Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act 1989 (for short the Act of 1989),
  • Sections 2(c), 2(p), 2(q), 3, 18 and 40 of the Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act, 1989,
  • clauses 2(c), 2(p) and 2(q) of the Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act, 1989
  • Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act, 1989:3. Recognition
  • Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act, 1989.18.
  • Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act, 1989.40.
  • SOCIETIES REGISTRATION ACT 1860
  • Section 3(c)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act 1989 (for short the Act of 1989),
  • Sections 2(c), 2(p), 2(q), 3, 18 and 40 of the Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act, 1989,
  • clauses 2(c), 2(p) and 2(q) of the Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act, 1989
  • Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act, 1989:3. Recognition
  • Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act, 1989.18.
  • Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act, 1989.40.
  • SOCIETIES REGISTRATION ACT 1860
  • Section 3(c)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Rajasthan High Court — Mr. Asopa, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The opinion concerns five special appeals challenging a common order of the learned Single Judge dated 08.11.2001 which upheld the Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institution Tribunal, Jaipur's common judgment dated 06.06.2001. The Tribunal's judgment had set aside dismissal orders passed against the respondents and granted continuance in service with service benefits. The Court is disposing of the five special appeals by a common judgment.

The undisputed factual matrix recorded in the opinion is as follows:

  • Smt. Pushpa Sharma (respondent no.1 in D.B. Civil Special Appeal No. 62/2002) — appointed as Teacher, confirmed 01.07.1992; dismissed on 02.09.1997.
  • Smt. Snehlata Sharma (respondent no.1 in D.B. Civil Special Appeal No. 202/2002) — appointed as Primary Teacher (Hindi); dismissed on 20.08.1997.
  • Mrs. Ella Boss (respondent no.1 in D.B. Civil Special Appeal No. 203/2002) — appointed as Music Teacher, confirmed 16.12.1994; dismissed on 26.08.1997.
  • Smt. Mamti Rani Pathak (respondent no.1 in D.B. Civil Special Appeal No. 204/2002) — appointed as Librarian, confirmed 23.11.1995; dismissed on 20.08.1997.
  • Smt. Manju Bhatnagar (respondent no.1 in D.B. Civil Special Appeal No. 205/2002) — appointed as Lab Assistant, confirmed 23.11.1995; dismissed on 22.08.1997.

Procedural history (as recorded): the respondents filed separate appeals before the Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institution Tribunal, which allowed the appeals on 06.06.2001 and set aside the dismissal orders. The appellant-Society thereafter filed five writ petitions which were dismissed by this Court by a common order dated 08.11.2001. The present special appeals attack the Single Judge's common order of 08.11.2001.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant-institution (a Society registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 and recognised by the Central Board of Secondary Education) is a "recognised non-Government educational institution" within the meaning of the Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act, 1989 and therefore covered by that Act.
  2. Whether Section 18 of the Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act, 1989 (which prescribes opportunity to be heard and prior approval of the Director of Education before removal/dismissal/reduction in rank) is applicable to the respondents' dismissals and, in particular, whether it applies only to penal disciplinary action or also to simple terminations.
  3. Whether the internal rules and regulations of the appellant-Society (framed under the Societies Registration Act) prevail over the provisions of the Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act, 1989, or whether the Act overrides inconsistent society rules (including by virtue of Section 40).
  4. Reliefs and consequences on reinstatement: entitlement to back wages, pay fixation and retiral benefits (as raised during hearing).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant-Society was constituted to run educational facilities for children of army personnel and is registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860; it has its own rules and regulations governing termination/dismissal procedures (Chapter-9), which prescribe show-cause notice and a remedy of three months' salary if not satisfied with the reply.
  • The institution has not taken recognition from the Government as required under Section 3 of the Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act, 1989; therefore the Act does not apply to the institution.
  • Section 18 of the Act of 1989 is applicable only where disciplinary (penal) action is taken and not in cases of simple termination; consequently Section 18 should not be applied to these dismissals/terminations.
  • The rules and regulations of the Society being contractual/internal should govern the adjudication of the orders of dismissal/termination/removal.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The learned Single Judge correctly construed the definitions in Sections 2(c), 2(p) and 2(q) of the Act of 1989 together with Section 3 and held that institutions recognised by the Board (including the Central Board of Secondary Education, Delhi) are "recognised institutions" and need not seek separate recognition under Section 3; the appellant's institution is admittedly recognised by CBSE and is therefore a non-Government recognised institution covered by the Act of 1989.
  • Section 18 applies to the employees of recognised institutions; there was no compliance with Section 18 in these dismissals, so the impugned orders rightly were set aside by the Tribunal and upheld by the Single Judge.
  • Even if the orders are characterized as simple terminations (and not penal), Section 18(iii) applies — the provision covers termination as well as dismissal — and mandatory requirements (unanimous Managing Committee resolution, six months' notice or salary in lieu, and consent of the Director) were not satisfied.
  • The Society's internal rules are not statutory and must yield to the legislative enactment; Section 40 gives the Act overriding effect over anything inconsistent in any instrument having effect by virtue of any law.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by reference to the text of the Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act, 1989 and the relevant defined terms and provisions expressly quoted in the opinion: Sections 2(c), 2(p), 2(q), Section 3, Section 18 and Section 40.

Primary analytical steps recorded in the opinion:

  1. Statutory definitions: The Court relied on clauses 2(c), 2(p) and 2(q) to interpret "Board", "non-government educational institution" and "recognised institution". The definition of "Board" explicitly includes the Central Board of Secondary Education, Delhi; a "recognised institution" is defined to include a non‑Government educational institution recognised by the Board.
  2. Applicability of Section 3: The Court accepted the Single Judge's finding that an institution recognized by the Board or the Central Board of Secondary Education need not seek separate recognition from the Competent Authority under Section 3. Therefore an institution already recognised by such a Board falls within the Act's scope.
  3. Consequences for the appellant: Because the appellant-institution is admittedly recognised by the Central Board of Secondary Education, it is a "non-Government recognised institution" for purposes of the Act and the statutory protections and requirements in the Act apply to its employees.
  4. Interpretation of Section 18: The Court examined Section 18 and its provisos and held that the main provision and proviso (iii) are intended to prevent arbitrary action by managements, and they cover both disciplinary dismissals and simple terminations. The Court emphasized that the Section mandates a reasonable opportunity of being heard, and (under proviso (iii)) either six months' notice or six months' salary in lieu and the consent of the Director of Education when the managing committee is of the unanimous opinion that continued service cannot be allowed.
  5. Application to facts: The Court found that none of the mandatory requirements of Section 18 were complied with in the present cases: there was no unanimous managing committee resolution, no six months' notice or salary in lieu, and no consent of the Director of Education. Consequently, even if the actions were treated as terminations, Proviso (iii) was violated and Section 18 applied.
  6. On Society rules versus statutory law: The Court accepted the respondents' submission that the Society's rules are non‑statutory and must give way to the legislative enactment. In support, the Court relied on the express provision in Section 40 which grants the Act an overriding effect over anything inconsistent in any instrument having effect by virtue of any law.
  7. Relief and ancillary directions: At the conclusion of hearing the parties agreed that, if the appeals were dismissed, respondents should receive 50% back wages from date of termination until the date of the Tribunal's judgment (06.06.2001). The Court recorded that the respondents who had been reinstated by interim orders (and upheld by the Supreme Court) would continue as if no dismissal/termination had been passed. The Court also addressed a specific fact that Smt. Pushpa Sharma retired on 30.04.2005 and directed payment of post‑retiral benefits accordingly. The Court expected the appellants to consider pay fixation for the respondents and pass appropriate orders within three months.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF

Holding (direct ruling):

  • The Court upheld the learned Single Judge's findings that the appellant-institution is a recognised non‑Government educational institution within the meaning of the Rajasthan Non‑Government Educational Institutions Act, 1989 and that the provisions of the Act apply.
  • The Court held that Section 18 of the Act (including proviso (iii)) applies to the respondents' dismissals/terminations; because the mandatory requirements of Section 18 were not complied with, the dismissal/termination orders are void. The Tribunal's order setting aside the dismissals and the Single Judge's upholding of that order stand affirmed.
  • Reinstatement consequences and monetary directions: the respondents who have been reinstated by interim orders will continue in service as if no dismissal/termination had been passed; they are entitled to 50% back wages from the date of termination until 06.06.2001 (the date of the Tribunal's judgment). Smt. Pushpa Sharma is to be deemed in continuous service until her retirement on 30.04.2005 and is entitled to retiral benefits (gratuity, leave encashment, etc.) within two months of receipt of certified copy of the judgment. The appellants are expected to consider pay fixation within three months and pass appropriate orders.

Implications (scope and effect):

  • The decision has direct effect on the parties: it affirms reinstatement and monetary relief (50% back wages up to 06.06.2001) and specific directions for pay fixation and post‑retiral benefits for an identified respondent.
  • The opinion reasons from the statutory text (Sections 2, 3, 18 and 40) and holds that the Act's mandatory protections apply to recognised institutions and override inconsistent society rules. The opinion does not purport to lay down a broader novel precedent beyond the statutory interpretation it applies to the facts of these matters.

Order: The instant appeals are disposed of. Order accordingly.

    Managing Committee Through Chairman (Brid.) Dy. G.O.C, Army School And Anr. v. Smt. Pushpa Sharma And Ors.

    Mr. Asopa, J.:— In all the aforesaid five special appeals, common order of the learned Single Judge dated 08.11.2001 is under challenge whereby the common judgment dated 06.06.2001 passed by the Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institution Tribunal, Jaipur (for short ‘the Tribunal’) setting-aside the dismissal order against the respondents, has been upheld. The learned Single Judge has rightly taken into consideration that for adjudication the question involved in the five writ petitions is one and the same and disposed of the same by a common order. We are also disposing of these five special appeals by this common judgment for the aforesaid reasons.

    2. The facts which are not in dispute are as follows:

    Smt. Pushpa Sharma (respondent no. 1 in D.B Civil Special Appeal No. 62/2002) was appointed on the post of Teacher and was confirmed on 1.7.1992 She was dismissed from service on 02.09.1997 Smt. Snehlata Sharma (respondent no. 1 in D.B Civil Special Appeal No. 202/2002) was appointed as a Primary Teacher in Hindi subject and she was dismissed from service by order dated 20.08.1997

    Mrs. Ella Boss (respondent no. 1 in D.B Civil Special Appeal No. 203/2002) was appointed as Music Teacher and was confirmed on 16.12.1994 She was dismissed from service on 26.8.1997

    Smt. Mamti Rani Pathak (respondent no. 1 in D.B Civil Special Appeal No. 204/2002) was appointed as Librarian and was confirmed on the post on 23.11.1995 She was dismissed from service by order dated 20.8.1997

    Smt. Manju Bhatnagar (respondent no. 1 in D.B Civil Special Appeal No. 205/2002) was appointed as a Lab Assistant in the appellant's School and was confirmed on the post on 23.11.1995 She was dismissed from service by order dated 22.08.1997

    3. Against the aforesaid dismissal orders of the respondents, they filed separate appeals before the Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institution Tribunal, Jaipur and the Tribunal vide its common order dated 06.06.2001 allowed the appeals and set-aside the orders of dismissal of the respondents from service and further granted continuance in service with all service benefits. Against the said judgment of the Tribunal dated 06.06.2001, the appellant-Society fled five writ petitions which were dismissed by this Court vide common order dated 08.11.2001 holding that petitioner no. 2, the Institution is a recognized institution, therefore, the provisions of the Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act 1989 (for short ‘the Act of 1989’), will apply and admittedly there was no compliance of Section 18 of the said Act, therefore, order of dismissal from service is valid and all the writ petitions have been dismissed without any order as to costs.

    4. Some other relevant facts on the basis of which the submissions have been made by the counsel for the appellants are that the petitioner-Society has been constituted with the aims and object amongst others to create and develop educational and technical training facilities at military stations to meet the needs of the children of army personnel including Ex. serviceman, The said Society is registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 and have also framed its rules and regulations which inter alia prescribe the simple termination and dismissal by way of disciplinary action under Chapter-9 after show cause notice followed by three months' salary on not satisfied with reply to the notice. It has been further stated that they have not taken any recognition from the Government as required under Section 3 of the act of 1989, therefore, the institution-Society will not be covered by the Act of 1989 and further in the special appeal an attempt has been made by raising legal question that Section 18 is applicable only when the action is taken as penal in nature which is not there in these cases to come out of the clutches of Section 18 of the Act of 1989 and much emphasis has been laid in the pleadings and contentions that the rules and regulations framed by the Society will hold the field and the orders of dismissal/termination/removal is to be adjudged as per the rules and regulations of the Society.

    5. The submission of the counsel for the appellants is that the Tribunal as well as the learned Single Judge has committed an error in covering the institution under the Act of 1989 and further applying Section 18 of the Act of 1989 without giving any specific finding with regard to the applications of rules and regulations of the society.

    6. The submission of the counsel for the respondents is that the learned Single Judge has rightly considered the definition of Board, Non-Government Educational Institution and recognised Institution given Under Section 2(c), 2(p) and 2(q) of the Act of 1989 respectively which has been further considered with reference to Section 3(c) of recognition of the institution and held that for the institutions which are recognized by the Board of Secondary Education, Rajasthan and Central Board of Secondary Education, Delhi need not to seek further recognition from the competent authority. Therefore, the petitioner's institution which is admittedly recognised by the Central Board of Secondary. Education, Delhi is a non-Government Educational recognized Institution and need not to seek further recognition under Section 3 of the Act of 1989 on account of being recognized by the Board. The further submissions of the counsel for the respondents is that the appellant-Institution is covered under the provisions of the Act of 1989 and Section 18 which is applicable in case of recognized institution will also apply on the employees of the institution. Admittedly, there is no compliance of Section 18 of the Act of 1989 and, therefore, the impugned orders of dismissal have been rightly set-aside by the Tribunal and upheld by the learned Single Judge. As regards the submission of the counsel for the appellant-Institution that the orders of dismissal are not penal in nature, therefore, Section 18 of the Act of 1989 will not apply., it is submitted by the counsel for the respondents that even in case of simple termination, Section 18(iii) of the Act of 1989 will apply. With regard to the further submission of the counsel for the appellant for applicability of rules and regulations of the Society the counsel for the respondents has submitted that the Act of 1989 is a legislative enactment, therefore, the rules of the Society which are non statutory in character has to vive way to the Act of 1989. Otherwise also, under Section 40 of the Act of 1989 overriding the effect has been given over anything inconsistent contained in any instrument having effect by virtue of any law.

    7. We have gone through the record of the writ petition, perused the judgment of the learned Single Judge and further considered the rival submissions made by the parties.

    8. Before we proceed to consider the submissions made by the parties with reference to relevant provisions of law, it will be useful to quote the same i.e Sections 2(c), 2(p), 2(q), 3, 18 and 40 of the Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act, 1989, which reads as under:—

    Section 2. Definitions.

    (c). “Board” means the Board of Secondary Education, Rajasthan or the Central Board of Secondary Education, Delhi and shall include the Council for the Indian School Certificate Examinations;

    (p). “non-government educational institution” means any college school, training institute or any other institution, by whatever name designated established and run with the object of imparting education or preparting or training students for obtaining any certificate, degree, diploma or any academic distinction recognized by the State or Central Government or functioning for the educational, cultural or physical development or the people in the State and which is neither owned nor managed by the State or Central Government or by an University or local authority or other authority owned or controlled by the State or Central Government;

    (q) “recognised institution” means a non-Government educational institution affiliated to any University or recognized by the Board, Director of Education or any officer authorised by the State Government or the Director of Education in this behalf.

    Section 3 of the Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act, 1989:

    3. Recognition of institutions. (1) Except in the case of institution affiliated to a University or recognized or to be recognized by the Board, the Competent Authority may, on an application made to it in the prescribed form and manner, recognize a non-Government educational institution on fulfillment of such terms and conditions as may be prescribed:

    Section 18 of the Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act, 1989.

    18. Removal, dismissal or reduction in rank of employees-Subject to any rules that may be made in this behalf, no employee of a recognized institution shall be removed, dismissed or reduced in rank unless he has been given by the management a reasonable opportunity of being heard against the action proposed to be taken.

    Provided that no final order in this regard shall be passed unless prior approval of the Director of Education or an officer authorised by him in this behalf has been obtained: Provided further that this section shall not apply—

    (i) to a person who is dismissed or removed on the ground of conduct which led to his conviction on a criminal charge, or

    (ii) where it is not practicable or expedient to give that employee an opportunity of showing cause, the consent of Director of Education has been obtained in writing before the action is taken, or

    (iii) Where the managing committee is of unanimous opinion that the services of an employee can not be continued without prejudice to the interest of the institution, the services of such employee are terminated after giving him six months notice or salary in lieu thereof and the consent of the Director of Education is obtained in writing.

    Section 40 of the Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act, 1989.

    40. Overriding effect of the Act-The provisions of this Act shall have effect notwithstanding anything inconsistent contained in any instrument having effect by virtue of any law.

    9. The learned Single Judge rightly held that the institution is a non-Government recognized institution as per the definition of clauses 2(c), 2(p) and 2(q) of the Rajasthan Non-Government Educational Institutions Act, 1989 which does not required to be further recognized by the competent authority under Section 3 of the Act of 1989 and once it is non-Government recognized institution, the provisions of the Act of 1989 will apply. The finding of the learned Single Judge on applicability of the Act of 1989 is in accordance with the provisions of the Act of 1989. We do not find any infirmity in the said finding and uphold the same.

    10. As regards further submission on applicability of Section 18 of the Act of 1989, only in case action is taken by way of disciplinary action and not simple termination, we are of the view that the main Section 18 and Proviso (iii) of the Act of 1989 will cover both type of cases and said Section has (iii) of the Act of 1989 will cover both tupe of cases and said Section has been enacted with a view to check the arbitrary action of the management in removing, dismissing, reducing in rank and termination also. Therefore, the provisions of reasonable opportunity/unanimous resolution of Managing Committee and approval/consent of the Director are made mandatory in the order to ensure the fairness of the action. Neither there is unanimous resolution of the Managing Committee no six months notice was given nor payment of six months salary in lieu of notice was given nor consent of the Director was taken. Therefore, even if the case is taken to be of termination, then also mandatory Proviso (iii) of Section 18 of the Act of 1989 has been violated. The said Section is applicable in respect of all the employees whose services have been dismissed by way of disciplinary action or simple termination.

    11. Admittedly, there was no compliance of the provisions of Section 18 of the Act of 1989, therefore, on this count, dismissal/termination orders are void. We also affirm the finding of the learned single Judge on this issue.

    12. The last submission of the counsel for the appellant was that rules of the Society will hold the field in case of termination/dismissal from service. The submission of the counsel for the respondents is that the same are not statutory in character and will give way to the legislative enactment as per well settled preposition of law. Otherwise also, Section 40 of the Act of 1989 is having overriding effect over anything inconsistent contained in any instrument having effect by virtue of any law. The judgment of the learned Single Judge does not call for interference on any of the submissions made by the appellants.

    13. At the time of conclusion of the hearing when the parties were heard on the issue of back wages also both the parties agreed that in case the appeals are dismissed, then 50% back wages from the date of termination till the date of judgment of the Tribunal be given. Request was also made by the counsel for the respondents that the appellants be also directed to make pay fixation within a period of one month. One more fact was brought to our notice that Smt. Pushpa Sharma, respondent no. 1 in D.B Civil Special Appeal No. 628/2002, retired on 30.04.2005 and therefore, the said direction for payment of post retiral benefits be also issued.

    14. The respondents who have been reinstated by virtue of the interim order of this Court, upheld by the Supreme Court, will continue as if no dismissal/termination order has been passed. The respondents shall be entitled for 50% back wages from the date of termination till the date of judgment of the Tribunal i.e 06.06.2001

    15. Smt. Pushpa Sharma will be deemed to be in continuous service till 30.4.2005 and shall also be entitled for retiral benefits i.e gratuity, leave encashment etc. within two months from the date of receipt of certified copy of this judgment.

    16. It is expected from the appellants to consider the case of the present respondents for pay fixation and pass appropriate order within a period of three months from the date of receipt of certified copy of this judgment. For these reasons, the instant appeal stand disposed of.

    17. Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Managing Committee T... v. Smt. Pushpa Sharma A...
    (Mar 31, 2006)