1. The applicant Subedar Manoj Kumar Bora has filed this application O.A. No. 108 of 2009 challenging the order dated 8.9.2009 of Station Headquarter, Delhi Cantonment denying further retention of separated family quarters 13/2, Chitral Lines Delhi Cantonment.
2. The applicant was earlier posted to 14 DOGRA/16 RAJPUT in Counter Insurgency Field Area from July 2005 to June 2008 and accordingly allotted separated family quarters 13/2, Chitral Lines Delhi Cantonment on 9.5.2006. However, he got posted out of AEC College, Pachmarhi on June 2008 which was in a peace area and did not entitle him to retain separated family accommodation. The applicant applied for another field posting on 26.12.2008. The applicant however applied for extension and was permitted to retain the separated family accommodation (SFA) on academic grounds till 31.3.2009. The applicants' wife again requested for extension. This was refused vide Station Headquarter, Delhi Cantonment vide order dated 8.9.2009 which declared him an unauthorised occupant wef 1.4.2009.
3. In the meanwhile eviction proceedings were initiated at the level of Estate Officer, Delhi Military Station, Delhi Cantonment who thereafter issued show cause notice and after due hearing declared him unauthorised occupant of public premises 13/2, Chitral Lines, Delhi Cantonment and directed him vide order dated 29.8.2009 to vacate the premises within fifteen days otherwise he would be physically evicted from the said public premises under the provisions of Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorised Occupants) Act 1971. No further steps were taken by the applicant in the matter as revealed by records.
4. On arrival at AEC College, Pachmarhi the applicant applied for a posting to another field area in view of his wife's' medical problems. He got posted out to Headquarters 4 Corps on 4 June 2009 which is also a field area and entitles him to separated family accommodation. The applicant therefore maintains that unauthorised occupancy is at best from 1.4.2009 to 3.6.2009 only. The applicant has stated that the order of Station Headquarter dated 8.9.2009 being illegal, as it did not grant extension. The same be quashed and he be permitted to continue to remain in the same separated family quarters (13/2, Chitral Lines, Delhi Cantonment) as he is again serving in a field area.
5. The respondents in reply have averred that the Armed Forces Tribunal has no jurisdiction in respect of Public Premises as the same is exclusively dealt under the Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorised Occupants) Act 1971. During arguments he drew our attention to Section 15 of the said Act and the remedy of appeal as provided under the Public Premises Act. The same has not been availed by the applicant and as such the present Original Application is not maintainable as there is a bar of jurisdiction by any other court. The applicant has not challenged the order passed by the Estate Officer and as such the applicant is not entitled for any relief. There is no justification for the applicant to retain the said accommodation.
6. We have examined the documents and heard the arguments at length. The applicant, despite having put in a request for a field posting was duty bound to vacate the separated family accommodation initially allotted to him and for which extension had been granted on academic grounds till 31.3.2009. The applicant has failed to do so and should bear the consequences. The applicant is presently posted in field area. He is entitled for separated family accommodation but cannot retain the present accommodation for which extension had already been given on academic grounds. There is also a long waiting list for separated family accommodation. No interference is necessary. Application is dismissed being non maintainable and with no justifiable grounds. No orders as to costs.