PASSED IN MVC.NO.286/2013 ON THE FILE OF THE SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE CUM MEMBER ADDITIONAL MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL- VI AT KUDLIGI, PARTLY ALLOWING THE CLAIM PETITION FOR COMPENSATION AND SEEKING ENHANCEMENT OF COMPENSATION. IN M.F.A. NO.103681 OF 2015 (MV-D) BETWEEN:
1. GOWRAMMA W/O. LATE M. SOMANNA AGE: 47 YEARS,
2. GANESH S/O. LATE M. SOMANNA AGE: 19 YEARS,
3. UMESH S/O. LATE SOMANNA AGE: 26 YEARS,
4. SAVITRAMMA D/O. LATE SOMANNA AGE: 24 YEARS, ALL ARE AGRICULTURIST R/O: HARAKABHAVI VILLAGE, KUDLIGI DIST: BALLARI. ... APPELLANTS (BY SRI M. AMARE GOUDA, ADVOCATE) AND:
1. RAVI KUPALURU S/O. MAHESHAPPA AGE: 42 YEARS, OCC: DRIVER OF LORRY BEARING NO.KA-16/A-4378, R/O: ALADAKATTE VILLAGE, TQ: RANEBENNUR, DIST: HAVERI.
2. K.S.RIYAJUDDIN S/O. LATE M.K. SIRAJUDDIN AGE: 43 YEARS, OCC: OWNER OF LORRY BEARING NO.KA-16/A-4378 R/O: BEHIND PNT QUARTERS, CHELAGUDDA, CHITRADURGA TOWN, TQ: CHITRADURGA.
3. THE MANAGER SREE RAM GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED, E-8, EPIP, RIICO, SITHAPURA, JAIPURA, RAJASTHAN STATE 302 022. ... RESPONDENTS (R-1 SD; BY MR. SADIQ N. GOODWALA ADVOCATE FOR R-2; SRI S.K. KAYAKAMATH, ADVOCATE FOR R-3) THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.173(1) OF MOTOR VEHICLES ACT 1988, AGAINST THE JUDGMENT & AWARD DATED:01.01.2015, PASSED IN MVC.NO.285/2013 ON THE FILE OF THE SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE CUM MEMBER ADDITIONAL MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL- VI AT KUDLIGI, PARTLY ALLOWING THE CLAIM PETITION FOR COMPENSATION AND SEEKING ENHANCEMENT OF COMPENSATION. THESE APPEALS COMING ON FOR ORDERS THIS DAY, NAGARATHNA J., DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING: JUDGMENT These appeals are filed by the claimants assailing the judgment and awards passed in MVC No.286/2013 and 285/2013 respectively dated 01.01.2015 by the Court of the Senior Civil Judge- cum-Member-VI Motor Accident Claims Tribunal at Kudligi (hereinafter referred to as the Tribunal for the sake of convenience).
2. Though these appeals are listed to consider I.A.No.1/2018 which has been filed by the owner of the offending vehicle, with the consent of learned counsel on both the sides, they are heard finally.
3. MFA No.103680/2015 is filed by the claimants in MVC No.286/2013 while MFA No.103681/2015 is filed by the claimants in MVC No.285/2013.
4. For the sake of convenience, the parties shall be referred to in terms of their status before the Tribunal.
5. It is the case of the claimants that respondent No.1 is the driver and respondent No.2 is the owner and respondent No.3 is the insurer of the vehicle being Lorry bearing No. KA-16/A-4378 which had a policy in force issued by the respondent-Insurance Company on the date of the accident.
6. That on 05.04.2012, Agasara Srikantha and Nagaraja being the cleaner and driver of Tata Ace vehicle bearing No.KA-35/A-7411 were proceeding to Challakere on State Highway No.19. At that time, the driver of the lorry bearing No.KA- 16/A-4378 came from the opposite direction driving the lorry in a rash and negligent manner and dashed against the Tata Ace vehicle. The accident took place between Mannyakote and Bovi colony, as a result, both the driver and the cleaner of the Tata Ace vehicle died on the spot and the said vehicle was damaged. Contending that they had lost their bread earners of their family, their legal representatives filed separate claim petitions seeking compensation on various heads.
7. In response to the summons issued by the Tribunal, respondent Nos.1 and 2 did not appear before the Tribunal and they were placed ex parte. Only respondent No.3-Insurance Company appeared through its counsel and filed its written statement. Respondent No.3 while denying the averments of the claim petitions contended that it had issued a policy in respect of the lorry in question. However, the driver of the vehicle did not possess a valid driving licence on the date of the accident and that the lorry was a goods carrying commercial vehicle and that there was no valid permit to ply on the public road. While denying its liability to satisfy the award, the Insurance Company sought for dismissal of the claim petitions.
8. On the basis of the above pleadings, the following issues were framed in both the cases:
(i) AP : 5-4-2012g Az wzg v Cz g ZP mm J A . P J- 35/J-7411 g Z P jU U Pz g
1 Jz g zg v Jz g U q Az Cw U v P v Az Z u P m v s P q wzg P rQ irz jAz U gdU U A g UAi U V z Ai v l J z Cfzg g z iq v g Ai ?
(ii) 1 Jzgzg ZPU jAiiz Z v E Jz 3 Jzgzgg ziqvgAi?
(iii) jU jAiiz gm E Jz 3 Jzgzg ziqvgAi?
(iv) Cfzg jgz t qAi CzAi? Uzg AiijAz J itz?
(v) Aii Dz Cx Cq?
9. In support to their respective cases, the claimants examined three witnesses and produced ten documents which were marked at Exs.P1 to P10. While the Insurance Company examined its Officer as RW1 and produced two documents namely, the copy of the insurance policy and the driving licence extract at Exs.R1 and R2. On the basis of the said evidence, the Tribunal answered Issue Nos.1 and 2 in the affirmative, Issue No.3 in the negative and Issue No.4 partly in the affirmative and allowed the claim petitions in part granting compensation of `4,55,000/- each in both the claim petitions with interest at the rate of six percent per annum from the date of the claim petition till realization and the Tribunal directed respondent Nos.1 and 2 jointly to satisfy the award and dismissed the claim petitions against respondent No.3-Insurance Company.
10. Being aggrieved by the judgment and awards of the Tribunal, the claimants have preferred these appeals. These appeals have been preferred both on the issue of liability on the part of the Insurance Company to satisfy the award as the Tribunal has exonerated the Insurance Company from its liability and also on seeking enhancement in compensation.
11. We have heard learned counsel for the claimants / appellants, learned counsel for the owner of the vehicle and learned counsel for the Insurance Company namely, respondent Nos.2 and
3 herein. The driver of the vehicle is served and unrepresented (respondent No.1 herein). We have perused the material on record as well as the original record.
12. Learned counsel for appellants-claimants contended that the Tribunal was not right in exonerating the Insurance Company from its liability. He contended that in the instant case, the driver of the lorry which is the offending vehicle had a driving licence for a light motor vehicle up to the year 2018. As far as the transport vehicle is concerned, he had a transport endorsement for the period from 03.02.2009 to 02.02.2012. The accident occurred on 05.04.2012. However, the licence to drive the transport vehicle i.e., the lorry in question was renewed by issuance of a transport endorsement shortly after the accident in question i.e., on 02.06.2012. The licence to drive a non-transport vehicle was effective from 24.07.1998 to 23.07.2018. According to learned counsel for claimantsappellants, this is not a case where the driver of the offending vehicle did not have any licence to drive the vehicle, or lacked the skill to drive a transport vehicle; it is a case of non-renewal of the transport endorsement. The Tribunal ought to have appreciated this aspect of the matter. He further contended that there was no other disqualification for the driver of the offending vehicle to drive the vehicle as such, that merely because on the date of the accident there was non-renewal of the transport endorsement, it would not imply that the driver had no licence at all to drive the offending vehicle or did not possess the expertise to drive the same. Relying on certain decisions of the Honble Supreme Court, he submitted that the Tribunals finding on the aspect of exoneration of the Insurance Company may be set aside and the liability may be fastened on the insurer.
13. Learned counsel for the appellants next contended that the award of compensation in both the cases is on the lower side. That the Tribunal has assessed the notional income of the driver and the cleaner of the vehicle on the lower side and that the accident occurred in the year 2012, therefore the notional income may be reassessed. Future prospects may be awarded in terms of the latest dictum of the Honble Supreme Court in the case of National Insurance Company Limited v. Pranay Sethi and others reported in AIR 2017 SC 5157 and that the award of compensation on the other heads may also be enhanced.
14. Learned counsel for respondent No.2, the owner of the offending lorry submitted that the driver did posses a valid driving licence to drive a transport vehicle which was issued on 03.02.2009 up to 02.02.2012, that the said licence was renewed thereafter on 02.06.2012 up to 31.05.2015. That, on the date of the accident, it may be that the licence to drive the lorry may not have been renewed, but the fact remains that non- renewal of the licence is not the same thing as driving of a vehicle without a licence. In support to his submissions, he placed reliance on National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh and others reported in AIR 2004 SC 1531 (Swaran Singh) and submitted that the non-renewal of the driving licence, does not amount to a fundamental breach of the policy condition so as to have contributed to the cause of the accident and hence the liability may be fastened on the Insurance Company. As far as the quantum of compensation is concerned, he submitted that if the liability to satisfy the award is on the Insurance Company, then appropriate directions could be issued on the quantum of compensation.
15. Learned counsel for respondent No.3- Insurance Company on the other hand contended that this is a clear case of the driver of the offending vehicle not possessing a valid licence to drive the lorry in question, which is a heavy goods vehicle. Non-renewal of transport endorsement is not equivalent to non-possession of a valid driving license to drive such a vehicle. He submitted that the Tribunal has rightly appreciated the case of the Insurance Company and has exonerated it from its liability to satisfy the award. If a person is to drive a heavy goods vehicle which is a transport vehicle without a transport endorsement and an accident occurs, then it would be a case of non-possession of a driving license. Therefore, the finding of the Tribunal on the said aspect of the matter may be affirmed. In support of his submission, he placed reliance on Section 3 as well as Section 15 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (hereinafter referred to as the Act for the sake of convenience) to contend if an application for a driving license is made within thirty days from the date of expiry of the license, the renewal would be from the day of the expiry of the license in which case there will be a continuity in the period of license, but in the instant case, the application has not been made within thirty days from the date of expiry. It has been therefore renewed with effect from 02.06.2012 which is the date of application and hence there was no renewal of the licence as on the date of the accident that is 05.04.2012. Thus, it is a case of not having a license to drive the transport vehicle on the date of the accident. Hence, the appeals filed by the claimants on the aspect of liability may be dismissed.
16. Insofar as to the enhancement of compensation sought by the claimants is concerned, he submitted that the award of the compensation is just and proper which would not call for any enhancement in these appeals.
17. By way of reply, learned counsel for the appellants while reiterating his submissions, contended that having regard to the dictum of the Honble Supreme Court in the case of Swaran Singh, this Court may modify the judgment and awards of the Tribunal by giving a finding that the driver of the offending vehicle being negligent, insurer of the said vehicle is liable to satisfy the awards and also enhance the compensation in both the appeals.
18. Having heard learned counsel for the respective parties and on perusal of the material on record as well as the original record and also the judgments cited at the Bar, the following points would arise for our consideration:
(i) Whether the Tribunal was right in exonerating the Insurance Company of its liability to satisfy the awards on the premise that there was a breach of terms and conditions of the policy inasmuch as the driver of the offending vehicle did not possess a valid and effective driving licence on the date of accident i.e., 05.04.2012? If the answer to the said question is in the negative, whether the liability to satisfy the awards must be passed on the insurer?
(ii) Whether the claimants are entitled to additional compensation? (ii i) What order? The aforesaid points shall be considered in seriatim.
19. The fact that the driver of lorry bearing No.KA-16/A-4378 dashed against the Tata Ace vehicle bearing No.KA-35/A-7411 on 05.04.2012 on account of his rash and negligent driving and caused the accident resulting into two deaths has been established. Regarding Point No.1
20. The first point of controversy is with regard to the liability of the insurer to satisfy the award. On this aspect having regard to Section 149(2)(ii)(a) of the Act, the Insurance Company can avoid its liability if a driver of a vehicle is not duly licenced or if on the fatal date the vehicle has been driven by a person who has been disqualified from holding or obtaining a driving licence and have driven the vehicle during the period of its disqualification. The crucial expression in the form of a defence that could be taken by an insurer is not duly licenced. If a person who is not duly licenced, drives a vehicle and causes an accident, then the Insurance Company can avoid its liability. The expression driving licence is defined in Section 2(10) of the Act to mean the licence issued by a competent authority under Chapter II authorizing the person specified therein to drive, otherwise than as a learner, a motor vehicle or a motor vehicle of any specified class or description. Section 3(1) deals with the necessity for driving licence and it states that no person shall drive a motor vehicle in any public place unless he holds an effective driving licence issued to him authorizing him to drive the vehicle; and no person shall so drive a transport vehicle other than motor cab or motorcycle hired for his own use or rented under any scheme made under Section 75(2) unless his driving licence specifically entitles him so to do.
21. Section 5 says that no owner or person in charge of a motor vehicle shall cause or permit any person who does not satisfy the provisions of Section 3 or Section 4 to drive the vehicle. Section
4 deals with the age limit in connection with driving the motor vehicles. The grant of driving licence is dealt with in Section 9 and the form and contents of licences to drive is dealt with in Section 10. Section 11(1) states that any person holding a driving licence to drive any class or description of motor vehicles, who is not for the time being disqualified for holding or obtaining a driving licence to drive any other class or description of motor vehicles, may apply to the licensing authority having jurisdiction in the area in which he resides or carries on his business in such form and accompanied by such documents and with such fees as may be prescribed by the Central Government for the addition of such other class or description of vehicles to the licence. Section 14 which deals with currency of licences to drive motor vehicles inter alia states in sub- section (2) that a driving licence issued or renewed under the Act shall, in the case of a licence to drive a transport vehicle, be effected for a period of three years.
22. Section 15 has been referred to by learned counsel for the Insurance Company which deals with renewal of driving licence. Sub-section (1) of Section 15 states that any licensing authority may, on application made to it, renew a driving licence issued under the provisions of this Act with effect from the date of its expiry. The proviso states where the application for the renewal of a licence is made more than thirty days after the date of its expiry, the driving licence shall be renewed with effect from the date of its renewal; that means in other cases, the renewal will take place from the date of its expiry. The other provisions of Section 15 are not relevant for the purpose of this case. The aforesaid provisions have been considered and interpreted by the Honble Supreme Court in the case of Swaran Singh and after dealing with a catena of judgments, the summary of its findings are noted in paragraph 105 as under:
105. The summary of our findings to the various issues as raised in these petitions are as follows:
(i) Chapter XI of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 providing compulsory insurance of vehicles against third party risks is a social welfare legislation to extend relief by compensation to victims of accidents caused by use of motor vehicles. The provisions of compulsory insurance coverage of all vehicles are with this paramount object and the provisions of the Act have to be so interpreted as to effectuate the said object.
(ii) Insurer is entitled to raise a defence in a claim petition filed under Section 163 A or Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 inter alia in terms of Section 149(2)(a)(ii) of the said Act. (ii i) The breach of policy condition e.g. disqualification of driver or invalid driving licence of the driver, as contained in sub-section (2)(a)(ii) of Section 149, have to be proved to have been committed by the insured for avoiding liability by the insurer. Mere absence, fake or invalid driving licence or disqualification of the driver for driving at the relevant time, are not in themselves defences available to the insurer against either the insured or the third parties. To avoid its liability towards insured, the insurer has to prove that the insured was guilty of negligence and failed to exercise reasonable care in the matter of fulfi l ling the condition of the policy regarding use of vehicles by duly licensed driver or one who was not disqualified to drive at the relevant time.
(iv) The insurance companies are, however, with a view to avoid their l iability must not only establish the available defence(s) raised in the said proceedings but must also establish 'breach' on the part of the owner of the vehicle; the burden of proof wherefore would be on them.
(v) The court cannot lay down any criteria as to how said burden would be discharged, inasmuch as the same would depend upon the facts and circumstance of each case.
(vi) Even where the insurer is able to prove breach on the part of the insured concerning the policy condition regarding holding of a valid licence by the driver or his qualification to drive during the relevant period, the insurer would not be allowed to avoid its liability towards insured unless the said breach or breaches on the condition of driving licence is/ are so fundamental as are found to have contributed to the cause of the accident. The Tribunals in interpreting the policy conditions would apply "the rule of main purpose" and the concept of "fundamental breach" to allow defences available to the insured under Section 149(2) of the Act.
(vii) The question as to whether the owner has taken reasonable care to find out as to whether the driving licence produced by the driver, (a fake one or otherwise), does not fulfi l the requirements of law or not will have to be determined in each case. (vii i) If a vehicle at the time of accident was driven by a person having a learner's licence, the insurance companies would be liable to satisfy the decree.
(ix) The claims tribunal constituted under Section 165 read with Section 168 is empowered to adjudicate all claims in respect of the accidents involving death or of bodily injury or damage to property of third party arising in use of motor vehicle. The said power of the tribunal is not restricted to decide the claims inter se between claimant or claimants on one side and insured, insurer and driver on the other. In the course of adjudicating the claim for compensation and to decide the availability of defence or defences to the insurer, the Tribunal has necessarily the power and jurisdiction to decide disputes inter se between insurer and the insured. The decision rendered on the claims and disputes inter se between the insurer and insured in the course of adjudication of claim for compensation by the claimants and the award made thereon is enforceable and executable in the same manner as provided in Section
174 of the Act for enforcement and execution of the award in favour of the claimants.
(x) Where on adjudication of the claim under the Act the tribunal arrives at a conclusion that the insurer has satisfactorily proved its defence in accordance with the provisions of Sections 149(2) read with sub-section (7), as interpreted by this Court above, the Tribunal can direct that the insurer is liable to be reimbursed by the insured for the compensation and other amounts which it has been compelled to pay to the third party under the award of the tribunal. Such determination of claim by the Tribunal will be enforceable and the money found due to the insurer from the insured will be recoverable on a certificate issued by the tribunal to the Collector in the same manner under Section 174 of the Act as arrears of land revenue. The certificate will be issued for the recovery as arrears of land revenue only if, as required by sub-section (3) of Section 168 of the Act the insured fails to deposit the amount awarded in favour of the insurer within thirty days from the date of announcement of the award by the tribunal.
(xi) The provisions contained in sub- section (4) with proviso thereunder and sub-section (5) which are intended to cover specified contingencies mentioned therein to enable the insurer to recover amount paid under the contract of insurance on behalf of the insured can be taken recourse of by the Tribunal and be extended to claims and defences of insurer against insured by relegating them to the remedy before regular court in cases where on given facts and circumstances adjudication of their claims inter se might delay the adjudication of the claims of the victims.
23. Clause 6 of the summation is relevant. It states that even where the insurer is able to prove breach on the part of the insured concerning the policy condition regarding holding of a valid licence by the driver or his qualification to drive during the relevant period, the insurer would not be allowed to avoid its liability towards insured unless the said breach or breaches on the condition of driving licence is/are so fundamental as are found to have contributed to the cause of the accident. The Tribunals in interpreting the policy conditions should apply the rule of main purpose and the concept of fundamental breach to allow defences available to the insured under Section 149(2) of the Act. A reading of the same would imply that every breach of the policy condition regarding licence would not ipso facto, be so fundamental so as to enable the Insurance Company to avoid its liability. The breach with regard to the condition of possessing a driving licence must be so fundamental so as to have contributed to the cause of accident. Thus, there must be a nexus between the absence of a valid and effective driving license by the driver of the offending vehicle and the accident. The same would imply that the driver of the offending vehicle is not duly licenced to drive the vehicle and in absence of possessing the skill to drive a vehicle has driven the same in a rash and negligent manner. It could also be a case where the driver is disqualified for holding or obtaining a driving licence and during the period of disqualification, has driven the vehicle in a rash and negligent manner and caused the accident. Therefore, the aforesaid interpretation of the Honble Supreme Court is in the context of the expression used in Section 149(2)(a)(ii) of the Act.
24. Applying the aforesaid decision to the instant case, it is noted that the driver of the offending vehicle had the licence to drive a non- transport vehicle for the period from 24.07.1998 to 23.07.2018. He also had the authorization to drive a transport vehicle for the period from 03.02.2009 up to 02.02.2012. The licence to drive a non-transport vehicle was renewed on 02.06.2012. It is in the interregnum i.e., on 05.04.2012 the accident occurred. Could it be inferred that the breach in the policy condition was so fundamental so as to have resulted in the driver of the offending vehicle causing the accident? We do not think so. This is not a case where the driver of the offending vehicle did not possess any licence at all to drive any vehicle; neither is it a case where the driver of the offending vehicle did not possess an authorization (transport endorsement) to drive a heavy goods vehicle at all (which is the offending lorry in the instant case). This is a case where the authorization to drive such a transport vehicle had expired on 02.02.2012 and it was subsequently renewed on 02.06.2012 i.e., four months later. But on the date of the accident that is on 05.04.2012, he had not got his licence renewed. This is a case of a non-renewal of a license and not a case of not possessing a license to drive a heavy goods vehicle. A non-renewal of the licence is totally different from the case of non-possession of the licence or driving a vehicle on being disqualified. In the latter two cases, the Insurance Company may have to be exonerated of its liability if the aforesaid reasons had a nexus with the occurrence of the accident as that is precisely what has been stated in the defences of the insurer under Section 149(2) of the Act. But insofar as non-renewal of a licence is concerned or absence of a transport endorsement to drive a particular transport vehicle but otherwise having a license to drive such a vehicle i.e., a non- transport vehicle, it cannot be equated to a case of non-possession of a licence or a case where a driver who was disqualified from driving the vehicle drove the same. It is only in the latter two cases where the insurer can avoid its liability.
25. A Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in the case of K.G.Srinivasamurthy Vs. Habib Khathun, reported in 2002 ACJ 557 has observed after referring to Section 15 of the Act that, if the application for renewal is made within thirty days after the date of expiry of the licence, the same shall be renewed from the date of its expiry. However, if the application is made more than thirty days after the date of its expiry, the driving licence shall be renewed with effect from the date of its renewal. The above said provisions also show that the licensing authority has no power to refuse renewal of licence unless the application is filed beyond the period of five years from the date of expiry in view of the proviso to Sub-section (4) to Section 15. That when the application for renewal is more than five years after the driving licence has ceased to be effective, the licensing authority may refuse to renew the driving licence, unless the applicant undergoes and passes to its satisfaction the test of competence to drive referred to in Sub-section (3) of Section 9. Therefore, if the application for renewal is made within five years after the expiry of the driving licence for renewal, the authority cannot refuse to renew the licence if the prescribed fee is paid and if only the application is made beyond the period of five years from the date of expiry of the driving licence, the applicant has to undergo and pass to the satisfaction of the licensing authority the test of competence to drive referred to in Sub-section (3) of Section 9. Thus if a person has not made an application for renewal of his license within a period of five years from the date of expiry of the license, such a driver entails a disqualification to drive the vehicle and has to undergo a fresh driving test and obtain a fresh driving license.
26. In the said case also, the offending driver was holding a driving licence which was renewed. However, there was delay in getting the licence renewed as the application had been made more than 30 days after the expiry of the period of licence, the renewal was made from the date of application and not from the date of expiry of the licence. Therefore, the question considered was as to whether the owner of the vehicle had handed over the vehicle to a person who was not holding any licence.
27. The Co-Ordinate Bench has held after referring to various judgments that even if there is no renewal endorsement, it cannot be said that the person driving the vehicle was not a licensed driver. It is not a case where the insured entrusted the vehicle to a person who does not hold a driving licence rather admittedly the driver to whom the vehicle was entrusted by the insured was having a valid driving licence duly granted by transport authority. Merely because of expiry of the period of licence and the omission of the driver to get the licence renewed, it cannot be said by any stretch of imagination that there is breach of condition of policy for which insurance company can be exonerated from the liability. The driver was authorised to drive a transport vehicle and the vehicle was entrusted by the insured to the licensed driver and, therefore, the insurance company cannot absolve itself from the liability. Therefore, it is clear that mere fact that the driver of the vehicle had not got his driving licence renewed on the date of the accident and got it renewed subsequently would not amount to breach of condition of the policy as it cannot be said that there was violation of the condition of the policy. Further, in view of the above findings, the Division Bench also held that the question of ordering any recovery of the amount by the insurance company from the insurer did not arise.
28. In the instant case, the driver of the offending vehicle was qualified to drive the vehicle and he had also the transport endorsement upto 02.02.2012 and the said endorsement was renewed subsequently on 02.06.2012 up to 31.05.2015. As noted already above, it was in the interregnum that is on 05.04.2012 that the accident occurred. Therefore, having regard to the interpretation made by the Honble Apex Court in the context of the defence of a insurer having regard to the Section 149 of the Act, it is held that the Insurance Company herein has not succeeded in its defence and therefore cannot be exonerated of its liability to satisfy the awards.
29. Of course, learned counsel for the Insurance Company has relied upon another judgment of the Honble Supreme Court in the case of Ram Babu Tiwari V. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. and others reported in 2008 ACJ 2654, wherein it has been held that if during the period of non-renewal of the licence, the accident occurs then the Insurance Company must be exonerated. However, the same does not take into consideration, the three Judge Bench opinion in the case of Swaran Singh referred to in detail above. Similarly, National Insurance Co. Ltd. V. Vidhyadhar Mahariwala and others reported in 2008 ACJ 2860 which is a judgment of two Honble Judges, whereas we deem it proper to follow the dictum of the Honble Supreme Court in the case of Swaran Singh which is a judgment of three Honble Judges of the Apex Court.
30. Reliance placed on another three Judge Bench decision of the Honble Supreme Court in the case of Pappu and others V. Vinod Kumar Lamba and another reported in 2018 ACJ 690 is also of no assistance to the Insurance Company as on a reading of paragraph Nos.9 and 11 in the said case, it becomes clear that respondent No.1 who was the owner of the vehicle did not produce any evidence in support of his plea taken in the written statement that the offending vehicle was plied by an authorized person having a valid driving permit. All that respondent No.1 therein did was to produce a valid driving licence of one Sri. Joginder Singh. The Tribunal on considering the said driving licence found that the truck was in fact not driven by the said Joginder Singh at the time of the accident. The view taken by the Tribunal was assailed before the High Court by the claimants as it was held by the Tribunal that the owner of the vehicle had not proved that his driver was holding a valid driving licence. The High Court after analyzing the record negatived the said contention. On noting from the evidence the High Court observed that there was no proof before the Tribunal by mere production of the driving licence of Sri. Joginder Singh by the owner of the vehicle. The same could not raise a presumption that it is Sri.Joginder Singh who was driving the vehicle at the time of the accident therein. The findings recorded by the Tribunal therefore, was not faulted. The Honble Supreme Court while considering the said controversy submitted that the Insurance Company can be fastened with the liability on the basis of a valid insurance policy only after the basic facts are pleaded and established by the owner of the offending vehicle; that the vehicle was not only duly insured but also that it was driven by an authorized person having a valid licence. Without disclosing the name of the driver in the written statement or producing any evidence to substantiate the fact that the copy of the driving licence produced was indeed of the person who, in fact, was authorized to drive the offending vehicle at the relevant time, the owner of the vehicle cannot be said to have extricated himself from his liability. The Insurance Company would become liable only after such foundational facts are pleaded and proved by the owner of the offending vehicle. In the circumstances, the Honble Supreme Court after referring to Swaran Singh and the summation of the findings therein allowed the appeal in part by directing the Insurance Company to pay the claimants in the first instance with liberty to recover the same from the owner of the vehicle in accordance with law.
31. But in the instant case, it is the Insurance Company who through RW1 has produced not only the copy of the insurance policy but also the driving licence extraction as Ex.D2. It is not in dispute that Ravi Kupaluru was the driver of the vehicle. Ex.D2 is the driving licence extract of Ravi Kupaluru, the driver of the vehicle. Therefore, the controversy in the instant case does not relate to discharge of the initial burden by the owner. The present case concerns the burden of proof and the discharge of the same cast on the Insurance Company. Since we have held that the defence as stated in Section
149 of the Act is not proved in the instant case, and in fact this case being one of non- renewal of licence and not a case of non- possession of a licence to drive the vehicle in question or the driver being disqualified to drive the vehicle, the liability ought to be fastened and is fastened on the Insurance Company. Therefore, Point No.1 is answered against the insurer and in favour of the claimants. Regarding Point No.2:
32. This point concerns the aspect of enhancement of compensation sought by the appellant-claimants. MFA No.103680/2015 = MVC No.286/2013:
33. The deceased in this case is Nagaraja. He was working as a Cleaner in the Tata Ace vehicle bearing registration No.KA-35/A-7411. PW-3, the owner of the vehicle was examined and he stated that he was paying salary to the deceased Nagaraj at the rate of `150/- per day, but since no document was produced in corroboration of the said fact, the Tribunal assessed his notional income to be `5,000/- per month. Since, he was a bachelor, 50% of the said amount was deducted and by applying multiplier of 14, the Tribunal awarded compensation of `4,20,000/- on the head of loss of dependency. In addition, a total sum of `35,000/- under the conventional heads and total compensation of `4,55,000/-with interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of fil ing of the petition till realization was awarded.
34. Learned counsel for the appellants has contended that the award of compensation on the head of loss of dependency is on the lower side as the assessment of notional income by the Tribunal is incorrect. He further submitted that 40% of the monthly income must be added towards future prospects and appropriate compensation may be awarded on the heads of loss of consortium, loss of love and affection and loss of estate and funeral expenses and transportation charges.
35. Per contra, learned counsel for respondents have supported the award made by the Tribunal.
36. However, we find force in the submission of learned counsel for the claimants. The deceased was a bachelor. He was working as a Cleaner of the lorry. Although the contention of the claimants is that deceased Nagaraj was receiving `8,000/- per month, in the absence of any corroborative evidence, the same cannot be reckoned as such. In the circumstances, we asses the notional income of the deceased at `6,500/- per month as the accident had occurred in the year 2012.
37. Having regard to the latest dictum of the Honble Supreme Court in the case of National Insurance Company Limited Vs. Pranay Sethi, reported in 2017 ACJ 2700(SC), 40% of the said income is added towards future prospects, in which event, it would be `6,500/- + `2,600/- = `9,100/-. As the deceased was a bachelor, 50% of the said income (`4,550/-) is deducted towards his personal expenses. The balance amount of `4,550/- which has to be reckoned as the notional income and applying the appropriate multiplier of 18 having regard to the age of the deceased, compensation on the head of loss of dependency would be `9,82,800/- [`4,550/- x 12 x 18].
38. Since, the claimants are the parents of the deceased, on the head of loss of fil ial consortium, a sum of `40,000/- each is awarded, making it `80,000/- in total. Further, towards loss of love and affection, at the rate of `20,000/- each, compensation of `40,000/- is awarded to deceaseds siblings. Towards loss of estate, `15,000/- is awarded and towards transportation of dead body and obsequies expenses, `15,000/- is awarded. Thus, the total compensation awarded on various heads is as under: Head of compensation Amount awarded
(i) Loss of Dependency `9,82,800/-
(ii) Loss of filial consortium to the parents [`40,000/- each]: `80,000/-
(iii) Loss of love and affection [`20,000/- each]: `40,000/-
(iv) Loss of estate : `15,000/-
(v) Transportation of dead body and obsequies expenses : `15,000/- Total: `11,32,800/-
39. Thus, the claimants are entitled to total compensation of `11,32,800/- instead of `4,55,000/-. The enhanced compensation of `6,77,800/- shall carry interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of claim petition till realization, except for the period of delay of 251 days in filing the appeal.
40. The enhancement of compensation shall be apportioned amongst the claimants in the following manner: 40% each to the parents of the deceased; 10% each to the siblings (two in number) of the deceased; 75% of the enhanced compensation awarded to the parents of the deceased shall be deposited in any post office deposit or in any nationalised bank for an initial period of five years. They shall be entitled to draw periodical interest on the said amount. The balance compensation shall be released to them. The compensation awarded to the siblings of the deceased shall be released to them. Consequently, this appeal is allowed in part in the aforesaid terms. Parties to bear their respective costs. ---- MFA No.103681/2015 = MVC No.285/2013:
41. The deceased was Agasara Srikantha who was working as a driver of the Tata Ace vehicle bearing No.KA-35/A-7411. According to the claimants, the deceased was earning `8,000/- per month and he was aged 25 years at the time of the accident. The claimants, being mother and siblings of the deceased, have contended that the deceased was the bread earner of the family and that the claimants being his mother and three siblings were depending on his earnings. According to the learned counsel for the appellants, the Tribunal has assessed the notional income at `5,000/- per month, which is on the lower side and no amount towards future prospects had been added to the said salary. It is further submitted, the multiplier applied is not having regard to the age of the deceased, but age of the mother, which is also not correct. It is also submitted that the award of compensation on the other heads is also on the lower side. Therefore, in this case also, the compensation may be enhanced.
42. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents supporting the judgment and award of the Tribunal submitted that this appeal also would not call for any enhancement in compensation. The Tribunal has assessed the notional income at `5,000/- per month and the annual income at `60,000/-. 50% of the said income had been deducted as the deceased was a bachelor and thereafter, multiplier of 14 has been applied having regard to the age of the mother.
43. However, we find that the appropriate multiplier to be applied is having regard to the age of the deceased who was 25 years. Hence, the appropriate multiplier is 18. Since, the accident occurred in the year 2012 and the deceased was working as a driver, we are of the view that the notional monthly income must be assessed at `7,500/- per month. 40% of the said amount (`3,000/-) must be added towards future prospects. The monthly income would then be `10,500/-. 1/3rd of the same (`3,500/-) is deducted towards his personal expenses, therefore, the net income is `7,000/- as there are four claimants and the mother of the deceased being a widow was dependent on deceased income. Similarly in the absence of their father who had died, the siblings of the deceased would have been dependent on his income. The same has to be reckoned for the purpose of annual notional income and by applying appropriate multiplier of 18, compensation on the head of loss of dependency would be `15,12,000/- instead of `4,20,000/-. In addition, a sum of `40,000/- is awarded towards loss of fil ial consortium to the mother of the deceased; `90,000/- in total, at the rate of `30,000/- each, is awarded to the brother and sisters of the deceased towards loss of love and affection; a sum of `15,000/- is awarded towards loss of estate and a sum of `15,000/- is awarded towards transportation of dead body and obsequies ceremony. Thus, the total compensation awarded on various heads is as under: Head of compensation Amount awarded
(i) Loss of Dependency `15,12,000/-
(ii) Loss of filial consortium to the claimant No.1: `40,000/-
(iii) Loss of love and affection [`30,000/- each]: `90,000/-
(iv) Loss of estate `15,000/-
(v) Transportation of dead body and obsequies expenses `15,000/- Total: `16,72,000/-
44. Consequently, the claimants are entitled to total compensation of `16,72,000/-. The same shall carry interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of petition till realization, except for the period of 251 days which is the period of delay in filing the appeal.
45. The enhancement of compensation is `16,72,000/- - `4,55,000/- = `12,17,000/-. The enhanced compensation is apportioned in the following manner: 70% of the enhanced compensation shall be paid to the mother of the deceased and 10% each to the siblings of the deceased (three in number).
46. The compensation awarded to the siblings of the deceased shall be released to them on due identification.
47. 75% of the enhanced compensation awarded to the mother of the deceased shall be deposited in any nationalised bank or in any post office deposit for an initial period of ten years. She shall be entitled to draw periodical interest on the said amount. The balance compensation shall be released to her.
48. In the result, MFA No.103680/2015 and MFA No.103681/2015 are allowed in part in the aforesaid terms. Parties to bear their respective costs. Sd/- JUDGE Sd/- JUDGE KGK/RK