Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Section 33 C (2) of the Industrial Dispute Act, 1947 (hereinafter called as Act)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Section 33 C (2) of the Industrial Dispute Act, 1947 (hereinafter called as Act)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Vasantha Samuel, who was employed as a Steno-typist with the first respondent, Periakaramalai Tea & Products Co., Ltd., was dismissed from service on 16.03.1992 after a domestic enquiry. She raised an industrial dispute under Section 33 C (2) of the Industrial Dispute Act, 1947 before the Labour Court, Coimbatore (second respondent). The Labour Court passed an award on 06.03.1996 directing reinstatement with continuity of service, back wages, and other benefits. The first respondent challenged this award via W.P.No.13684 of 1996, which was dismissed by this Court, thereby confirming the award.

During the pendency of the writ petition, the first respondent deposited Rs.70,000/- in two installments as directed by the Court, which was paid to the petitioner. The petitioner retired on 11.02.1995. She claimed full back wages from dismissal till retirement. On 28.02.2004, she issued a notice to the first respondent demanding payment of dues. The first respondent paid Rs.1,46,962/- thereafter. The petitioner filed computation petition No.1098 of 2004 before the Labour Court, claiming various dues including back wages, allowances, medical benefits, leave travel allowance, annual leave wages, bonus, encashment of unavailed leave, and interest on provident fund contributions.

The Labour Court allowed claims towards back wages, allowances, and bonus but rejected claims for medical benefits, leave travel allowance, annual leave wages, encashment of unavailed leave, and interest on provident fund contributions, on the ground that these benefits were payable only to those actually working during the relevant period.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to medical benefits, leave travel allowance, annual leave with wages, encashment of unavailed leave, and interest on provident fund contributions and arrears of salary, despite not having actually worked during the relevant period after reinstatement but before retirement.
  2. Whether the Labour Court erred in rejecting the petitioner's claims for these benefits based on the UPASI agreement and relevant statutory provisions.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner contended that the Labour Court wrongly rejected claims for medical benefits, leave travel allowance, annual leave wages, and other benefits without any valid basis.
  • Though the matter was referred to the Tamil Nadu Mediation Conciliation Centre, no settlement was reached.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents argued that the Labour Court correctly rejected the claims for medical allowances, annual leave, and other benefits, as these are payable only to employees who actually worked during the relevant period.
  • Since the petitioner was not employed during the relevant time, she was not entitled to these allowances.
  • The respondents relied on a prior decision of the Madras High Court in W.P.No.9244/91 dated 14.09.1999 and subsequent judgments, which held that a workman is not entitled to claim such benefits if he/she had not actually worked during the relevant period.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
W.P.No.9244/91 dated 14.09.1999 (Madras High Court) Benefit claims such as medical allowances and leave travel allowance are payable only to employees who have actually worked during the relevant period. The Court applied this principle to conclude that since the petitioner did not work during the relevant period, she was not entitled to these benefits.
2001 (1) L.L.J. 706 Reinforcement of the principle that allowances and benefits form part of wages only if the employee has rendered actual service. Relied upon to uphold the Labour Court's rejection of the petitioner's claims for certain allowances and benefits.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the facts that the petitioner was reinstated by the Labour Court's award but retired on 11.02.1995. The petitioner filed the computation petition in 2004 claiming various dues. The Labour Court allowed claims related to back wages and bonus but rejected claims for medical benefits, leave travel allowance, annual leave wages, and other benefits on the ground that the petitioner was not working during the relevant period to claim those benefits.

The Court found the respondents' reliance on earlier decisions persuasive, which held that benefits like medical allowances and leave travel allowances are contingent upon actual service rendered during the relevant period. Since the petitioner did not work during the period for which these benefits were claimed, the Labour Court correctly rejected those claims. The Court noted that the Labour Court followed due process and considered statutory provisions and precedents before rejecting the claims.

Accordingly, the Court dismissed the writ petition, affirming the Labour Court's decision.

Holding and Implications

The Court's final ruling is the dismissal of the writ petition.

The direct effect of this decision is that the petitioner is entitled only to the back wages, allowances, and bonus previously awarded by the Labour Court, but not to medical benefits, leave travel allowance, annual leave wages, encashment of unavailed leave, or interest on provident fund contributions for the period after dismissal until retirement, as she did not actually work during that period. This decision does not establish any new legal precedent but affirms existing principles regarding entitlement to allowances linked to actual service.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Vasantha Samuel v. Management

    1

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS

    DATED : 28.04.2018

    CORAM

    THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE M.DHANDAPANI

    W.P.No.27384 of 2006 Vasantha Samuel ... Petitioner Vs.

    1. The Management of the Periakaramalai Tea & Products Co., Ltd.,

    Cowcoody Chambers

    234 - A, Race Course Road,

    Coimbatore - 641 018.

    2. The Presiding Officer, Labour Court,

    Coimbatore. ... Respondents

    Prayer: Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India to issue a writ of Certiorarified Mandamus to call for the records in C.P.No.1098/2004 dated 19.04.2006 on the file of the second respondent and quash the portion of the order refusing to direct the first respondent to pay Rs.13,675.80 towards Medical Benefits, Rs.3,520.00 towards leave travel allowance, Rs.2,400.00 towards annual leave with wages based on UPASI agreement, Rs.11459/- towards encashment of unavailed leave and interest upon provident fund contribution and interest for the arrears of salary and to direct the first respondent to pay Rs.13,675.80 towards Medical Benefits, Rs.3,520.00 towards leave travel allowance, Rs.2,400.00 towards annual leave with wages based on UPSAI agreement, Rs.11,459.00 towards encashment of

    2

    unavailed leave and interest upon provident fund contribution and interest for the arrears of salary to the petitioner.

    For Petitioner : Mr.A.Immanuel

    For Respondents : M/s.B.S.Rajan Rajagopalan

    O R D E R

    The petitioner has filed this writ petition seeking issuance of Certiorarified Mandamus to call for the records in C.P.No.1098/2004 dated 19.04.2006 on the file of the second respondent and quash the portion of the order refusing to direct the first respondent to pay Rs.13,675.80 towards Medical Benefits, Rs.3,520.00 towards leave travel allowance, Rs.2,400.00 towards annual leave with wages based on UPASI agreement, Rs.11459/- towards encashment of unavailed leave and interest upon provident fund contribution and interest for the arrears of salary and to direct the first respondent to pay Rs.13,675.80 towards Medical Benefits, Rs.3,520.00 towards leave travel allowance, Rs.2,400.00 towards annual leave with wages based on UPSAI agreement, Rs.11,459.00 towards encashment of unavailed leave and interest upon provident fund contribution and interest for the arrears of salary to the petitioner.

    3

    2. The case of the petitioner is that the petitioner had been working as Steno-typist in the office of the first respondent and she was dismissed from service on 16.03.1992 after conducting a domestic enquiry. As against the order of dismissal, she raised an industrial dispute under Section 33 C (2) of the Industrial Dispute Act, 1947 (hereinafter called as Act) before the second respondent and the second respondent passed the award dated 06.03.1996, directing the first respondent to reinstate the petitioner with continuity of service, back wages and other attendant benefits. As against the award, the first respondent filed a writ petition in W.P.No.13684 of 1996 before this Court and this Court dismissed the Writ petition and confirmed the award passed by the second respondent.

    3. The learned counsel for the petitioner further submitted that during the pendency of the writ petition in W.P.No.13684 of 1996 as per the direction of this Court the first respondent deposited a sum of Rs.40,000/- on 23.10.1996 and Rs.30,000/- on 24.05.1999 and the petitioner also withdrew the interest from the above deposit. However, the said amount of Rs.70,000/- which was in the custody of the second respondent, was paid to the petitioner.

    4. The petitioner retired from service on 11.02.1995. As per the award, the petitioner is entitled to full back wages from the date of dismissal till the

    4

    date of retirement of service. On 28.02.2004, she issued a lawyer notice to the first respondent calling upon the first respondent to pay the amount due to the petitioner. After receipt of notice, the first respondent paid a sum of Rs.1,46,962/-. The petitioner filed computation petition No.1098 of 2004 before the second respondent. The claim made by the petitioner are as follows:

    1. Basic Pay, Dearness Allowance, House Rent Allowance, Educational Allowance, Conveyance Allowance, Gas Allowance ... 1,56,555.16

    2. Minimum Bonus ... 10,000.00

    3. Medical Allowance ... 13,675.80

    4. Leave Travel Allowance ... 3,520.00

    5. Annual Leave with Wages ... 2,400.00

    6. Interest on Company Share of GPF ... 29,774.00 ---------------

    2,27,384.00

    ---------------

    5. After adjudication, the second respondent allowed the petitioner's claim of Rs.1,56,555.16/- towards back wages and allowances and Rs.10,000/- towards Bonus. Accordingly, the second respondent allowed the computation petition in the above terms. The second respondent refused to allow the petitioner's claim of Rs.13,675.80/- towards Medical Benefits, Rs.3,520/-

    5

    towards leave travel allowance, Rs.2,400/- towards annual leave with wages based on UPASI agreement, Rs.11,459.00 towards encashment of unavailed leave and interest upon provident fund contribution and interest for the arrears of salary.

    6. Mr.A.Immanuel, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submitted that though this case has been referred to Tamilnadu Mediation Conciliation Centre, the matter was not settled between the parties. Though, the second respondent partially allowed the computation petition. However rejected other allowances without any basis.

    7. M/s.B.S.Rajan Rajagopalan, learned counsel appearing for the respondents would submit that the second respondent, Labour Court rejected the petitioner's claim i.e., medical allowances and annual leave and other benefits which will be awarded only to those who are working in the relevant period. In the present case, the petitioner has not worked in the particular time and hence she is not entitled to claim leave and travel allowances. Hence, the second respondent labour Court rejected the petitioner's claim.

    8. The learned counsel appearing for the respondent further relied upon para 3.4 of the counter affidavit filed by the first respondent, the relevant

    6

    portion of which reads as follows:

    This point also is covered by the above decision of Madras High Court in W.P.No.9244/91 dated 14.09.1999 by Justice N.V.Balasubramaniam and followed by Justice Sathasivam which is reported in 2001 (1) L.L.J. 706.

    "After considering relevant provisions of I.D.Act as well as catena of decisions of various High Court and the Apex Court, the learned Judge has held that the workman is not entitled to claim the same as part of wages inasmuch as he had not actually worked". In this circumstances the petitioner had rendered no actual service and so payment of leave travel allowance would not arise.

    9. The learned counsel appearing for the respondents further submitted that after elaborate discussion the second respondent, Labour Court rightly rejected the claim of the petitioner after following the due process of law and after considering the provisions of the Act in this aspect.

    10. Heard, Mr.A.Immanuel, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and Mr.B.S.Rajan Rajagopalan, learned counsel appearing for the respondents.

    11. On perusal of the computation petition filed under Section 33 C (2) of the Act, it is known that the petitioner was initially reinstated in service

    7

    when she obtained order from the labour Court. Thereafter, she retired from service on 11.02.1995. Thereafter, in the year 2004, the petitioner filed the computation petition under Section 33 C (2) of the Act. After consideration, the labour Court awarded the claim Rs.1,56,555.16/- towards the back wages and allowances and Rs.10,000/- towards the minimum bonus. However, the petitioner was retired. The petitioner had been working during the relevant period. Accordingly, she is entitled to claim the same as part of wages inasmuch as she had not actually worked. However, the second respondent Labour Court rejected the other allowances on the ground the petitioner is not entitled to other allowances when she was not actually employed. Accordingly, the decision relied upon by the learned counsel for the respondent squarely apply to the present case on hand. Hence, this writ Petition is dismissed. No costs.

    28.04.2018

    Speaking Order/Non Speaking Order Index: Yes/ No

    Internet: Yes/ No

    dh

    To

    The Presiding Officer,

    Labour Court, Coimbatore.

    8

    M.DHANDAPANI, J.

    dh W.P.No.27384 of 2006

    28.04.2018

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Vasantha Samuel v. Management
    (Apr 28, 2018)