[Per Justice Shri. U. V. Bakre, President] 2This Appeal is filed against the Judgment and Order dated 15/11/2017 passed by the Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum, South Goa (the Forum, for short) in CRC No. 05/2017. The Appellants were the accused persons whereas Respondents were the Complainants in the said Case. Parties shall hereinafter be referred to as per their status in the said Case.
2. Briefly, the facts are as follows: By Order dated 05/05/2010 passed by the Forum in Complaint No. 12/2004, the accused persons were directed to deliver the possession of shop No. S-1 completed as per the agreement to the Complainants; to obtain occupancy certificate and completion certificate from the appropriate authorities and also to get NOC for the sale of shop No. S-1 of the suit building; to execute the deed of sale in respect of the said shop in favour of the Complainants; to pay to the Complainants interest at the rate of 18% per annum on the sum of Rs. 3,00,000/- from 05/03/2002 to 05/08/2002 and also costs of Rs. 5000/. The accused persons had filed an appeal against the said order along with an application fr condonation of delay registered under C.D. MA. No. 23/2012, before this Commission. By Order dated 13/12/2012, the application and the Appeal were both dismissed. It appears that the Order dated 05/05/2010 passed by the Forum in Complaint No. 12/2004 was not further challenged and hence became final.
3. Since the said final Order of the Forum was not complied with, the Complainants had filed Execution Application No. 13/2010. The Decree Holders 3(Complainants), inter alia, prayed for direction to the Judgment Debtors (accused persons): (a).- to pay to them the amount awarded along with interest as awarded; (b).- to pay to them costs of Rs. 5,000/-; (c).- to comply with the Order dated 05/05/2010 and deliver possession of the said shop no. S-1; (d).- to obtain occupancy certificate, completion certificate, NOC for the sale of shop no. S-1 and to execute sale deed in their favour; (e).- to attach and sell the property of the Judgment Debtors (accused persons) in case the Judgment Debtors fail to make the said payment; and (f).- to arrest and detain the Judgment Debtors (accused persons)(Judgment Debtors) in civil prison and to execute sale deed in their favour. By a common Order dated 24/10/2017, the said execution application No. 13/2010 was disposed of by the Forum, by rejecting the prayers (b), (c), (d), (e) and (f) and in so far as the prayer (a) of payment of money is concerned, ordered to issue recovery certificates to the Decree Holders (Complainants) and directed the Collector to execute the same by recovering the certified amount as arrears of land revenue. The Deputy Collector (Revenue) deputed the Mamlatdar of Salcete to attach the properties of the Judgment Debtors (accused persons). The Mamlatdar, in his report dated 29/08/16, stated that due process was initiated to attach one flat and five shops situated at Murida, Fatorda but it was found that the said flat and the five shops were already sold to different parties.
4. In that execution application No. 13/2010, the Decree Holders (Complainants) had filed an application dated 12/06/2012 for arrest and detention of the accused persons. The Forum had ordered to issue show cause notice to the accused persons. Since the accused persons 4refused to collect the notice inspite of being intimated, the Forum held that the accused persons were deemed to have been served with the show cause notice. Non bailable warrants were ordered to be issued against the accused persons. Accordingly, accused persons were brought before the Forum under warrants and they were released on bail. The Substance of accusation was framed and explained to the accused persons on 27/08/2012. The accused persons pleaded not guilty and the matter was fixed for trial and the Complainants were directed by the Forum to file affidavit-in-evidence. On 08/10/2012 the first Complainant filed his affidavit-in-evidence. He was cross examined on 03/05/2013. On 17/12/2013 the Accused No. 1 was absent and only the accused No. 2 was present. The advocate for the accused persons was also absent. The accused No. 2 was asked to cross examine the Complainant No. 1 and since they could not do so the cross examination was closed on 17/12/2013. On 28/01/2014, the statements of both the accused persons were recorded under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Cr. P. C., for short). The accused No. 2 thereafter filed affidavit-in-evidence and she was also cross examined. Vide order dated 01/08/2014 the Forum convicted the accused persons and directed them to undergo simple imprisonment for nine months each and to pay Rs. 5000/- each as compensation and in default to undergo simple imprisonment for another fifteen days. The accused persons filed Appeal before the Goa State Commission under Section 27A of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 (the Act, for short). The said Appeal No. 71/2014 was dismissed vide order dated 24/10/2014. The accused persons filed Execution Revision Petition No. 86/2014 before the Honble National Commission. By 5order dated 23/07/2015 the Honble National Commission set aside the orders of the State Commission and the Forum. The Honble National Commission found that the Forum did not follow the procedure prescribed in Cr. P. C. for trial of summons cases in its entirety. It was found that though the Forum recorded evidence of the Complainants followed by statements of the accused persons under Section 313 of Cr. P. C. and also examined the accused persons as witnesses, neither any notice in terms of Section 251 of the Cr. P. C. was given to the accused persons nor were they given an opportunity to cross examine the Complainants. The Honble National Commission directed that the application under Section 27 of the Act should be decided afresh after strictly complying with the prescribed procedure. It was further directed that if the accused persons pleaded not guilty of the said notice, the Forum should examine the Complainants and their witnesses giving an opportunity to the accused persons to cross examine them. Further direction was that the Forum should thereafter examine the accused persons in terms of Section 313 of Cr. P. C. and then give opportunity to them to produce defence witnesses. The National Commission lastly directed that a fresh order will thereafter be passed by the Forum on the application filed under Section 27 of the Act. The Forum was directed to decide the application within three months from the date of the appearance of the parties before it. The parties were directed to appear before the Forum on 02/09/2015.
5. Accordingly the parties appeared before the Forum on 02/09/2015. The Forum directed the Complainants to take steps. On 08/09/2015 the Complainants filed a fresh application under Section 27 of the Act. On 10/09/2015 6the accused persons filed reply. The Forum then issued Show Cause Notice to the accused persons and fixed the matter for reply. On 22/09/2015 the accused persons again filed a reply to the show cause notice. The Forum again fixed the matter for compliance of the order of the Honble National Commission. On 29/09/2015 summons to the accused persons in Form No. 1 of schedule II of Cr. P.C. was served on both the accused persons. On 01/10/2015 the Forum explained the substance of accusation to the accused persons in the same words as was earlier done on 27/08/2015. Thereafter, the Forum fixed the matter for filing affidavit-in-evidence by the Complainants. The Complainant No. 1 filed his affidavit- in-evidence on 08/10/2015. He was cross examined on 27/10/2015. Thereafter on 03/11/2015 statement only of the accused No. 2 under Section 313 of Cr. P. C. was recorded. On 05/11/2015 the accused No. 1 filed affidavit-in-evidence as directed by the Forum and the said accused was cross examined on 14/11/2015. The Forum heard arguments and by order dated 21/01/2016 held that the accused persons were guilty of committing the offence of failing to comply with the order dated 05/05/2010 passed by the Forum and sentenced the accused persons to undergo simple imprisonment of nine months and to pay a sum of Rs. 5000/- each to the Complainants as compensation in default to undergo simple imprisonment for a period of another 15 days.
6. The said Order dated 21/01/2016 of the Forum was challenged by the accused persons by filing FA No. 09/2016 before this Commission and this Commission quashed and set aside the Order dated 21/01/2016 of the Forum and directed the Forum to decide the said 7application under Section 27 of the Act afresh after strictly complying with the procedure prescribed in Cr. P. C. for trial of summons cases. The Forum was directed to frame and explain the substance of accusation to the accused persons properly by mentioning the particulars of offence preferably as mentioned in the summons and to record pleas of both the accused persons. It was further directed that if accused persons plead not guilty, the Forum should proceed to examine the Complainant/s and their witnesses, if any, orally and not by way affidavits and then to permit the accused persons to cross examine them. Thereafter, the Forum was directed to examine the accused persons under Section 313 of the Cr. P. C. and then to take evidence of the accused persons and their witnesses, if any, orally and not by way of affidavit-in-evidence and permit the Complainants to cross examine them and thereafter hearing both the parties to pass fresh order in accordance with law.
7. It appears that the said application under Section 27 of the Act was then registered by the Forum as CRC/05/2017. Thereafter, on 28/04/2016, the Forum again explained detail substance of accusation to the accused persons. The accused persons pleaded not guilty. The deposition of the Complainant No. 1 was recorded. He was duly cross-examined The statement of both the accused persons, under Section 313 of Cr. P. C., were recorded. Both the accused persons examined themselves and they were also cross-examined. Additional statement of the accused persons under Section 313 of Cr. P.C. were recorded. After hearing the final arguments, the Forum passed the impugned order. The accused persons have been held guilty of the offence under Section 27 of the Act. 8The accused persons have been convicted for not paying the amount due with interest as per Order dated 05/05/2010 and sentenced to pay fine of Rs. 10,000/- in default to undergo simple imprisonment for 15 days. The accused persons have been convicted for not delivering the possession of the flat No. S-1 of the Complainants and have been sentenced to undergo imprisonment of 6 months. The accused Nos. 1 and 2 have been convicted for not obtaining certificates from the concerned authorities and have been sentenced to pay fine of Rs. 10,000/- each in default to undergo simple imprisonment for 15 days. Lastly, the accused persons have been convicted for not executing sale deed in favour of the Complainants and have been sentenced to pay fine of Rs. 10,000/- each in default to undergo simple imprisonment of 15 days. The accused persons are aggrieved by the impugned Judgment and Order and have filed the present Appeal under Section 27A of the Act.
8. Records and proceedings of CRC No. 05/2017 have been called for. Heard arguments. Mr. Mahambrey, Lr. Counsel, argued on behalf of the Accused persons whereas Mr. Almeida, Lr. Counsel, argued on behalf of the Complainants.
9. The Lr. Counsel for the accused persons submitted that the operative parts of the impugned Order in Clauses (b), (c) and (d) are in relation to the shop No. S-1 and the accused persons are no longer the owners of the said shop since by sale deed dated 09/10/2007, the said shop has been sold. The Lr. Counsel pointed out to the certificate of recovery under Section 25 of the Act issued by the Mamlatdar of Salcete wherein it has been specifically 9stated that due process was initiated to attach the said flat and shops but it was found that the said flat and 5 shops were already sold to different parties. In such circumstances, the Lr. Counsel for the Accused persons submitted that delivery of possession of the shop and obtaining certificates from concerned authorities and executing sale deed in favour of the Complainants was not at all possible and therefore the accused persons could not have been penalized for what they could have never done. He further argued that the accused persons have no means to pay to the Complainants and therefore they could not have been penalized. According to the Ld. Counsel for the accused persons, the Forum erred in inflicting imprisonment and fine without establishment of mens rea and wilfull disobedience of the Order. He further submitted that the accused No. 2 is a woman and woman cannot be arrested and detained in prison. He relied upon Section 56 of CPC. Lr. Counsel for the Complainants relied upon the following Judgments.
(i) Jancy Joseph V/s. Union of India, reported in 1998 Law Suit (KER) 239.
(ii) Jolly George Varghese V/s. Bank of Cochin, reported in1980 Law Suit (SC) 51.
(iii) Oral Order dated 14/10/2009 of Maharashtra State Commission in Revision Petition No. 79/2008 (M/s. Chandrasavitri Developers & Builders and another V/s. Kumari Vanmala Aatmaram Badhe.
10. On the other hand Mr. Almeida, Lr. Counsel for the Complainants submitted that all the points which have been now raised by the Counsel for the accused persons were earlier raised before this State Commission and the Hon'ble National Commission and all have been decided and only because the procedure was not properly followed the matter was remanded back. He therefore submitted that there is absolutely no merit in the Appeal and the same should be dismissed.
11. We have gone through the entire material on record.
12. This time it is not the grievance of the accused persons that proper procedure prescribed by law has not been followed by the Forum. Even otherwise records reveal that required procedure has been duly followed. We have narrated the said procedure in paragraph 5 above.
13. It is very sad to note that the Complainants have a final Order in their favour passed on 05/05/2010 in a Consumer Complaint and now even after about nine years, they cannot enjoy the fruits of the said Order.
14. A perusal of the Order dated 24/10/2014 passed by this Commission (Quorum: Shri Justice N. A. Britto, President and Smt. Vidhya R. Gurav, Member) in FA No. 71/2014 reveals that there is truth in the contention of the Ld. Counsel for the Complainants that almost all the points now raised by the Ld. Counsel for the accused persons were raised in the above appeal and were duly answered. In the Execution Revision Petition No. 86/2014, the Hon'ble National Commission did not set aside the said Order dated 24/10/2014 by holding that the said objections raised by the accused persons were good but set aside the Order on the ground that the Forum did not follow the procedure prescribed in the Cr. P. C. for trial of summons cases in its entirety. Nothing new has been argued by the Ld. Counsel for the accused persons in this appeal and hence the question of changing the findings given in Appeal No. 71/2014, by this commission, does not arise.
15. The accused persons have produced the sale deed dated 09/10/2007 by which they have sold the shop No. S-
1 on the ground floor (which is the subject matter of the order dated 05/05/2010 passed by the Forum) to one Mr. Mahesh krishnanath Raikar. The Complaint No. 12/2004 was filed by the Complainants in the year 2004. In the written version, the accused persons had only stated that they had already agreed to sell the said shop no. S-1 to some person and had taken part payment for the same from the said person. However, a miscellaneous application was filed by the Complainants on 23/07/2004 inter alia praying for interim relief and after hearing both the parties, the Forum had passed an order thereon, inter alia, temporarily restraining the accused persons from parting with the possession of the said shop no. S-1 or in any way transferring the same during the pendency of the Complaint. The said interim order was confirmed on merits by the Forum by a further order dated 13/09/2005. The said order dated 13/09/2005 was not challenged. Hence pending the Complaint, the accused persons could not have disposed of the said shop no. S-1. However, the accused persons knowingly disobeyed the said order dated 13/09/2005 and without even informing the Forum sold the said shop no. S-1 to a third person, during the pendency of the Complaint. Since the Forum was kept in darkness regarding the said sale, the final order came to be passed in the manner as it has been passed. The said final order dated 05/05/2010 has become final. When the Order dated 01/08/2014 was passed by the Forum on the application under Section 27 of the Act and even when the Order dated 24/10/2014 was passed by this Commission in FA No. 71/2014, the accused persons had not produced the sale deed of shop no. S-1 and of the other shops and the flat. In the proceedings, the accused persons had only stated vaguely that they were not the owners of the premises that are mentioned in the Order of the Forum. However, they did not specify as to who were the owners of the said shop no. S-1. They did not state as to what they had done with the said shop and when. They did not even disclose that they had already sold that shop to some third party. The inference drawn by this Commission (Quorum: Shri Justice N. A. Britto, President and Smt. Vidhya R. Gurav, Member), on account of the said non-disclosure, in the Order dated 24/10/2014 in FA No. 71/2014, was that the accused persons either have the possession of the said shop with them or they have sold the same to someone else for a higher price thereby depriving the Complainants of the same under the said agreement dated 05/07/2001. Only in the fresh deposition of the accused no. 2 recorded on 07/03/2017, the said sale deed dated 09/10/2007 in respect of the shop no. S-1 and other sale deeds were produced. The above clearly shows the attitude of the accused persons to keep the Forum in darkness till it is possible. We are unable to set aside the impugned Judgment and order on the ground that the accused persons could not have been penalized for what they could have never done since the shop no. S-1 was already sold and hence the delivery of possession of the said shop and obtaining certificates from concerned authorities and executing sale deed in favour of the Complainants was not at all possible. The said sale effected by the accused persons was also in disobedience of the order dated 13/09/2005 passed by the Forum.
16. It is true that the accused no. 2 who has been convicted, inter alia, to undergo imprisonment is a woman. In the case of "Jancy Joseph" (supra), the High Court of Kerala, following the decision of the Division Bench of the Madras High Court in the case of "Registrar, University of Madras Vs. Union of India, 1996 CCJ 668, has held that when the Forum is executing an order for recovery of money, it cannot order the arrest of a woman for recovery of the amount. The Kerala High Court has observed that Sections 56 and 58 of the Code of Civil Procedure becomes relevant. Under Section 56 CPC "notwithstanding anything in this Part, the Court shall not order the arrest or detention in the civil prison of a woman in execution of a decree for payment of money." The above decision of the Kerala High Court is dated13/11/1998, which is before amendment of Sections 25 and 27 of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 (the 'Act', for short). At that time the final order of a Forum was executable in the same manner as if it were a decree or order made by a Court in a suit pending therein. In the event of its inability to execute the order/decree, the Forum could send the same for execution to the Court within the legal limits of whose jurisdiction the person, against whom it was made, resided or carried on business or personally worked for gain. The Kerala High Court therefore held that the provisions of CPC are applicable. The Kerala High Court has assumed that the provisions of CPC are made applicable even when Section
27 of the Act is invoked. Now with effect from 15/03/2003, the things have changed. Sections 25 and 27 of the Act have been amended. Now, Section 25 does not say that the order of the Forum is executable in the same manner as if it were a decree or order made by a Court in a suit pending therein.
17. Be that as it may, Section 27(1) of the Act, inter alia, provides that when a person against whom the complaint is made fails or omits to comply with any order made by the Forum, such person shall be punishable with imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than one month but which may extend to 3 years or with fine which shall not be less than Rs. 2,000/- but which may extend to Rs. 10,000/- or both. Sub-section (2) of Section 27 of the Act, inter alia, gives the Forum the powers of a Judicial Magistrate of the First Class for the trial of offences under the Act. The Forum is deemed to be a judicial Magistrate of the First Class for the purpose of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. In the present case, we are not concerned with the arrest of the accused no. 2 in the execution proceedings. She has been held guilty, convicted and sentenced, inter alia to undergo imprisonment in Criminal proceedings bearing No. CRC No. 05/2017. Section 27 of the Act makes disobedience of an order of the Forum a criminally offence which can be punished with imprisonment or fine or both. The proceedings under Section 27 of the Act are criminal in nature. In the case of "Ravi Kant Vs. National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission", reported in AIR 1997 Delhi 182, the High Court of Delhi, by judgment dated 27/01/1997, has observed thus: "In fact, Section 27 of the Act has created a statutory offence the non-compliance of an order of a duly constituted Tribunal under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 - and has made the said non-compliance an offence punishable with simple imprisonment or fine. A statute can create a Tribunal and might say that non- compliance with the orders of the Tribunal is an offence and is punishable by the way of imprisonment or fine (as in Section 27) and this penal provision can be in addition to any other mode of recovery (as in Section 25). as a civil court and may also permit arrest under Section
51 and Order 25 Rule 37 as a mode of recovery. But under Section 25 no statutory offence is created; while under Section 27 a separate offence is created if Section 25 order is not implemented."
18. There can be no distinction made whether the person disobeying is a man or woman. In the case of "Radhika Purushothaman and Anr. V/s. Kala Manivannan and Anr.", reported in [1999 Law Suit (Mad)] 405 or [1997 (97) Comcas 782], the High Court of Madras has observed as under: "..... In Vikmans V. Rakesh Kumar, 1992 1 CPR 287, the State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission at Delhi has observed that the proceedings under Section 27 of the Consumer Protection Act are criminal in nature. A plain reading of the section itself would show that the section is punitive. It mentions penalty in the form of imprisonment and levy of fine. Therefore, when it comes to criminal proceedings, it cannot be said that the Criminal Procedure Code differentiates between a man and woman as done under Section 56 of the Civil Procedure Code. A person whether man or woman is liable for punishment for violation of the order passed by the forum. Therefore, the principles of the Civil Procedure Code cannot be applied to the punitive provision of the Consumer Protection Act." we are therefore of the view that the Forum has not committed any illegality by convicting the accused No. 2 with imprisonment.
19. Last contention of the Ld. Counsel for the accused persons is that the Forum erred in not placing reliance on the report of the Mamlatdar and considering the fact that the accused persons have no means to pay the decretal amount and that there is no mens rea and wilfull disobedience. The Honble Supreme Court, in the case of Jolly George Varghese (supra), has held that in the absence of some vice or mens rea, on the part of the judgment debtor, detention on mere failure to pay the debt is not called for. The Apex Court has observed that where the judgment debtor if once had the means to pay the debt but subsequently after the date of decree has no means to pay or where he has money on which there are other pressing claims, it will be violative of Article 21 of the Constitution and Article 11 of the International Convention on Civil and Political Rights Act, to arrest and detain him in the jail so as to coerce him into payment. The Honble Supreme Court has further observed that what is required is not mere omission to pay but attitude of refusal as demanded verging on dishonest disowning of the obligation. In the Oral Order dated 14/10/2009 of Maharashtra State Commission in Revision Petition No. 79/2008 (supra), the same observations of the Apex Court have been followed. In the present case, in our considered view, the accused persons cannot be said to be persons having no means to pay the decretal amount. The attitude of refusal by the accused persons is verging on dishonest disowning of the obligation. In the present case, the dishonest attitude of the accused persons is clear since pending the disposal of the Complaint and in spite of there being an Order against them not to part with the possession of the said shop S-1 to any third party or transfer the same, the accused persons clandestinely sold the said shop S-1 ot one Mahesh Raikar and further kept even the Forum in darkness about the same, till the same was disclosed belatedly in the proceedings under Section
27 of the Act. The accused persons have sold a flat and five shops to different persons between the year 2003 to to the year 2013 (after the filing of the Complaint) and still they claim that they have no means to pay the decretal amount. All the sale deed are on record. The accused persons went to the extent of saying that they were not aware of the Order dted 05/05/2010 passed by the Forum. The Forum has dealt with this point and it cannot at all be believed that they were not aware of the said Order. Admittedly, the accused persons got lot of money from the sale of the said premises. According to the accused persons the proceeds of the said sales were utilized for construction of the building and repayment of the loan taken for construction. It was for the accused persons to prove that all the money which they got from the sale of the said flat and five shops was spent for the construction and repayment of the loan. A show cause notice was issued to the accused persons as to why the proceedings under Section 27 of the Act should not be initiated against them. before explaining the substance of accusation to them. In reply to that, the accused persons, inter alia, simply stated that they have no means to pay the decretal amount and that the accused No. 2 being a woman cannot be arrested and detained and that the disobedience is not wilfull. After holding the accused persons guilty of the offence under Section 27 of the Act, they were duly heard on the point of sentence and the Forum has duly considered all the contentions of the accused persons. The Forum has observed that the accused persons have not produced any accounts of the income earned from or expenses incurred on the said construction and hence it cannot be believed that the accused persons are financially broke. Mere statement on oath cannot be taken as sufficient evidence. If such oral statements are allowed, all accused persons, in other cases, will say like that and the cases will have to be dismissed. The mens rea and wilfull dishonest attitude of the accused persons is clearly established, as has been held by the Forum. It is duly proved that though the accused persons have means to pay they have deliberately and wilfully disobeyed the Order.
20. The impugned Judgment holding the accused persons guilty of the offence under Section 27 of the Act and the Order convicting and sentencing them in the manner as done is in accordance with the settled principles of law. No interference with the same is called for.
21. Hence, we pass the following: ORDER The appeal is rejected. The accused persons shall surrender before the Forum within 30 days from today to comply with the Order failing which the Forum shall take appropriate steps to secure their presence for the purpose of implementation of the Order. A copy of this Judgment and Order be sent to the Forum along with the records and proceedings. [Shri. Dhananjay A. Jog] [Justice Shri. U. V. Bakre] Member President sp/-