AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 196(5) of Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act, 1993.6. Re. Question
  • CONSTITUTION 73RD AMENDMENT ACT
  • Section 196(5) of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act 1993.
  • Section 184 of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act
  • sub-section 5 of Section 196
  • Nyaya Panchayats Act, 1983
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 196(5) of Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act, 1993.6. Re. Question
  • CONSTITUTION 73RD AMENDMENT ACT
  • Section 196(5) of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act 1993.
  • Section 184 of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act
  • sub-section 5 of Section 196
  • Nyaya Panchayats Act, 1983
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners, employed on daily-wage basis in various Group 'C' and 'D' posts and other positions in Zilla Panchayats, challenged the denial of regularisation of their services by the Respondents. The petitioners had served for over 10 years, with appointments dating from 1984 onwards. Earlier writ petitions seeking regularisation were disposed of with directions to consider representations. Despite resolutions and government orders for regularisation of daily-wage employees in certain categories, these petitioners' requests were declined. The petitioners thus filed writ petitions praying for mandamus to compel regularisation of their services. The controversy also involved the question of constitution of services for Zilla Panchayats under the Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act, 1993, which impacts the regularisation process.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioners are entitled to the benefit of any existing scheme governing regularisation of temporary/daily wage employees?
  2. If not, whether the petitioners, based on their service as daily wagers, are entitled to claim regularisation?
  3. Whether regularisation can be ordered without the State constituting services for the Zilla Panchayats under Section 196(5) of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act, 1993?

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dharwad District P.W.D L.D.W.E Association v. State of Karnataka (1990 2 SCC 396) Regularisation scheme for daily-rated employees appointed on or before 1st July 1984, providing fixed pay and eventual absorption. Held that petitioners did not fall within this scheme, which applied only to employees appointed on or before 1.7.1984 and continuously in service till 6.8.1990.
State of Haryana v. Piara Singh (AIR 1991 SC 2130) A temporary employee serving for many years acquires a right to claim regularisation; presumption of need for continuance of services. Affirmed that petitioners serving over 10 years have a right to be considered for regularisation.
Bhagwat Prasad v. Delhi State Development Corporation (1990 1 SCC 361) Daily rated employees working for considerable length of time should not be denied confirmation. Supported the principle that long-serving daily wagers merit regularisation.
Dr. V.L Chandra v. All India Institute of Medical Sciences (1990 3 SCC 38) Efforts must be made to accommodate long-serving temporary researchers in employment. Used to emphasize the need for regularisation of long-serving temporary employees.
Arun Kumar Rout v. State of Bihar (AIR 1998 SC p-1477) Daily wagers working for about 9 years directed to be considered for regularisation. Reinforced the principle of consideration for regularisation based on length of service.
State of Maharashtra v. Vijay Vasantrao Deshpande (1998 7 SCC 231) An ad-hoc employee continuing for eight years can be considered for regularisation. Supported the view that long service justifies consideration for regularisation.
Director, Institute Of Management Development, U.P v. Pushpa Srivastava (Smt) (1992 4 SCC 33) Appointment for a limited period (one year) does not entitle regularisation. Distinguished from petitioners’ cases, which involved longer continuous service.
J&K Public Service v. Dr. Narinder Mohan (1994 2 SCC 630) Government cannot circumvent statutory recruitment rules to regularise temporary employees. Clarified that regularisation must comply with relevant rules; petitioners’ appointments were lawful.
Dr. Arundhati Ajit Pargaonkar v. State of Maharashtra (1994 Supp 3 SCC 380) Temporary government servants must satisfy prescribed requirements for regularisation. Emphasized lawful appointment as a prerequisite for regularisation; petitioners’ appointments were valid.
State of Tamil Nadu v. L. Krishnan (1996 1 SCC 250) Regularisation must follow proper recruitment rules and schemes. Referenced to reject claims based on irregular appointments; petitioners’ appointments were not irregular.
Ashwani Kumar v. State of Bihar (1997 2 SCC 1) Illegal appointments cannot be regularised; no rights accrue from unauthorized excess appointments. Applied to distinguish petitioners’ lawful appointments from illegal ones in that case.
State of U.P v. Jogendra Singh (AIR 1963 SC 1618) Constitution of services for Panchayats is mandatory despite permissive language in statute. Supported the view that services for Zilla Panchayats must be constituted.
State (Delhi Administration) v. I.K Nangia (1980 1 SCC 258) Mandatory constitution of services for Panchayats to ensure proper staffing and governance. Reinforced need for constituting Panchayat services under statutory provisions.
Jagga Singh v. State of Punjab (AIR 1995 SC 133) Constitution of Panchayat services is essential for administrative efficiency. Used to underline the necessity of service constitution for Zilla Panchayats.
Reserve Bank of India v. Peerless General Finance and Investment Company Ltd. (1996 1 SCC 642) Constitution of services is a legal obligation for effective functioning of Panchayats. Supported the mandate to constitute Panchayat services under Section 196(5).
Mansukhlal Vithaldas Chauhan v. State Of Gujarat (1997 7 SCC 622) Emphasized the mandatory nature of constituting services for Panchayats despite statutory wording. Affirmed that the State must constitute services for Panchayats for proper governance.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analysed the petitioners' claims in light of existing schemes, government orders, and Supreme Court precedents. It found that the petitioners did not qualify under the specific Dharwad District P.W.D scheme, which applied only to employees appointed on or before 1 July 1984 and continuously employed till 6 August 1990. However, the Court relied on Supreme Court decisions recognizing that long-serving temporary employees (generally around 10 years or more) acquire a right to claim regularisation, based on principles of fairness and non-exploitation under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution.

The Court distinguished cases where appointments were illegal or contrary to recruitment rules, noting that the petitioners' appointments were lawful and continuous. It emphasized that regularisation is an exception to the general rule of recruitment through competitive selection and should be granted only in cases where denial would be arbitrary and unfair.

Regarding the constitution of services for Zilla Panchayats under Section 196(5) of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act, 1993, the Court noted the Government's explanation that reorganisation and financial viability concerns delayed constituting such services. Nevertheless, the Court observed that the constitutional objective of Panchayats and the statutory provisions indicate that constituting services is mandatory and essential for proper functioning. The Court urged the Government to initiate this process promptly to avoid ad hoc and temporary appointments leading to avoidable regularisation claims.

The Court thus held that while the Government should constitute services within a year, petitioners who meet the length of service requirement should be considered for regularisation against existing sanctioned posts. If services are constituted, petitioners without current vacancies should be considered for absorption against future vacancies with relaxation of age limits. If not, petitioners should be regularised as per the Dharwad scheme modified as necessary, with the process completed by 31 December 2000.

Holding and Implications

The writ petitions are allowed to the following extent:

  • The Respondents shall consider for regularisation those petitioners working against sanctioned posts who have served continuously for 10 years.
  • The Government shall constitute services for Zilla Panchayats under Section 196(5) of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act, 1993 within one year. Upon constitution, petitioners not covered under the first category shall be considered for absorption against vacancies, with eligibility and age relaxation.
  • If the Government fails to constitute services within the stipulated time, petitioners shall be considered for regularisation under the Dharwad scheme, subject to modifications, with completion of absorption by 31 December 2000.

The direct effect is that petitioners meeting the criteria will be considered for regularisation or absorption, ensuring protection of their rights after long service. The judgment underscores the constitutional and statutory imperative for the Government to constitute services for Panchayats, thereby promoting administrative efficiency and reducing ad hoc employment. No new precedent was set; rather, the Court applied established principles to the facts and urged prompt administrative action.

The parties are directed to bear their own costs.

    H.S Raghupathi Gowda And Others v. State Of Karnataka And Others

    10. (1996) 1 SCC 250 : AIR 1996 SC P. 497 - State of Tamil Nadu v. L. Krishnan (do) 13 11. (1997) 2 SCC 1 : AIR 1997 SC P. 1628 - Ashwani Kumar v. State of Bihar (do) 13 12. AIR 1963 SC 1618 - State of U.P v. Jogendra Singh (do) 20 13. (1980) 1 SCC 258 : AIR 1979 SC 1977 - State (Delhi Admn) v. I.K Nangia (do) 20 14. AIR 1995 SC 133 - Jagga Singh v. State of Punjab (do) 20 15. (1996) 1 SCC 642 : AIR 1996 SC 646 - Reserve Bank of India v. Peerless General Finance & Investment Co. Ltd. (do) 20 16. (1997) 7 SCC 622 : AIR 1997 SC 3400 - Mansukhlal Vithaldas Chauhan v. State Of Gujarat (do) 20

    Sri G.V Shantaraju, for M/s. H.N Nagamohan Das & Associates
    Sri V. Lakshminarayana, Advocate for Petitioners
    Sri K. Srinivasa Gowda, Advocate for Petitioner
    Sri K.V Prasad Hegde, Advocate for Petitioner
    Sri S.V Tilgul, Advocate for Petitioner
    Smt. Vidya, HCGP for Respondents
    Sri M.H Sawkar, Advocate for R-2
    Sri G.R Ramachandrappa, Advocate for R2 & R3

    Tirath S. Thakur, J.:—

    The petitioners have in these Writ Petitions called in question the validity of orders passed by the Respondents declining regularisation of their services and prayed for a mandamus directing them to do the needful. The controversy arises against the following backdrop:—

    Petitioners in Writ Petitions No. 34556-587/1998, 34046-084/1998 and 37486/98 were appointed against Group-‘C’ and ‘D’ posts on different dates from the 2nd of July, 1984 onwards. Having served on daily-wage basis for over 10 years they filed Writ Petitions No. 380033-57; 3858076/1998 and 10243-49/98 for a mandamus directing the Respondents to regularise their Services. These petitions were disposed of by Raveendran, J. by orders dated 19th of March, 1998 and 30th March, 1998, with a direction to the Respondents to consider the representations, which each one of the petitioners was directed to make.

    2. In Writ Petition No. 37166/1997, the petitioner was appointed as a literate Assistant in Bangalore Rural Zilia Panchayat, by an order dated 1.6.1988 on a consolidated salary of Rs. 780/- per month. By a resolution dated 29th of August, 1995 the Panchayat decided to regularise the services of daily wages employed by it. That Resolution was not however implemented forcing the petitioner to file W.P No. 8148 which was disposed of by P.V Shetty, J., by order dated 2nd of April, 1997 with a direction to the respondent to consider the petitioner's case nor regularisation.

    3. In Writ Petitions No. 34666-680/1998, the petitioners are working as F.D.As, S.D.As, Stenographers, Typists, Drivers and peons, on daily wage basis. Although the Respondent, Zilla Panchayat, had by resolution dated 18th January, 1992 resolved to regularise their services yet apprehending that their services may be terminated pursuant to Government Circular dated 12th of April, 1990, they filed Writ Petitions No. 2735-771/1992 which were disposed of by a Single Bench of this Court by order dated 17th of December, 1997 with the direction that their cases may be considered for regularisation.

    4. In Writ Petition No. 92909/1999 the petitioner was appointed as a Typist in Zilla Panchayat on 1st of December, 1988 eversince when he has been working in that capacity. The grievance in this petition is that despite Government order dated 8th of September, 1997 sanctioning regularisation of the services of Stenographers and Typists appointed on temporary basis pursuant to Circular dated 9th of July 1987, his case for regularisation has not been considered.

    5. In Writ Petitions No. 33541-571/1998, 33959-965/98, 3725-738/98, the petitioners were appointed as Graduate Assistants, Literate Assistants, Typists, Stenographers, Watchmen, Gangman, etc. In Writ Petitions No. 31526-80/96, filed by them earlier they claimed a mandamus directing the Respondents to regularise their services. By an order dated 5th of February, 1997 Shetty, J., allowed the said petitions with a direction to the Respondents to regularise the services of the petitioners and to pay to them emoluments attached to the post with effect from 2nd of August, 1995. Services of the petitioners were accordingly regularised by the respondents subject to the result of Writ Appeals No. 5865/1997 and 474-98/97 filed by them against the order of the learned Single Judge. The Writ Appeals were eventually disposed of by order dated 10.2.1998, whereby the order passed by the learned Single Judge was modified and the eases of the petitioners directed to be considered in accordance with the policy of the State Government and the pronouncements of the Supreme Court. The petitioners were in compliance with the directions issued by the Court considered for regularisation but declined the relief prayed for. Aggrieved they have assailed the orders issued by the respondents as noticed earlier.

    6. I have heard learned Counsel for the parties at length. Three questions fall for determination namely:—

    1) Whether the petitioners are entitled to the benefit of any existing scheme governing regularisation of temporary/daily wage employees?

    2) If answer to No. 1 above be in the negative, whether the petitioners are on the basis of the service rendered by them as daily wagers entitled to claim regularisation?

    3) Whether regularisation can be ordered without the State continuing services for the Zilla Panchayats in terms of Section 196(5) of Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act, 1993.

    6. Re. Question No. 1:—

    In Dharwd District P.W.D L.D.W.E Association v. State of Karnataka . 1990 2 SCC 396 daily and monthly rated employees working in different Government establishments who had put in 16 to 20 years of continuous service prayed for regularisation of their services. Pursuant to the directions issued by their Lordships the State prepared a Scheme for regularising the services of the daily rated employees which was accepted by the Court with certain modifications. The scheme envisaged that those appointed casual/daily rated employees on or before 1st of July 1984 shall be treated as monthly rated establishment (MRE) employees with a fixed pay of Rs. 780/- per month with effect from 1.1.1990 They were entitled to an annual increment of Rs. 15/- till their services were regularised. On regularisation they were to be put in the minimum of the time scale of pay applicable to the lowest group ‘D’ cadre under the Government and entitled to all other benefits available to regular Government servants of the corresponding cadre. The petitions filed before the Supreme Court were accordingly disposed of with directions.

    7. Pursuant to the above order, the Government issued Official Memorandum dated 3rd July 1984 followed by Government Order dated 6th of August, 1990, prescribing the modalities for regularisation/absorption of casual/daily rated employees in M.R.E and their eventual absorption as regular Government servants. The scheme so prepared was however applicable only to such of the employees as had been appointed on or before 1st of July 1984 and remained continuously in service till 6th of August, 1990.

    8. The cases of the petitioners in these Writ Petitions do not admittedly fall with the purview of the above scheme so as to entitle them to be brought on the monthly rate establishments or absorption as regular employees. No other scheme has been brought to my notice by Counsel for the petitioners in support of their claim for regularisation. All that has been referred to and relied upon are Government Orders issued from time to time permitting regularisation of daily-rated employees of different categories. Some of these orders are as under:—

    (i) Order dated 20th May, 1989 issued by the State Government to the Chief Secretaries of Zilla Parishats permitting regularisation of the services of the temporary employees of Ex. DRDS/TDBs in Zilla Parishats;

    (ii) Government Order No. DPAR 13 SLC 94, dated 29th September, 1994 directing that dailywage Engineers appointed on or after 1.7.1984 but on or before 5th of October, 1992, shall be brought on monthly rated establishment subject to their fulfilling other conditions stipulated in Government Order dated 6th of August, 1990. The order further directs that after being brought on the monthly rated establishment, the employees shall be eligible to be absorbed against regular posts in establishments/departments where they are working subject to their fulfilling the conditions prescribed in the Annexure to the said order;

    iii) Government Order P.W.D No. 357 PWL 90, Bangalore dated 2.12.1994, directing that daily-rated Engineering Graduates and Diploma Holders, working in Public Works and Irrigation Department, appointed on or after 1st of July, 1984 and who are in service as on 29th of September, 1994 and who fulfil all other conditions laid down in Government orders dated 6th of August, 1990, 29th of September, 1994 and 20th of October 1994, shall be brought on monthly rated establishment, against posts created in the said establishment;

    iv) Government Order No. PWD PWC 94, Bangalore dated 3rd of April, 1995 sanctioning regularisation of such of the employees as were serving in the Public Works Department on 1st of July, 1984 and earlier thereto and who had completed 10 years of uninterrupted service subject to the conditions stipulated in the said order.

    v) Government Order No. PWD. 121, 128, PWC. 97 dated 6th of October, 1997, and Government Order No. PWD 125 PWC 97 dated 8th October, 1997, regularising the services of Assistant Engineers and Jr. Engineers mentioned in the said orders on monthly rated establishments.

    9. It is evident from the above that the State Government have from time to time regularised services of daily-rated employees by bringing them on the monthly rated establishment, subject to such employees satisfying the broad parameters prescribed for grant of such benefit. One of the requirements-that is discernible from the said orders is that the person concerned must have been in continuous service as a daily-rated employee for a period of 10 years. The cumulative effect of the orders does not however constitute a Scheme under which all such persons as have served as daily rated employees may be entitled to claim regularisation directly or placement on the monthly rated establishment as a step in that direction. While the orders have granted relief to the concerned employees from time to time obviously with a view to mitigate the hardship which is implicit in their discharge from temporary service. It is difficult to construe the said orders as providing a perennial source or scheme for every daily rated employee to claim the benefit thereof. The orders at best demonstrate that the State has not been averse to the grant of regularisation in cases where the same is merited by the length of the service rendered and the requirement of permanent staff to look after the work which such employees have been doing for over 10 years. My answer to question No. 1 therefore is in the negative.

    10. Re. Question No. 2:—

    In State of Haryana v. Piara Singh . AIR 1991 SC 21300. the Supreme Court held that a temporary employee who continued in service for a number of years, acquired a right to claim regularisation. A presumption declared the Court arose in such cases that there is need for the continuance of his services making it obligatory for the authorities to examine the feasibility of his regularisation.

    11. In Bhagwat Prasad v. Delhi State Development Corporation . 1990 1 SCC 361, the Court declared that those appointed on daily rated basis and allowed to work for considerable length of time should not be denied confirmation.

    12. In Dharwad District P.W.D L.D.W.E Association v. State of Karnataka (supra), the Court while recognising the need for the regularisation of the services of those who had served for more than 10 years, directed the formation of a Scheme governing the absorption of such persons.

    13. In Dr. V.L Chandra v. All India Institute of Medical Sciences . 1990 3 SCC 38, the Supreme Court was considering the case of some of Researchers appointed by the All India AIMS under several Schemes and who were continued for more than 10 to 15 years before termination on the ground that further schemes were not available. The Court held that efforts must be made to accommodate them to provide employment. Similarly in Arun Kumar Rout v. State of Bihar . AIR 1998 SC p-1477. cases of dailywagers who had worked for about 9 years were directed to be considered for regularisation. In State of Maharashtra v. Vijay Vasantrao Deshpande . 1998 7 S 231., the Court observed that when an ad-hoc employee continued for eight years, the Administrative Tribunal could direct the Government to consider his case for regularisation.

    It is therefore evident that there is near unanimity of view expressed by the Apex Court in so far as regularisation on long serving daily wagers is concerned. The Court has not frowned upon regularisation of such employees if they have served the State for years. The juristic basis for the Schemes formulated by the authorities and even the directions issued by the Court is that denial of regularisation and resultant termination of those who have spent the best part of their life serving the Respondents on daily-wage basis would be extremely harsh and unfair tantamounting to exploitation of their labour in violation of their rights under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. Regularisation I may hasten to add has not been favoured as an alternative mode of appointment to the services otherwise regulated by proper Rules on the subject. Doing so may even be against public interest for more often than not, daily rated employments are given without any competitive examination, process of selection or determining of the merit of candidates chosen for the same. Such appointments following a Scheme which the Government may formulate on its own or pursuant to the directions issued by the Court are meant only to prevent inequitable situations in which persons who have served for over a decade may be asked to leave only because his daily rated or temporary employment does not create any right in his favour to hold the post against which he was appointed. Cases are not inconceivable where any such employee has on account of temporary employment given to him lost the chance to compete for any other job on account of his having stepped beyond the upper age limit prescribed for the purpose. The ideal method of recruitment to public service always is through the mechanism prescribed for making such appointments in which competitive claims of all those who are eligible are considered in a fair and dispassionate manner. Fairness and transparency in the selection process are of paramount importance for it is the confidence of the citizen in the fairness of the system which sustains his faith. Appointments through the medium of regularisation of temporary employees, has therefore to be an exception to that General Rule and can be resorted to only in rare cases where any other view in the matter may look so patently unfair and unjust as to be arbitrary and hence offensive to Article 14 of the Constitution. While it is difficult to formulate any norms for purposes of the granting regularisation, the tenor of the decisions on the subject is that the person concerned should have served for a fairly long period say for 10 years to entitle him to consideration. Shorter duration may not qualify for that relief as the predominant consideration behind a direction for regularisation of a temporary employee is the length of service which he has rendered. That view is in my opinion not displaced by the decisions of the Supreme Court in Director, Institute Of Management Development, U.P v. Pushpa Srivastava (Smt). . 1992 4 SCC 33, J&K Public Service v. Dr. Narinder Mohan . 1994 2 SCC 630., Dr. Arundhati Ajit Pargaonkar v. State of Maharashtra . 1994 Supp 3 SCC 380. State of Tamil Nadu v. L. Krishnan . 1996 1 SCC 250, Ashwani Kumar v. State of Bihar . 1997 2 SCC 1, reliance whereupon was placed by Counsel for the Respondents. In Pushpa Srivastava's case, the appointment was for a period of one year only, whereas in Dr. Narendra Mohan's case, the question was whether the Government could in exercise of its executive power circumvent the requirement of the statutory Rules and regularise the services of a temporary employee. In A.A Paragaonkar's case, the Court was dealing with a situation where a temporary Government servant had to satisfy the prescribed requirement for getting his services regularised, one such requirement was that the original appointment itself was made in accordance with the relevant recruitment rules. The Court held that the appointment of the appellant was in disregard of the relevant Rules and could not therefore be regularised. In Hindustan Shipping Yards' case the Court declared that regularisation could be effected only in accordance with the Rules for direct recruitment and that the Court ought to direct Constitution of a Selection Committee to consider the matter for regularisation as per the Rules governing regular appointment. In Ashiwini Kumar's case, the Court was dealing with a situation where as against 2250 class III and IV posts, created for implementing a scheme, the Deputy Director of Health in the State of Bihar had appointed nearly 7000 employees. The Court found that such appointments were wholly unjustified and illegal and those who had secured the same could not claim regularisation. The following passage from the said decision is in this regard instructive:—

    “As we have seen earlier when the initial appointments by Dr. Mallick so far as these daily wagers were concerned, were illegal there was no question of regularising such employees and no right accrued to them as they were not confirmed on available clear vacancies under the Scheme. It passes one's comprehension as to how against 2500 sanctioned vacancies confirmation could have been given to 6000 employees. The whole exercise remained in the realm of an unauthorised adventure. Nothing could come out of nothing. Ex nibilo fit. Zero multipled by zero remain zero. Consequently no sustenance can be drawn by the appellants from these confirmation orders issued to them by Dr. Mallick on the basis of the directions issued by the concerned authorities at the relevant time. It would amount to regularisation of back door entries which were vitiated from the very inception. It is not possible to agree with the contention of learned Counsel for appellants that the vacancies on the scheme had nothing to do with regular posts. Whether they are posts or vacancies they must be backed up by budgetary provisions so as to be included within the permissible infrastructure of the Scheme.”

    14. It is not shown by the respondents that the initial appointments of the petitioners whether under the State or those by the Ziila Panchayats, suffered from any illegality like the one referred to in Ashwin Kumar's case. It is also not in dispute that the petitioners have served as daily-rated employees for more than 10 yeas and in some cases even 15 years. Subject to the availability of vacancies and their eligibility the petitioners have on account of the length of their service acquired a right for being regularised. Question No. 2, is accordingly answered in the affirmative.

    15. Re. Question No. 3:—

    Most of the petitioners were initially appointed in their respective departments, on daily wage basis, more often than not without a formal appointment order. Their names figured in the muster sheet for disbursement of the wage earned by them till the Schemes for the extension whereof they were employed got transferred to the Zilla Parishats, under Karnataka Zilla Parishats, Taluk Panchayat Samitis, Mandal Panchayats and Nyaya Panchayats Act, 1983 w.e.f 1.4.1987 Govt. Circular dated 15.5.1987 issued in this regard prescribed the following guidelines for transfer of such employees.

    “1. The cost of establishment consisting of work charged Establishment/Supernumerary/NMR Monthly rated/NMR on daily wages have to be apportioned to Zilla Parishats and State sector proportionately on the work load based on the grants provided for both budgeted works and maintenance and repair works keeping the percentage of establishment costs retained with PWD transferred to Zilla Parishat approximately the same. This should be done districtwise.

    2. As far as possible the incumbent transferred to Zilla Parishats of the above category should continue to be deployed on the same works. Only in cases where the staff transferred to Zilla Parishats is inadequate surplus staff from the nearest place should fill up the gap.

    3. While transferring the numbers to Zilla Parishats sub-divisionwise list may be prepared in order of the length of service of the incumbents and a blend of both senior and juniors should be transferred to the Zilla Parishads and since Zilla Parishats are to be formed newly more number of Senior Personnel be transferred to Zilla Parishats so that their experience useful to the Zilla Parishats.”

    16. A large number of Development and Welfare Schemes were in the meantime transferred to the Zilla Parishat under Section 182 of the Act aforementioned by Government Order dated 1.4.1987 This was followed on 23.4.1987 by another Order sanctioning Staff to Offices of the Zilla Parishats/Administrative Organisational structure for the Zilla Parishats was also sanctioned by the Government by an order dated 2.3.1987 based on the recommendations of the Committee appointed for the purpose. By a notification dated 28.10.1988 the Government in exercise of its power under Section 285 of the Act, prescribed the qualifications and the method of recruitment for the posts mentioned therein. There was no significant change in the scheme of things till the year 1993 when Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act, 1993 came under force repealing the 1983 Act, that held the field till then. The new Act envisages Zilla Panchayats to perform the functions specified in Schedule-III to that Act besides such other functions as may be assigned to them by the Government under Section 185 thereof. By a notification dated 16.7.1994, the Government added certain additional activities, programmes and schemes to Schedules-II and III in exercise of its power to do so under Section 312 of the Act. By another notifications of even date, the Government entrusted to the Zilla Panchayats additional functions relating to Sports and Youths Services and Sericulture. The net result is that in addition to the duties and functions stipulated in Schedule-III the Government have transferred a series of other duties and functions which the Zilla Panchayats are required to discharge. The execution of the schemes and development works which the Panchayats are now handling involve hundreds of crores of rupees, placed at their disposal by the Government. The magnitude of the work which the Zilla Panchayats are entrusted with, it is obvious would require a matching administrative and organisational machinery comprising administrative, technical, skilled and unskilled personnel. It cannot be disputed that a well oiled organisations machinery cannot be set up by the Panchayats unless an exercise for determining the requirement is undertaken at the appropriate level and legal shape given to the same by constituting services for the Panchayats. Section 196 of the Act amply empowers the State Government to appoint a Chief Executive Officer, and Chief Planning Officers, and one or more Deputy Secretaries for each Panchayat. It also empowers the Government to post from time to time such number of Officers and officials from the State Government and Officers of the All India Services as may be considered necessary. More importantly sub-section 5 of Section 196 empowers the Government to constitute such services for each Zilla Panchayat as may be prescribed. Section 196(5) reads as under:—

    “The Government may as from the specified day constitute such services for each Zilla Panchayat as may be prescribed.”

    17. By an order dated 31.3.1999 the Secretary to Government was directed to file an additional affidavit indicating the following:

    i) Whether the Government have at any stage after enforcement of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act, 1993 examined the question of constituting services for Zilla Panchayats in terms of Section 196(5) of the Act and if so the result thereof;

    ii) In case, no such examination has taken place till now, the possible impediments which the Government anticipates in constituting such services immediately within a given time framed;

    iii) Whether any norms have been fixed and guidelines issued by the Government in terms of proviso to Section 184 of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act and to place on record the copies of the Government orders if any issued on the subject.

    18. An Affidavit was accordingly filed by Sri M.R Sreenivasa Murthy, Secretary, Department of Rural Development and Panchayat Raj, Government of Karnataka, in which he states that the Government have not considered it necessary to take up the question of constituting Zilla Panchayat Services under Section 196(5) of the Act, primarily because the Government is at present engaged in reorganisation of the existing Grama Panchayats into larger village level Panchayats as existed before 1987. On such reorganisation being completed, the Government proposes to consider transferring some more functions of the higher level Panchayats to the Grama Panchayats which would call for a review of the existing allocation of development functions between different tiers of Panchayats. It is only after the allocation of functions upon review that the State Government can establish appropriate staffing pattern, allocation of funds and procedural norms for the development expenditure being incurred through different levels of Panchayats. The current year's estimated expenditure through different levels of Panchayats is about Rs. 4,000/- crores. The affidavit goes on to state that the finance of the Zilla Panchayats are yet to be put on a firm footing and it would be advisable for the State to consider Constitution of separate services for the Zilla Panchayats after further strengthening their financial viability. Since the functions of the Zilla Panchayats are currently being discharged with the assistance of the Staff of the Government who are on deputation, it is not proposed to consider constitution of separate services at this juncture.

    19. The explanation offered by the Government for not constituting the services for the Panchayats cannot be rejected out of hand. Reorganisation and financial viability are important areas which need to be taken care of. And yet the difficulty expressed cannot be considered insurmountable. An exercise could and ought to have stated during a period of one decade which has rolled by. It is difficult to accept that the proposed reorganisation could place on hold a process of evaluation of the staff requirement of the Panchayats or prevent the Government from proceeding on the ‘bare minimum’ principle assuming that the re-organisation takes shape and marginally attests the burden of the Zilla Panchayats.

    20. Relying upon the decisions of the Supreme Court in State of U.P v. Jogendra Singh . AIR 1963 SC 1618., State (Delhi Administration) v. I.K Nangia . 1980 1 SCC 258, Jagga Singh v. State of Punjab . AIR 1995 SC 133., Reserve Bank of India v. Peerless General Finance and Investment Company Ltd. . 1996 1 SCC 642, Mansukhlal Vithaldas Chauhan v. State Of Gujarat . 1997 7 SCC 622, that the Constitution of services was mandatory and unavoidable for the Government no matter Section 196(5) uses the work ‘may’ and not ‘shall’ while empowering the Government to constitute services.

    21. I consider it unnecessary to express any opinion on that aspect of the matter in the present proceedings. All that need be said is that Panchayats have been established in satisfaction of a constitutional objective introduced by Constitution (73rd Amendment) Act whereunder Articles 243 to 2430 were incorporated. Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act 1993 as also its predecessor Act of the year 1983 were enacted by the State Legislature in furtherance of the constitutional provision referred to above. It is not therefore as though Panchayats are a temporary feature or a passing phase. The concept of local self-government and decentralisation of power is a profound constitutional development which has come to stay. The Panchayats have therefore to be accepted as essential instruments in the machinery which the constitutional scheme now envisages especially in so far as the implementation of schemes for economic development and social justice are concerned. Such being the position, temporary, measures can hardly advance the purpose underlying the constitution of Panchayats. While it is true that Section 196(3) entitles the Government to post from time to time such Officers or officials as may be considered necessary to work in the Zilla Panchayat yet working for ever with borrowed manpower can hardly be ideal conditions in which the Panchayat Raj would be required to carry out their duties and discharge their functions. The power to constitute appropriate services for each Zilla Panchayat would necessarily imply the power to examine the staff requirement of such Panchayats determine the cadre strength and prescribe qualifications as also the method of recruitment against the vacancies available in the same. This exercise may be an arduous one but has to be undertaken sooner or later though sooner it is started the better it would be. In the absence of Rules providing for the method of recruitment and qualifications for such appointment, the power to make appointments can and is likely to be abused. Experience has shown how despite circulars issued by the Government not to make appointments such appointments have over the years been made for a variety of reasons. Suffice it to say that the Government need to immediately address themselves to the question of constituting services to prevent recurrence of situations where employees are engaged on temporary or ad hoc basis allowed to continue making their regularisation unavoidable. In case the process is initiated and concluded within a reasonable time, such of the petitioners as are at present not holding any clear vacancy can be considered for regularisation against the same depending upon whether he satisfies the conditions of eligibility prescribed for the post. In case however it is not for any reason possible to constitute the services within a reasonable time those who have served for 10 years or more cannot be made to wait indefinitely till such time the Government may consider it feasible to constitute the services and thereby provide a legitimate opening to them for their eventual absorption. Their cases shall then have to be considered on the basis of scheme which have been framed and implemented in the post subject to such modifications and adoptions as may be necessary.

    22. In the result, these Writ Petitions succeed and are hereby allowed but only to the following extent:

    i) the respondents shall consider the cases of such of the petitioners as are working against sanctioned posts for regularisation subject to the condition that they have served for a period of 10 years continuously:

    ii) the Government may within a period of one year from the date of this order Constitute Services for the Zilla Panchayats in terms of Section 196(5) of the Karnataka Panchayat Raj Act 1993. In case, the services are constituted, the cadre strength determined, the qualifications and the method of recruitment prescribed, such of the petitioners as do not fall under (i) above on account of the absence of sanctioned/regular vacancies shall be considered for absorption against the vacancies becoming available upon Constitution of the services in accordance with the relevant recruitment Rules subject to their being eligible for such consideration and appointment. The petitioners in that case shall be entitled to relaxation of age bar to the extent of their service as daily rated employees:

    iii) In case however the Government does not in terms of (2) above constitute services or the process which it initiates is not concluded within the time given, the petitioners shall be considered for regularisation on the terms and conditions stipulated by the Government pursuant to directions of the Supreme Court in The Dharwad District P.W.D Literate Daily Wages Employees Association v. State of Karnataka, subject to the condition that they have been in continuous service on whole time basis for over 10 years from the date of their appointment till the date of this order. Conditions stipulated in the Government Orders issued for implementation of the Scheme in Dharwad case (supra) shall to that extent stand modified. The process of absorption of the petitioners shall be completed by 31.12.2000

    23. In the circumstances, the parties are left to bear their own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    H.S Raghupathi Gowda And Others v. State Of Karnataka And Others
    (Sep 10, 1999)