Honble Shri V. K. Majotra, Vice-Chairman (A) : Applicant has challenged penalty of forfeiture of one years approved service temporarily for a period of one year, i.e., reduction by one stage from Rs.4600/- per month to Rs.4500/- per month for a period of one year with immediate effect. It has also been ordered by the respondents that applicant shall not earn increments of pay during the period of reduction and on the expiry of this period, the reduction will not have the effect of postponing his future increments of pay.
2. Among other grounds, the learned counsel of the applicant pointed out that vide Annexure A-9 dated 9.2.2000, respondents had issued to the applicant notice to show cause why his five years approved service should not be forfeited permanently on account of the partly proved charge by the enquiry officer in his findings. On the basis of this show cause notice, the disciplinary authority had passed the impugned order dated 29.6.2000 (Annexure A-2). This very order has been upheld by the appellate authority. Exception has been taken by the learned counsel of applicant that the rules do not permit the disciplinary authority to issue a show cause notice to the delinquent for awarding a punishment even without affording the delinquent an opportunity of being heard. Annexure A-9 reveals pre-determination of mind by the disciplinary authority to punish the delinquent, which is impermissible under the rules and hence, illegal.
3. The learned counsel of respondents on being asked the provisions of law under which Annexure A-9 had been issued by the disciplinary authority to the applicant, was unable to refer to any provision of law which permits issuance of a show cause notice for awarding a punishment without affording an opportunity of hearing.
4. We are inclined to agree with the learned counsel of applicant that Annexure A-9 is violative of the prescribed procedure and against the principles of natural justice. The punishment based on Annexure A-9 in turn will also be rendered illegal and violative of the principles of natural justice. The punishment inflicted upon the applicant is liable to be quashed and set aside on this ground alone. As such, we are not dwelling upon the other grounds raised on behalf of the applicant. The impugned orders Annexure A-1 and A-2 imposing the aforesaid penalty upon the applicant are consequently quashed and set aside. Applicant shall be entitled to all consequential benefits. Respondents are directed to provide the consequential benefits to the applicant expeditiously and preferably within a period of three months of communication of these orders.
5. The OA is allowed in the above terms. ( Shanker Raju ) ( V. K. Majotra ) Member (J) Vice-Chairman (A) /as/