PER ABRAHAM P. GEORGE, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER : These three appeals of the Revenue assail the orders of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-V, Chennai, deleting penalty levied on the assessee under Section 271D of Income-tax Act, 1961
I.T.A. Nos. 1446 to 1448/Mds/09 2 (in short the Act) of the amounts ` 32,55,000/-, ` 32,09,000/- and ` 76,56,980/- for the respective assessment years.
2. Short facts apropos are that assessee had accepted share application money in cash from various persons during the relevant previous years. Assessing Officer was of the opinion that such money received took the character of deposits, relying on the decision of Hon'ble Jharkhand High Court in the case of Bhalotia Engineering Works P. Ltd. v. CIT (275 ITR 399). Therefore, according to him, there was a violation of Section 269SS of the Act. Assessee was put on notice in this regard. Assessee relying on the decision of Hon'ble jurisdictional High Court in the case of Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Idhayam Publications Ltd. (285 ITR 221),submitted that it was a private limited company registered under Companies Act,1956 and money accepted towards share application pending allotment was not a deposit under Rule 2(b)(vii) of the Companies(Acceptance of Deposit) Rules, 1975. As per the assessee, for taking the view that money received from Directors / shareholders could not be considered as deposits, Hon'ble jurisdictional High Court, in the case of Idhayam Publications Ltd. (supra) had relied on the above mentioned rules. Reliance
I.T.A. Nos. 1446 to 1448/Mds/09 3 was also placed on a host of other decisions in support of its contention. Assessee further argued before the A.O. that shares were indeed allotted to all the persons eventually, and Form No.2 under the Companies Act, 1956 being the return on share allotment, was filed with Registrar of Companies. Assessee also endeavoured to differentiate its case with that of the facts in the case of Bhalotia Engineering Works P. Ltd. (supra) of Hon'ble Jharkhand High Court.
3. However, the A.O. was not appreciative of the above contentions. According to him, cash received by the assessee against share applications were not from any existing shareholders since first allotment of 8,37,064 shares was done by the assessee on 31st March, 2002. Hence, according to A.O., money received by the assessee from various persons prior to 31st March, 2002 could never be considered as equivalent to money received from existing shareholders. Therefore, according to him, assessees case was well distinguishable from the facts in the case of Idhayam Publications Ltd. (supra) of the Hon'ble jurisdictional High Court, since there the money received by the said company was from director-cum- shareholder, through a running current account. As per the A.O., the
I.T.A. Nos. 1446 to 1448/Mds/09 4 facts of assessees case were more in tandem with that of the decision of Bhalotia Engineering Works P. Ltd. (supra) by Hon'ble Jharkhand High Court. He thus came to a conclusion that what was received by the assessee was nothing but deposits and there was violation of Section 269SS of the Act the money having been received in cash. Insofar as assessment years 2003-04 and 2004-05 were concerned, the A.O. also cited a reason that assessee could not prove the amounts received to be deposits falling under Rule 2(b)(ix) of Companies (Acceptance of Deposit) Rules, 1975 since there were no declarations furnished from the concerned persons, that the amounts given by them were not out of any borrowings or sums accepted from any other persons. As per the A.O., in none of these decision relied on by the assessee, a issue regarding character of share application money was adjudicated. Thus he held that there was violation of Section 269SS of the Act in all the years and penalty was levied under Section 271D of the Act.
4. In its appeal before ld. CIT(Appeals), argument of the assessee was that decision of Hon'ble Jharkhand High Court in the case of Bhalotia Engineering Works P. Ltd. (supra) would not apply since
I.T.A. Nos. 1446 to 1448/Mds/09 5 there the concerned company had received share application money in excess of specified limits. According to assessee, it was for this reason their Lordship of Jharkhand High Court held that such money received in excess was nothing but deposits. As per the assessee, Hon'ble jurisdictional High Court in the case of Idhayam Publications Ltd. (supra) had accepted as proper, reliance placed on Companies (Acceptance of Deposit) Rules, 1975 for interpreting the term deposit in the context of application of Section 269SS of the Act. Reliance was further placed on the decision of Hon'ble jurisdictional High Court in the case of CIT v. Rugmini Ram Raghav Spinners Private Limited (304 ITR 417). Ld. CIT(Appeals) was appreciative of these contentions. According to him, in view of the decision of Hon'ble jurisdictional High Court in the case of Rugmini Ram Raghav Spinners Private Limited (supra), the ratio of Hon'ble Jharakhand High Court in the case of Bhalotia Engineering Works P. Ltd. (supra) could not be applied. Ld. CIT(Appeals) noted that assessee had indeed allotted shares against such applications eventually, and also not paid any interest to such applicants. Further as per ld. CIT(Appeals), assessee had a reasonable cause to believe that share application money received would not be considered as deposit
I.T.A. Nos. 1446 to 1448/Mds/09 6 and hence its explanation on these lines was also acceptable. He, therefore, deleted the levy of penalty for all the years.
5. Now before us, the learned D.R. assailing the order of ld. CIT(Appeals), submitted that assessees authorized capital for financial year 31.3.2002 and 31.3.2003 was ` 85 lakhs as clear from its balance sheet for the respective years placed at Departmental paper-book pages 3 and 8. According to him, against such authorized capital, assessee had already issued equity shares to ` 83,74,640/-. Learned D.R., therefore, submitted that share application money received after 31st March, 2002 was in excess of authorized capital which stood already almost fully subscribed and hence, such money could not be considered as share application money, but, only as deposits. Insofar as year ended 31.3.2004 was concerned, learned D.R. submitted that authorized capital stood increased to ` 2,30,00,000/- and this was nothing but a ploy adopted to wriggle out of situation, whereby penalty would be levied for accepting deposits otherwise than through account payee cheque/demand draft. Therefore, according to him, ld. CIT(Appeals) fell in error when he deleted the penalty levied when the facts of the
I.T.A. Nos. 1446 to 1448/Mds/09 7 case clearly pointed out that the money received was nothing but deposits and that too not from any existing shareholders or directors.
6. Per contra, learned A.R., strongly supporting the order of ld. CIT(Appeals), submitted that the whole of the share application money was converted to share capital. By the year ended 31.3.2004, there was no share application money pending allotment. For this he relied on balance sheet of the company as on 31st March, 2004 placed at paper-book page 13 of the Department. Further, according to him, Hon'ble jurisdictional High Court in the case of Rugmini Ram Raghav Spinners Private Limited (supra) had clearly held that share application money retained by a company was neither deposit nor loan and hence, provisions of Section 269SS and Section 269T of the Act would have no application. Further reliance was also placed on the decision of Hon'ble Punjab and Haryana High Court in the case of CIT v. Speedways Rubber (P) Ltd. (326 ITR 31).
7. We have perused the orders and heard the rival contentions. Copies of final accounts placed before us by learned D.R. show that the authorized capital of the assessee-company as on 31.3.2002 and 31.3.2003 (paper-book pages 3 and 8) stood at ` 85 lakhs. The
I.T.A. Nos. 1446 to 1448/Mds/09 8 issued, subscribed and paid up capital as on these days stood at ` 83,76,640/-. Nevertheless, by the year ended 31.3.2004 (paper-book page 13), the authorized capital had increased to ` 2,30,00,000/- and the issued, subscribed and paid up capital gone up to ` 2,29,97,620/-. The share application money pending allotment as per these balance sheets as on 31.03.2002 stood at ` 35,55,000, as on 31.3.2003 stood at ` 64,60,000/- and as on 31.3.2004 stood at nil. What is clear from the data is that assessee had indeed allotted shares on all the share application money received. It was not a sham transaction. Hence, the genuineness of the transaction cannot be questioned. The only question to be answered is whether by accepting such share application money in cash, any violation of Section 269SS of the Act calling for a levy of penalty under Section 271D of the Act has happened. This question can be answered if we first find whether the money received against share application is a deposit or loan amount. No doubt, the Hon'ble Jharkhand High Court in the case of Bhalotia Engineering Works P. Ltd. (supra) clearly held that share application money received had to be treated on par with deposits. Their Lordships held that amounts received as share application money till the point of allotment or refund was nothing but deposit.
I.T.A. Nos. 1446 to 1448/Mds/09 9 Para 6 of that judgement clearly brings out that in the said case also assessee concerned had eventually allotted shares to such share applicants. Here also there was no return of money to any share applicants, but, there was full allotment of shares and assessee had also filed return of allotment of shares to Registrar of Companies. Nevertheless, the share application money held for a period one to three years, could only be considered as deposits if we apply the decision of Hon'ble Jharkhand High Court in the case of Bhalotia Engineering Works P. Ltd. (supra). However, Hon'ble jurisdictional High Court in the case of Rugmini Ram Raghav Spinners Private Limited (supra), has taken a view that advance received towards allotment of shares, even if there is no stipulation regarding any time frame for refund of money, as long as such money was received without any condition regarding interest, could not be considered as deposit. Relevant paras 6 and 10 of this decision are reproduced hereunder :-
6. Heard counsel. The assessee had received cash over a period of time, as advance towards allotment of shares from 16 persons without stipulating any time frame towards return/refund of money without interest, in case of non- allotment of shares either fully or partly. In this case, the money retained by the company was neither deposit nor loan, but
I.T.A. Nos. 1446 to 1448/Mds/09 10 it is only share capital advance. Penalty under s. 271E is not automatic and to be levied only in the absence of a reasonable cause. No doubt, reasonable cause has to be established by the assessee. The rationale behind the provisions of ss. 269SS and 269T is to prevent tax evasion, i.e., the laundering of concealed income by parties in the guise of cash loans or deposits in or outside the accounts. The provision of ss. 269SS and 269T therefore, have application only in a limited way in respect of deposits or loans. When it is neither deposit nor loan, the provisions of ss. 269SS and 269T have no application at all. Even if there is repayment by cash it could not be said to attract the levy of penalty automatically, under s. 271E of the Act. The advances of share application money or repayments of such advances have not flown from any undisclosed income of the assessee or the concerned persons. It is also seen from the records that the assessee had not paid any interest at all on any of the advances repaid after quite some time. If the intention was to receive them as loans or deposits, then certainly the lenders would not have made the advance gratuitously. It is also a factual finding given by the authorities below that the assessee was not called upon to explain the default under s. 269SS on receipt of the advances in earlier years, which would show that the assessees case was not governed by the said provisions. Penalty under s. 271E is not automatic, and a bona fide belief to the effect that the receipt of advances against allotment of shares would not be termed as loans or deposits, would be sufficient to drop the penalty leviable, unless and until the material on record positively shows that money received is only a deposit or loan. There is no dispute that the impugned advances were only against allotment of shares and not by way of loans or deposits. The authorities below have given a factual finding to the effect that it is not a deposit or loan. The Tribunal, in para 3 of its order, held as under : The Departmental Representative could not bring on record any material that would go to show that the assessee in fact wanted only loan or deposit but tried to show them as share application
I.T.A. Nos. 1446 to 1448/Mds/09 11 money. Merely for the reason that some of the applications were rejected and in some of the applications the share allotments were not in full, it cannot be taken to mean that it was not share application money. Upholding the order of the CIT(A) the appeal by the Revenue is dismissed.
10. The above section provides that if the assessee proves that there is a reasonable cause, he is not subject to levy of penalty. The case of the assessee is that the amount received by the assessee is only for the purpose of allotment of shares and it is not a deposit or loan. In this case, the reasonable cause is that the assessee was under the boa find belief that the money received is only for the purpose of allotment of shares. Also, there is no material or evidence or any compelling reason produced by the Revenue to prove that the money received is a deposit or loan. The first appellate authority as well as the Tribunal have come to a correct conclusion after accepting the explanation offered by the assessee. It is a question of fact and the order of the Tribunal is not a perverse one. The concurrent finding given by both the authorities below is based on valid materials and evidence. In the case of Commissioner Of Income Tax v. P. Mohanakala (2007) 210 CTR (SC) 20 : (2007) 291 ITR 278 (SC), the Supreme Court held that whatever there is a concurrent finding by the authorities below, no interference should be called for by the High Court. Under these circumstances, we do not find any error or legal infirmity in the order of the Tribunal so as to warrant interference. Here also nothing has been brought on record by Revenue to show that share applicants had given the money as deposit, gratuitously. There is also no finding that any interest was paid by the assessee to the share applicants. No examination of any of the share applicant has been done by the Revenue to show that money received by the
I.T.A. Nos. 1446 to 1448/Mds/09 12 assessee was as a loan or deposit and not for allotment of shares. We are, therefore, of the opinion that decision of Hon'ble jurisdictional High Court in the case of Rugmini Ram Raghav Spinners Private Limited (supra) would be more appropriate for application on the facts here. Though the latter decision was given on a question regarding levy of penalty under Section 271E for violation of Section 269T, Sections 269SS and 269T are two sides of the same coin, the former governing acceptance of loan/deposits and latter governing repayment of loan/deposits. When there are two High Court decisions which are seemingly on opposite poles, one of the jurisdictional High Court has necessarily to be followed. The Revenue has not doubted the genuineness of the transaction. Assessee had a bonafide belief that share application money received was neither loans or deposits. It could always increase its authorized capital, and in any case, there is no prohibition under the Companies Act, 1956, against accepting share application for allotment of shares in excess of authorized capital. In such circumstances, we are of the opinion that the rigour of Section 269SS of the Act cannot be applied. The money received from share applicants being neither a deposit nor a loan. When rigours of
I.T.A. Nos. 1446 to 1448/Mds/09 13 Section 269SS of the Act cannot be applied, there can be no question of levy of penalty under Section 271D of the Act. Even otherwise, there was reasonable cause for the assessee in holding a bonafide belief that money accepted was nor loan or deposits. Ld. CIT(Appeals) was justified in deleting the penalty for all these years. We have no reason to interfere with the order of ld. CIT(Appeals).
8. In the result, all the three appeals filed by Revenue stand dismissed. The order was pronounced in the Court on 23rd September, 2011. sd/- sd/- (Hari Om Maratha) (Abraham P. George) Judicial Member Accountant Member Chennai, Dated the 23rd September, 2011. Kri. Copy to: (1) Appellant (2) Respondent (3) CIT(A)-V, Chennai-34 (4) CIT, Chennai-III, Chennai (5) D.R. (6) Guard file