J.C Gupta, J.:— Heard Sri S.S Misra, counsel for the petitioners and learned A.G.A for the State.
2. In the facts and circumstances of the case and with the consent of the parties counsel, this application is disposed of finally.
3. By means of this application, the applicants have challenged the validity of impunged notice purporting to be under Section 111 Cr. P.C Learned A.G.A raised a preliminary objection that the impunged notice is only in the nature of show cause and, therefore this application at this stage is premature. On the other hand learned counsel for the petitioners urged before the Court that the applicants have challenged the validity of the impunged notice on the ground that it does not fulfil the requirement of mandatory provisions of Section 111 Cr. P.C and, therefore, the notice in question is null and void and the proceedings before the learned Magistrate are a nullity. It cannot be disputed that an Executive Magistrate gets jurisdiction to proceed under Section 110 Cr. P.C only after passing an order as envisaged under Section 111 Cr. P.C If the order as contemplated under Section 111 Cr. P.C has not been passed, the Magistrate cannot proceed in law.
4. A plain reading of this section would show that the order under Section 111 Cr. P.C must be in writing and it should contain the following elements:
(1) substance of the information received under Section 107-110-Cr. P.C (as the case may be);
(2) that upon consideration of such information, the Magistrate has formed the opinion that there is likelihood of the breach of peace;
(3) that it is necessary to proceed under relevant Sections 107 to 110 Cr. P.C as the case may be;
(4) that amount of the bond to be executed;
(5) the term for which the bond is to remain in force; and
(6) the character and class of sureties required.
5. Learned counsel for the applicants submitted before the Court that the impunged notice suffers from illegality inasmuch as it is not only vague but the Magistrate has not set forth in the order the substance of the information received by him as required by Section 111 Cr. P.C
6. It is well settled that the objective of setting forth in the order the substance of the information received by the Magistrate is to inform the person asked to show cause what allegations he has to answer. If the substance of the information set forth in the notice is vague and ambiguous, the very object of Section 111 Cr. P.C is defeated. A perusal of the instant notice leaves no room of doubt that substance of the information as set forth therein is wholly incomplete, vague and ambiguous. It simply recites that the Magistrate has been informed that the applicants are habitual in causing harassment to general public perhaps on account of theft, dacoity etc. This in my opinion hardly fulfils the requirement of Section 111 Cr. P.C The notice purporting to be under Section 111 Cr. P.C is thus found wholly defective and invalid. As such the Magistrate does not have jurisdiction to proceed on the basis of this void notice and the proceedings pending against the applicants before him are a nullity being without jurisdiction.
7. For the reasons stated above, this application is allowed. The impunged notices are set aside and the proceedings initiated on the basis of these null and void notices are quashed as being without jurisdiction. It is, however, made clear that it shall be open for the learned Magistrate to initiate fresh proceedings in accordance with law, if he deems necessary.
Application Allowed.