U.T Shah, J.M:— The only point involved in this appeal pertains to the taxability of City Compensatory Allowance (CCA) received by the assessee.
2. The assessee is an individual and is a government servant. The assessment year is 1984-85 and the relevant previous year ended on 31-3-1984.
3. In his return of income as well as at the time of assessment proceedings, the assessee claimed that the C.C.A allowance of Rs. 900 received by him was not taxable. The ITO, however, negatived the assessee's contention, in the following manner:
“Assessee has received CCA. of Rs. 900 and claimed exemption. In view of s. 10(14) of the IT Act, 1961 and Explanation inserted CCA. is taxable.
As per Explanation any allowance granted to the assessee to meet his personal expenses at the place where the duties of his office or employment of profit are ordinarily performed by him or at the place where he ordinarily resides shall not be regarded, for the purpose of this clause, as a special allowance granted to meet expenses wholly, necessarily and exclusively incurred in the performance of duties,”
4. In appeal, relying on the AAC's order in his own case, it was urged by the assessee that CCA was not exigible to tax. Following the order of his predecessor, the AAC accepted the assessee's contention and directed the ITO “to allow the appellant's claim regarding CCA. The appellant gets relief of Rs. 900.”.
5. Being aggrieved by the order of the AAC, the revenue has come up in appeal before the Tribunal. The assessee has filed written submissions as he is now posted at Bangalore. Inviting our attention to the Explanation inserted in s. 10(14) by the Finance Act, 1975 with retrospective effect from 1-4-1962, the ld. representative for the department submitted that the AAC was not justified in accepting the assessee's submission and directing the ITO to delete Rs. 900 from the total income of the assessee. In this connection, he also invited our attention to the relevant note on clauses of Finance Bill, 1975, (1975) 98 ITR 197 (St) as well as relevant paragraph viz. paragraph 58 of the Memorandum explaining the provisions in the Finance Bill, 1975, (1975) 98 ITR 197 (St) and submitted that the said Explanation was inserted in s. 10(14) of the Act, w ith a view to over come the decision of the Hon'ble Bombay High Court in the case of CIT v. D.R Pathak (1975) 99 ITR 14 (Bom). He also submitted that the decision in the case of Bishambar Dayal v. CIT (1976) 103 ITR 313 (MP) would also not be any help to the assessee as in that case, the Hon'ble Madhya Pradesh High Court had construed the relevant article of the Constitution of India under which High Court judges are appointed. He also submitted that the decision of the Hon'ble Gujarat High Court in the case of CIT v. S.G Pgnatale (1980) 16 CTR (Guj) 337 : (1980) 124 ITR 391 (Guj), would also not help the assessee, as in that case, the Hon'ble High Court had held that “living allowances” received by the assessee were not “perquisites” which could fall within the provisions of s. 17(ii) of the Act. He, therefore, urged that in view of the clear provisions of the Explanation to s. 10(14) of the Act, the ITO was fully justified in including Rs. 900 in the total income of the assessee. To a query raised by the Bench as to whether any appeal was preferred against the order of the AAC in respect of the asst. yr. 1981-82, the ld. representative for the department stated that no such appeal was preferred because of “low tax effect”. However, he hastened to state that since the point involved in the present appeal would have effect on innumerable assessments of salaried tax payers, the department has filed the present appeal with a view to obtain the opinion of the Tribunal.
6. With a view to complete our order, we would reproduce below the written submissions filed by the assessee:
“The issue involved is the taxability of the City Compensatory Allowance.
Similar issue has been decided in my favour by the ld. AAC for asst. yr. 1981-82 vide his order No. VI-B/109/81-82. dt. 11-8-1983. It appears the said decision has not yet been set aside.
My case in brief is detailed below:
Compensatory Allowance means an allowance granted to meet personal expenditure necessitated by the special circumstances in which the duty is performed. In CIT v. Dr. Pathak (1975) 99 ITR 14 (Bom) it was clearly held that a city compensatory allowance is not “perquisite” (see page 18). It is therefore, not coming within the meaning of the term ‘salary’. In other words a compensatory allowance is not an ‘income’ at all (see (1976) 103 ITR 313 (MP) and (1975) 99 ITR 14 (Bom). Since the said allowance is not chargeable to tax at all, claiming exemption in respect thereof under s. 10 (14) of the Act or denial of exemption by referring to Explanation to that section brought on Statute Book by Finance Act, 1975 with retrospective effect from 1962 does not arise at all.
Further, as an analogous case the decision of Gujarat High Court in the case of CIT v. S.G Pgnatale (1980) 16 CTR (Guj) 337 : (1980) 124 ITR 391 (Guj) may also please be referred to. In the said case payment of living allowance, which is in the nature of-compensatory allowance, was held as not liable to be assessed. On the same reasoning City Compensatory Allowance paid is not part of salary or income otherwise chargeable under the Act. City Compensatory Allowance of Rs. 900 is accordingly claimed as not liable for assessment and hence exempt.”
7. We have carefully considered the rival submissions of the parties and in our opinion, in view of the insertion of the Explanation to s. 10(14) of the Act, the stand taken by the revenue is unassailable. The decision of the Hon'ble Bombay High Court in the case of D.R Pathak (supra) is so well known decision that we do not find it necessary to refer it in our order only in view of the subsequent amendment made in s. 10(14; of the Act. Paragraph 58 of the Memorandum explaining the provisions of the Finance Bill, 1975 has a great relevance in this connection and therefore, the same is reproduced below:
“58. Certain allowance not to qualify for exemption under s. 10(14) of the Income-tax Act. Under s. 10(14) of the Income-tax Act, any special allowance or benefit (not being in the nature of entertainment allowance or other perquisite) specifically granted to meet expenses wholly, necessarily and exclusively incurred in the performance of the duties of an office or employment of profit is exempt from income-tax, to the extent such expenses are actually incurred for that purpose. In a recent decision in the case of Commissioner of Income-tax, Bombay v. D.R Pathak, the Bombay High Court has held that Compensatory (City) Allowance paid to compensate Government servants for the extra expenditure which they are called upon to bear by reason of their posting at a particular place is exempt from income-tax under s. 10(14) of the Income-tax Act. The decision of the Bombay High Court has far-reaching implications. Compensatory (City) allowance has been charged to tax in the assessments of salaried taxpayers made in the past. If the decision of the Bombay High court is followed, innumerable assessments of salaried taxpayers made during the last several years would have to be rectified. This would generate enormous administrative work and would also entail refund of crores of rupees paid as income-tax attributable to the Compensatory (City) Allowance included in computing the taxable income. Besides, the ratio decidendi of the decision of the Bombay High Court could also lead to considerable abuse by employers collusively describing a substantial part of the remuneration paid to favoured employees as being in the nature of compensatory city allowance. With a view to getting over the difficulty arising from the interpretation placed by the Bombay High Court on the provisions of s. 10(14) of the Income-tax Act, the Bill seeks to make a retrospective amendment in the Income-tax Act with effect from 1st April, 1962 (i.e the date from which that Act came into force) to clarify that any allowance (other than house rent allowance which is exempt from income-tax under s. 10(13)A of the Income-tax Act) granted to a person to meet his personal expenses at the place where he ordinarily resides will not be regarded, for the purposes of s. 10(14) of the Act, as a special allowance granted to meet expenses wholly, necessarily and exclusively incurred in the performance of the duties.”
8. It would appear from the above that the Explanation to s. 10(14) of the Act, has been brought on the statute retrospectively from 1-4-1962, with a view to over come “far-reaching implications” of the decision in the case of D.R Pathak (supra). We are aware of the hardship which a taxpayer like the present assessee has to face. But in view of the clear provisions contained in the Explanation to s. 10(14) of the Act, it is not possible to decide the point at issue in favour of the assessee. In this connection, the following observations made by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Smt. Tarulata Shyam v. CIT 1977 CTR (SC) 275 : (1977) 108 ITR 345 (SC), are very illuminative:
“We have given anxious thought to the persuasive arguments of Mr. Sharma. His arguments, if accepted, will certainly soften the rigour of this extremely drastic provision and bring it more in conformity with logic and equity. But the language of ss. 2(6A)(e) and 12(1B) is clear and unambiguous. There is no scope for importing into the statute words which are not there. Such importation would be, not to construe, but to amend the statute. Even if there be a casus omissus, the defect can be remedied only by legislation and not by judicial interpretation.
To us, there appears no justification to depart from the normal rule of construction according to which the intention of the legislature is primarily to be gathered from the words used in the statute. It will be well to recall the words of Rowlatt J. in Cape Brandy Syndicate v. Inland Revenue Commissioners (1921) 1 KB 64 (KB) at 71, that:
“….in a Taxing Act one has to look merely at what is clearly said. There is no room for any intendment. There is no equity about a tax. There is no presumption as to a tax. Nothing is to be read in, nothing is to be implied. One can only look fairly at the language used.”
9. Once it is shown that the case of the assessee comes within the letter of the law, he must be taxed, however great the hardship may appear to the judicial mind to be.”
10. Further, we find from the definition of “Compen satory Allowance” mentioned in the Fundamental Rules and Supplementary Rules issued by the Govern ment, that the Compensatory Allowance means “an allowance granted to meet personal expenditure neces sitated by the special circumstances in which duty is performed………….”. Now, if we look to the Explana tion to s. 10(14) of the Act, which reads as under:
“Explanation : For the removal of doubts, it is hereby declared that any allowance granted to the assessee to meet his personal expenses at the place where the duties of his office or employment of profit are ordinarily performed by him or at the place where he ordinarily resides shall not be regarded, for the purposes of this clause, as a special aliowance granted to meet expenses wholly, necessarily and exclusively incurred in the performance of such duties :”
(Underlining. italicized in print, supplied)
11. It is quite clear that the Compensatory Allowance mentioned in the Fundamental Rules and Supplementary Rules fully fits in the said Explanation. In this view of the matter, in our opinion, the AAC was not justified in accepting the assessee's contention and deleting Rs. 900 from the total income of the assessee. We would, therefore, set aside the order of the AAC and restore that of the ITO on this point.
12. In the result, the appeal is allowed.