Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Bench: Ranbir Singh, Member (A) and Sanjeev Kaushik, Member (J). Place: Chandigarh. Dated: 12.8.2013.

The applicants are Group C employees of Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (BSNL) in the Jammu & Kashmir Circle who challenged notifications and the respondents' policy regarding recruitment to the post of Junior Accounts Officer (JAO). Recruitment to the post is governed by recruitment rules which require qualifying both JAO Part-I and JAO Part-II examinations. The respondents initiated recruitment processes beginning with a notification dated 12.10.2004 which retained the old syllabus as a one-time relaxation while indicating that it would be the last examination under the old syllabus.

A number of candidates sought relaxation in the residency/experience requirement (from 10 to 5 years). The process that was started in 2004 was completed in 2007. A letter dated 24.8.2009 (Annexure A-8) called for JAO Part-II Internal Competitive Examination against 40% quota which was held on 30.11.2009 and 2.12.2009. Subsequently, BSNL issued a notification dated 3.9.2012 (Annexure A-1) to hold JAO Part-II Internal Competitive Examination against the 40% quota but limited consideration to candidates who had failed JAO Part-II in the 2009 examination (conducted pursuant to the 2004 notification). The applicants challenge the 2012 notifications and seek directions for holding JAO Part-I examination for candidates who became eligible during the period 2007–2012, contending that the one-time relaxation should not be applied perpetually and that eligible candidates who became so after 2004/2007 have been deprived of a chance.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the notifications dated 3.9.2012 (Annexure A-1) and 18.9.2012 (Annexure A-2) restricting the JAO Part-II Internal Competitive Examination to only those candidates who had failed the earlier examination (2009/2007 process) are legally valid.
  2. Whether the one-time relaxation in eligibility (reduction of residency/experience requirement from 10 to 5 years) granted earlier can be continued or applied in 2012, or whether that relaxation was limited to the earlier process and cannot be extended indefinitely.
  3. Whether the respondents were required to conduct JAO Part-I examination against the 40% quota for candidates who became eligible during the period 2007–2012 and to consider such candidates for promotion/appointment with consequential benefits.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicants' Arguments

  • The one-time relaxation granted earlier (reduction of residency/experience from 10 to 5 years) was intended only for the earlier process and cannot be used perpetually to allow the same set of failed candidates to remain eligible for future vacancies.
  • Candidates who became eligible after 2004 (including those who acquired 10 years' service subsequently) should be given the opportunity to appear in the JAO Part-I examination; no JAO Part-I exam has been conducted regularly since 2004.
  • Restricting consideration to candidates who failed earlier is discriminatory, arbitrary and against natural justice, as it deprives newly eligible candidates of promotion opportunities.
  • Vacancies remaining unfilled as a result of the 2009 examination should be treated as vacancies for 2012 and be filled after providing chances to all eligible candidates under the relaxed criteria who became eligible thereafter.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The reduction in eligibility requirement from 10 to 5 years was granted as a one-time measure in response to representations from associations and unions and with the approval of the competent authority.
  • No further relaxation was intended beyond the one-time measure; the JAO Part-I examination originally scheduled for January 2004 had been deferred and the one-time relaxation was given because that was the last examination under the old pattern.
  • Candidates who had qualified JAO Part-I or the screening test (or had subject-wise exemptions) were eligible to appear in the main (Part-II) examination; screening-test-qualified candidates were being given a second attempt in accordance with BSNL guidelines and the scheme/syllabus dated 13.8.2002.
  • The applicants in the present O.A. were not eligible to appear in the present examination because they were neither JAO Part-I qualified nor screening-test-qualified; there was no discrimination as the relaxation was granted after representations and with competent authority approval.
  • Any interference with the departmental competitive examination scheme would defeat the purpose of a competitive process; the demands of the applicants (e.g., conducting a screening test before main exam) were described as arbitrary and baseless by respondents.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ujagar Sugar Works Ltd. v. Delhi Administration & Others, (2001) 3 SCC 635 Courts ordinarily do not interfere with executive policy decisions unless such policy is vitiated by mala fide, unreasonableness, arbitrariness or unfairness. The court relied on this authority to explain that a tribunal should not substitute its judgment for a policy decision of the executive and that interference is permissible only upon clear proof of arbitrariness or mala fide; finding none, the court declined to interfere with the respondents' policy decision.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court characterized the dispute as primarily a matter of policy and administrative discretion concerning relaxation in qualification of experience. It observed that the relaxation had been granted on representations from a specific class of employees and with the involvement of employee unions, constituting a policy decision taken by the competent authority after considering relevant factors.

Applying the principle (as cited in Ujagar Sugar Works Ltd. v. Delhi Administration) that courts and tribunals will not ordinarily interfere with policy decisions of the executive unless shown to be mala fide, arbitrary, unreasonable or unfair, the court examined the record for any such vitiating elements. The court concluded that there was no evidence of arbitrariness or mala fide in the respondents' decision to grant a one-time relaxation or in the manner it was applied for the internal competitive examination process.

The court further noted institutional limits: a tribunal is not equipped to substitute its view for the policy judgment of the executive authority. It also observed that none of the beneficiaries of the policy decision were parties to the proceedings, and it would therefore be improper to make an order adverse to their interests. Given these considerations and the absence of a showing of mala fide or arbitrariness, the court declined to invalidate the impugned administrative policy or notifications.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Original Application (O.A.) is DISMISSED for lack of merit. The court found no arbitrariness or mala fide in the respondents' policy decision and therefore refused relief sought by the applicants. No costs were awarded.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The applicants' challenge to the notifications and the request for directions to conduct JAO Part-I examinations for those who became eligible during 2007–2012 was refused; the reliefs sought in paras (i)–(iii) of the O.A. were not granted.
  • The court did not set aside the administrative policy or notifications challenged, nor did it order fresh procedures in the manner requested by the applicants.
  • The opinion does not announce any new legal principle beyond applying established judicial restraint in reviewing executive policy decisions; no broader precedent was created by this decision beyond its application of the settled principle that administrative policy will not be disturbed absent mala fide or arbitrariness.

    Arun Kumar v. Vijay Sharma

    HONBLE RANBIR SINGH , MEMBER (A) As per the O.A. the applicants are Group C employees in BSNL in J&K Circle. The recruitment to the post of Junior Accounts Officer is governed by Recruitment Rules of Junior Accounts officer in Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited for which an examination is conducted consisting of two parts i.e. JAO Part-I and JAO Part-II. A candidate qualifying JAO Part-I Examination is allowed to take JAO Part-II and it is only after qualifying in both parts, that one attains eligibility for appointment. The respondents had initiated the process to fill in the vacancies of JAO through notification dated 12.10.2004 whereby old syllabus was retained as a one time relaxation. However, the eligibility remained the same as in old rules, with an indication that it will be the last examination under the old syllabus.

    2. It is further stated that a number of ineligible candidates applied against the aforesaid notification with a representation to grant them one time relaxation in the residency period from 10 years to 5 years. Such kind of relaxation in qualification had been extended in the cadre of Senior Accountants/Junior Accountant on 12.10.2012 (Annexure A-7). Though process for JAO-I examination was initiated in 2004, but it came to be completed in 2007. Respondent No. 2 had issued letter dated 24.8.2009 (A-8) for holding JAO Part-II Internal Competitive Examination against 40% which was held on 30.11.2009 and 2.12.2009.

    3. The O.A. goes on to state further that the respondent BSNL issued notification dated 3.9.2012 (Annexure A-1) for holding JAO Part-II Internal Competitive Examination against 40% quota, restricting the consideration only to the candidates who had failed in the JAO Part-Ii Examination conducted in the year 2009, as per notification dated 12.10.2004 (A-5). The grievance of the applicants is that the respondents are going to chose one set of employees who were eligible for selection in the year 2004 and remained unsuccessful in the year 2009 and the same relaxation has been continued in the year 2012 which cannot be sustained as it was only a one time relaxation in the year 2004 and 2009. The candidates who could not qualify examination in 2007 and 2009 cannot be given relaxation for all times to come as it would affect changes of promotion of those who have become eligible as per rules. The vacancies which remained unfilled as a result of 2009 examination should be treated as vacancies for the year 2012 and all the candidates who are eligible under the relaxed criteria which was granted in 2004 or 2007 but did not qualify should not be allowed to enjoy further relaxation.

    4. All the applicants had already become eligible under the relaxed criteria for JAO Part-I Examination in the year 2007. However, the respondents are considering only JAO-II failed candidates, who qualified JAO part-I Examination under the relaxed criteria, whereas it was a one time relaxation. JAO Part I examination was conducted in 2004, and even after 10 years, no examination has been conducted, although it is required to be held every year. By passage of time, the applicants have acquired even 10 years of service and are eligible for examination.

    5. The relief sought in this case is as follows :- (i) Quash notification No. 28-2/2012-Rectt. Dated 3rd September, 2012, issued by Respondent No. 1, copy Annexure A-1, whereby JAO Part-II Internal Competitive Examination against 40% quota has been restricted only to the candidates who had failed in the earlier examination, 2007, whereas the vacancies of the Junior Accounts Officer pertain to the period from 20076 to 2012 and quashing thereof to that extent.

    (ii) Quash notification No. 863/40%/2012 SRI = dated 18.09.2012, copy Annexure A-2, by the CGMT, J&K Circle on the basis of Corporate Office circular dated 03.09.2012, and for quashing of the same.

    (iii) Issue directions to the respondents to conduct JKAO Part-I Examination also against the said quota for the candidates who became eligible during the period from 2007 -2012, in terms of the same condition, which were applied by the respondents while granting relaxation to the candidates in which examination was postponed to 2009, process for which was initiated in 2007 and completed in 2009, result was also declared in 2009 and to consider all those including the applicant who became eligible in terms of the criteria, which was notified by the respondents while conducting the examination announced in 2004 with all consequential benefits. The grounds taken for the relief sought are as under :-

    (i)The BSNL had initiated the process for holding JAO Part-I examination in the year 2004 and completed the same in the year 2009. The candidates who had qualified JAO Part-I examination under the relaxed criteria were allowed to appear in the JAO-II Examination. Thus, the candidates who failed in JAO Part-II Examination can not be made eligible forever to appear in the JAO-Part-II Examination.

    (ii)After 2004, no examination of JAO-Part-I was held by the BSNL whereas it should have been conducted every year and the candidates who became eligible have to be given chance.

    (iii)In service jurisprudence every employee must be given chance and it should not be restricted to a category, especially in the circumstances when process was initiated in the year 2004 and no examination of JAO Part-I has been conducted thereafter.

    (iv)The action of the respondents is discriminatory, arbitrary and against the principles of natural justice. Failed candidates have allowed frequent relaxation whereas eligible candidates are being deprived of their right.

    6. Respondents no. 1 and 2 have filed a common reply statement. They submit that a one-time relaxation was given in pursuance of a number of representations received from various Associations and Unions to relax the eligibility conditions at the relevant time. The JAO Part-I Examination which was scheduled to be held in the month of January, 2004 was deferred till further orders. The relaxation in service conditions eligibility from 10 to 5 years was given as a one time measure only as it was the last examination on old pattern. No relaxation is to be given thereafter. All candidates who had qualified JAO Part-I exam or the Screening test (proposed) or got exemption in JAO Part-Ii examination were eligible to take the examination. The candidates who have got exemption in certain subject (s) of JAO Part-II examination were required to appear in the remaining subjects only. All other candidates were required to appear in all papers of the main exam. Any interference in the Departmental Competitive Examination system shall jeopardize the entire purpose of competitive examination. Since screening test qualified candidates had appeared in the main examination only on one occasion i.e. 2010, hence the 2nd attempt as per Scheme and syllabus of JAO Internal examination as per letter dated 13.8.2002 has been given to screening test qualified candidates which is as per the BSNL guidelines. The screening test qualified candidates had appeared in the main examination as per old syllabus, therefore, it was decided with the approval of competent authority to allow the candidate to appear in the 2nd chance of main examination with the old syllabus which is their last exam as per old syllabus and as per the scheme and syllabus circulated by the BSNL vide letter dated 13.8.2002. Therefore, there is no violation of any ruling, order or instructions. Screening test qualified candidates are getting only their second chance which is as per scheme and syllabus issued by the BSNL and the candidates who could not qualifying in the main examination I this second chance have to appear in the screening test once again in which the applicants can also appear, if otherwise eligible. The demand of the applicants to conduct screening test before the main exam (JAO Part-II) is totally arbitrary, illegal and baseless. The applicants in the present O.A. were not eligible to appear in the present examination since they were neither JAO Part-I qualified candidates nor screening test qualified candidates. There has been no discrimination and arbitrary action on the part of the respondents as the relaxation was granted after receiving a large number of representations both from the Unions and from the employees and subsequently with the approval of the competent authority one time measure eligibility conditions were relaxed.

    7. The applicants have filed a rejoinder in which the averments made in he O.A. have been reiterated.

    8. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

    9. We find that it is question of policy matter and exercise of discretion on the part of the competent authority regarding relaxation in qualification of experience. In this case the relaxation has taken place on the request of a particular class of employees and with the participation of the Union of the employees. A policy decision of the Government is taken after considering many factors and a Tribunal is not equipped to take a decision in such matters nor can it interfere with such policy decision taken by the Government unless there is a clear cut case on arbitrariness and malaflde. In Ujagar Sugar Works Ltd. Vs. Delhi Administration & Others, (2001) 3 SCC 635, it has been held that in exercise of their powers of judicial review, the Courts do not ordinarily interfere with policy decisions of the executive unless the policy can be faulted on the ground of mala fide, unreasonableness, arbitrariness or unfairness etc. If the policy cannot be touched on any of these grounds, the mere fact that it may affect the interests of a party does not justify invalidating the policy.

    10. In this case we do not find any element of arbitrariness and malaflde in the impugned policy decision of the respondents. We do not want to sit as an appellate authority over the wisdom of the competent authority. None of the beneficiaries of such a policy decision is a party before us and as such it would not be proper for us to pass an order adverse to their interests. In view of the above discussion, this O.A. is devoid of any merit and is dismissed accordingly. No costs. (RANBIR SINGH) MEMBER(A) (SANJEEV KAUSHIK) MEMBER (J) Place: Chandigarh Dated: 12.8.2013

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Arun Kumar v. Vijay Sharma
    (Aug 12, 2013)