HON'BLE MR. S.S GARG, JUDICIAL MEMBER ST/21243/2018-SM Final Order No. 20079 / 2019 Per: S.S GARG The present appeal is directed against the impugned order dated 02.05.2018 passed by the Commissioner (Appeals) whereby the Commissioner (Appeals) has rejected the appeal of the appellant. Briefly the facts of the present case are that the appellants are engaged in carrying out services of cleaning activities, Business Auxiliary Services, Erection and Commissioning and Transport of Goods by Road and have been providing the services at various oil refineries, fertilizer and other chemical industries. During the course of Audit on the appellants record, it was noticed that the appellants have availed inadmissible credit of input services on hiring of vehicles and rent-a-cab amounting to Rs. 10,87,632/- (Rupees Ten Lakhs Eighty Seven Thousand Six Hundred and Thirty Two only). It was also noticed that in some instances there is a delay in issuing of invoices and hence an amount of Rs. 77,256/- (Rupees Seventy Seven Thousand Two Hundred and Fifty Six only) towards interest is to be paid in respect of delay in payment of ST. The appellant has paid an amount of Rs. 10,87,632/- (Rupees Ten Lakhs Eighty Seven Thousand Six Hundred and Thirty Two only) vide challan 085/10.10.2015, 086/10.10.2015 and 087/10.10.2015 respectively under protest. Thereafter a show-cause notice was issued and after following the due process, the original authority confirmed the demand of wrongly availed cenvat credit of Rs. 10,87,632/- (Rupees Ten Lakhs Eighty Seven Thousand Six Hundred and Thirty Two only) along with interest of Rs. 5,81,225/- (Rupees Five Lakhs Eighty One Thousand Two Hundred and Twenty Five only), interest of Rs. 77,256/- (Rupees Seventy Seven ST/21243/2018-SM Thousand Two Hundred and Fifty Six only) on delay in issuing of invoices and penalty was also imposed under Section 78. The adjudicating authority vacated the protest and appropriated the payment made by the appellant against the confirmed demand. Aggrieved by the said order, appellant filed appeal before the Commissioner who rejected the said appeal.
2. Heard both the parties and perused the records.
3. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the impugned order is not sustainable in law as the same has been passed without properly appreciating the facts and the law. He further submitted that the Commissioner (Appeals) in the impugned order has wrongly upheld the demand of cenvat credit availed on renting/hiring of motor vehicle on the ground that during the period in dispute there was a specific exclusion in the definition of input service under the Cenvat Credit Rules 2004 and further the appellants have not produced any proof that the motor vehicles are registered in the name of service provider so as to classify as capital goods for them. He further submitted that the credit on renting of motor vehicle is availed as input service for the appellant as the exclusion under the definition of input service on renting of motor vehicle is applicable only if the vehicle is not a capital goods for the service provider whereas in the present case vehicles are admittedly capital goods for the car rental service provider. He further submitted that this issue of liability of cenvat credit on rent-a-cab after the amendment to the definition of input service from 2011 has also been considered by the Honble Tribunal in the case of Marvel ST/21243/2018-SM Vinyls Ltd. Vs. CCE, Indore 2016-TIOL-3071-CESTAT-DEL. wherein the Tribunal held that the cenvat credit on car rental is available as input service credit for the service receiver if the cars are capital goods for the car rental service provider. He also relied that this issue has been considered by various benches of the Tribunal and consistently being held as input service. For this submission, he relied upon the following decisions: a. Sundaram Clayton Ltd. Vs. CCE, Chennai-II 2018-TIOL-2882- CESTAT-MAD. b. Macurex Sensors Pvt. Ltd. Vs. CCT 2018 (5) TMI 544 CESTAT-BANGALORE c. Godawari Power & Ispat Ltd. Vs. CCE & ST, Raipur 2017 (12) TMI 894 CESTAT NEW DELHI d. Sundaram Clayton Ltd. Vs. CCE, Chennai 2017 (7) TMI 1162- CESTAT CHENNAI e. CST, Pune Vs. Nihilent Technologies Pvt. Ltd. 2017 (8) TMI 1049-CESTAT-MUMBAI f. Terex India Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Commr. of GST & CE, Salem 2018- TIOL-3555-CESTAT-MAD. 3.1. He also submitted that he has produced on record the registration certificate to show that the motor vehicles are registered in the name of service provider. Learned counsel fairly conceded that he is not contesting the demand of interest of Rs. 77,256/- (Rupees Seventy Seven Thousand Two Hundred and Fifty Six only) on delayed payment of service tax. ST/21243/2018-SM
4. On the other hand the learned AR defended the impugned order.
5. After considering the submissions of both the parties and perusal of the material on record, I find that the Tribunal in the case of Marvel Vinyls Ltd. cited supra has considered the issue after the amendment in the definition of input service after 01.04.2011 and the Tribunal in this case has observed as under:
3. After hearing both the sides, I find that the definition of input service is contained in Rule 2(l) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 and relates to any service used by a manufacturer, whether directly or indirectly, in or in relation to manufacture of their final product and includes many services specified therein but excludes some of the services specified. An Exclusion Clause B was introduced w.e.f. 01.04.2011 to the following effect: [(b) [Services provided by way of renting of a motor vehicle], insofar as they relate to a motor vehicle which is not a capital goods;]
4. A reading of the above Exclusion Clause show that services provided by way of renting of a motor vehicle do not stand excluded in totality. The Exclusion Clause is in respect of input services of renting of a motor vehicle, insofar as they relate to a motor vehicle which is not capital goods. The contention of the assessee is that motor vehicle is a capital goods, as per the definition of the capital goods contained under Rule 2(a) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004. The appellate authority has specifically observed that the said input service, i.e., renting of motor vehicles ST/21243/2018-SM have been specifically included except in case where motor vehicle is eligible for cenvat credit as capital goods.
5. He has however denied the benefit to the assessee on the ground that such motor vehicle are not capital goods for the appellant, cenvat credit availed on the input services of renting of motor vehicle would not be admissible.
6. However, I find flaw in the above interpretation of appellate authority. He has rightly observed that the exclusion is only in respect of that motor vehicle which is not a capital goods. However, he has not extended the benefit to the assessee by observing that the same is not a capital goods for the appellant. A person who is receiving the input services of renting of immovable property, can never avail cenvat credit of duty paid on the motor vehicles and as such motor vehicle can never be a capital goods to the recipient of the said services. The motor vehicle will always be a capital goods or otherwise for the person who is providing the services. For service provider falling under the category of renting of motor vehicle the motor vehicle would always be a capital goods. As such the expression which is not a capital goods appearing in the said exclusion clause would require examination vis--vis the service provider and not vis--vis the services recipient. As such the interpretation of the lower authorities that motor vehicle are not capital goods for the service recipient cannot be appreciated inasmuch as motor vehicles are admittedly capital goods in terms of the Rule 2(A) of Cenvat Credit Rules.