These writ petitions are filed by the defendant in O.S.No.8509/2012, assailing the orders passed on
These writ petitions are filed by the defendant in O.S.No.8509/2012, assailing the orders passed on I.A. No.14 & 15 filed by the petitioner herein. The respondent plaintiff has filed a suit seeking recovery of money on the basis of a promissory note. During the pendency of the suit two applications were filed by the petitioner herein. One under Order XII Rule 8 R/w Section 151 of CPC, 1908 seeking production of Cash Book, Ledger, Cash Receipt, Pass book pertaining to finance, Payment receipt, Finance License and statement of accounts. Another application was filed under Order XIV Rule 5 of CPC R/w Section 24 and 33 of Karnataka Money Lenders Act seeking framing of additional issue as to whether the plaintiff has complied with the provisions of Section 20 and 21 of the Karnataka Money Lenders Act. By the impugned orders the said applications have been rejected. Being aggrieved by the rejection of the said applications, these two writ petitions have been filed.
2. I have heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and learned counsel for the respondent and perused the materials on record.
3. It is stated at the Bar by the learned counsel for the respondent that at the stage of the final arguments the said applications were filed. Be that as it may, the application IA No.15 was filed seeking framing of additional issue with regard to the plaintiff having a licence under the Karnataka Money Lenders Act so as to be able to file the said suit. The trial court has observed that in the absence of any pleading to that effect, the said issue cannot be raised at the fag end of the suit. In respect of IA No.14, the defendants sought for production of certain documents in order to prove that the plaintiff had no licence under the Karnataka Money Lenders Act so as to do business in money lending and therefore was not entitled to file the suit seeking recovery of money from the defendant. It is noted that in the absence of there being any pleading in the written statement with regard to the respondent/plaintiff being entitled to file the suit, in the absence of possessing a licence under the aforesaid Act, the defendant could not have sought for framing of an issue with regard to the maintainability of the suit. Hence, the trial court was justified in dismissing the said application (IA-15). For the aforesaid reasons the trial court was also justified in dismissing the IA-14 filed under Order XII Rule 8 R/w Section 151 of CPC seeking production of certain documents. In fact, even if the said application had been allowed and certain documents were directed to be produced by the respondent, the same would not establish that the plaintiff did or did not have any licence to conduct business under the Karnataka Money Lenders Act. In fact, IA-14 was totally misconceived. Hence the trial court is justified in dismissing the application particularly in the absence of there being any pleading in the written statement filed by the defendant. I do not find any infirmity in the order of the trial court. There is no merit in these writ petitions. The writ petitions are dismissed. Parties to bear their respective costs. Sd/- JUDGE KLY/