Mr. P.K. Basu, Member (A) The applicant joined as Assistant Director in the respondent organization i.e. National Productivity Council (NPC) in 1969 and after serving the organization, retired as Director on 30.04.2002. This application has been filed by the applicant seeking the following reliefs: respondent to pay to the petitioner his due honorarium @ US$15 per page for 200 pages of editing and proof reading work completed by the petitioner for the programme organized by NPC in collaboration with Asian Productivity Organization (APO) after deducting NPC share; respondent to pay honorarium due to the petitioner @ US$500 per programme for the three programmes organized in collaboration with the Colombo Plan Secretariat (CPS) for discharging the duties of programme coordinator i.e. full payment amounting to US$1500; to release ex-gratia payment for the year 1994-95 to the petitioner in accordance with the rules of the NPC; to reimburse the medical claim of the petitioner to the tune of Rs.5,500/-.
2. The applicant, at the stage of arguments, did not press the other two prayers in the TA i.e. of release of benefits relating to one of his transfers and compensation for harassment, humiliation and mental agony. This application was originally filed as a Writ in the High Court. However, the Honble High Court vide order dated 19.03.2009 in WP ) No.23110/2005 transferred the matter to the Administrative Tribunal.
3. Heard both the parties.
4. The learned counsel for the applicant, first of all, clarified on the question of multiple relief being raised in the application, stating that since the matter was first filed in the Honble High Court in its writ jurisdiction, multiple reliefs were sought from the Honble High Court. Since the matter has been remanded by the Honble High Court to this Tribunal, this ground cannot be taken at this stage to disallow the application by the respondents. We accept the contention of the applicant.
5. In their counter, the respondents have also raised the issue of delay by the applicant as the petition is filed in the year 2005, whereas the grievance relates to the period 1994-95 or 1998-2000 and, therefore, it is claimed that the application is barred by limitation. It would be seen that the applicant has been pursuing with the department in the intervening period and only when the department failed to respond, the applicant approached the Honble High Court in 2005. In fact, the correspondence had started right from the year 2001 onwards after the respondents failed to reply. Therefore, we feel that there is continuity of cause of action and as such, we do not hold this matter to be barred by limitation.
6. The respondents counsel also raised the initial objection that this matter fell outside the jurisdiction of this Tribunal because the dispute was between the petitioner and recovery of honorarium from the APO. We, however, feel that the issue is only arising out of the term of employment of the applicant with the NPC and that these assignments were given to him by the NPC. Grievance relating to honorarium, ex-gratia or reimbursement of medical expenses are very much within the jurisdiction of this Tribunal and thus, we hold this application to be maintainable. HONORARIUM
7. On the first prayer of payment of honorarium @ US$15, the applicant produced letter dated 19.10.2001 from the APO which mentions about the proceedings of the conference in maximum 200 pages and that APO will pay US$15 per finished page etc. The letter is addressed to the applicant designated as Director (SIPS), NPC. Another email dated 21.11.2002 from Mr. S.A. Khader, DDG, NPC states the following: He is keen to know from you about the progress of the publication. He wonders whether the material received by you must have met your approval and gone thru for final publication. I do not know if u have some communication for him in this regard particularly with respect to his honorarium for the work. (`He here refers to the applicant) In email dated 22.11.2002 from APO addressed to Mr. Khader, it is stated as follows: In fact, we are trying to forward a note to you to request how we can make the payment to Gupta on the honorarium for the text preparation. Can you assist us in requesting him to forward to us the necessary forwarding address or bank details for remittance of payment. The main contention is that whereas the applicant claims that this job was assigned by APO to him in his individual capacity, the respondents refute this and state that the assignment was to NPC and not to the applicant in his individual capacity and, therefore, there is no question of payment of honorarium to the applicant and that the payment was to be credited to NPC by APO.
8. The applicant states that the work concerning publication continued and was carried out by the applicant even after his retirement on 30.04.2002 and the final text was summed up some time in July-August, 2002. It was, therefore, argued that if NPC was given the assignment, then the person who took charge from the applicant on his retirement in NPC should have continued with the unfinished work and there would have been no question of the applicant completing the work after his retirement.
9. On this issue, the respondents argued that after the email dated 22.11.2002 from APO to Mr. Khader, there is a subsequent email from APO to Mr. Khader stating that NPC has advised that payment should be made to NPC, India and not to the individual. In fact, our attention has been drawn to letter dated 30.01.2003 issued by the NPC to the applicant stating that the APO had issued a letter on assigning of the job to NPC as an organization for undertaking this work and questioned Mr. Gupta to clarify under what authority/ basis he was soliciting APO to issue the letter of assignment of work to him and pay honorarium directly to him for the publication. Attention has also been drawn to communication dated 31.03.2003 in which it has been mentioned that other officials also had similarly not been allowed to take up the work on personal basis. The respondents also referred to administrative instructions No.337/82 dated 10.06.1982 (file No.10801) which deals with the subject of specialist charges for international assignments and sharing of fees by NPC Consultants. From a reading of this circular, it would be clear that these programmes in collaboration with international organization such as APO were of two kinds, one in which the international assignment is to NPC in which the payment etc. are received only by NPC and the second category was where the fee is received by NPC Consultants, in which case prior sanction of the competent authority (NPC) has to be taken and 1/3rd of fee received has to be credited to the account of NPC. Therefore, the respondents counsel argued that even if for the sake of arguments it is agreed that assignment of proof reading was to the applicant directly, he should have obtained prior permission, which the applicant has not been able to produce and then 1/3rd of the fee so obtained by the applicant would have to be deposited.
10. The question of prior permission does not appear to be relevant here as the issue was in the full knowledge of the NPC and, therefore, now to turn around and say that the applicant did not get prior permission is far-fetched and cannot be accepted.
11. We have considered the issue and seen all the correspondence between the concerned offices/ officials. It would be clear from the administrative instructions dated 10.06.1982 that there is provision of individual Consultants receiving payment. It is not that this is some unique arrangement. The rules envisage such a situation. From the email of APO to Mr. Khader, DDG, as quoted above, it is clear that the understanding was that the payment would be made to the applicant on account of honorarium for the text preparation. This is also apparent from the fact that Mr. Khader, DDG in his email dated 21.11.2002 has referred to the applicants honorarium for the work. Moreover, it is admitted that the applicant kept on working and finished the assignment 3-4 months after his retirement and sent the documents to APO. It is only in January, 2003 that the NPC suddenly decided that it will receive the payment and not the person who had actually done the work. To our mind, this is an absurd argument being adopted by the respondents. The paper trail and facts clearly show that the intention was that somebody in NPC would do proof reading on behalf of APO and the task was assigned to the applicant. Mr. Khader, DDGs email also indicates that. The APO, in fact, asked for the bank account of the applicant to release the payment. We have no doubt in our minds that the applicant should be the recipient of the honorarium. Therefore, this issue is decided in favour of the applicant and the respondents are directed to release the amount received by them from the APO to the applicant after deduction of 1/3rd of the amount as mentioned in the Rules. ASSIGNMENT WITH CPS
12. Regarding assignment with the CPS, the applicant referred to letter dated 16.03.2000 from NPC to the Acting Director wherein, regarding CPS participation, in item no.8, it is clearly written that CPS will pay honorarium of US$ 500 for the Programme Coordinator, who would function as a Resource Person through out the programme and would lead the sessions on Country Paper presentations. Moreover, in its letter dated 2.05.2002, the CPS had indicated that honorarium of US$ 500 for the Programme Coordinator who would function as a resource person through out the programme and would lead the sessions on Country Paper presentations shall be given. It was further clarified in the letter as follows: However, at a subsequent meeting, on my suggestion, the NPC undertook to disburse the said payments, one behalf of the CPS, out of an allocation of US$ 5000 to be made available to the NPC as programme implementation costs per programme in the future. The CPS has been granting the NPC a sum of US$ 5000 to cover the cost components apportioned to the CPS, including that of the Programme Coordinator (US$ 500) since then.
13. It was further mentioned by the learned counsel for the applicant that in similar programmes in 1998 and 1999, the resource person was paid US$ 500 for coordinating the programme. Only in the applicants case, the respondents have denied the payment.
14. The respondents pointed out letter dated 20.03.2000 from CPS to the NPC in which the following has been stated: US$ 500 that is to be provided by the CPS to the NPC is to cover all expenses in respect of the entire faculty, including the Programme Coordinator, and the quantum of such disbursements to be decided and made by the NPC. Such an arrangement was found to be more feasible to the NPC.
15. Again the argument was put forward that as per administrative instructions dated 10.06.1982, if at all it is admitted that the applicant was to be paid directly, then he should have taken prior permission which he did not. On this point we have already given our finding in para 10 above.
16. The paper trail in this case clearly indicates that honorarium was to be paid to the Programme Coordinator @ US$ 500 and even if NPC were to receive the total amount of US$ 5000, it would include the cost components apportioned to the CPS, including that of the Programme Coordinator i.e. US$ 500.
17. Needless to say the administrative instructions clearly envisage receiving honorarium from international organizations for such collaborative efforts between NPC and the international organizations subject to 1/3rd of the remittance being deposited in the NPC funds. Therefore, here also we are convinced that the prayer of the applicant is justified and the respondents are, therefore, directed to ascertain whatever amount they have received from the CPS for three conferences and pay to the applicant @ US$ 500 per conference for discharging the duties of Programme Coordinator. EX-GRATIA PAYMENT
18. On the question of ex-gratia payment, neither side could produce any document to show what this ex-gratia payment is about. However, during the course of arguments, learned counsel for the applicant pointed out that this in the nature of honorarium for the good work done in a particular year. The Tribunal is also aware of such type of ex-gratia payments given as honorarium in government organizations. The applicants apprehension is that he has not been paid this ex-gratia payment for the year 1994-95 because of some adverse entry in his ACR for that year. His argument is that he was never communicated any adverse entries in his ACR in time but much later i.e. only on 13.02.1996 and, therefore, relying on the judgment of the Honble Supreme Court in Dev Dutt Vs. Union of India, (2008) 8 SCC 725, it was argued that since he was never given an opportunity to represent against his adverse ACRs, he cannot be denied ex-gratia payment solely on this ground. In counter reply, no clear answer has been provided by the respondents as to why the honorarium was not paid to the applicant. Neither is it clarified whether such ex-gratia was paid to other employees. There is strength in the applicants argument that he could not be penalized and not paid ex-gratia on the ground of adverse ACRs in case he was never given an opportunity to represent against ACRs and his representation considered and a reasoned order passed. Therefore, we dispose of this matter with a direction to the respondents that in case ex-gratia was paid to similarly placed persons in the relevant year i.e. 1994-95 and it was not paid to the applicant solely on the ground of adverse entries in ACRs, then the respondents would release the ex-gratia amount to the applicant as per Rules. MEDICAL BILL
19. As regards the medical bill of Rs.5,500/-, the applicant has said that he had submitted his medical bill for the period 26.06.1996 to 3.11.1996 amounting to Rs. 3780.30 by registered post. This medical bill pertained to prolonged treatment for post operative care after angioplasty and was submitted within three months from the last date of treatment but the NPC passed that bill only for Rs.512.80. It appears from the respondents reply that total claim of Rs.5,500/- included Rs.1700/- which was pertaining to the claim of angioplasty in 1992 and Rs.3800/- for post operational care for the period June, 1996 to November, 1996. From para 3.22 of the counter reply, it appears that the ground for non-payment of the bill was that they were not submitted in time. No where is it denied that the applicant actually availed the medical treatment. The amount is also very small and spent on his treatment. To reject that on the ground of not having submitted the bill within the stipulated time of three months reflects extreme insensitivity on the part of respondents and we deplore this attitude and the way a retired senior employee of the organization is being treated. In any case, he has sent the bill by registered post. Therefore, we direct the respondents to release the amount of Rs.5,500/- to the applicant forthwith.
20. We have considered all the four issues raised by the applicant in his application and various arguments advanced by the respondents in their defence and give our findings on each issue separately. In conclusion, we direct the respondents to release the following amounts to the applicant within a period of two months from the date of this order: Release the payment received by the respondents for proof reading @ US$ 15 per page from APO to the applicant; Release US$ 1500 to the applicant for three programmes in which he performed duties of Programme Coordinator in CPS; Release ex-gratia payment to the applicant for the year 1994-95 in case such ex-gratia was paid to other similarly placed persons and the applicant denied solely on the ground of adverse ACR in 1994-95; and Release the amount of Rs.5,500/- claimed by the applicant towards medical treatment undertaken by him forthwith.
21. The OA stands disposed of with the above directions. No costs. ( P.K.Basu ) ( V. Ajay Kumar) Member (A) Member (J) /dkm/