(Pronounced by Hon'ble Mr. Justice A. Arumughaswamy, Member (J)) On 5.1.2017, the matter was admitted and notices directed to be issued and time granted for filing reply. Learned counsel for the applicant produces proof of service. Hence, we proceed in the matter.
2. The applicant has filed the O.A. seeking the following relief:- to direct the respondents to pass the reasoned speaking order in the matter of Charge Memorandum No. 130806/FY/64/15/E!D dated 21.10.11 within a period of four weeks.
3. The case of the applicant is that he is presently working as Asst. Engineer (Civil), Asst. Commander Works Engineer Building and Roads Addl. Asst. Director in the office of Commander Works Engineer, Wellington, The Nilgirs. It is stated that he served at Garrison Engineer (Independent), Factory Avadi Chennai from the period from April 2007 to January 2010. He was issued with two independent Charge Memos dated 23.06.2011 bearing No. 130806/FY/57 /E1D and dated 30.09.2011 bearing No. 130806/57/45/E1D by the 2nd respondent. Applicant preferred O.A. No. 967/2011 challenging the Charge Memo dated 23.06.2011, which was quashed by the Tribunal by its order 29.7.2011. Pursuant to the directions of the Tribunal, 2nd respondent issued fresh Charge Memo dated 30.9.2011 without cancelling the earlier charge memo dated 23.6.2011. Inquiry proceedings commenced on 05.09.2012.
4. Applicant preferred a representation dated 28.2.2013 and 07.06.2013 before the 1st respondent/ Statutory Disciplinary Authority. Pending disposal of the said representations, the inquiry officer had completed the inquiry proceedings and submitted combined inquiry report before the 2nd respondent on 24.7.2013. Based on the enquiry report, the 2nd respondent awarded minor penalty for Charge memo dated 21.10.2011 by order dated 30.12.2013 and cancelled the charge memo dated 30.09.2011.
5. Applicant preferred an appeal before the appropriate appellate authority dated 24.2.2014. When the same was pending, Applicant filed O.A. N. 497/2014, which was disposed of with a direction to decide the appeal within a period of six weeks. Subsequently, C.P. No.110/2014 was filed, in which the Tribunal by order dated 09.4.2014 modified the order passed in O.A. No. 497/2014 and directed the applicant to prefer the appeal before the 1st respondent. In pursuance of the same, applicant preferred an appeal to the 1st respondent, who by order dated 3.6.2015 set aside the penalty imposed by the 2nd respondent by order dated 30.12.2013 in the charge memo dated 21.10.2011 and remitted the case back to the 2nd respondent for re-conducting the enquiry from the earlier stage of enquiry proceedings.
6. Pursuant to the directions of the 1st respondent, 2nd respondent appointed inquiry officer and presenting officer by an order dated 14.8.2015. The applicant was summoned for the enquiry proceedings on 20.11.2015. He requested for enlisted documents of the charge memo and additional documents to said case of inquiry proceedings. The applicant preferred a representation dated 13.2.2016 before the 2nd respondent, which has not been disposed of till date. In the mean time inquiry officer completed the enquiry. Enquiry report of the inquiry officer dated 28.06.2016 was received by the 2nd respondent and copy of the same was served to the applicant by 2nd respondents letter dated 18.08.2016. The original was served to the applicant later on 01.09.2016. Applicant submitted his reply on 15.09.2016 to the charge memos dated 30.09.2011 and 21.10.2011 but no decision has been taken by the respondents even-after a lapse of two months. Hence he filed the instant O.A. seeking the aforesaid relief.
7. Learned counsel for the applicant submits that the applicant would be satisfied at this stage, if a direction is given to the disciplinary authority to pass orders on the inquiry report within a time frame.
8. In view of the limited relief sought, the O.A. is disposed of with a direction to the respondents to pass an order on the inquiry report within a period of three months from the date of receipt of copy of this order. There shall be no order as to costs. (R. RAMANUJAM) (JUSTICE A. ARUMUGHASWAMY) MEMBER(A) Member (J) 14.02.2017 asvs.
1 of 4