AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 309 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Rule 97 of the DSC Rules,
  • Rule 98 (2) of the DSC Rules
  • Rule 97 of the DSE Rules.
  • Delhi School Education Act, 1973 (DSC Act") and Delhi School Education Rules, 1973 (DSE Rules").
  • Recruitment Rules (RRs") prescribed the Directorate of Education (DoE"), 1 Government of NCT of Delhi (GNCTD")
  • Rule 43 of the DSE Rules.
  • B Post) Recruitment Rules, 2011 (2011 Rules")
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 309 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Rule 97 of the DSC Rules,
  • Rule 98 (2) of the DSC Rules
  • Rule 97 of the DSE Rules.
  • Delhi School Education Act, 1973 (DSC Act") and Delhi School Education Rules, 1973 (DSE Rules").
  • Recruitment Rules (RRs") prescribed the Directorate of Education (DoE"), 1 Government of NCT of Delhi (GNCTD")
  • Rule 43 of the DSE Rules.
  • B Post) Recruitment Rules, 2011 (2011 Rules")
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from the dismissal of the appellant's writ petition challenging the denial of age relaxation for appointment as a librarian at Respondent No.1, an aided school governed by the Directorate of Education (DoE) and relevant Delhi education laws and rules. The appellant applied for the librarian post following an advertisement in February 2008 and was selected subject to age relaxation. The Selection Committee noted that the appellant required relaxation beyond the prescribed limit under the Recruitment Rules (RRs) and relied on a 1975 Department of Education (DoE) letter granting age relaxation to teachers with prior experience.

Despite selection, the appellant did not receive an appointment letter due to the DoE's refusal to approve the age relaxation, asserting that librarians are non-teaching staff and thus not entitled to such relaxation. The appellant pursued administrative remedies and filed writ petitions challenging this refusal. The Single Judge dismissed the writ petition in December 2017, and the appellant's review petition was also dismissed in May 2018. The present appeal challenges these decisions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant is entitled to age relaxation for appointment as a librarian in Respondent No.1 school.
  2. Whether the post of librarian qualifies as a teaching post for the purpose of age relaxation under the relevant DoE circulars and clarifications.
  3. Whether the DoE's earlier refusal to grant age relaxation based on the librarian being non-teaching staff was justified in light of subsequent clarifications.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant relied on a 1975 DoE letter and a 1976 DoE decision granting age relaxation to teachers with experience in recognized schools, asserting that librarians should be included.
  • The appellant pointed to a 2009 circular and a 2011 DoE order equating librarians with teaching staff, thereby entitling them to age relaxation.
  • The appellant argued that the presence of the DoE nominee in the Selection Committee dispensed with the need for separate approval under Rule 98(2) of the Delhi School Education Rules.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The DoE maintained that the librarian post is non-teaching staff, and hence the appellant was not entitled to age relaxation under the 1975 letter.
  • The DoE relied on the Recruitment Rules notified in 2003 and subsequent government orders, contending that the 1976 letter granting age relaxation was impliedly repealed.
  • The DoE cited a decision in Raj Bala v. GNCT of Delhi to support the position that newer rules override earlier circulars granting age relaxation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Smt. Promila Dixit v Govt. of NCT of Delhi, 178 (2011) DLT 377 Grant of relief where teacher's service was utilized and prevented from joining back; age relaxation context. Distinguished on facts; relief granted in that case was not treated as precedent for the present matter.
Sachin Gupta v DSSSB (W.P.(C) No.7297/2007, decided 28.08.2008) Implied repeal of earlier age relaxation circulars by newer Recruitment Rules approved by Lt. Governor. Held not applicable here as no corresponding new rules for librarian post exist; DoE's reliance on this precedent was rejected.
Raj Bala v GNCT of Delhi (W.P.(C) 7240/2017, decided 23.08.2017) Whether rules made under proviso to Article 309 override previous notifications granting age relaxation. Held that since no such new rules exist for librarian post, earlier circulars were not impliedly repealed; precedent distinguished.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined whether the appellant was entitled to age relaxation for appointment as librarian, focusing on the classification of the librarian post as teaching or non-teaching. It noted that the DoE had initially denied approval for age relaxation relying on the post being non-teaching and on the 1976 letter granting relaxation only to teachers. However, subsequent clarifications, including a 2009 circular equating pay scales of librarians with teachers and a 2011 DoE order declaring the librarian post as a teaching post for all purposes (prospectively), undermined the DoE's earlier stance.

The Court found that the refusal to grant relaxation based on the librarian's non-teaching status no longer survived after the 2011 clarification. It also observed that the post of librarian in other government schools, such as Kendriya Vidyalayas, is considered a teaching post, supporting the appellant's claim.

The Court rejected the DoE's reliance on precedents concerning other posts with specific new Recruitment Rules, as no such rules existed for the librarian post that would impliedly repeal the earlier relaxation orders.

Given that the appellant had relevant prior experience exceeding the period of relaxation sought, and the post remained vacant, the Court held that the DoE was obliged to grant the age relaxation approval.

Holding and Implications

The Court set aside the impugned decisions of the DoE dated 23rd October 2008, 2nd July 2009, and 6th February 2010 which declined approval for age relaxation in the appellant's case.

The DoE was directed to issue a formal letter approving the age relaxation to enable the appellant to join as librarian on or before 15th April 2019. The appellant's appointment date will be deemed as 15th April 2019 without entitlement to arrears of pay but with all other benefits.

The appeal was allowed with no order as to costs. No new precedent was established beyond the direct effect on the parties.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Bal Raj Parashar v. Union Academy Senior Secondary School And Others

    $~ * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

    2

    + LPA 502/2018

    BAL RAJ PARASHAR ..... Appellant Through: Mr. R.K. Saini with Mr M.N. Dudeja, Advocates.

    versus

    UNION ACADEMY SENIOR SECONDARY

    SCHOOL AND ORS. ..... Respondents

    Through: Ms. Vibha Mahajan Seth, Advocate for R-3 and 4.

    Mr T.R. Verma, OSD (Zone-26),

    DOE, GNCTD.

    CORAM:

    JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR

    JUSTICE I.S.MEHTA

    O R D E R

    % 04.04.2019 Dr. S. Muralidhar, J.:

    1.This appeal is directed against the judgment dated 4thDecember, 2017 passed by the learned Single Judge dismissing the Appellant"s writ petition being W.P.(C) No.2272/2012 as well as the order dated 8thMay, 2018 whereby the Review Petition No. 194/2018 filed by the Appellant seeking review of the judgment dated 4thDecember, 2017 was dismissed.

    2. The background facts are that by an advertisement published on 20th February, 2008, the Respondent No.1 school invited applications for the post of librarian. The Respondent No.1 is an aided school and is governed by the Recruitment Rules („RRs") prescribed the Directorate of Education („DoE"),

    1

    Government of NCT of Delhi („GNCTD") and further governed by the Delhi School Education Act, 1973 („DSC Act") and Delhi School Education Rules, 1973 („DSE Rules").

    3. The Appellant applied for the said post and vide letter dated 8thApril 2008 the Appellant was called to appear before the Selection Committee for an interview on 15thApril, 2008. The Selection Committee selected the Appellant for the said post. The minutes of the Selection Committee stated, as far as the Appellant is concerned, states that the Appellant was selected for the said post "subject to relaxation of age under the order of Minister of Education vide DO Letter No. F.44-7/75/UTI dated 29thOctober 1975".

    4. The Selection Committee made the above noting for the reasons that under the RRs for the post of librarian at the relevant point in timeas per Recruitment Rules notified vide Notification DE.4(19)/3/E-IV/99- Edn./12255-269 dated 16.01.2003, the age limit for direct recruits was 30 years. This was relaxable up to five years for government servants in accordance with the instructions issued by the Central Government. The Appellant was 36 years 10 months and 12 days on the date of his selection and he needed relaxation for a period of 6 years 10 months and 12 days. He had a previous experience as a librarian from 3rdJune, 1998 to 30thApril, 2005 at the Nalanda Modern Public School at Burari, Delhi. On the basis of a DO letter dated 29thOctober, 1975 as noted by the DoE in its letter dated 3rd May, 1976, the Appellant claimed that he was entitled for grant of relaxation in age in view of the aforementioned service already rendered by him as a librarian.

    2

    5. It must be noticed at this stage that the said letter dated 29thOctober, 1975, granted relaxation in age to teachers i.e. "persons who have experience in recognized schools". The DoE by the letter dated 3rdMay 1976 decided to extend the benefit of age relaxation to teachers of all recognized schools, whether aided or not.

    6. As far as the present case is concerned, the Respondent No.1 School decided to seek the approval of the DoE in terms of the Rule 97 of the DSC Rules, which reads as under:

    "97. Relaxation to be made with the approval of the director— Where the relaxation of any essential qualification for the recruitment of any employee is recommended by the appropriate selection committee, the managing committee of the school shall not give effect to such recommendation unless such recommendation has been previously approved by the Director."

    7. However, when the Appellant inquired from the Respondent No. 1 school as to why he had not been issued the appointment letter, they drew his attention to Rule 98 (2) of the DSC Rules which reads as under:

    " 98 (2) Every appointment made by the managing committee of an aided school shall, initially, be provisional and shall require the approval of the Director;

    Provided that the approval of the Director will be required only where Director's nominee was not present in the Selection Committee/DPC or in case there is difference of opinion among the members of the Selection Committee :

    Provided further that the provision of this sub-rule shall not apply to a minority aided school."

    3

    8. According to the Appellant, the first proviso to Rule 98 (2) dispenses with such approval where the representative of the Director is present at the meeting. It is pointed out that in this case in the Selection Committee the DoE"s nominee, viz., the Education Officer, Zone-11 was present.

    9. With no appointment letter forthcoming, the Appellant on 10thNovember, 2008 wrote to the DoE drawing its attention to the DO letter 29thOctober, 1975 and the DoE"s own letter dated 3rdMay, 1976, granting the relaxation in age. When no response was received the Appellant served legal notice dated 15thDecember 2008 on the DOE and the Deputy Director of Education. In response to the legal notice, the Deputy Director of Education (Respondent No.4), by letter dated 2ndJanuary, 2009 informed the Appellant that his case was under consideration of the Competent Authority on priority basis and the result would be communicated when the decision is received.

    10. When despite best efforts no replies were received, the Appellant filed W.P.(C) No.479/2011, which was heard by this Court on 25thJanuary, 2011. Learned counsel appearing for the DoE, on advance notice, informed the Court that the matter of grant of age relaxation to the Appellant was still pending under consideration before the Competent Authority. The Court then disposed of the said writ petition directing the Respondents to take a decision in the matter within four weeks.

    11. In compliance with the said order, the DoE issued an order dated 11th February, 2011 stating that the case of the Appellant had already been considered and rejected and conveyed to the school authorities by letter dated

    4

    23rdOctober, 2008. In this letter addressed to the School, it was stated that the case of the Appellant had already been examined in light of the order dated 3rdMay, 1976 and it was decided that he was not covered thereunder because a librarian was treated as „non-teaching staff". This was reiterated by the letters dated 2ndJuly, 2009 and 6thFebruary, 2010, copies of which have now emerged by way of enclosures to the order dated 11thFebruary, 2011. It appears that for some reasons these letters were not available with the Respondent No.1 and, in any event, not conveyed to the Appellant.

    12. In view of the above rejection of the request of the Respondent No.1 school, for approval of the selection of the Appellant by relaxing the age requirement, the Appellant again filed, for the second time, by filing W.P.(C) No.2272/2012.

    Impugned order of the Single Judge

    13. The said petition was finally heard on 4thDecember, 2017 and dismissed by the learned Single Judge holding that the case of the Appellant had to be considered under Rule 97 and not 98 of the DSE Rules and, therefore, the Appellant"s plea that there had to be a deemed approval cannot be accepted. It was further held that an office order dated 21stJanuary, 2011 issued by the DoE clarifying that librarians have been equated with teachers cannot be given retrospective effect since the recommendations to appoint the Appellant were of the year 2008.

    14. As regards a circular dated 20thJanuary, 2009, equating the pay scales of teachers and librarians, the learned Single Judge held that the said circular

    5

    would not justify grant of age relaxation, which is an essential qualification/condition. The decision of this Court in of Smt. Promila Dixit v Govt. of NCT of Delhi 178 (2011) DLT 377 relied upon by the Appellant was held to be distinguishable on facts. It was held that in that case, the services of the teacher had already been utilized by the school for one and a half years and she was not allowed to join back. Relief was granted by the Court to that teacher, clarifying that it would not be treated as a precedent.

    Additional affidavit of the DoE

    15. During the pendency of the present appeal, the DoE has filed an additional affidavit placing on record the government orders, gazette notifications and relevant extracts from the OMs. The stand taken by the Respondents in the said affidavit is that in view of the RRs approved by the Lt. Governor of Delhi by notification dated 14thAugust, 1986, circulated on 27thOctober, 1993 and a subsequent notification on 16thJanuary, 2003, "The said notification of 3rdMay, 1976, stands impliedly repealed". Reliance is also placed on the decision dated 28thAugust, 2008 of this Court in W.P.(C) No.7297/2007 (Sachin Gupta v DSSSB) which was upheld by the Division Bench of this Court in its decision dated 23rdAugust, 2017 in W.P(C) 7240/2017 ( stRaj Bala v GNCT of Delhi) where a similar circular dated 1 November, 1980 granting relaxation to women as regards the upper age limit was held to have been impliedly repealed.

    16. This Court has heard the submissions of Mr. R.K. Saini, learned counsel appearing for the Appellant and Ms. Vibha Mahajan Seth, learned counsel appearing for the DoE.

    6

    Analysis and reasons

    17. The short question to be addressed in the present case is whether the Appellant is entitled to age relaxation for being appointed as librarian of the Respondent No.1 school. At the outset, the Court inquired and informed that the said post continues to remain vacant. Further, the Respondent No.1 school has not expressed any opposition to the prayer of the Appellant. Being an aided school, it is essentially the decision of the DoE in this regard that matters.

    18. The further question is whether the stand taken by the DoE in the present case, as conveyed by its letters dated 23rdOctober, 2008, 2ndJuly, 2009 and 6thFebruary, 2010, viz., that "since the librarian is a non-teaching staff" and was, therefore, not entitled to relaxation in terms of the letter dated 29th October, 1975, notified by the DoE on 3rdMay, 1976 was correct?

    19. In support of his plea that the librarians have been equated with teaching staff, reliance has been placed by the Appellant on the circular dated 28th January, 2009 which issued a clarification regarding „miscellaneous categories of teachers" The said clarification reads as under:

    "These- pay scales are applicable to misc./allied category of .teachers i.e. music teacher, drawing teacher, art teacher, craft teacher, vocational guidance instructors, PETs, Language teachers, Librarians or equivalent teaching post carrying any other designation. The scale of pay in respect of all these categories is equated to one or the other category of teachers. The parity will be retained and these teachers will be granted the appropriate pay scale keeping in view the parity that already exists." (emphasis supplied)

    20. It does appear from the above clarification that the clarification has been

    7

    issued in terms of an OM dated 3rdNovember, 1987 issued by the Ministry of Human Resources Development.

    21. A reference has also been made to the order dated 21stJanuary, 2011, issued by the DoE itself clarifying as under:

    "The post of Librarian in Govt. School of Directorate Of Education, Govt. of NCT of Delhi is hereby declared as teaching post for all purpose with immediate effect and accordingly the Librarians shall avail all-benefits applicable to teaching category in prospective manner only. It is further ordered that the Librarians-shall take classes also besides the work of Library as and when required by concerned HOS/any Other higher authority.

    This issues with the prior approval of Director of Education."

    22. The above clarification by the DoE is consistent with the practice followed in many other schools including the Kendiya Vidyalayas („KVs"), as is evident from the response given to the Appellant on 13thOctober, 2012 by the Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan (HQ) under the RTI Act. In the KVs, the post of librarian is a teaching post.

    23. It would be recalled that the only ground on which the DoE declined the relaxation of age in the case of the Appellant was that the post of librarian was a non-teaching post. The stand taken by the Respondents was never that on account of the RRs, all the earlier instructions and circulars stood impliedly superseded.

    24. The issue in Raj Bala v. GNCT of Delhi (supra) concerned the Rule 43 of the DSE Rules and whether the rules made under the proviso to the

    8

    Article 309 of the Constitution of India, namely, the Directorate of Education, Physical Education of Teachers (Group B Post) Recruitment Rules, 2011 („2011 Rules") would override all the notifications and instructions issued by the Lt. Governor under Rule 43 of the DSE Rules. It was held that since the 2011 Rules had been passed by the LG himself, in exercise of the powers conferred by the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of India, an earlier notification granting age relaxation to women (PET) by a notification dated 1stNovember, 1980, did not survive.

    25. The present case does not deal with the PETs at all. There is no corresponding set of Rules, like the 2011 Rules made under the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of India. Therefore, the recourse by the DoE to the aforementioned judgment, which in turn refers to the earlier decision in Sachin Gupta v DSSSB (supra) is to no avail.

    26. In the present case, the question is whether the DoE was justified in declining approval for the relaxation of age in exercise of the powers under Rule 97 of the DSE Rules. The occasion to exercise that power arises only where the RRs otherwise do not provide for age relaxation. In the present case, the age relaxation provided by the RRs was only in respect of the government servants and only to the extent of 5 years. It is only where a case is not covered by the existing RRs, like the present Appellant, that it becomes necessary for a selection committee to seek the approval of the DoE under Rule 97 of the DSE Rules. The power exercised thereunder has to be obviously on a case to case basis. Several factors have to be taken into account in granting such relaxation.

    9

    27. The letter dated 26thOctober, 1975, which is relied upon by the Appellant, was indeed examined by the DoE and it was not applied because the post of a librarian is a non-teaching post. If the clarification like the one now issued in 2011 by the DoE that the post of librarian is equivalent to teaching post, had been issued at the relevant time, clearly then DoE would have granted the approval for relaxation of age in the case of the Appellant. There is no other plausible ground based on which the benefit of relaxation of age could have been refused to the Appellant.

    28. That ground no longer survives after the clarification issued by the DoE itself in January, 2011. This is consistent with the equation of pay scales of the teaching staff and the librarian by the circular of 2009, which in turn refers to an earlier circular of 1987 of the HRD. Therefore, it appears that in government schools generally, the post of librarian was considered to be a teaching staff. It is only that as far as the DoE is concerned, it clarified this position in 2011.

    29. In the instant case, with the post of librarian in the Respondent No.1 school, which is an aided school, remained unfilled, what is to really be seen whether at the time of the Appellant being appointed to that post, he suffered from any disqualification as such. The Court is of the view that with the position that a librarian is equivalent to a teaching post having been made clear, the only hurdle in the way of the Appellant being granted the benefit of age relaxation, no longer survives. There should be no difficulty, therefore with the DoE agreeing to relax the age in the case of the Appellant, particularly since he has previous experience as librarian for a period which

    10

    is greater than the period of relaxation being sought.

    30. For all of the aforementioned reasons, this Court sets aside the impugned decisions of the DoE dated 23rdOctober 2008, 2ndJuly 2009 and 6th February 2010 declining approval to for age relaxation in the case of the Appellant. The DoE will now issue, in terms of the present judgment, a formal letter to the Respondent No.1 conveying its approval to the age relaxation in the case of the Appellant to enable him to join the post of librarian in the Respondent No.1, on or before 15thApril, 2019.

    31. The impugned judgment of the learned Single Judge is accordingly set aside. It is clarified that the Appellant will report for duty as librarian in the Respondent No.1 school on 15thApril, 2019 and function as a librarian from that date. While the Appellant will not be entitled to any arrears of pay, for all other purposes, his date of appointment as librarian in the Respondent No.1 school will be 15thApril, 2019.

    32. The appeal is allowed in the above terms but, in the circumstances, with no order as to costs.

    S. MURALIDHAR, J.

    I.S. MEHTA, J.

    APRIL 04, 2019

    rd

    11

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bal Raj Parashar v. Union Academy Senior Secondary School And Others
    (Apr 4, 2019)