M.A. No. 581 of 2012
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner on M.A. No. 581/2012.
The M.A. has been filed praying for permission to cross-examine the deponent of the affidavit being Maj. Alifa Akbar and Maj. Sree Kumar V.R. The averment in the M.A. is that the respondents made false and misleading statements in their counter reply and subsequent affidavits, the respondents have also suppressed the material facts about the service career of the applicant, and the truth in the matter, the applicant seeks opportunity to cross examine.
It would be suffice to say, that the affidavit of Maj. Alifa Akbar is dated 30.07.2012 and filed in the Court on 02.08.2012. All that, this affidavit deposes, is about the deponent being aware in the official capacity, of the facts and circumstances of the case, being based on record of the case available with the answering respondents, and by way of documents a letter dated 13.05.2011 has been filed. Then, so far as Maj. Sree Kumar V.R. is concerned, he has not filed any affidavit, but is said to be signatory of the letter dated 13.05.2011, giving out the details of the applicant's service career.
From the letter dated 13.05.2011 it is conveyed that the petitioner was promoted from Signalman to Naik with seniority from 01.07.1993 and from Naik to Havildar with seniority from 01.01.1998, and in this promotion from the rank of Naik to Havildar, it is mentioned that he was not promoted earlier on account of not meeting ACR criteria. However, after receipt of the ACR for 1998, he has been promoted, protecting his seniority from 01.01.1998.
The cross-examination is sought on the ground of there being variance between the stand taken in the reply and the stand said to have been taken in the letter of 13.05.2011.
In our view, it would be suffice to say, that in the reply, originally filed, the stand taken is about the petitioner having not been promoted to the rank of Naib Subedar on account of his having completed 44 years of age on 30.06.2008, while his batch mates were promoted to the rank of Naib Subedar on 01.07.2008. Then, regarding seniority of the persons, said to be junior to the petitioner, the stand taken in reply to para 4.11 of the O.A. is, that it is not true that Havildar Keshav Chauhan and Hav. Dharamveer were promoted earlier, rather both of them are having seniority of Havildar rank w.e.f. 01.01.1998, even according to para 4(iv) of the O.A. the petitioner is also having the seniority in the rank of Havildar from 01.01.1998.
Then in the letter dated 13.05.2011 also, so far as the promotion to the rank of Naib Subedar is concerned, in para 2(c) the stand taken is, about the petitioner having completed 44 years of age on 30.06.2008, and was, therefore, not promoted to the rank of Naib Subedar.
Thus, on the face of it, so far as entitlement of promotion to the rank of Naib Subedar is concerned, there is no variance in the stand, as sought to the conveyed i.e. taking one stand of age and taking other stand of ACR.
We may clarify here that the stand regarding ACR was taken, and is taken, only with respect to the promotion to the rank of Havildar, and not to the rank of Naib Subedar.
It is not in dispute that for the purpose of promotion to the rank of Naib Subedar seniority in the rank of Havildar only is to be considered, and the original seniority from the date of enrolment is relevant only for the purpose of consideration for promotion upto the rank of Havildar.
In that background, since in the entire O.A. there is not even a whisper as to how his promotion to the rank of Havildar with seniority from 01.01.1998 is bad, we do not find any inconsistency in the documents, or affidavit, and the original reply, so as to entitle the petitioner to cross-examine any of the persons. The M.A. is, therefore, dismissed.
O.A. No. 112/2009
Put up for hearing on 18.12.2012, as prayed by the learned counsel for the petitioner.