Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Companies Act, 1956 (Act for short).
  • CENTRAL SALES TAX ACT
  • provisions of Karnataka Sales Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Companies Act, 1956 (Act for short).
  • CENTRAL SALES TAX ACT
  • provisions of Karnataka Sales Tax Act

    Larsen & Toubro Limited Ecc Construction Group 400 Kvs/S Project Hoody Bangalore-48 Petitioner v. The State Of Karnataka

    1. Petitioner before this Court is a company registered under the provisions of Companies Act, 1956 (‘Act’ for short). It is also registered under the provisions of Karnataka Sales Tax Act as well as under the Central Sales Tax Act (‘KST Act’ and ‘CST Act’ for short).

    2. The narration of facts in detail may not be necessary for the purpose of disposal of these revision petitions.

    3. Petitioner as well as the State had questioned the correctness or otherwise of the orders passed by the first appellate authority namely, the Joint Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (Appeals), Bangalore Division, Bangalore, dated 21.4.1999 before the Karnataka Appellate Tribunal in appeal and cross appeal Nos. 547 & 1088/1999.

    4. The Tribunal had raised nearly twelve (12) issues for its consideration and decision. In these revision petitions, we are primarily concerned with the answer furnished by the Tribunal on issue No. 11. The said issue reads as under:

    “11. Whether the first appellate authority was justified in treating the goods like Iron and Steel involved in the execution of works contract as those transferred as such (in the same form) and levying tax at concessional rate of 4% and not subjecting to turnover tax?”

    5. The Tribunal has proceeded to answer the aforesaid issue against the petitioner and in favour of the revenue based on facts as follows:

    “……………….in respect of roof slabs, slabs of standard sizes are prepared at the site (precasted outside the building) and then the roof slabs as a whole are erected into the structure by placing individual small slabs. The steel which has gone into preparation of slab has already lost its identity before the slab (RCC) is placed in the roof. Every changed form is a new goods or a new item. In the present case, RCC slab is accredited into the building and not Steel, Cement or Jelly, which form the RCC slabs.”

    6. Smt. A. Rama, learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner would submit that the facts stated by the Tribunal are not relevant for the assessment year in question. According to the learned Counsel, those facts may be relevant tor the subsequent assessment years but not for the assessment year in question.

    7. The Tribunal by heavily placing reliance on the facts referred to by it in its order, has proceeded to answer issue No. 11 against the assessee and further has stated that the petitioner is not entitled to the concessional rate of tax provided under Sec.5(4) of the Act.

    8. If for any reason, the petitioner is of the view that the facts stated by the Tribunal is either incorrect or improper, it is for the assessee to go before the Tribunal by making an appropriate application interalia requesting it to rectify the mistake apparent on the face of the record which includes the mistake on facts also.

    9. At this stage, Smt. A. Rama, learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner requests the Court to permit her to withdraw the revision petitions with liberty to approach the Tribunal by filing an appropriate application for rectification of the order made by it on 11.1.2002 in STA Nos. 547/1999 and 1088/1999 respectively.

    10. However, Sri Anand, learned Govt. Advocate appearing for the revenue opposes the said request made by the learned Counsel for petitioner.

    11. In our opinion, if the request made by the learned Counsel for petitioner is granted and if the petitioner is permitted to file an appropriate application before the Tribunal for rectification of a mistake committed by it on facts, it would not cause any prejudice to the other side. Therefore, while permitting the petitioner to withdraw these revision petitions, we intend to give liberty to the petitioner to make an appropriate application before the Tribunal for rectification of the order dated 11.1.2002 made in STA Nos. 547/1999 and 1088/1999.

    12. In the result, the following:

    I. Revision Petitions are disposed off as withdrawn.

    II. Liberty is reserved to the petitioner to make an appropriate application before the Tribunal, within a month's time from today, if it so desires, for rectification of the order dated 11.1.2002 made in STA Nos. 547/1999 and 1088/1999 respectively.

    III. If such an application is made by the petitioner within the time granted by this Court, the Tribunal shall decide the application on merits without reference to the period of limitation as expeditiously as possible at any rate within four months' from the date of filing of the application.

    IV. All the other contentions of both the parties are left open. Ordered accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Larsen & Toubro Limi... v. The State Of Karnataka
    (Jun 14, 2004)