Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act
  • Section 3(7) and Rule 8A,
  • Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act and Rule 8A of the 2007 Rules
  • Classes) Act, 1994 (for short the 1994 Act),
  • 10.07.2012), declared Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act,
  • 22.03.1994 Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act
  • Section 3(7) and Rule 8A,
  • Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act and Rule 8A of the 2007 Rules
  • Classes) Act, 1994 (for short the 1994 Act),
  • 10.07.2012), declared Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act,
  • 22.03.1994 Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion concerns a writ petition addressing the constitutional validity and applicability of reservation in promotion for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, and Other Backward Classes under the U.P. Public Services (Reservation for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes) Act, 1994 ("the 1994 Act"). Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act allowed continuation of Government Orders on reservation in promotions until modified or revoked. The Supreme Court in U.P Power Corporation v. Rajesh Kumar held Section 3(7) and Rule 8A of the 2007 Rules ultra vires, invalidating statutory sanction for such Government Orders. Subsequently, a Division Bench of this Court in Vinod Prakash Nautiyal v. State of Uttarakhand struck down Section 3(7) prospectively, prohibiting further promotions under it in Uttarakhand. A review application clarified that if the State was undertaking the necessary exercise as per Supreme Court mandates in M. Nagaraj v. Union of India, the prior order would not affect such efforts. Later, the Supreme Court in Jarnail Singh v. Lachhmi Narain Gupta revisited the principles in M. Nagaraj and Indra Sawhney v. Union of India, holding that the requirement to collect quantifiable data for reservations in promotion was invalid to the extent it conflicted with the earlier nine-Judge Bench ruling in Indra Sawhney. The State Government's decision to fill promotion posts without reservation was challenged and struck down as contrary to Supreme Court law.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Section 3(7) of the U.P. Public Services (Reservation for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes) Act, 1994, and Rule 8A of the 2007 Rules, which provided statutory sanction to Government Orders on reservation in promotions, are constitutionally valid.
  2. Whether the State Government of Uttarakhand can provide reservation in promotions without collecting quantifiable data on backwardness or representation of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, in light of the Supreme Court judgments in Indra Sawhney, M. Nagaraj, and Jarnail Singh.
  3. The validity of the Government of Uttarakhand's decision to fill promotion vacancies without reservation for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes following the Division Bench order in Vinod Prakash Nautiyal.
  4. The extent to which prior Government Orders or notifications providing reservation in promotions remain operative after the striking down of Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
U.P Power Corporation v. Rajesh Kumar (Civil Appeal No. 2608 of 2011) Held Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act and Rule 8A ultra vires as contrary to the principles in M. Nagaraj. Confirmed the invalidity of statutory sanction for reservation in promotion under Section 3(7) and Rule 8A, affecting promotions granted under those provisions.
M. Nagaraj v. Union of India (2006) 8 SCC 212 Set conditions for reservation in promotion including collection of quantifiable data on backwardness and inadequacy of representation. Supreme Court's dictum questioned the validity of Section 3(7); later clarified and partially overruled by Jarnail Singh.
Indra Sawhney v. Union of India 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217 Established foundational principles on reservation policy, including the legitimacy of reservation by Government Orders. The Court relied on this precedent to hold that reservation in promotion can be provided by Government Orders without legislative sanction.
Vinod Prakash Nautiyal v. State of Uttarakhand (Writ Petition (S/B) No. 45 of 2011) Struck down Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act prospectively in Uttarakhand, prohibiting further promotions under it. Applied the Supreme Court's ruling to Uttarakhand, making Section 3(7) non-existent for future promotions.
Jarnail Singh v. Lachhmi Narain Gupta (2018) 10 SCC 396 Clarified that the requirement of quantifiable data in M. Nagaraj was inconsistent with Indra Sawhney and thus invalid to that extent. Allowed reservation in promotion without the need for quantifiable data; influenced the Court's decision to strike down the Government's decision to exclude reservation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by acknowledging the Supreme Court's decision in U.P Power Corporation v. Rajesh Kumar which invalidated Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act and Rule 8A of the 2007 Rules as contrary to the constitutional principles laid down in M. Nagaraj. The Division Bench of this Court had accordingly struck down Section 3(7) prospectively in Uttarakhand. A review application clarified that if the State was undertaking the necessary data collection and exercise as required by M. Nagaraj, the prior order would not affect such efforts.

Subsequently, the Supreme Court in Jarnail Singh clarified that the requirement to collect quantifiable data on backwardness and representation was inconsistent with the earlier nine-Judge Bench ruling in Indra Sawhney. This rendered the data collection requirement unnecessary for providing reservation in promotions.

The Court then analyzed the Government of Uttarakhand's decision to fill promotion vacancies without reservation, as communicated by the Chief Secretary in 2012. It found this decision contrary to the Supreme Court's clarified law in Jarnail Singh and Indra Sawhney, and accordingly struck down the Government's decision.

While the Court recognized that it could not revive the struck down Section 3(7) in collateral proceedings, it emphasized that reservation in promotion may still be provided by Government Orders, as held in Indra Sawhney. Existing Government Orders or notifications providing such reservation remain valid unless challenged. Furthermore, Article 16(4-A) of the Constitution empowers the State to provide reservation in promotions without the necessity of collecting quantifiable data.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is disposed of with no costs.

The Court struck down the Government of Uttarakhand's decision to fill promotion posts without reservation for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes as contrary to Supreme Court law. It confirmed that while Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act remains struck down and cannot be revived except by appeal to the Supreme Court, reservation in promotion can continue to be provided by Government Orders or notifications in force. The State has constitutional authority under Article 16(4-A) to provide reservation in promotions without needing to collect quantifiable data on backwardness or representation. This decision directly affects the parties by invalidating the Government's exclusion of reservation in promotions but does not establish a new precedent beyond reaffirming existing Supreme Court rulings.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Gyan Chand v. State Of Uttarakhand And Others

    Ramesh Ranganathan, C.J (Oral):— Heard Sri. M.S Tyagi, learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri. Paresh Tripathi, learned Chief Standing Counsel for the State of Uttarakhand and, with their consent, this writ petition is being disposed of at the stage of admission.

    2. Reservation in promotion in favour of the Scheduled Castes, the Scheduled Tribes and the Other Backward Classes was extended by the U.P Public Services (Reservation for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes) Act, 1994 (for short ‘the 1994 Act’), which was enacted by the then U.P State Legislature on 22.03.1994 Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act stipulated that if, on the date of commencement of the Act, reservation was in force under Government Orders, for appointment to posts to be filled up by promotion, such Government Orders shall continue to be applicable till they are modified or revoked. The constitutional validity of Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act was subjected to challenge before the Allahabad High Court and, in the light of two conflicting judgments, the said controversy was resolved by the Supreme Court in U.P Power Corporation v. Rajesh Kumar (judgment in Civil Appeal No. 2608 of 2011 and batch dated 27.04.2012) holding that Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act and Rule 8A of the 2007 Rules were ultra vires as they ran counter to the dictum in M. Nagaraj v. Union of India: (2006) 8 SCC 212; and any promotion that had been given on the dictum of Indra Sawhney v. Union of India: 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217, and without the aid or assistance of Section 3(7) and Rule 8A, would remain undisturbed.

    3. Thereafter, a Division Bench of this Court, in Vinod Prakash Nautiyal v. State of Uttarakhand (judgment in Writ Petition (S/B) No. 45 of 2011 dated 10.07.2012), declared Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act, which was adopted by the State of Uttarakhand, as suffering from the same vires as was pronounced by the Supreme Court in its order in Civil Appeal No. 2608 of 2011 and batch. The Division Bench held that no further promotion could be granted; its pronouncement was prospective with effect from the date of the first interim order passed in that writ petition and connected writ petitions, as persons who had been promoted prior thereto were not before the Court. The Division Bench, however, made it clear that, henceforth, no promotion could be given by the State of Uttarakhand by taking recourse to Section 3(7) of the Act; and the said provision should be deemed to be nonexistent from that day.

    4. Thereafter an application, seeking review of the said order, was filed and a Division Bench of this Court, in its order in Review Application No. 105 of 2013 dated 01.04.2013, observed that, before the 1994 Act was made by the State of Uttarakhand, the Central Government had issued certain instructions; in terms thereof, certain reservations were available in promotion posts; by the 1994 Act, a statutory recognition was given to those instructions and, accordingly, they became enforceable in law; as those instructions were issued without carrying out the basic necessary work, required to be carried out, as pointed by the Supreme Court in M. Nagaraja, that part of the 1994 Act had been struck down by the judgment and order under review, whereby statutory blessing was given to those instructions; the review applicant had submitted that, while the writ petition was pending, the Government of Uttarakhand was carrying out the exercise, as was required to be carried out and as pointed out in M. Nagaraja, but the said aspect of the matter had not been considered by the Court; and if the State Government had carried out, or was in the process of carrying out any exercise, in terms of the mandate contained in the judgment of the Supreme Court in M. Nagaraja, the judgment and order under review did not affect the same. The Review Application was disposed of accordingly.

    5. Thereafter, in Jarnail Singh v. Lachhmi Narain Gupta: (2018) 10 SCC 396 : AIR 2018 SC 4729, the Supreme Court again examined, among others, the applicability of the earlier Constitution Bench judgment of the Supreme Court in M. Nagaraja to reservation in promotion made in favour of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes. The Constitution Bench concluded that the judgment in M. Nagaraja was not required to be referred to a seven-Judge Bench; however, the conclusion in M. Nagaraja, that the State Government was to collect quantifiable data showing backwardness of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes, being contrary to the nine-Judge Bench in Indra Sawhney, was invalid to this extent.

    6. In the light of the clarification, issued by the Constitution Bench in Jarnail Singh, and in view of the nine-Judge judgment of the Supreme Court in Indra Sawhney, it is wholly unnecessary for the State Government to collect quantifiable data regarding representation of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes in services, or regarding their backwardness, before providing reservation in their favour in promotion posts.

    7. This Court, in collateral proceeding, may not be justified in reviving a statutory provision which has been struck down by a Coordinate Division Bench, more so when the review petition, filed there against, has also been disposed of. The only recourse, to have the said judgment of the Division Bench annulled, is by carrying the matter in appeal to the Supreme Court.

    8. The Chief Secretary, Government of Uttarakhand had, by proceedings dated 05.09.2012, conveyed the decision taken by the Government that, in the light of the judgment of the Division Bench of this Court in Vinod Prkash Nautiyal, all posts/vacancies of promotion would be filled up without giving reservation to the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes, and without applying the earlier roster system of reservation in promotions. In the light of the clarification of the Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in Jarnail Singh, relying on the nine-Judge judgment in Indra Sawhney, the proceedings dated 05.09.2012, whereby the Government had decided to fill up the promotion posts/vacancies without providing reservation to the Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes, must be, and is accordingly, struck down as contrary to the law declared by the Supreme Court in Indra Sawhney and in Jarnail Singh.

    9. While we may not be justified in reviving Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act in collateral proceedings, as the earlier order of the Division Bench in Vinod Prakash Nautiyal has attained finality, suffice it to observe that, since the aforesaid judgment of the Division Bench of this Court only struck down Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act and nothing more, reservation can be provided, as held by the Supreme Court in Indra Sawhney, even by way of Government Orders, and not necessarily only by legislation-plenary or subordinate.

    10. If the Government of Uttarakhand has either adopted the earlier notifications issued by the Government of Uttar Pradesh, or has issued notifications after its creation on 09.11.2000 providing reservation in promotions in favour of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes, then those notifications would remain in force, as its validity was not put in issue before the Division Bench in Vinod Prakash Nautiyal, and the challenge in those proceedings was confined only to the constitutional validity of Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act whereby legislative sanction was given to the earlier Government Orders in force. We also make it clear that, even if there are no such Government Orders in force in the State of Uttarakhand, Article 16(4-A) of the Constitution of India, an enabling provision, confers power on the Government of Uttarakhand to take necessary steps, if they so choose, to provide reservation in promotion in favour of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes, without having to gather quantifiable data regarding either their backwardness or the adequacy of their representation in services.

    11. The writ petition is disposed of accordingly. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gyan Chand v. State Of Uttarakhand And Others
    (Apr 1, 2019)