Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges

    Rama Devi Mehta (Dr.) v. Union Of India

    Justice V. K. Bali, Chairman: By this common order, we propose to dispose of three Original Applications bearing OA nos. 2321/2008, 2322/2008 and 2323/2008, concededly based upon exactly the same facts. Learned counsel representing the parties also suggest likewise. The facts, in the context of the limited or practically no controversy, may require only a brief mention, which have been extracted from OA No.2321/2008 in the matter of Dr. Rama Devi Mehta & another v. Union of India. The same reveal that Dr. Rama Devi Mehta, applicant no.1, was appointed as Senior Research Assistant on 2.9.1983 and promoted as Principal Research Assistant on 1.9.1993. She was then promoted as Scientist B on 17.1.1996 and finally as Scientist C on 20.7.2004. Likewise, Shri S. K. Verma, applicant no.2, was also appointed and promoted in the manner referred to above. He too was finally promoted as Scientist C with effect from the same date, i.e., 20.7.2004. The applicants are presently working as Scientist C with National Institute of Hydrology (Roorkee), a registered Society controlled by Ministry of Water Resources. It is the case of the applicants that clause 29 of the bye laws of the Institute provides that till such time separate regulations concerning its employees are framed, the concerned rules and orders applicable to government employees would govern the field, subject to modifications effected by the governing body of the Institute. All powers are reserved with the governing body of the Institute, which is also authorized to resolve any doubts. In exercise of powers vested in its governing body, the Institute had its own Assessment Promotion Scheme (APS) since 1987 and the same was revised in the year 1990 and then in the year 2000. In the year 2002, the applicants had sent their self-appraisal for promotion to the post of Scientist C in the review year 2002. They were due for promotion as Scientist C as per APS 2000 on the anniversary dates as per the reviewing year, i.e., 17.1.2002 in the case of the 1st applicant, and 4.7.2002 in the case of the 2nd applicant. However, they were given promotion on the post of Scientist C vide orders 19.7.2004 and 20.7.2004 w.e.f. 20.7.2004. In the order promoting them, it was mentioned as follows: The promotion of Scientists will be further subject to the final outcome of writ-petitions No.4916/2003 and 4928/2003 filed by Shri J. V. Tyagi, Scientist E-1 & Others and Dr. Bhishm Kumar, Scientist F & Others respectively, pending disposal in the High Court of Delhi. The in-situ promotion of the above scientists will take effect from the date of their assuming the charge. Their promotion will be further subject to the final outcome of the Writ Petitions No.4916/2003 & No.4928/2003 pending disposal in the High Court of Delhi. The writ petitions aforesaid came to be disposed of by the High Court on 27.10.2005. The orders passed by the High Court were challenged in the Apex Court, but the SLP filed in that behalf was dismissed on 14.11.2007. The respondents vide order dated 8.5.2008 implemented the judgment of the High Court, which has since been confirmed by the Honble Supreme Court as well. However, with regard to those who had not gone to the court, the same decision, which was squarely applicable, was not implemented, even though while promoting the applicants it was clearly stated that their promotion would be subject to final outcome of the writ petitions referred to above. Aggrieved thus, the applicants made several representations, and when the same were rejected vide order dated 22.7.2008 by specifically saying that the judgment would be implemented only in the case of those who had gone to the court, have filed present Original Application under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, obviously seeking the same relief as has been granted to the petitioners of the writ petitions mentioned above. Obviously, the applicants are seeking setting aside of the orders rejecting their representations as well.

    2. Pursuant to notice issued by this Tribunal, the respondents have entered appearance and by filing their reply, it appears, have only formally contested the cause of the applicants. The facts as mentioned above, have been admitted in their entirety. The relief sought for by the applicants is sought to be denied on the only ground as mentioned in the order rejecting their representation.

    3. We have heard the learned counsel representing the parties and with their assistance examined the records of the case. The facts of the present case and the one culminating into order dated 27.10.2005 passed by the Honble High Court of Delhi in WP(C) Nos.4916/2003 and 4928/2003 are admittedly the same. Like the petitioners in the writ petitions aforesaid, the applicants before us are claiming promotion from the dates of their having completed qualifying service. We may make a mention of the operative part of the judgment recorded in the aforesaid writ petitions. The same reads as follows: 32. In these proceedings petitioners were denied promotions from the date of their having completed the qualifying service. These petitioners completed their qualifying services after 1-1-1999. In the light of the discussion in WP(C) 4916/03 and connected cases, the petitioners are entitled to the benefit of clauses 8(b) read with 12(b). Thus, they would be entitled to promotion on their anniversary date (ie date of completing the qualifying service in the year of review). As discussed earlier, in WP(C) 4916/2003, the concerned officials have a right to be considered, in accordance with Clause 8(b) on particular dates. Correspondingly, the respondents are under an obligation to consider their cases as on the date they complete qualifying service, subject to the conditions in clause 8(a). The relief granted to the petitioners in the said writ petitions is as follows: 33. In these cases, therefore, the petitioners are entitled to be considered and promoted relative to the end of the period their appraisals were called, by the Institute. Having regard to the circumstance that the orders of promotion in these cases though made in the year December 2002, and January, 03 the respondent-Institute ought to treat it as applicable as on the dates when the appraisals were called for and as on the dates on which the review for the purposes of promotion fell due, as per clause 8(a). Thus, if the petitioners completed their qualifying service and were asked to submit their appraisals as on a particular date, such a date shall be their date for purposes of promotion. A direction is accordingly issued to carry out consequential amendments to the promotion orders issued to the petitioners.

    34. These petitions are accordingly allowed to the extent indicated above, with no orders as to costs.

    4. Admittedly, the anniversary date, as per the reviewing year, insofar as the applicant no.1 is concerned, is 17.1.2002, and so far as applicant no.2 is concerned, the same is 4.7.2002. We do not find any merit whatsoever in the stand taken by the respondents that only those who had gone to court would get the desired relief. In fact, we are of the considered view that as a model employer, the respondents ought to have implemented the judgment of the Honble High Court in case of persons similarly situate of their own, and if there be any such instructions which may say otherwise, the same ought to be ignored being wholly illegal. This was perhaps, a case where the respondents in denying the relief to the applicants for the reasons as stated above, should have been burdened with costs. However, taking into consideration that at least when the matter has come up before this Tribunal, there appears to be realization on the part of the respondents that their stand may not be correct, we make the costs of this litigation easy.

    5. For parity of reasons given in the judgment dated 27.10.2005 in WP (C) Nos.4916/2003 and 4928/2003, we issue the same directions as have been issued therein. ( L. K. Joshi ) ( V. K. Bali ) Vice-Chairman (A) Chairman /as/

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rama Devi Mehta (Dr.) v. Union Of India
    (Aug 18, 2009)