Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2018 INSC 271
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2018 INSC 271
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Muthulakshmi (Accused 4) married Murugan on 5-2-1999 after a police-brokered settlement of an earlier complaint filed because Murugan initially refused to marry her. Post-marriage, quarrels erupted between the two families, culminating in Accused 4 leaving the matrimonial home. On 4-8-1999 two separate but connected murders occurred:

  • Murder of Murugan: Ponnu (A-1), Ganapathi (A-2) and Chitravelu (A-3) allegedly attacked Murugan in a public street-hotel. A-2 stabbed him in the chest with a knife; A-3 hacked him with a sickle; A-1 instigated the attack. Murugan died on the spot while his father (PW-1) and brother (PW-2) watched.
  • Murder of Poomari: Later that day, the same three accused and Muthulakshmi (A-4) confronted Murugan’s sister, Poomari, near a well. A-3 cut her with a sickle; A-2 stabbed her stomach; A-4, handed the sickle by A-3, inflicted additional blows. Ten-year-old Sakunthala (PW-3), daughter of Poomari, witnessed the killing.

The police registered Crime No. 72/99, conducted investigation, seized weapons and other material objects, and forwarded the case to the Court of Session. After a full trial, the Sessions Court convicted all four accused. On appeal, the Madras High Court acquitted A-1 but affirmed the convictions of A-2, A-3 and A-4. The present special-leave appeals were filed by A-2, A-3 and A-4 in the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the evidence of related eyewitnesses (PWs 1 & 2) could be safely relied upon in the absence of independent public witnesses for Murugan’s murder.
  2. Whether the testimony of a ten-year-old child witness (PW-3) in Poomari’s murder was credible in light of a school attendance register and the testimony of the school headmaster (DW-1) claiming she was in school at the time.
  3. Whether the High Court erred in acquitting A-1 but sustaining the convictions of A-2 to A-4 on the same set of eyewitness accounts.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • PWs 1 and 2 are interested witnesses (father and brother of the deceased) and their evidence should not have been relied upon, particularly when the High Court did not trust them against A-1.
  • The murder of Murugan occurred in a public place, yet no independent witnesses were produced.
  • For A-4, reliance on PW-3’s testimony was misplaced because DW-1 and the school attendance register (Ext. D-1) showed the child was present in school, contradicting her claim of witnessing the crime.

State's Arguments

  • Supported the concurrent findings of the trial court and High Court, asserting that the eyewitness testimonies were natural, consistent and corroborated by medical evidence.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Rajasthan v. Kalki (1981) 2 SCC 752 Distinction between “related” and “interested” witnesses; a natural eyewitness from the family is not disqualified merely by relationship. Used to validate reliance on the testimonies of PWs 1 & 2 despite their relationship to the deceased.
Maranadu v. State (2008) 16 SCC 529 Relationship alone does not impair credibility; a relative is unlikely to falsely implicate an innocent person absent a demonstrated motive. Reinforced the Court’s acceptance of the related witnesses’ evidence and rejection of the plea of false implication.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court undertook a two-pronged analysis:

  1. Credibility of Related Witnesses (PWs 1 & 2): Adopting the principles in Kalki and Maranadu, the Court held that relationship does not equate to interestedness. Their testimonies were consistent, corroborated by medical evidence, and no motive for false implication was proved.
  2. Credibility of Child Witness (PW-3): The attendance register showed every student marked “present” over seven months, indicating unreliable record-keeping. Hence DW-1’s evidence did not undermine PW-3’s ocular account, which aligned with the post-mortem findings for Poomari.

The Court also noted the clear motive arising from prior family disputes and a challenge allegedly issued the previous day at the police station. Hostile independent witnesses (PWs 5 & 6) did not weaken the prosecution case because their hostility was explained and the remaining evidence met the standard of proof beyond reasonable doubt.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS DISMISSED. The convictions and life sentences of Accused 2, 3 and 4 are affirmed.

Implications: The decision reinforces the principle that credible testimony of related or child witnesses, when corroborated by medical and surrounding evidence, is sufficient for conviction even absent independent eyewitnesses. No new legal doctrine was created; the Court applied existing precedent to the facts.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Ganapathi And Another v. State Of Tamil Nadu .

    N.V. Ramana, J.— These appeals by way of special leave petitions arise out of a judgment dated 20-2-2007 passed by a Division Bench of the Madras High Court, Bench at Madurai in Ponnu v. State 2007 SCC OnLine Mad 1426. By the said judgment, the High Court confirmed the conviction and sentence imposed by the trial court against the appellants herein, while acquitting Accused 1 of the charges levelled against him. Criminal Appeal No. 1312 of 2008 is preferred by Accused 2 and 3 and the appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 1313 of 2008 is Accused 4. As the order impugned in both the appeals is one and the same, we propose to deal with both the appeals by way of a common order.

    2. Briefly stated, the prosecution case is that Muthulakshmi (Accused 4 — appellant herein) had love affair with one Murugan, son of PW 1—Armugam. When the said Murugan refused to marry her, a complaint was lodged in Kovilpatty Police Station and with the intervention of villagers and police, their marriage was solemnised on 5-2-1999. Ever since their marriage had taken place, there were frequent quarrels and rifts between both the families leading to strained relations between the couple. Petchimuthu, the father of A-4 had even lodged a complaint against his son-in-law—Murugan, his father (PW 1) and sister (Poomari) as she was held to be the root cause for all disturbances between the couple. Police had called the couple and advised them to live together peacefully, but after some days, Muthulakshmi (A-4) came out of her matrimonial home and returned to her parental home.

    3. On 4-8-1999, Ponnu (A-1), Ganapathi (A-2) and Chitravelu (A-3) carrying deadly weapons, spotted Murugan near a street hotel and attacked him. While Ponnu (A-1) instigated the other two accused to hack Murugan, Ganapathi (A-2) stabbed Murugan with a knife on the chest and Chitravelu (A-3) had inflicted cut injuries with a sickle on Murugan leading to his instantaneous death on the spot. The assailants then fled away from the scene of offence. Father of the deceased—PW 1 (Armugam) and PW 2 (Poomurugan—another son of Armugam) who were standing nearby had witnessed the occurrence.

    4. While that being so, on the same day when Poomari (daughter of Armugam—PW 1) along with her daughter Sakunthala (PW 3) went to a nearby well for washing clothes and taking bath, the four accused, appeared there and attacked Poomari in front of her daughter. Chitravelu (A-3) inflicted cut injuries on Poomari with a sickle and Ganapathi (A-2) stabbed thrice with knife in her stomach causing her intestine to come out of her stomach. After that Chitravelu (A-3) gave the sickle to Muthulakshmi (A-4) and instigated her to attack Poomari. Muthulakshmi then inflicted cut injuries on the head, hand and face near nose of Poomari with the sickle, and Poomari had died on the spot. PW 3 (Sakunthala), daughter of Poomari, a ten-year-old school-going child, who was present at the scene, had witnessed the crime.

    5. On the complaint of PW 1 (Ext. P-1), Ottapidaram Police Station registered Crime Case No. 72/99 against the accused under Section 302 IPC and conducted investigation. The Investigating Officer visited the spots, conducted inquest (Ext. P-31), prepared observation mahazars (Exts. P-2 and P-3) and sketches of scenes of death (Exts. P-27 and P-29), recovered bloodstained earth and normal earth, severed hair-locks, mangalsuthra and other incriminating articles from the scene of offence in the presence of witnesses and obtained their signatures. Other formalities such as recording of statements of witnesses and sending the bodies of the deceased for post-mortem were followed. The accused were arrested on 5-8-1999 at 5.30 a.m. on Velayuthapuram Junction at Ottapidaram Cross Roads and the police seized weapons from them that were used in the crime and sent the same for chemical examination. The case was then committed to the Court of Session and their statements recorded under Section 313 CrPC the accused pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.

    6. In order to bring home the guilt of the accused, the prosecution has relied on as many as 21 witnesses and marked Exts. P-1 to P-31 and there were 27 material objects. On the defence side, a school headmaster was examined as witness and marked Ext. D-1.

    7. The trial court, after undertaking a full-fledged trial, found the accused guilty and convicted accused Ponnu (A-1) under Sections 302/34 IPC sentenced to undergo life imprisonment and imposed a fine of Rs 500, in default, to further suffer six months' imprisonment. Ganapathi (A-2) and Chitravelu (A-3) were awarded life imprisonment under Section 302 IPC (two counts) with a fine of Rs 1000, in default, to suffer six months' imprisonment further. However, their sentence on each count was directed to run concurrently. Muthulakshmi (A-4) was sentenced to undergo life imprisonment under Section 302 IPC with a fine of Rs 500, and in default, to suffer further imprisonment of six months.

    8. The aggrieved accused approached the High Court by way of appeal. By the judgment impugned herein, the High Court set aside the conviction and sentence against Accused 1 and affirmed the conviction and sentence awarded by the trial court against Accused 2 to 4. Being dissatisfied with the judgments of the courts below, the appellants are before us. As the State has not preferred any appeal against acquittal of A-1, we are only concerned with the appeals arising out of conviction.

    9. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and carefully gone through the entire material on record.

    10. The contentious arguments as advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the appellants are that the courts below have erred in giving undue importance to the evidence of PWs 1 and 2 who are interested witnesses as they are father and brother, respectively, of the deceased and they are in inimical terms with the accused. The High Court though disbelieved their evidence against Accused 1, yet relied on their evidence for sustaining the conviction and sentence of Accused 2 and 3, the appellants herein. The prosecution case cannot be believed for the simple reason that the alleged incident in respect of deceased Murugan had taken place at a hotel, which is a public place, but there was no independent witness to the incident. As regards the case of Accused 4, the wife of deceased Murugan, the learned counsel vehemently contended that the courts below committed a grievous error by giving weight to the evidence of PW 3—the ten-year-old daughter of the deceased Poomari while disbelieving the evidence of Ponraj (DW 1), the Headmaster of the school where PW 3 was studying, who deposed that the girl child was present in the school at the time of occurrence and supported his claim with Ext. D-1, the attendance register of the school wherein it was clearly shown that the student was present in the school.

    11. The learned counsel appearing for the State, however, supported the view taken by the High Court in affirming the conviction and sentence awarded by the trial court against Accused 2 to 4—the appellants herein.

    12. Having given our thoughtful consideration to the submissions made by the respective learned counsel, we have perused the material on record in the light of facts and circumstances of the case. There is no denial of the fact that the marriage between the deceased Murugan and accused—Muthulakshmi did not take place in a cordial atmosphere and there were strained relations between the couple and their families as well. About a month after her marriage, Accused 4 came out of her matrimonial home and due to that fact, the other accused persons (brothers of A-4) developed grudge against Murugan and his sister—Poomari, who was alleged to be the root cause of disturbances between the couple. Thus, the motive to commit the crime on the part of the accused is quite clear inasmuch as on the previous day of occurrence also, the parties met at the police station and the accused had a heated discussion with the victims and laid a challenge to finish both Murugan and his sister Poomari.

    13. The evidence of ocular witnesses, PWs 1 and 2, father and brother of the deceased, clearly exhibits the way in which the accused took away the life of deceased Murugan. Their evidence narrates the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt and corroborates with that of the medical evidence. Dr Danraj (PW 12) who conducted the post-mortem on the body of deceased Murugan, had pointed out as many as 10 cut injuries out of which Injuries 1, 2, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10 are fatal which were possible by sickle and capable of causing death whereas Injuries 7 and 9 were possible by knife. It appears that there were two independent witnesses (PWs 5 and 6) projected by the prosecution, but they have turned hostile. In several cases, only the family members are present at the time of incident, then the case of the prosecution will be based only on their evidence. When their evidence is the only evidence available, the courts should be cautious and meticulously evaluate the evidence in the process of trial and we are not able to appreciate the contention on behalf of the accused that the non-examination of independent witnesses and conviction based on the evidence of family members is fatal to the case of the prosecution.

    14. “Related” is not equivalent to “interested”. A witness may be called “interested” only when he or she derives some benefit from the result of a litigation; in the decree in a civil case, or in seeing an accused person punished. A witness who is a natural one and is the only possible eyewitness in the circumstances of a case cannot be said to be “interested” [See: State of Rajasthan v. Kalki (1981) 2 SCC 752].

    15. Merely because the eyewitnesses are family members their evidence cannot per se be discarded. When there is allegation of interestedness, the same has to be established. Mere statement that being relatives of the deceased they are likely to falsely implicate the accused cannot be a ground to discard the evidence which is otherwise cogent and credible. Relationship is not a factor to affect credibility of a witness. It is more often than not that a relation would not conceal actual culprit and make allegations against an innocent person. Foundation has to be laid if plea of false implication is made [See: Maranadu v. State (2008) 16 SCC 529].

    16. Here in the case, PWs 1 and 2, though father and brother of the deceased, are natural witnesses and there is no bar in law in examining family members or any other person as witnesses. Their testimonies provided clear picture of the attack carried on by the accused over the deceased. We find from the record that the evidence of PWs 1 & 2 is consistent and inspires confidence in the mind of the Court. The courts below have also properly scrutinised their evidence before taking them into account and there is nothing unusual in believing their testimonies. Apart from that, the prosecution has examined the independent witnesses PWs 5 and 6 who turned hostile. The prosecution has taken all possible steps to bring home the guilt of the accused. Hence conviction based on the evidence of PWs 1 and 2 is not fatal to the case of the prosecution.

    17. Similarly, the evidence of Sakunthala (PW 3) clearly depicted the circumstance and narrated the way in which the deceased Poomari was attacked by the accused explaining the role played by each of the Accused 2, 3 and 4. Her evidence has credibility and it clearly corroborated with that of the medical evidence. The post-mortem report of the deceased Poomari (Ext. P-16) shows that there were about 10 cut injuries besides three stab injuries on the body of the deceased. According to PW 12 Dr Danraj, the cut injuries were possible by sickle and the stab injuries were possibly caused by knife. Among all those injuries, Injuries 1, 10, 11, 12 and 13 are grave and capable of causing death instantaneously.

    18. The argument of the learned counsel for the accused that the courts below erred in disbelieving the evidence of DW 1, cannot be accepted for the reason that it is manifest on record that all the students were marked as present in the attendance register (Ext. D-1) of the school in which PW 3 was studying, for a continuous period of seven months i.e. from June 1999 to December 1999, and there was not even a single absentee. Thus it is indicative of the fact that irrespective of the fact whether the students have attended the school or not, attendance was marked to all the students. In those circumstances, neither the evidence of DW 1 nor Ext. D-1 will come to the rescue of the accused and on this count, the evidence of PW 3 cannot be disbelieved.

    19. Giving our consideration to the circumstances in totality, we cannot find fault with the view taken by the High Court in convicting the accused whose guilt has been proved beyond reasonable doubt. For all the foregoing reasons, we are of the considered opinion that there is no error in appreciation of evidence or any error of law in the judgment passed by the High Court. Therefore, we are not inclined to interfere with the impugned judgment. The appeals are, therefore, dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ganapathi And Another v. State Of Tamil Nadu .
    (Mar 27, 2018)