AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges

    Shri Bharat V. Patel, 13, Sandalwood Society, Race Course Circle, Baroda () v. Asstt. Cit, Cir-2, Baroda ().

    D.C Agrawal, A.M:— This is an appeal filed by the assessee raising following grounds:—

    (1) The ld. CIT(A) has erred in law and on facts in confirming the action of AO in erroneously quantifying the capital gains on redemption of Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs) granted to the appellant.

    (2) The ld. CIT(A) has erred in law and on facts in confirming the action of AO in quantifying the ‘Net Consideration’ at Rs. 7,46,44,405/- for the purpose of calculating exemption u/s. 54EA of the Act. Under the facts and circumstances of the case the ‘Net Consideration’ ought to have been calculated at Rs. 4,85,98,022/-.

    (3) The ld. CIT(A) has erred in law and on facts in taking the date of transfer of the said SARs as 15/10/1997 whereas the correct date of transfer ought to have been 20/01/1997 when the appellant actually received the sales consideration.

    (4) Alternatively and without prejudice, for the purpose of granting and quantifying exemption u/s. 54EA of the Act, the date of transfer may be taken as the date on which the appellant received the sales consideration on the sale of the said SARs.

    (5) The ld. CIT(A) has erred in law and on facts in confirming the action of AO who has not given correct and proper effect of the ITAT order and directions given therein. Both the lower authorities have erred in not appreciating the directions given in the order of the Hon. ITAT in its correct perspective.

    (6) Both the lower authorities have erred in law and on facts in not properly appreciating the considering various submissions, evidences and supporting placed on record during the course of the assessment as well as appellate proceedings and not properly appreciating various facts and law in their proper perspective.

    (7) Levy of interest u/s. 234A/B/C/D of the Act is not justified.

    2. The facts of the case are that the assessee is an individual and was employed at the relevant time in Procter and Gamble India Ltd., USA. He was Chairman and Managing Director of that company in India. During his employment, Procter and Gamble USA issued following stock appreciation rights (SARs) to the assessee:—

    Date of grant of SARs No. of shares covered in grant Feb. 26, 1991 1,700 Feb. 24, 1992 1,800 Feb. 26, 1993 3,200 Feb. 25, 1994 3,200 Feb. 28, 1995 3,600 Feb. 29, 1996 3,585

    It was explained to the AO that object of SARs was to enable the employee of the group to benefit from future appreciation in market price without requiring him to make any investment. The stock appreciation rights so issued to the assessee were extinguished on 15.10.1997 and were accordingly redeemed. On redemption of shares so granted to the assessee, assessee received a consideration of Rs. 6,80,40,727/- from Procter and Gamble of USA. The assessee sought to explain that this amount will not be taxable under section 17(2) of the Act as perquisite as there was in fact no employee and employer relationship of Procter and Gamble (P & G) USA. In fact he was employee of Procter and Gamble India Ltd. According to the assessee these SARs have been transferred as capital asset and capital gains would arise on the date of redemption. The assessee accordingly submitted computation of capital gains as under:—

    “my total capital gain on SARs is of Rs. 6,80,40,724/- out of which Rs. 1,94,42,627/- is towards short term capital gain and Rs. 4,85,98,097/- is towards long term capital gain. Against above long term capital gain, investment within the prescribed time of six months is made of Rs. 3,99,99,900/- in the scheme u/s. 54EA which may be allowed. We agree for taxation and payment of tax on above stated short term capital gain as well as balance long term capital gain as well as balance long term capital gain if any against which no appeal shall be preferred.”

    The AO, however, did not agree. He invoked Circular No. 710 dated 24.07.95 holding the receipt on redemption of shares as perquisites and taxed it accordingly. The matter traveled to the Tribunal which held that receipt of redemption of shares should be taxed under the head capital gains. In this regard we refer to para 4.1 of Tribunal's order in ITA No. 2241.Ahd/2002, Asst. Year 1998-1999 dated 27/6/2003 as under:—

    “4.1 Regarding the alternative stand of assessee that SARs acquired by assessee from Procter & Gamble, USA constitutes capital assets and no capital gain arose on redemption to SARs since they were acquired without cost. We are of the view that acceptance of SARs amount to accept the liability to pay the amount on date of allotment of SARs which also is evident from the fact that assessee got net amount i.e difference between the market price and liability to pay the amount on the date of allotment. The acquisition of SARs were not without any cost. Though nothing was actually paid at the time of acceptance of SARs but element of consideration not only include the actual payment but also the promise to pay the same and since by allotment of SARs the employee impliedly promised to pay for the cost which is also evident from the ultimate transactions under which assessee got only net amount of redemption as admitted by the ld. Counsel for the assessee before us. Thus it would be a case of acquisition of SARs with consideration. This position is further clear by the conduct of the assessee who has agreed for capital gain on the same. Not only this, assessee agreed not to file appeal against such levy of capital gain. The claim for exemption under section 54EA of the IT Act by investing the said gain in specified channel notified under section 54EA of the Act cannot be gone into at this stage as the said investment details are not on record. So the AO is directed to verify the same, of course, after providing reasonable opportunity of hearing to the assessee and allow necessary relief to the assessee under this section.”

    After the order of Tribunal the AO passed an order under section 250 giving effect to that order and worked out short term and long term capital gains and also allowed exemption under section 54EA accordingly. The AO, however, adopted the notional value of acquisition of shares as cost of acquisition and notional value of redemption as sale consideration, the difference being sum of Rs. 6,80,40,649/- paid to the assessee by P & G, USA was treated as gains on transfer/redemption of shares on which the AO worked out the capital gains as under:—

    No. SARs Rate in $ Exchange price in Rs. of one $ 6800 71.97 38.70 7200 71.97 38.70 6400 71.97 38.70 6400 71.97 38.700 26800 (total) 71.97 38.70 Net consideration = 26800 × 71.97 × 38.70 = 7,48,44,405

    Working of exemption u/s. 54EA:

    = Capital Gain amount of eligible investment u/s. 54EA within 6 months Net consideration.

    Taxable capital gain is worked out as under:

    Long term capital gain Rs. 4,85,98,021/- Exempted u/s. 54EA Rs. 2,60,41,767/- Taxable L.T.C.G Rs. 2,25,56,254/-

    3. The assessee being aggrieved went in appeal before ld. CIT(A) who confirmed the order of the AO in calculating the capital gains on the basis of notional sale consideration on redemption of the shares and not treating the net consideration as total sale consideration. According to the ld. CIT(A) at the time of allotment of SARs there was a liability to pay the amount equal to the price of the stock as on the date of allotment of SARs but the liability was deferred till date of redemption of these SARs and was adjusted/deducted out of the market price of the stock as on the date of redemption. Thus only the net amount being appreciation or gain was paid to the appellant. The net amount accordingly was capital gain and cannot be considered to be net consideration. The ld. CIT(A) also upheld the calculation of exemption under section 54EA on the basis of gross consideration being market value of the SARs at which they were redeemed. We for the sake of convenience reproduce the order of ld. CIT(A) to highlight the view he has taken:—

    “4.3 I have considered the submission of the appellant and also perused the order giving effect to the ITAT's order as well as comments of the AO. The main issue under consideration is that what is the date of transfer of SAR. The AO has taken the date of transfer as 15.10.97, whereas the appellant contends that he has received the redemption proceeds on 20.01.98 and accordingly, same should be taken as the date of transfer. The appellant has contended that there could not be any transfer of SAR and same could be and were in fact, extinguished by redemption and the redemption of SAR took place on 20.01.98 upon appellant receiving the redemption proceeds. It was further contended that the earlier date, if at all, only represented a reference date for the purpose of actual quantification of redemption right.

    On going through the various documents and details, the claim of the appellant was found to be incorrect. In fact, at page 2 of the assessment order, it has been clearly mentioned that the SARs were extinguished on 15.10.97 by Procter & Gamble Co., USA and redemption was carried out on 15.10.97 Similar fact was mentioned in the order of the CIT(A) while deciding the quantum appeal. Apart from this, it is noticed that the appellant in its written submission before the AO has furnished the details in which the date of redemption was mentioned as 15.10.97 (by typographical error, same was mentioned as 15.10.98 instead of intention of the appellant to mention the date as 15.10.97). In fact, on redemption, two cheques were issued by the P & G, USA in favour of the appellant amounting to $12,55,762.84 and $ 5,02,393.13 totaling to $ 17,58,156.33. Both the cheques were dated 24.10.97 Incidentally, the money related to these cheques were credited in the bank account of the appellant on 20.01.98 However, the date of receipt of money i.e 20.01.98 cannot be considered to be the date of transfer. As per the definition of transfer provided in section 2(47) relinquishment of asset or extinguishment of any right therein is included within the definition of “transfer” in relation to capital asset. In the present case, such date of extinguishment of right by way of redemption is undisputedly 15.10.97 It is the appellant himself who has given this date as the date of redemption while furnishing details before the AO. Accordingly, the date of transfer of capital asset as per section 2(47) will obviously be the date of extinguishment of right i.e the date of redemption i.e 15.10.97 For such redemption, the cheques were also admittedly issued by the company on 24.10.97 The date of realization of the amount will have nothing to do with the date of transfer of asset. It is a fact of common knowledge that in some of the cases, though the transfer of property takes place in some earlier date, but the sale consideration is actually given afterwards as per the mutual agreement between both the parties. But this will not and cannot change the date of transfer of the asset.

    4.4 In view of these facts, it is held that the AO has correctly taken the date of transfer of asset in the form of SAR as 15.10.97 As the investment to the extent of Rs. 86 lacs (Rs. 46 lacs + Rs. 40 lacs) has been made on 17.06.98 & 18.06.98 respectively, which is beyond six months from the date of transfer, action of the AO in not considering the aforesaid sum as eligible for deduction u/s. 54EA, is hereby confirmed.”

    4. Against this, ld. AR for the assessee submitted that assessee has not paid any consideration at the time of conferring on him SARs, therefore, he in fact not incurred any cost. Whatever net consideration he has received was accordingly invested in the specified securities for the purpose of claiming exemption under section 54EA. Once assessee has not received any gross amount calculated at Rs. 7,46,44,405/- the question of considering it for the purpose of determining exemption u/s. 54EA should not arise. Another point raised by ld. AR was that assessee has actually received the redemption money on January 20, 1998 only as under:—

    Sl. No. SAR Grant datex SAR encashed date SAR value increased Total gains exchange rate Total gain Nos. Grant price $x Enchased price $ $ 1$=Rs. In Rs. A A B C A × (A-B) 1. 26.1.91 20.1.98 6,800 20.94 71.97 47,012.84 38.7 13,429,396.9 2 24.4.92 20.1.98 7,200 25.53 71.97 334,350 38.7 12,939,345 3 26.2.93 20.1.98 6.400 25.78 71.97 295,600 38.7 11,439,720 25.2.94 28.1.98 6.400 78.41 71.97 278,800 38.7 10,789,560 48,598,021.97

    Therefore, in place of sum of Rs. 7,46,44,405/- an actual amount received should be taken at Rs. 4,85,98,022/-. According to him net consideration as contemplated in section 54EA of the Act could only mean the sum received by the assessee.

    5. The assessee was required to invest a net consideration so received which has been invested by him as under:—

    Name of the securities Amount invested Date of investment Alliance Mutual Fund Rs. 1,00,00,000/- March 18, 1998 Alliance Mutual Fund Rs. 33,33,300/- March, 18, 1998 Templeton Mutual Fund Rs. 1,00,00,000/- March 18, 1998 Templeton Growth Fund Rs. 33,33,000/- March 18, 1998 Birla Mutual Fund Rs. 1,00,00,000/- March 18, 1998 Birla Mutual Fund (Advantage) Rs. 33,33,000/- March 18, 1998 UTI Bonds 46,00,000/- June 17, 1998 ICICI Mutual Fund Rs. 40,00,000/- June 17, 1998 Total Rs. 4,85,99,900/-

    Thus the period of 6 months as required for allowing exemption under section 54EA should be reckoned from 20 January, 1998 and not 15 October, 1997.

    6. On the other hand, ld. DR submitted that computation done by AO is correct and in accordance with the directions of the Tribunal. The Tribunal has considered that acquisition of stock by the assessee was not without consideration and, therefore, sale proceeds has to be computed by including cost of acquisition plus net amount received by the assessee as done by the AO.

    7. Regarding date of redemption ld. DR submitted that once shares are redeemed on 15 October, 1997 then period of six months for exemption under section 54EA should be reckoned from this date. It is immaterial when assessee actually received the consideration, in cash.

    8. We have considered the rival submissions and perused the material on record. In our considered view there are two issues involved in the present appeal. One is what should be the net consideration, whether the net amount received by the assessee or the market value of SARs which comprised of net amount received by the assessee plus cost of acquisition (which was in fact not paid by the assessee and was finally deducted by the P & G USA from market value of SARs). This issue is settled by the Tribunal in its order dated 27.6.2003 out of which we made a reference as above. It is held therein that it is a case of acquisition of SARs with consideration. The Tribunal held that even nothing was actually paid at the time of acceptance of SARs but the element of consideration not only includes actual payment but also the promise to pay the sum. At the time of allotment of SARs, the employee impliedly promised to pay for the cost. In fact the Tribunal had restored the matter only for the purpose of computation of exemption under section 54EA and not for determining what should be the net consideration. The issue is already settled by the Tribunal in their earlier order in the case of the assessee, which we have referred to. Accordingly we hold that the net consideration will include the amount received in cash by the assessee and the amount deducted by the P & G, USA as cost of allotment of SARs. Accordingly this part of the ground of assessee is rejected.

    9. The second issue is as from which date computation of six months should be reckoned. In our considered view the authorities below were justified in treating October 15, 1997 as date of redemption of shares and to reckon the period of six months there-from. It is a case of transfer of stocks by book entries on that date and therefore, the period of six months has to be reckoned from the date of transfer. Accordingly this part of the ground of assessee is rejected. We accordingly uphold the orders of authorities below. The appeal filed by the assessee is therefore, dismissed.

    10. In the result, the appeal filed by the assessee is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shri Bharat V. Patel... v. Asstt. Cit, Cir-2, B...
    (Sep 24, 2010)