Clause (vi), which allows the Authorized Agency to keep names of suitable candidates on a reserve list up to 50% of the vacancies and to recommend candidates from this list within six months. The Court emphasized that the examination of eligibility and appointment occurs at the Zila Parishad level. Since the select list contained fewer candidates than the total vacancies advertised, vacancies indeed existed, creating a legitimate expectation for candidates on the reserve list to be considered for appointment.

The Court rejected the respondents' submission that the provision to "keep" names on the reserve list is merely directory and does not require publication. It held that publication is necessary to inform candidates of their status and to ensure the recruitment process is complete and transparent. The Court directed the Authorized Agency to upload the reserve list and the Zila Parishads to comply with the Rule's provisions regarding vacancies and appointments from the reserve list.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF

The writ petition was disposed of with directions that the authorized agency (respondent No. 3) upload the reserve list as per Clause (vi) of Rule 227A within four weeks and that the concerned Zila Parishads act in accordance with the Rule to fill any vacancies. The decision enforces compliance with Rule 227A but does not establish new precedent beyond affirming the binding nature of the reserve list provisions as interpreted in Bhushan Kumar Pandya. The direct effect is to ensure that vacancies arising from non-joining candidates are filled from the reserve list, protecting the legitimate expectations of candidates on that list.

    Urmila Devi, And Others v. State Of Rajasthan, Through Principal Secretary Rural Development And Panchayti Raj Department, And Others

    Arun Bhansali, J.:— Learned counsel for the petitioners confines the prayer made in the writ petition to declaring the waiting list against the vacancies available due to non-joining of the selected candidates.

    2. It is submitted by learned counsel for the petitioners that the issue raised in the present writ petition is squarely covered by judgment in Bhushan Kumar Pandya v. State of Rajasthan: S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 14505/2018, decided on 25.10.2018.

    3. It is submitted that pursuant to the revised advertisement dated 11.9.2017, select lists were issued and appointments were made, however, several of the selected candidates have not joined, however, the respondents did not comply with the provisions of Rule 227A of the Rajasthan Rajasthan Panchayati Raj Rules, 1994 (‘the Rules of 1994’) requiring issuance of the waiting list and accord appointments from the said waiting list.

    4. Learned counsel for the respondents made submissions that the petitioners have simply filed the petition based on the assumptions that several of the candidates who have selected, have not joined and that there are vacancies available pursuant to the posts advertised by the advertisement dated 11.9.2017.

    5. I have considered the submissions made by learned counsel for the parties and have peruse the material available on record.

    6. This Court in the case of Bhushan Kumar Pandya (supra) after considering the provisions of Rule 227A of the Rules of 1994 inter alia came to the following conclusion and directed as under:

    “A perusal of proviso to Clause (vi) of Rule 277A of the Rules would reveal that the Authorized Agency may to the extent of 50% of the finally intimated vacancies, keep names of suitable candidates on the reserve list. Further the Authorized Agency may on requisition recommend the name of such candidate in the order of merit to the Zila Parishad concerned within six months from the date on which original list was forwarded by the Authorized Agency.

    The said clause read with the stipulation made in the advertisement clearly indicates that it is only at the level of Zila Parishad where the documents, eligibility etc. of the candidates selected and allotted by the Authorized Agency are examined and if after grant of appointments to the eligible selected candidates vacancies remain at the Zila Parishad level, the Zila Parishad has to seek further names from the reserve list from the Authorized Agency and on being asked for such names, the Authorized Agency has to send the names to the concerned Zila Parishad and the said exercise has to be completed within six months from the date on which the original list was forwarded by the Authorized Agency.

    As already noticed, when 1492 posts were advertised and the select list only contain names of 1379 candidates as filed by the petitioners, obviously the vacancies do exist and therefore, the candidates like petitioners, who have not been selected, have a legitimate expectation i.e. if their names appear in the reserve list, they may get chance of appointment.

    The submission made by learned counsel for the respondents that the provision being directory and providing only for the Authorized Agency to ‘keep’ the names of suitable candidates on the reserve list, does not require the respondents to publish the said list cannot be countenanced. Once the provision provides for keeping the suitable candidates on the reserve list, the same must be published by the respondents so as to keep the concerned candidates aware of their status in the reserve list. Further once the provisions are there for the concerned Zila Paris had to seek names of the suitable candidates from the Authorized Agency within a period of six months for the vacant posts, normally the said aspect also must be followed so as to make the recruitment complete and in normal circumstances they must not let the list to expire. In view of the above fact situation, wherein the scrutiny of the eligibility etc. of the candidates is to be made at the level of concerned Zila Parishads, there are already vacant positions available, inasmuch as, the Authorized Agency has not recommended full names against the vacancies advertised, it would be in fitness of things, the reserve list which is required to be prepared by the Authorized Agency in terms of proviso to Clause (vi) of Rule 277A of the Rules must be published and operated in terms of the Rules and requirements.

    Consequently, the writ petition filed by the petitioners is partly allowed. The respondent-Authorized Agency i.e. respondent No. 3 is directed to upload the reserve list in terms of proviso to Clause (vi) of Rule 277A of the Rules on its website within a period of four weeks from today. Further the concerned Zila Parishads are also directed to act in accordance with the provisions of the said proviso in respect of the vacancies and the reserve list.”

    7. In view of the interpretation put by this Court to the provisions of Rule 227A of the Rules of 1994, in case, the vacancies pursuant to the advertisement dated 11.9.2017 are available, the provisions of the said Rule would operate and it would be required of the respondents to do the needful as directed in the case of Bhushan Kumar Pandya (supra).

    8. Consequently, the writ petition filed by the petitioners is disposed of. The authorized agency i.e. respondent No. 3 is directed to upload the reserve list in terms of proviso to Clause (vi) of Rule 227A of the Rules of 1994 on its website within a period of four weeks from today. Further the concerned Zila Parishads are directed to act in accordance with the provisions of the said proviso in respect of the vacancies, if any qua the posts advertised and the reserve list.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Urmila Devi, And Others v. State Of Rajasthan, ...
    (Jan 7, 2019)