Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Article 163 of Civil Services Regulations
  • Section 124 of Constitution of Jammu
  • Rule 359 of the J&K Police
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Article 163 of Civil Services Regulations
  • Section 124 of Constitution of Jammu
  • Rule 359 of the J&K Police
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was appointed as a Constable in 1998 and was deployed as security in-charge at J&K Bank Shangus. In 2000, following a militant attack on the bank resulting in a loss of Rs. 47,920 and a rifle, the petitioner was discharged from service on allegations of negligence and dereliction of duty by respondent No. 4 through order No. 900 of 2000 dated 03.10.2000. The petitioner challenged this discharge via a Civil Suit in the Court of Sub Judge, Anantnag, which declared the discharge order null and void and directed reinstatement with salary benefits. The State appealed, and the appellate court upheld the trial court’s decision but allowed the respondents to hold a departmental enquiry. The petitioner faced criminal prosecution and was acquitted on 29.03.2003. Subsequently, a departmental enquiry was conducted, initially exonerating the petitioner, but a de novo enquiry was ordered by respondent No. 5, leading to the impugned order No. 734 of 2009 dated 11.09.2009. This order stopped the petitioner’s annual increment for two years and treated the period of absence from 03.10.2000 to 07.06.2008 as Dies-non. The petitioner challenges the treatment of this period as Dies-non, while not contesting the stoppage of increment penalty.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the period of absence of the petitioner from 03.10.2000 to 07.06.2008 can be lawfully treated as Dies-non despite the discharge order being declared null and void and the petitioner’s exoneration from charges?
  2. Whether treating the said period as Dies-non violates the principles of equality and non-arbitrariness under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India?
  3. Whether the principle of "no work no pay" justifies non-payment of salary without invoking the consequences of Dies-non?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner contends that having been exonerated of all charges, the period of absence due to an illegal discharge order should not be treated as Dies-non.
  • The petitioner does not dispute the penalty of stoppage of increment but challenges the legal validity of treating the absence period as Dies-non with its attendant severe consequences.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The respondents justify the penalty of stoppage of increment imposed after a departmental enquiry conducted under Rule 359 of the J&K Police Manual.
  • They argue that since the petitioner did not perform any duty during the absence period from 03.10.2000 to 07.06.2008, it was lawful to treat this period as Dies-non on the principle of no work no pay.
  • Respondent No. 5 distinguished between criminal prosecution and departmental enquiry, justifying a de novo enquiry despite the petitioner’s acquittal in criminal court.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the meaning and consequences of the term Dies-non as defined under SRO 514 dated 22.11.1999 and Article 163 of the Civil Services Regulations. Dies-non is a legal fiction whereby the period treated as such does not count for salary, pension, promotion, seniority, experience, or leave benefits. The court emphasized that invoking Dies-non has serious adverse consequences on an employee's service career and cannot be applied casually.

It was undisputed that the petitioner was acquitted of criminal charges and exonerated in the initial departmental enquiry. However, the record did not clearly show whether the charges were established in the de novo enquiry, nor was the petitioner provided a copy of that report or heard before imposing the penalty of stoppage of increments and treating the absence period as Dies-non.

The petitioner’s absence was due to an order of discharge later declared null and void by a competent civil court, meaning the absence was not unauthorized. While the principle of no work no pay justified withholding salary, treating the entire period as Dies-non was not justified because of the severe legal consequences associated with Dies-non and the absence of procedural fairness in imposing it.

The court held that the order impugned, insofar as it treated the period from 03.10.2000 to 07.06.2008 as Dies-non, was illegal, arbitrary, and violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. However, the court did not interfere with the penalty of stoppage of increments.

Holding and Implications

The court allowed the writ petition to the extent of quashing the order treating the period of absence from 03.10.2000 to 07.06.2008 as Dies-non. The petitioner is not entitled to salary for this period on the principle of no work no pay, but the severe consequences attached to Dies-non cannot be imposed.

This decision directly affects the parties by restoring the petitioner’s service benefits for the absence period except salary, but it does not set a broader precedent beyond the facts of this case.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Nazir Ahmad Baba v. State of J&K and others

    Honble Mr Justice Sanjeev Kumar, Judge Appearing Counsel: For Petitioner(s): Mr. Mohsin Qadiri, Adv. For Respondent(s): Mr. B. A. Dar, Sr. AAG.

    1. The petitioner in this petition has assailed the validity of order No. 734 of 2009 dated 11.09.2009 passed by respondent No. 4, whereby, the annual increment of the petitioner was directed to be stopped for a period of two years and the period of absence/ discharge w.e.f 03.10.2002 to 07.06.2008 was treated as dies- non.

    2. Briefly stated, the facts of the case are that the petitioner came to be appointed as Constable in the year 1998. In the course of performance of his duties, he came to be deployed to the J&K Bank Shangus as security incharge. In the year 2000, when militants attacked the aforesaid bank and looted an amount of Rs. 47920/- and took away one rifle from the Santri on duty, on the allegations of negligence and dereliction of duty, the petitioner was discharged from services by the respondent No. 4 vide his order No. 900 of 2000 dated 03.10.2000. The petitioner assailed the aforesaid order by way of a Civil Suit in the Court of Sub Judge, Anantnag. Suit was decreed in favour of the petitioner and ____________________________________________________________ SWP No. 2008/2015 MP No. 01/2015 2 | P a g e the order of discharge was declared null and void. Consequently the respondents were directed to permit the petitioner to resume his duties as constable. The petitioner was held entitled to the salary attached to the post of constable.

    3. Feeling aggrieved, the State filed an appeal before the Court of District Judge Anantnag. The District Judge Anantnag-appellate court upheld the judgement and decree of the trial court with the modification that the respondents would be free to hold a departmental enquiry into the conduct of petitioner. The petitioner also faced criminal prosecution along with other constables on duty on the date of occurrence. The petitioner along with other accused was ultimately acquitted of all the charges by the Court of Judicial Magistrate 1st Class Shangus vide its order and judgement dated 29.03.2003. The petitioner was however, subjected to the departmental enquiry taking cue from the observations made by the appellate court.

    4. The enquiry officer conducted the enquiry and recommended that the petitioner be exonerated from the charges of carelessness and negligence on the ground that on the similar charges, the criminal prosecution initiated has ended in acquittal. The recommendations made by the enquiry officer came up for consideration before the respondent No. 5, who disagreed with the findings of enquiry officer on the ground that the criminal prosecution and departmental enquiries were two different type of proceedings and, therefore, the petitioner could not have been exonerated by the enquiry officer only on the ground that the criminal prosecution against him had ended in acquittal. Accordingly, de novo enquiry was ordered and entrusted to ____________________________________________________________ SWP No. 2008/2015 MP No. 01/2015 3 | P a g e Dy. SP component Kokernag. On the basis of findings returned by the enquiry officer-the Dy. SP Kokernag and the recommendations made therein the order impugned was passed. Penalty of stoppage of annual increment for a period of two years was ordered by the respondent No. 4 to serve the petitioner as corrective in future. Simultaneously, the period of his discharge w.e.f 03.10.2000 to 07.06.2008, when he was reinstated, was treated as Dies-non. It is this order the petitioner feels aggrieved of and has challenged the same in this writ petition, in so far as it relates to treating the period from 03.10.2000 to 07.06.2008 as Dies-non, on the principle no work no pay.

    5. The petitioner challenges the order impugned to the extent aforesaid, primarily on the ground that once the petitioner was exonerated of all the charges of carelessness and negligence, there was no reason or justification to treat the period during which he remained out of service due to illegal order of discharge

    i.e. from 03.10.2000 to 07.06.2008 as dies-non. The petitioner however has not assailed the other part of order impugned so far as the penalty of stoppage of his annual increment for two years period is concerned.

    6. Per contra, the counsel for respondents justifies the other part of order by submitting that for the act of carelessness, dereliction of duty and cowardice, the petitioner was subjected to the departmental enquiry, which was conducted strictly in accordance with Rule 359 of the J&K Police manual and on the basis of the findings of the enquiry officer and the recommendations made by him, the petitioner was awarded appropriate penalty, so as to serve as corrective in future. It is ____________________________________________________________ SWP No. 2008/2015 MP No. 01/2015 4 | P a g e however submitted by the learned counsel for the respondents that since the petitioner did not perform any duty from the date of his discharge i.e. 03.10.2000 till the date of his reinstatement

    i.e. 07.06.2008, as such, the respondent No. 4, correctly, treated the period of his absence as Dies-non on the principle of no work no pay.

    7. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

    8. Before proceeding further and for appreciating the arguments of learned counsel for the parties, it would be appropriate to reproduce the provisions of SRO 514 dated 22.11.1999, whereby the Government in exercise of powers conferred by Section 124 of Constitution of Jammu and Kashmir, recast the explanation to Article 163 of Civil Services Regulations Volume 1. The word Dies-non is an abbreviated form of Dies-non Juriducus means a day on which no legal business is transacted or which is not reckoned for some particular purpose. The period which is directed to be treated as Dies-non cannot therefore be counted for service benefits otherwise available for that period. In fact, the period required or ordered to be treated as Dies-non is by way of concession for permitting the beneficiary thereof to have service in continuation of period before the beneficiary proceeded on un-authorized absence for a particular period. Literal meaning of Dies-non would boil down to mean that this period is not capable of being counted at all for purposes of possible benefits to the beneficiary. Rights which have accrued to him till the date of his proceeding on un-authorized leave or rights which may accrue to him after he is allowed to join service as a result of direction that the period of absence be treated as Dies-non remain quite intact, but no benefit whatsoever can accrue to him as a result of call it concession or legal fiction of construing the period of un-authorized absence as Dies- non under any circumstance. This period cannot count for any purpose, whatsoever. ____________________________________________________________ SWP No. 2008/2015 MP No. 01/2015 5 | P a g e Accordingly the import of the term Dies-non is that:-

    (i) It does not qualify for any remuneration (pay and allowances);

    (ii) It does not count for pension:

    (iii) It does not count for pension;

    (iv) It does not came any interruption for leave earned up to the date proceding that on which the period of Dies-non has commenced;

    (v) It does not cause any interruption for the past service qualifying for pension;

    (vi) It shall not count for experience;

    (vii) During Dies-non the concerned Govt. servent shall not be entitled for promotion;

    (viii) The concerned shall lose seniority in his cadre/category by the period which is treated as Dies-non;

    9. From the perusal of Article 163 and the explanation appended thereto in terms of SRO (supra), it is abundantly clear that Dies- non entails several consequences, in so far as the service career of an employee is concerned. Besides that, it does not qualify for any remuneration. It affects pension, increment, experience, seniority and promotion etc. Provision of Dies-non has serious consequences on the service prospectus of an employee and therefore cannot be invoked in casual manner. It is not in dispute that the petitioner was prosecuted in a criminal court, where he was acquitted of all the charges levelled against him. Even the departmental enquiry ordered by the respondent No. 4, after the discharged order was declared as null and void by the Civil Court, ended in exoneration of the petitioner from the charges levelled against him.

    10. From the perusal of record as also from the reply affidavit filed by respondent No. 4, it is not forthcoming clearly as to whether the charges of carelessness and negligence were proved against the petitioner even in the de novo enquiry conducted by Dy. SP component Kokernag. Even the copy of aforesaid report does not ____________________________________________________________ SWP No. 2008/2015 MP No. 01/2015 6 | P a g e appear to have been supplied to the petitioner nor there is anything on record to suggest that he was heard while inflicting the penalty by the respondent No. 4 in terms of the order impugned. Since the petitioner is reinstated, his relief is only restricted to treatment of his period from 03.10.2000 to 07.06.2008, as dies-non. This Court would not venture to comment on the other aspects of the matter. The adjudication in this writ petition is therefore only restricted to find out as to whether the order impugned, so far as it pertains to treating the period of absence from 03.10.2000 to 07.06.2008 as on duty, is sustainable in law or not.

    11. Indisputably the petitioner remained out of service w.e.f 03.10.2000 to 07.06.2008, but this cannot be treated as an unauthorized absence. The petitioner remained out of duty because of an order of discharge which was ultimately declared null and void by a Civil Court of competent jurisdiction. He was then reinstated on 07.06.2008 pending an enquiry into his conduct. He was exonerated in the first enquiry. However in the de novo enquiry ordered, the penalty of stoppage of increment for two years was ordered by respondent No. 4. In the given facts and circumstances, the order impugned, in so far as it pertains to treating the period of absence of the petitioner as Dies-non, is apparently illegal, arbitrary and violative of Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution. The respondent No. 4 could well justify not to disburse the salary for the period w.e.f 03.10.2000 to 07.06.2008 on the principle of no work no pay but was not justified to treat the aforesaid period as Dies-non which has serious consequences. In any case Dies-non is not one of the penalties prescribed ____________________________________________________________ SWP No. 2008/2015 MP No. 01/2015 7 | P a g e under the J&K Police Manual. The order impugned, in so far as it pertains treating the period of absence from 03.10.2000 to 07.06.2008 as Dies-non, is therefore bad in the eye of law and therefore quashed. However the petitioner shall not be entitled to the salary for the aforesaid period only on the principle of No Work No Pay. The writ petition is allowed to the aforesaid extent. No order as to costs. (Sanjeev Kumar) Judge Srinagar 01/09/2017 Ishaq

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Nazir Ahmad Baba v. State of J&K and others
    (Sep 1, 2017)