AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Acts
  • section 147 of the 6 ITA No.1381/Kol/2017 M/s Asiatic Oxygen Ltd. A.Yr. 2008-09 6 Act
  • section 147 / 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (in short the Act)
  • section 114(e) of the Indian Evidence Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Acts
  • section 147 of the 6 ITA No.1381/Kol/2017 M/s Asiatic Oxygen Ltd. A.Yr. 2008-09 6 Act
  • section 147 / 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (in short the Act)
  • section 114(e) of the Indian Evidence Act
Smart Summary

Concise Analytical Summary of the Tribunal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The assessee, M/s Asiatic Oxygen Ltd., filed its return of income for the assessment year 2008-09 on 23.09.2008. A regular assessment under section 143(3) was completed on 02.12.2010 determining total income at Rs. 62,10,223/-. Subsequently, the assessing officer (AO) issued a notice under section 148 (dated 27.04.2012) and recorded reasons (dated 07.04.2012) to reopen the assessment under section 147, alleging that interest of Rs. 34.58 lakhs on loans advanced to M/s Six Sigma Gases India Pvt. Ltd. had not been accounted for despite the assessee following mercantile accounting, thereby resulting in escape of income.

In the original assessment proceedings the AO had specifically queried non-charging of interest and the assessee had replied (15.11.2010), explaining that due to the poor financial condition of the borrower and a conscious decision recorded in a board resolution (31.01.2008), interest was not being charged. The assessee also relied on certain High Court decisions. The assessee filed objections to the reopening and pointed out that rectification proceedings under section 154 (notice dated 30.11.2011) were pending in respect of the same issue.

The AO held that non-charging of interest for A.Y. 2008-09 represented income escaping assessment and brought Rs. 34.58 lakhs to tax; the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)] upheld the reopening and assessment. The assessee appealed to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), which heard the matter and pronounced the order under the signatures of Judicial Member S.S. Godara and Accountant Member M. Balaganesh on 07.09.2018.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the reopening of assessment under section 147 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 was valid where the AO had previously considered and accepted the assessee's explanation in the original assessment and no fresh/tangible material was brought to his notice after completion of assessment.
  2. Whether a notional interest amounting to Rs. 34,58,000 on loans advanced to Six Sigma Gases Pvt. Ltd. accrued to the assessee so as to be taxable for A.Y. 2008-09, despite the assessee's decision (supported by a board resolution) not to charge interest due to the borrower's poor financial condition.

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee's Arguments

  • The issue of non-charging of interest was specifically raised and considered in the original assessment (u/s 143(3)), and the AO had accepted the assessee's explanation at that time.
  • The assessee had filed a detailed reply dated 15.11.2010 and produced a Board Resolution dated 31.01.2008 evidencing a conscious decision not to charge interest because the borrower was in poor financial health.
  • Rectification proceedings under section 154 (notice dated 30.11.2011) were pending on the same subject; reopening by the AO while those were pending evidenced absence of any fresh material to justify reassessment.
  • There was no fresh or tangible material brought to the AO's notice post-completion of assessment; reopening therefore constituted an impermissible change of opinion.
  • The assessee relied on jurisdictional High Court decisions (CIT v. Balarampur Commercial Enterprises and Giriraj Udyog) to support that no real income had accrued in respect of the notional interest.
  • There was no allegation of mala fides or that the assessee had intentionally suppressed facts; hence the reopening was not warranted.

Revenue / Assessing Officer's Arguments

  • The AO's recorded reason was that the assessee, following mercantile accounting, ought to have credited interest of Rs. 34.58 lakhs to profit & loss account and its omission resulted in underassessment of income and short levy of tax.
  • Although advances were made out of capital and reserves, the assessee had charged interest on similar advances in prior years (AYs 2006-07 and 2007-08), and hence non-charging in 2007-08 could not be explained merely by the borrower's poor financial health.
  • On that basis the AO formed the view that income had escaped assessment and initiated reassessment under section 147.
  • The CIT(A) upheld the AO's action; the precise detailed submissions of revenue before the Tribunal were not reproduced beyond these contentions in the opinion.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
CIT v. Balarampur Commercial Enterprises, 262 ITR 439 (Cal) Cited by the assessee for the proposition that no real income had in fact accrued/arose in respect of interest on amounts advanced, supporting non-recognition of notional interest. The Tribunal noted the assessee relied on this High Court decision to support its factual-legal stance that interest was not really accrued and accepted that the assessee had not realized interest and had taken a conscious decision not to charge interest in view of the borrower's poor financial health.
Giriraj Udyog, 273 ITR 495 (All) Cited by the assessee for a similar proposition that notional interest had not accrued/realized and therefore was not exigible to tax. The Tribunal recorded that the assessee placed reliance upon this Allahabad High Court decision and, consonant with the factual findings about non-realization and the board resolution, treated this precedent as supportive of the assessee's position on the merits.
Kelvinator of India Ltd., 320 ITR 561 (SC) Principle that reassessment proceedings under section 147 cannot be sustained if they are founded merely on the AO's change of opinion; an order passed without application of mind cannot be a basis to benefit the authority seeking reopening. The Tribunal applied this Supreme Court authority to hold that there was no fresh/tangible material post-completion of assessment and that the AO's act amounted to a change of opinion; consequently the reopening under section 147 did not survive.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal proceeded through the following analytical steps:

  1. Temporal and procedural threshold: The Tribunal observed the reopening was within four years from the end of the relevant previous year, so the proviso to section 147 dealing with failure to make full and true disclosure (which operates beyond four years) was not applicable here.
  2. Existence of prior application of mind: The AO had specifically raised the non-charging of interest during the original assessment under section 143(3) and had, after considering the assessee's detailed reply (including board resolution), accepted the assessee's explanation at that stage. A presumption exists that a regular assessment was passed after due application of mind (referencing section 114(e) of the Indian Evidence Act as supporting the presumption of regularity of judicial/official acts).
  3. Absence of fresh/tangible material: On examination of the reasons recorded by the AO, the Tribunal found that the material relied upon to reopen was already on record prior to completion of the assessment. No new evidence or material with a live nexus to formation of belief that income had escaped assessment was brought to the AO’s notice post-assessment.
  4. Change of opinion principle: Based on the absence of fresh material, the Tribunal concluded the AO's action amounted to a mere change of opinion, which is not a permissible basis for initiating reassessment under section 147. The Tribunal relied on the principle articulated by the Supreme Court in Kelvinator of India Ltd. to the effect that reopening cannot be based on mere change of opinion and that permitting reopening on such a basis would enable an authority to benefit from its own wrong.
  5. Merits on the accrual question: Even on merits, the Tribunal noted that the assessee had not been able to realize interest in earlier years, that the assessee took a conscious and documented decision (board resolution) not to charge interest for the year in question in view of the borrower's poor financial health, and that the revenue did not dispute the borrower's poor financial condition. The Tribunal observed it would be futile to fasten tax liability on notional interest which was unlikely to be realized and might in future crystallize as a bad debt claim.
  6. Conclusion from law and facts: Combining the absence of tangible fresh material, the prohibition on reassessment founded on change of opinion, the supporting precedents, and the substantive factual position as to non-realization and board action, the Tribunal concluded that the reassessment did not survive either in law or on facts.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The Tribunal quashed the reassessment proceedings framed under section 147 and allowed the assessee's appeal.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The reassessment initiated by the AO and upheld by the CIT(A) (which sought to bring Rs. 34,58,000 of notional interest to tax) has been quashed by the Tribunal on both legal and factual grounds.
  • Accordingly, the assessee's liability in respect of the said notional interest for A.Y. 2008-09 is removed as a result of this order.

Broader implications: The opinion applied established principles (including the Supreme Court's decision in Kelvinator) regarding the impermissibility of reopening assessments on mere change of opinion and reiterated the necessity of fresh/tangible material to form a reason to believe under section 147. The opinion did not purport to lay down a novel precedent beyond applying those established principles.

Order pronounced in Court on 07.09.2018. Members: S.S. Godara (Judicial Member) and M. Balaganesh (Accountant Member). Appeal allowed; reassessment quashed.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    M/s. Asiatic Oxygen Limited, Kolkata v. DCIT, Circle - 4, Kolkata , Kolkata

    Per M.Balaganesh, AM

    1. This appeal by the Assessee arises out of the order of the Learned Commissioner of Income Tax(Appeals)-2, Kolkata [in short the ld CIT(A)] in Appeal No. 132/CIT(A)- 2/14-15 dated 01.05.2017 against the order passed by the DCIT, Circle-4, Kolkata [ in short the ld AO] under section 147 / 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (in short the Act) dated 10.12.2012 for the Assessment Year 2008-09.

    2. The only ground raised by the assessee is with regard to challenging the validity of re-opening proceedings u/s 147 of the Act and consequentially bringing to tax a sum of Rs. 34,58,000/- towards interest income on loan advanced to Six Sigma Gases Pvt. Ltd. on notional basis. ITA No.1381/Kol/2017 M/s Asiatic Oxygen Ltd. A.Yr. 2008-09

    3. The brief facts of this issue are that the return of income for the assessment year 2008-09 was filed by the assessee company on 23.09.2008. The assessee was completed u/s 143(3) on 02.12.2010 determining total income at Rs. 62,10,223/-. Later the assessment was sought to be reopened by issuance of notice u/s 148 of the Act dated 27.04.2012. The reasons recorded by the ld. AO for reopening the assessment are as under: OFFICE OF THE JOINT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (OSD), CIRCLE-4 P- 7, CHOWRINGHEE SQUARE, AAYAKAR BHAWAN, 8TH FLOOR, KOLKATA-700069. No. JCIT, OSD,Cir-4/Kol/Asiatic Oxy/2012-13 dated 07.04.2012 The Principal Officer M/s Asiatic Oxygen Ltd. 8, BBD Bag East, Kolkata-700001. Sir, Sub: Reasons recorded for taking action u/s 147 for the A.Y. 2008-09 in the case of M/s Asiatic Oxygen Ltd., PAN: AACCA 6748 G- Reg. Ref: Your Letter dated 21.05.2012. Please refer to the above. The reasons recorded by this office to take action u/s 147 for the assessment year 2008-09 in the case of your company is as under: It was noticed that the assessee did not account for interest amounting Rs. 34.58 lacs on the amount of loan given to M/s Six Sigma Gases India Pvt. Ltd. on the ground that the above company had approached the assessee intimating its inability of pay interest due to their poor financial health. However, as the assessee followed mercantile system of accounting during the previous year relevant to the assessment year, the amount of interest was required to be credited to the profit & loss account. Omission to add back the same in course of assessment resulted in underassessment of income of Rs. 34.58 lacs resulting in short levy of tax of Rs. 10.68 lac. Although the assessee had made the advance out of capital and reserve and not out of borrowed capital, the assessee had charged interest on the advance during financial year 2005-06 and 2006-07 and only the poor financial health of the said ITA No.1381/Kol/2017 M/s Asiatic Oxygen Ltd. A.Yr. 2008-09 company could not be the reason for not charging the interest in the FY 2007-08 if the assessee had been following mercantile system of accounting. As per provision of the Act, writing off bad debt of an amount in the P/L account entitles an assessee to claim deduction in the computation of tax. Yours Faithfully (P.B.Pramanik) JCIT, (OSD), Circle-4, Kolkata. The assessee filed objections to the said reasons vide its letter dated 18.09.2012 wherein it was specifically brought to the notice of the ld. AO that in the course of original assessment proceedings u/s 143(3) of the Act, a specific query was raised as to why interest had not been charged on the amount advanced to M/s Six Sigma Gasses Pvt. Ltd. The assessee had submitted a detailed reply in that regard vide its letter dated 15.11.2010 wherein it was explained that the said company was incurring losses and even the interest credited in the accounts by the assessee in the earlier two years on accrual basis could not be realized. Further the said party had also requested the assessee for not charging any interest as they had become a victim of ongoing deep recession worldwide. It was submitted by the assessee that considering the poor financial health of the said company, the directors of the assessee company after taking a conscious decision, passed a resolution deciding therein, not to charge any interest on the amount advanced to the said company. A copy of the letter dated 15.11.2010 along with copy of Board Resolution dated 31.01.2008 along with proposal for not charging of interest which was filed before the ld. AO in the original assessment proceedings was again filed before the ld. AO in the reassessment proceedings. The assessee placed reliance on the decision of the Honble Jurisdictional High Court in the case of CIT vs. Balarampur Commercial Enterprises reported in 262 ITR 439 (Cal) and Honble Allahabad High Court in the case of Giriraj Udyog reported in 273 ITR 495 (All) stating that no real income had in fact accrued/arose to the said company in respect of interest on amount advanced to Six Sigma Gasses Pvt. Ltd. It was specifically pointed out by the assessee while filing the objections to the reasons recorded in the reassessment ITA No.1381/Kol/2017 M/s Asiatic Oxygen Ltd. A.Yr. 2008-09 proceedings that since this issue was already examined by the ld. AO in the original assessment proceedings, reopening of the assessment on the same issue on which decision was already taken by the ld. AO after due application of mind, tantamount to change of opinion and accordingly it was contested that the reopening was not in accordance with law. The assessee placed reliance in support of this proposition on various decisions of Honble Supreme Court and Honble Jurisdictional High Court. It was also pointed out that there was no allegation that there was any malafide on the part of the assessee in postponing or shifting the income to subsequent years for the purpose of taxation. No new material or tangible material or other evidences has been brought on record by the ld. AO while recording the reasons to show that income by way of interest had in fact actually been accrued.

    4. It was also submitted that prior to issue of notice u/s 148 of the Act, the assessee company was served with a notice u/s 154 of the Act dated 30.11.2011 proposing to rectify the alleged mistake of the ld. AO for not assessing the notional interest on loan advanced to Six Sigma Gases Pvt. Ltd., treating the same as mistake apparent from record. The assessee had given a detailed reply for the same. When the said rectification proceedings were pending, the ld. AO reopened the assessment u/s 147 of the Act. Accordingly, it was argued that there was no tangible material or new evidence that had come to the notice of the ld. AO which would enable him to form a reasonable belief that income of the assessee had escaped assessment other than the issue originally mooted in the rectification proceedings u/s 154 of the Act. The ld. AO however did not agree to any of the contentions of the assessee detailed hereinabove. The ld. AO observed in this order that although the advance to Six Sigma Gases Pvt. Ltd. were made in the earlier years out of capital and reserves of the assessee company and not out of borrowed funds, the assessee had charged interest on the said advance during assessment years 2006-07 and 2007-08. Accordingly, he held that non-charging of ITA No.1381/Kol/2017 M/s Asiatic Oxygen Ltd. A.Yr. 2008-09 interest for assessment year 2008-09 represents income escaping assessment and hence the same is required to be brought to tax in the sum of Rs. 34.58 lacs. This action of the ld. AO was upheld by the ld. CIT(A). Aggrieved the assessee is in appeal before us.

    5. We have heard rival submissions. At the outset, we find that the reopening of the assessment for the assessment year 2008-09 has been made within the four years from the end of the relevant previous year. Hence the applicability of that proviso to section

    147 on the aspect of failure of the assessee to make full and true disclosure of the facts does not apply in the instant case. We find from the facts narrated above that the ld. AO had duly applied his mind in the original assessment proceedings by raising a specific query on non-charging of interest on amount advanced to M/s Six Sigma Gases Pvt. Ltd. The ld. AO on examining the reply given by the assessee in that regard had accepted the stand of the assessee of not charging the interest for the year under consideration duly taking into account the poor financial conditions of M/s Six Sigma Gases Pvt. Ltd. We find that the very same issue was the subject matter of the rectification proceedings u/s 154 of the Act for which assessee gave a detailed reply and both the ld. AR as well as ld. DR before us failed to bring evidence on record to prove the status of completion of such rectification proceedings. Be that as it may, the ld. AO had sought to reopen the assessment for adjudicating the same issue towards notional interest on loan advance to M/s Six Sigma Gases Pvt. Ltd. in the sum of Rs. 34,58,000/-. From the reasons recorded by the ld. AO as reproduced hereinabove, we find that the entire information was very much available on record and there was absolutely no tangible material or fresh material or new evidence that had come to the possession of the ld. AO post completion of assessment proceedings, having live link or live nexus with his formation of belief that income of the assessee had escaped assessment warranting the reopening u/s 147 of the Act. Hence this is a clear case of change of opinion on the part of the ld. AO. It is now well settled that section 147 of the ITA No.1381/Kol/2017 M/s Asiatic Oxygen Ltd. A.Yr. 2008-09 Act does not postulate conferment of power upon the ld. AO to initiate reassessment proceedings upon his mere change of opinion. If reason to believe of the ld. AO is founded on an information which might have been received by the ld. AO after completion of assessment, it might be a sound foundation for exercising the power u/s

    147 of the Act. When a regular assessment u/s 143(3) has been made earlier, a presumption can be raised that such an order has been passed on due application of mind. It is well known that a presumption can also be raised to the effect that in terms of section 114(e) of the Indian Evidence Act and judicial and official acts have been regularly performed. The Honble Supreme Court in the case of Kelvinator of India Ltd. reported in 320 ITR 561 (SC) had held in similar circumstance that if it be held that an order which has been passed purportedly without application of mind would itself confer jurisdiction upon the AO to reopen the proceedings without anything further, the same would amount to giving premium to an authority exercising quasi-judicial function to take benefit of its own wrong. The necessary ingredients of section 147 in the form of tangible material post completion of assessment proceedings are conspicuously absent. Hence the reopening of assessment does not survive. We find even on merits, that the assessee was not able to realize interest income offered by it on amount advanced to Six Sigma Gases Pvt. Ltd. in the earlier two assessment years . During the year under consideration, the assessee had duly taken note of the poor financial condition of Six Sigma Gases Pvt. Ltd. and had taken a conscious call of not recognizing the interest income on accrual basis and had even further taken a call for not charging any interest on the said loan for which a separate Board Resolution had also been passed. The poor financial condition of Six Sigma Gases Pvt Ltd had not been disputed by the revenue. The poor financial condition of Six Sigma Gases Pvt Ltd had not been disputed by the revenue. In this scenario, it would not serve any purpose by the ITA No.1381/Kol/2017 M/s Asiatic Oxygen Ltd. A.Yr. 2008-09 assessee having unnecessarily fastened with a tax liability on notional interest income which would never be realized and in future eventually result in claim of bad debt.

    6. In view of the aforesaid observationS, we hereby quash the reassessment proceedings framed by the ld. AO both on law as well as on facts.

    7. In the result, the appeal of the assessee is allowed. Order pronounced in the Court on 07.09.2018 Sd/- Sd/- [S.S. Godara] [ M.Balaganesh ] Judicial Member Accountant Member Dated : 07.09.2018 SB, Sr. PS Copy of the order forwarded to:

    1. M/s Asiatic Oxygen Ltd., 8, B.B.D. Bag, East, Kolkata-700001.

    2. DCIT, Circle-4, Kolkata, Aayakar Bhawan, P-7, Chowringhee Square, Kolkata- 700069. 3..C.I.T(A).- 4. C.I.T.- Kolkata.

    5. CIT(DR), Kolkata Benches, Kolkata. True copy By Order Senior Private Secretary Head of Office/D.D.O., ITAT, Kolkata Benches

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M/s. Asiatic Oxygen Limited, Kolkata v. DCIT, Circle - 4, Kolkata , Kolkata
    (Sep 7, 2018)