AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2019 INSC 223
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • The Indian Penal Code (for short, “the IPC”)
  • Sections 148, 323 and 302 read with 149 of the Indian Penal Code (for short, “the IPC”)
  • Section 148, Section 323 and Section 302 read with Section 149 of the Indian Penal Code
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2019 INSC 223
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • The Indian Penal Code (for short, “the IPC”)
  • Sections 148, 323 and 302 read with 149 of the Indian Penal Code (for short, “the IPC”)
  • Section 148, Section 323 and Section 302 read with Section 149 of the Indian Penal Code
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

In the early morning of 9 November 1995, at approximately 6:00 a.m., a group of 26 persons armed with spears, arrows, lathis and other deadly weapons allegedly surrounded the residence of Md. Aziz Ali, Md. Kutub Ali, Md. Mamud Ali, and Samir Ali. They allegedly trespassed into the house, dragged the occupants outside, and assaulted them. Four victims—Md. Aziz Ali, Md. Kutub Ali, Md. Mamud Ali, and Samir Ali—succumbed to their injuries, and one person, PW7 Atar Ali, sustained injuries.

An FIR regarding this incident was registered the same day at 8:30 a.m. A counter-FIR was lodged two days later, on 11 November 1995, by Promila Begum, wife of Turen Ali (from the accused group), concerning the death of Turen Ali and injuries to six others from the accused side. The counter-case was tried separately.

Although 26 persons were originally named as accused, a chargesheet was filed against 15. During trial, one accused died and two absconded. The trial proceeded against 12 accused; 8 of them (the appellants) were convicted. By judgment dated 29 April 2006 in Sessions Case No. 68/2001, the Additional Sessions Judge, Barpeta convicted the appellants under Sections 148, 323, and 302 read with 149 of the Indian Penal Code, and acquitted the remaining accused. The Gauhati High Court, by judgment dated 5 March 2010 in Criminal Appeal No. 121 of 2006, affirmed the convictions and sentences. The convicted accused filed the present appeal challenging the concurrent findings.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the convictions could be sustained on the basis of testimonies of eyewitnesses who were closely related to the deceased, and the legal distinction between “related” and “interested” witnesses.
  2. Whether minor discrepancies among multiple eyewitness accounts undermined the prosecution’s case.
  3. Whether the alleged suppression of the “origin and genesis” of the incident—given a counter-case reporting the death of one person from the accused side and injuries to others—vitiated the prosecution’s case.
  4. Whether the absence of recovered weapons and the alleged weakness of motive affected the reliability of the prosecution evidence and the existence of requisite intent.
  5. Whether the proven facts established unlawful assembly and common object sufficient to sustain convictions under Sections 148 and 302 read with 149 IPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • All six eyewitnesses are closely related to the deceased, rendering their testimonies interested and unreliable.
  • The alleged motive is weak: a minor quarrel the previous day arising from a collision of bicycles between PW1 Md. Hanif Ali and accused Md. Saifuddin (absconding); hence, no intention to commit murder can be inferred.
  • No weapons were recovered from the appellants.
  • The prosecution suppressed the death of Turen Ali (from the accused side) and injuries to six accused in the same incident, thereby concealing the origin and genesis of the occurrence and approaching the court with unclean hands.

State's Arguments

The State supported the judgments of the Trial Court and the High Court.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Rajasthan v. Kalki, (1981) 2 SCC 752 Distinction between “related” and “interested” witnesses; a related witness is not, by that fact alone, an interested witness. Relied upon to reject the argument that eyewitnesses should be disbelieved solely due to their close relationship with the deceased.
Amit v. State of Uttar Pradesh, (2012) 4 SCC 107 Related witness testimony is not inherently unreliable; focus is on credibility and consistency. Cited among authorities affirming that related testimony can be accepted if cogent and trustworthy.
Gangabhavani v. Rayapati Venkat Reddy, (2013) 15 SCC 298 Clarification of when a witness can be termed “interested.” Used to support that mere relationship does not make a witness “interested” absent motive to falsely implicate.
Ganapathi v. State of Tamil Nadu, (2018) 5 SCC 549 Reiteration of the “related” versus “interested” distinction, referring back to Kalki. Quoted to reinforce acceptance of related eyewitness testimony where otherwise reliable.
Dalip Singh v. State of Punjab, 1954 SCR 145 Close relatives are often natural witnesses; ordinarily the last to screen the real culprit and falsely implicate another. Invoked to affirm the credibility of family-member eyewitnesses present at the scene.
Jayabalan v. Union Territory of Pondicherry, (2010) 1 SCC 199 Courts should be cautious but not suspicious when evaluating evidence from related witnesses; look for consistency. Applied to emphasize consistency and reliability as the touchstones for accepting related witnesses.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

  • Undisputed features: Four persons died (Md. Aziz Ali, Md. Kutub Ali, Md. Mamud Ali, and Samir Ali), and PW7 Atar Ali was injured in the same incident. The FIR was lodged promptly at 8:30 a.m. on the day of occurrence; a counter-FIR from the accused side was filed two days later. The counter-case was tried separately, and the present appeal was decided on the record of this case alone.
  • Eyewitness testimony: Six eyewitnesses (PWs 1, 2, 3, 7, 8, and 9) testified, including injured eyewitness PW7. PW7 provided specific, detailed overt acts attributed to individual accused (e.g., stabbing with spears; assaults with lathis and a heavy bamboo stick) and stated he himself was assaulted. His cross-examination did not shake his account. The other eyewitnesses corroborated PW7 on material particulars.
  • Medical corroboration: The post-mortem evidence (PWs 5 and 6) supported the eyewitness accounts.
  • Related versus interested witnesses: The Court emphasized settled law that related witnesses are not inherently “interested.” It cited multiple precedents clarifying that mere kinship does not taint testimony; reliability, probability, and consistency remain the key criteria. Applying these principles, the Court found the eyewitnesses trustworthy and their presence natural given the timing and location.
  • Minor discrepancies: The Court rejected the contention that minor variations regarding the manner of assault undermined the prosecution case, noting that such differences are expected where multiple assailants launch a sudden group attack and do not amount to material contradictions.
  • Alleged suppression of origin/genesis: PW8 and PW9 expressly deposed about the death of Turen Ali and injuries on the accused side, which formed the subject of a counter-case. In light of this, the Court found no basis to conclude the prosecution suppressed the genesis of the incident.
  • Motive and recovery: The Court held that, given the ample ocular evidence, motive was not significant. The argument regarding non-recovery of weapons did not displace the consistent and credible eyewitness and medical evidence.
  • Intention and unlawful assembly: The facts demonstrated that the accused, as aggressors, came armed in a group, trespassed into the victims’ house, dragged them out, and assaulted them with deadly weapons at about 6:00 a.m. This indicated prior preparation, premeditation, absence of provocation, and the requisite intention to commit murder, sustaining liability under Sections 148 and 302 read with 149 IPC.
  • Concurrent findings: On the totality of the evidence, the Court found no reason to fault the appreciation of evidence by the Trial Court and the High Court.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED. The Court found no ground to interfere with the impugned judgments; the convictions and sentences of the appellants under Sections 148, 323, and 302 read with 149 IPC were affirmed.

Implications: The immediate consequence is that the appellants’ convictions and sentences remain intact. The decision applies settled principles regarding the evidentiary value of related eyewitnesses and the limited impact of minor discrepancies where the core narrative is consistent and corroborated. No broader or novel legal rule was set; the judgment reinforces existing jurisprudence.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Md. Rojali Ali And Others v. State Of Assam Ministry Of Home Affairs Through, The Secretary .

    Mohan M. Shantanagoudar, J.:— In this most unfortunate and beastly incident, four persons fast asleep in their home in the early hours of the morning, oblivious to their imminent fate, were mercilessly murdered in a barbaric manner by the armed accused, without any instigation or provocation.

    2. Against the concurrent judgments of conviction and sentence dated 29.04.2006 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Barpeta in Sessions Case No. 68/2001 and the judgment dated 5.3.2010 passed in Criminal Appeal No. 121 of 2006 passed by the Gauhati High Court, this appeal is presented by the convicted accused.

    3. The case of the prosecution in brief is that 26 persons including the appellants herein, armed with deadly weapons like spears, arrows, lathis etc. surrounded the house of Md. Aziz Ali, Md. Kutub Ali, Md. Mamud Ali and Samir Ali at about 6.00 a.m. on 9.11.1995 and trespassed into their house, dragged them outside and then assaulted them. As a result of this, Md. Aziz Ali, Md. Kutub Ali, Md. Mamud Ali and Samir Ali (not mentioned as deceased in FIR) succumbed to the injuries sustained by them and one Md. Atar Ali was injured. Though 26 persons were arrayed as accused in the first information, the chargesheet came to be filed against 15 persons. During the course of the trial, one of the accused died, and two others absconded. Thus, the trial was held against 12 accused, 8 of whom are the appellants herein. The Trial Court after following due procedure convicted the appellants under Sections 148, 323 and 302 read with 149 of the Indian Penal Code (for short, “the IPC”), and acquitted the other accused. The judgment of the Trial Court came to be confirmed by the High Court. Hence, the convicted accused are in appeal before us.

    4. Shri Raj Kishore Chaudhary, appearing on behalf of the appellants, took us through the material on record, and contended that though there are six eye-witnesses to the incident in question, all these eye-witnesses are closely related to the family of the deceased. It was also contended that the motive for commission of the offence is very weak, only being to the effect that on the day before the incident, a minor quarrel took place between the parties because the bicycles of PW1, Md. Hanif Ali and accused Md. Saifuddin (absconding) collided with each other. Thus, according to the appellants, there was no intention on their part to commit the murder of the four deceased, and moreover that no weapons were recovered from them. It was further contended that the prosecution witnesses have suppressed the death of one Turen Ali, who was part of the group of the accused, and whose death occurred during the course of the same incident. In the same incident, six persons from the group of the accused were also injured. Thus according to the learned Counsel for the appellants, the prosecution witnesses have not come before the Court with clean hands, inasmuch as they suppressed the origin and genesis of the incident.

    5. Per contra, the advocate for the State argued in support of the judgment of the courts below.

    6. It is not in dispute that in the case at hand, four persons have died viz., Md. Aziz Ali, Md. Kutub Ali, Md. Mamud Ali and Samir Ali, and that PW7 Atar Ali was injured in the same incident. The incident took place at about 6.00 a.m. on 9.11.1995 and the first information came to be registered at 8.30 a.m. on the same day. A counter first information was filed by one Promila Begum, wife of Turen Ali (deceased belonging to the group of the accused) on 11.11.1995 i.e. two days after the date of the incident in question. In the said counter case, the trial went on separately in respect of the death of Turen Ali and the injuries sustained by the other six persons (accused herein). Thus, there were cases and counter cases related to the incident in question. Since the case at hand has to be dealt with on the basis of the material on record on its own merit, we do not propose to make any comment in respect of the counter case.

    7. As mentioned supra, there are several eye-witnesses, viz., PWs 1, 2, 3, 7, 8 and 9, and among them PW7 is the injured eyewitness. It is also not in dispute that they are inter se closely related to the deceased. PW5 and PW6 are the doctors who conducted the post-mortem examinations.

    8. In view of the ample ocular evidence on record, the motive for commission of the offence may not be so significant in this matter.

    9. PW7, the injured eye-witness testified that after hearing a hue and cry at about 5.00 a.m., he went to his courtyard and saw all the accused assaulting Md. Aziz Ali, Md. Kutub Ali, Md. Mamud Ali and Samir Ali. He specified the overt acts of each of the accused by deposing that Accused No. 5 stabbed Aziz Ali with a spear; Accused No. 12 assaulted Samir Ali with a lathi; Accused No. 8 stabbed Samir Ali with a spear; Accused Saif (absconding) assaulted Kutub Ali using a heavy bamboo stick; Accused No. 2 stabbed Kutub Ali with a spear; Accused No. 1 and Accused No. 9 assaulted Mamud Ali on the chest, etc. He also deposed that he himself was assaulted by Accused No. 3. Though the prosecution cross-examined PW7 at length, his evidence remained unshaken. Even in the cross-examination, PW7 has reiterated the incident in question without any blemishes.

    10. The evidence of PW7 is fully supported by the evidence of the other eye-witnesses, i.e., PWs 1, 2, 3, 8 and 9. To satisfy our conscience, we have gone through the evidence of these witnesses as well. On examining the same, we find that the Trial Court and the High Court are justified in observing that these witnesses are trustworthy and reliable. We do not wish to burden this judgment by quoting the evidence of all these eye-witnesses, inasmuch as their evidence has been dealt with in detail by the Trial Court and the High Court, and the appreciation of the evidence by the Courts cannot be faulted by us in any manner. Having considered the evidence of all the eye-witnesses in detail, suffice it to say that the evidence of all of these eye-witnesses is consistent with the case of the prosecution with respect to all material particulars, and is credible and trustworthy. Their presence on the spot can also not be doubted as they are family members of the deceased, who could reasonably be expected to be in their respective houses at the relevant point of time, i.e., the early hours of the day, when they (as well as the deceased) could be expected to have been asleep, and to be about to wake up and start their daily routine.

    11. As regards the contention that all the eye-witnesses are close relatives of the deceased, it is by now well-settled that a related witness cannot be said to be an ‘interested’ witness merely by virtue of being a relative of the victim. This Court has elucidated the difference between ‘interested’ and ‘related’ witnesses in a plethora of cases, stating that a witness may be called interested only when he or she derives some benefit from the result of a litigation, which in the context of a criminal case would mean that the witness has a direct or indirect interest in seeing the accused punished due to prior enmity or other reasons, and thus has a motive to falsely implicate the accused (for instance, see State of Rajasthan v. Kalki, (1981) 2 SCC 752; Amit v. State of Uttar Pradesh, (2012) 4 SCC 107; and Gangabhavani v. Rayapati Venkat Reddy, (2013) 15 SCC 298). Recently, this difference was reiterated in Ganapathi v. State of Tamil Nadu, (2018) 5 SCC 549, in the following terms, by referring to the three-Judge bench decision in State of Rajasthan v. Kalki (supra):

    “14. “Related” is not equivalent to “interested”. A witness may be called “interested” only when he or she derives some benefit from the result of a litigation; in the decree in a civil case, or in seeing an accused person punished. A witness who is a natural one and is the only possible eye witness in the circumstances of a case cannot be said to be “interested”…”

    12. In criminal cases, it is often the case that the offence is witnessed by a close relative of the victim, whose presence on the scene of the offence would be natural. The evidence of such a witness cannot automatically be discarded by labelling the witness as interested. Indeed, one of the earliest statements with respect to interested witnesses in criminal cases was made by this Court in Dalip Singh v. State of Punjab, 1954 SCR 145, wherein this Court observed:

    “26. A witness is normally to be considered independent unless he or she springs from sources which are likely to be tainted and that usually means unless the witness has cause, such as enmity against the accused, to wish to implicate him falsely. Ordinarily, a close relative would be the last to screen the real culprit and falsely implicate an innocent person…”

    13. In case of a related witness, the Court may not treat his or her testimony as inherently tainted, and needs to ensure only that the evidence is inherently reliable, probable, cogent and consistent. We may refer to the observations of this Court in Jayabalan v. Union Territory of Pondicherry, (2010) 1 SCC 199:

    “23. We are of the considered view that in cases where the Court is called upon to deal with the evidence of the interested witnesses, the approach of the Court while appreciating the evidence of such witnesses must not be pedantic. The Court must be cautious in appreciating and accepting the evidence given by the interested witnesses but the Court must not be suspicious of such evidence. The primary endeavour of the Court must be to look for consistency. The evidence of a witness cannot be ignored or thrown out solely because it comes from the mouth of a person who is closely related to the victim.”

    14. In the instant matter, as already discussed above, we find the testimony of the eye-witnesses to be consistent and reliable, and therefore reject the contention of the appellants that the testimony of the eye-witnesses must be disbelieved because they are close relatives of the deceased and hence interested witnesses.

    15. Furthermore, though the counsel for the appellants tried to convince the Court with regard to minor discrepancies in the evidence of the six eye-witnesses with respect to the manner in which the assault took place, such attempt remains futile and cannot be accepted, inasmuch as minor variations in the evidence of the witnesses are bound to occur in a case like the one on hand, wherein a number of accused came in a group and assaulted a few persons suddenly and mercilessly, out of which a few died and others sustained injuries. We do not find any major contradiction in the evidence of the eye-witnesses. Their evidence is fully supported by the version of the doctors who conducted the post-mortem examinations.

    16. It is relevant to note that PW8 and PW9 have clearly deposed about the death of Turen Ali, for which the counter case was lodged. Of course, the other eye-witnesses did not depose about the same. Since the evidence of the two prosecution witnesses named above reveals that the accused party had also sustained injuries and one of them had expired, we do not find any ground to conclude that the prosecution tried to suppress the origin and genesis of the incident.

    17. The evidence clearly reveals that the accused are the aggressors who came in a group to the house of deceased, trespassed into their houses, dragged the deceased out and mercilessly assaulted the deceased with sharp spears, arrows and lathis. The incident had taken place at about 6.00 a.m., which suggests that all the accused came with the clear intention to commit the murder of the four persons in the early hours of the day. The accused were armed with deadly weapons and they came with prior preparation and premeditation. There was no provocation by the deceased or by the injured. In view of the same, it cannot be said that there was no intention on the part of the accused to commit murder.

    18. Having regard to the totality of the facts and circumstances of the case, we find no ground to interfere with the impugned judgment. Hence, the appeal is hereby dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Md. Rojali Ali And Others v. State Of Assam Ministry Of Home Affairs Through, The Secretary .
    (Feb 19, 2019)