AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • u/s 263 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (in short 'the Act').
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • u/s 263 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (in short 'the Act').
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Bench and administrative details (as stated in the opinion): Bench comprised Shri Sanjay Garg, Judicial Member and Dr. B.R.R. Kumar, Accountant Member. Hearing was on 28.02.2019 and order pronounced on 16.04.2019.

The assessee appealed against an order dated 01.02.2017 passed by the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax‑2 (PCIT) under section 263 of the Income‑tax Act, 1961, whereby the PCIT set aside an assessment order dated 30.12.2014 passed under section 143(3) and directed the Assessing Officer to make a fresh assessment. The appeal to the Tribunal was filed with a delay of 265 days; the assessee moved an application for condonation of delay supported by an affidavit asserting that delay was caused by erroneous or inadequate advice from their earlier counsel (Shri Varinder Garg), who had allegedly not advised the assessee about the maintainability of an appeal against an order under section 263 and had not appeared in relevant proceedings. The PCIT had found cash payments by the assessee (including two cash payments of Rs. 73,68,000 each and other cash payments exceeding Rs. 20,000) and concluded that disallowance under section 40A(3) was warranted, leading to the exercise of revisionary powers under section 263.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the delay of 265 days in filing the appeal should be condoned in view of the explanation that the assessee's earlier counsel had given wrong professional advice and had not acted for the assessee in the relevant proceedings.
  2. Whether the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax was justified in invoking jurisdiction under section 263 by holding that the assessment order passed by the Assessing Officer was erroneous and prejudicial to the interest of Revenue (specifically for failing to disallow certain cash payments under section 40A(3)).
  3. Whether, on merits, disallowance under section 40A(3) was applicable given the assessee's contention that no expenditure had been claimed in the relevant year as there were no sales and the amounts formed part of closing stock (work-in-progress).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (Assessee)

  • The delay of 265 days in filing the appeal was due to wrong professional advice and inaction by the earlier counsel (Shri Varinder Garg), who did not advise about maintainability and did not appear in proceedings; this amounted to a bona fide cause for delay and condonation should be granted.
  • The order passed by the Assessing Officer dated 30.12.2014 arose out of a limited scrutiny (CASS) into the large increase in unsecured loans; enquiries were restricted to genuineness and verification of unsecured loans and the Assessing Officer completed assessment at the returned loss of Rs. 10,21,815/-, so there was no occasion for the Assessing Officer to examine or adjudicate issues beyond the limited scope (and therefore the assessment order cannot be said to be erroneous).
  • On merits, the assessee contended that there were no sales during the year and the payments/expenditures were part of closing stock (work-in-progress); since no expenditure was claimed in profit computation for the year, section 40A(3) disallowance could not be invoked.
  • The impugned order under section 263 was ex parte and the earlier counsel had not appeared in the section 263 proceedings, supporting the case for condonation based on lack of proper representation.

Respondent's Arguments (Revenue / PCIT)

  • The Revenue strongly opposed the application for condonation of delay (no further detailed arguments on merits by the Revenue are recorded in the opinion beyond noting the PCIT's findings under section 40A(3)).
  • PCIT's position (as recorded) was that cash payments made by the assessee (including cash payments in excess of Rs. 20,000 in a day to a person) attracted disallowance under section 40A(3), and that the assessing officer's failure to disallow such payments rendered the assessment order erroneous and prejudicial to the revenue, warranting exercise of revisionary powers under section 263.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Malabar Industrial Co Ltd v. CIT (2008) 109 Taxman 66 (SC) Establishes the twin conditions for exercise of jurisdiction under section 263: (i) the order must be erroneous and (ii) it must be prejudicial to the interest of Revenue. The Tribunal relied on this Supreme Court decision to conclude that both twin conditions were not satisfied (the AO's order could not be said to be erroneous) and therefore the PCIT was not authorised to invoke section 263; accordingly the PCIT's order was quashed on this ground.
Sahalbuddin Quadiri v. DCIT, ITA No. 1617/Kol/2016 (Kolkata Bench, Tribunal) (dated 22.11.2018) Coordinate Bench decision where delay in filing appeal against an order under section 263 was condoned where the assessee relied on bona fide advice of counsel that appeal was not maintainable. The Tribunal relied on this coordinate-bench decision as supporting authority to condone the delay in filing the present appeal given the assessee's claim of wrong professional advice and the earlier counsel's failure to act.
Ashte Logistics Pvt. Ltd. v. Pr. CIT‑1, ITA No. 229/Mum/2018 (Mumbai Bench, Tribunal) (dated 03.12.2018) Coordinate Bench decision condoning delay where an assessee was misadvised by counsel about maintainability of appeal against an order under section 263. The Tribunal treated this decision as further supporting authority for condoning the delay on the basis of the assessee's bona fide reliance on erroneous advice of earlier counsel.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal's analysis proceeded in two phases: first addressing the condonation application and then the substantive challenge to the PCIT's order under section 263.

Condonation of delay:

  • The Tribunal examined the explanation in the condonation application together with the affidavit of Shri Amarjit Garg (partner of the assessee firm) and noted that the earlier counsel allegedly did not act for the assessee, did not appear in the PCIT's section 263 proceedings and did not advise the assessee on maintainability.
  • The Tribunal took judicial notice of coordinate-bench decisions (Sahalbuddin Quadiri and Ashte Logistics) where delays were condoned in somewhat similar factual circumstances where the assessee had been misadvised by counsel that an appeal against a section 263 order was not maintainable.
  • Balancing the explanations, the Tribunal concluded that the interest of justice would be served by condoning the delay and accordingly granted condonation.

On merits (challenge to exercise of jurisdiction under section 263):

  • The Tribunal recorded the PCIT's findings: the assessee had made large cash payments (including two payments of Rs. 73,68,000 each) and other cash payments in excess of Rs. 20,000, which PCIT treated as attracting disallowance under section 40A(3); on that basis PCIT held the assessment order erroneous and prejudicial to Revenue and set it aside under section 263, directing fresh assessment after affording the assessee an opportunity.
  • The Tribunal accepted the assessee's submission that the assessment was the result of a limited scrutiny under the CASS focused on the large increase in unsecured loans, that the Assessing Officer's enquiries were restricted to genuineness and verification of unsecured loans (for which evidence was furnished), and that the AO completed the assessment at the returned loss of Rs. 10,21,815/-, with no finding recorded by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) against the AO's conduct on the limited scrutiny issue.
  • Applying the legal principle from Malabar Industrial Co Ltd (the twin conditions test for section 263), the Tribunal held that where the AO's order cannot be said to be erroneous, the PCIT lacks jurisdiction to revise the order under section 263. The Tribunal found the first twin condition (error) absent and therefore concluded the PCIT was not authorised to exercise revisionary powers.
  • Separately, on the substantive claim of disallowance under section 40A(3), the Tribunal accepted the assessee's contention that no expenditure was claimed in the year because there were no sales and the amounts were part of closing stock (work‑in‑progress); hence no disallowance could be made under section 40A(3) in the computation for that year. The Revenue did not successfully rebut this contention as recorded in the opinion.
  • On these bases (procedural scope of AO's limited scrutiny, absence of an erroneous AO order, and the assessee's contention on the nature of payments/expenditure), the Tribunal concluded that the PCIT's order under section 263 was not sustainable.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Tribunal quashed the order passed by the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax under section 263 of the Income‑tax Act and allowed the assessee's appeal.

Implications / Consequences:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The order passed by the PCIT under section 263 (dated 01.02.2017) setting aside the assessment order dated 30.12.2014 was quashed and the assessee's appeal was allowed.
  • The Tribunal granted condonation of delay (265 days) in filing the appeal on the facts of this case, relying on the explanation of erroneous professional advice and coordinate-bench decisions that treated similar explanations as adequate for condonation.
  • The opinion rests its decision on established principles governing section 263 (as articulated by the Supreme Court in Malabar Industrial Co Ltd) and on factual findings about the limited scope of AO's scrutiny and the absence of a claimed expenditure in the year under consideration; the opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent beyond applying these authorities to the facts.
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Aggarwal Promoters v. Principal Commissioner Of Income Tax-2, Chandigarh .

    , ,  IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL DIVISION BENCH, A, CHANDIGARH  ,   . .., ,  BEFORE SHRI SANJAY GARG, JUDICIAL MEMBER AND DR. B.R.R. KUMAR, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER ./ ITA No. 1708/CHD/2017   / Assessment Year : 2012-13 M/s Aggarwal Promoters, Villagae Desumajra, Kharar The Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax-2, Chandigarh  ./PAN NO. AASFA5580H /Appellant /Respondent  /Assessee by : Sh. Parikshit Aggarwal, CA  / Revenue by : Sh. Ashish Gupta, CIT DR %/Date of Hearing : 28.02.2019 %/Date of Pronouncement : 16. 04.2019 /Order Per Sanjay Garg, Judicial Member: The present appeal has been preferred by the assessee against the order dated 01.2.2017 of the Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax-2, Chandigarh [herein referred to as PCIT].

    2. The assessee in this appeal has agitated the action of the PCIT in setting aside the assessment order passed by the Assessing officer exercising his revision powers u/s 263 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (in short 'the Act').

    3. There is a delay of 265 days in filing the present appeal. A separate application has been moved for Condonation of Delay which has also been supported with the affidavit of Shri Amarjit Garg, partner of the assessee ITA Nos. 1464/Chd/2017- M/s Bhandari Knit Exports, Ludhiana firm. It has been explained in the application that the tax matters of the assessee firm were looked into by his counsel namely Shri Varinder Garg, Advocate. That the partners of the assessee firm were not well-versed with the procedure and technicalities of the tax matters and were dependent on the counsel, Shri Varinder Garg. That when the notice of the proceedings u/s 263 was received by the assessee, the same was supplied to Shri Varinder Garg, Advocate for further action. Thereafter, the assessee received the impugned order passed by the Ld. PCIT u/s 263 of the Act which was also supplied to their counsel Shri Varinder Garg. However, Shri Varinder Garg, did not take any action in this respect and never advised the assessee about the maintainability of the appeal against the order u/s 263 of the Act. Even thereafter a fresh assessment order was passed by the Assessing officer which was again supplied to Shri Varinder Garg, counsel for the assessee for further action. However, at this stage, Shri Varinder Garg surrendered and suggested that he had no experience of appearance before the Appellate Authorities and that the assessee should engage some other counsel to pursue the matter before the Appellate authority. When the assessee sought advise of some other counsels, then it was pointed out by them that assessee was not properly advised by the earlier counsel about the maintainability of the appeal against the order passed u/s 263 of the Act. The assessee thereafter engaged the present counsel and immediately f iled the appeal against the order passed by the Ld. PCIT u/s 263 of the Act. That the delay in filing the appeal was neither intentional nor deliberate but solely due to wrong professional advice given by their earlier counsel. That there was a reasonable and ITA Nos. 1464/Chd/2017- M/s Bhandari Knit Exports, Ludhiana bonafide cause for the delay in filling the appeal, therefore, the delay deserves to be condoned.

    4. The Ld. Counsel has also invited our attention to the impugned order passed u/s 263 of the Act to submit that even the earlier counsel did not the appear before the PCIT in the proceedings carried out u/s 263 of the Act and that the said order passed by the Ld. PCIT u/s 263 of the Act was an ex-parte order. The averments made in the application have been further corroborated with the affidavit of Shri Amarjit Garg, partner of the assessee firm. The Ld. Counsel for the assessee has further relied on the two decisions of the Coordinate Bench of the Tribunal, firstly, the decision of Kolkata Bench of the Tribunal dated 22.11.2018 in the case of Sahalbuddin Quadiri Vs. DCIT ITA No. 1617/Kol//2016 and secondly on the decision dated 3.12.2018 of the Mumbai Bench of the Tribunal in the case of Ashte Logistics Pvt Ltd, Mumbai Vs. Pr. CIT-1, ITA No. 229/Mum/2018, wherein, in somewhat similar circumstances, the respective counsels for the assessee did give wrong advise about the maintainability of the appeal against order passed u/s 263 of the Act, and the Coordinate Benches of the Tribunal taking into consideration the bonafide belief of the assessees which was based on the advise of the counsel that appeal against the order passed u/s 263 of the Act was not maintainable, have held that the assessee should not suffer on account of wrong advise of the consultant and, therefore, have condoned the delay of

    409 days and 214 days respectively in filling the appeals against the orders passed u/s 263 of the Act. ITA Nos. 1464/Chd/2017- M/s Bhandari Knit Exports, Ludhiana

    5. The Ld. DR has strongly opposed the application for condonation of delay.

    6. Considering the explanation given in the application which is further corroborated with the affidavit of Shri Amarjit Singh, partner of the assessee firm and also considering the rival submissions and also taking note of the fact that the earlier counsel of the assessee even did not appear before the PCIT in the proceedings carried out u/s 263 of the Act and also in the light of the decision of the Coordinate Koklata Bench in Sahalbuddin Quadiri Vs. DCIT (supra) and Mumbai Bench of the Tribunal Ashte Logistics Pvt Ltd, Mumbai Vs. Pr. CIT-1 (supra), in our view, interest of justice will be served, if the delay in filing the present appeal is condoned. We order accordingly.

    7. Now coming to the merits of the case. The Ld. PCIT noted from the assessment order that the assessee had claimed expenditure of 1,59,45,020/- in the trading account as land cost. He further noted that while purchasing the said land, out of total consideration, the assessee had made cash payment of 73,68,000/- twice vide receipt Nos. 2065 & 2066 respectively on 9.8.2011 to the seller. Further, from the perusal of the ledger account, the Ld. PCIT noted that the assessee had made cash payment of 62,762/- on account of expenditure in respect of Job Work charges to M/s Dhiman Aluminum and Interior Decorator on 3.3.2012 and Building Material to other two parties. He, therefore, held that as per the provisions of section 40A(3), where the assessee incurs any expenditure in respect of which a payment or aggregate of payments made to a person in a day, otherwise than by account pay cheques / bank draft, exceeds ITA Nos. 1464/Chd/2017- M/s Bhandari Knit Exports, Ludhiana 20,000/- rupees, no deduction shall be allowed in respect of such expenditure. The Ld. PCIT, therefore, noted that since the aforesaid payments were made in cash, hence, the provisions of section 40A(3) were attracted and the disallowance of aforesaid amount was warranted which the Assessing officer failed to do so. He, therefore, held that the assessment order passed by the Assessing officer dated 30.12.2014 was erroneous and prejudicial to the interest of Revenue. The Ld. PCIT, therefore, set aside the assessment order dated 30.12.2014 passed u/s 143(3) of the Act for the assessment year under consideration with a direction to the Assessing officer to pass the assessment order afresh in accordance with law keeping in view of the aforesaid observations of the Ld. PCIT regarding disallowance u/s 40A(3) of the Act after allowing opportunity of being heard to the assessee.

    8. Aggrieved by the said order of the PCIT passed u/s 263 of the Act, the assessee has come in appeal before us.

    9. At the outset, Ld. Counsel for the assessee has invited our attention to the assessment order in question of the Assessing officer dated 30.12.2014 passed u/s 143(3) of the Act and has submitted that the return filed by the assessee was originally processed u/s 143(1) of the Act, however, the case was later selected for limited scrutiny under the CASS to verify the large increase in unsecured loans raised during the year. The enquiries of the Ld. Assessing officer were, therefore, limited to the aspect of the genuineness and verification of unsecured loans, the details and explanation regarding which were duly supplied to the Assessing officer and the Assessing officer being satisfied with the evidences given by the ITA Nos. 1464/Chd/2017- M/s Bhandari Knit Exports, Ludhiana assessee competed the assessment at the returned loss of 10,21,815/- That neither the Assessing officer was authorised nor there was any occasion to the Assessing officer to scrutinize and make enquiries, about the other factors of the case as it was a limited scrutiny assessment case, hence, the enquiry, if any, was restricted to the limited issue of unsecured loans which was duly done by the Assessing officer and no fault has been found by the Ld. CIT(A) in that respect. Under the circumstances, the order passed by the Assessing officer cannot be said to be erroneous.

    10. As per the provisions of section 263 of the Act, the CIT / PCIT on exerciser jurisdiction u/s 263 of the Act, if he consider that the order passed by the Assessing officer is erroneous in so far as it is prejudicial to the interest of Revenue. It has been held time and again by various Courts of law including the Hon'ble Apex Court of the country that for exercise of jurisdiction u/s 263 of the Act, the twin conditions must be satisfied i.e.

    (i) the order passed by the Assessing officer is erroneous, and; (ii) it must be prejudicial to the interest of Revenue. If any of the twin conditions is absent, the Commissioner cannot exercise jurisdiction u/s 263 of the Act. Reliance in this respect is placed on the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Malabar Industrial Co Ltd Vs. CIT (2008) 109 Taxman 66 (SC). In view of the above discussion, the order passed by the Assessing officer since cannot be said to be erroneous, hence, the Ld. PCIT was not authorised to invoke his powers u/s 263 of the Act and cancel the assessment order. Therefore, the order passed by the Ld. PCIT is quashed on this score alone. ITA Nos. 1464/Chd/2017- M/s Bhandari Knit Exports, Ludhiana

    11. Even on merits, the Ld. Counsel for the assessee has invited our attention to the trading account of the assessee for the year ended on 31.3.2012 i.e. for the assessment year under consideration to show that the assessee during the year did not make any sales. That all the payments / expenditure during the year was part of the closing stock (work in progress). That since there was no sales made during the year, hence, there was no question of booking any expenditure against any profit or loss against any sales. That since the assessee has not claimed any expenditure during the year, hence, there was no question of disallowance of any expenditure under the provisions of section 40A(3) of the I.T. Act.

    12. The Ld. DR could not rebut the aforesaid contention also of the assessee.

    13. Since the assessee did not claim any expenditure during the year, no disallowance of expenditure can be made even under the provisions of section 40A(3) of the Act. Therefore, the order passed by the Assessing officer even on merit cannot be said to be prejudicial to the interest of Revenue. In view of the above discussion, the order passed by the Ld. PCIT u/s 263 of the Act is not sustainable in the eyes of law and the same is accordingly quashed. In the result, the appeal of the assessee is hereby allowed. Order pronounced in the Open Court on 16.04.2019 Sd/- Sd/- ( .., / B.R.R. KUMAR) / Accountant Member (  / SANJAY GARG )   /Judicial Member Dated : 16.04.2019 ITA Nos. 1464/Chd/2017- M/s Bhandari Knit Exports, Ludhiana  ,- .-/ Copy of the order forwarded to :

    1. / The Appellant

    2. / The Respondent

    3. // CIT

    4. / ()/ The CIT(A)

    5. -  2, % 2, 4/ DR, ITAT, CHANDIGARH

    6.  / Guard File / By order, / Assistant Registrar

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Aggarwal Promoters v. Principal Commissioner Of Income Tax-2, Chandigarh .
    (Apr 16, 2019)