Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges

    The State Of Karnataka By The Finance Secretary Vidhana Soudha Bangalore-1 Petitioner v. M/S. Anant Engineering Works No. 452, 4Th Cross Muneshwaranagara Subramanyapura Main Road Bangalore Rep. By The Manager

    1. The State of Karnataka is before us, aggrieved by the order of the Tribunal dated 19.01.2006 passed in STA No. 85/2004 in this revision petition.

    2. The assessee claimed deduction towards purchase value of iron and steel, consumables, gross profit and in respect of the value of iron and steel, consumables and labour, it was disallowed by the Assessing Authority. In an appeal by the assessee, the same was confirmed by the first appellate authority. The matter was taken to the Tribunal by the assessee. The Tribunal has chosen to accept the case of the assessee. It is in these circumstances, the Government is before us, challenging the order on several grounds.

    3. The following questions of law are raised by the Government for our consideration:-

    “(1) In the facts and circumstances of the case whether Appellate Tribunal was justified in allowing the claim of deduction towards purchase value of iron and steel purchased from the registered dealer used in the manufacture of finished goods and then in turn used in the execution of works contract as per Rule 6(4)(m) and (1) of the Rules and Explanation-III thereof?

    (2) In the facts and circumstances of the case whether Appellate Tribunal was justified in giving a finding that the iron and steel purchased from the registered dealer and making doors, window frames, grills etc., would not change the character of iron and steel purchased from the registered dealer?

    (3) In the facts and circumstances of the case whether erection of doors, window frames and grills etc., in the execution of the works contract is ‘in the same form’ as that of the materials i.e, iron and steel purchased from the registered dealer?”

    4. Smt. S. Sujatha, learned Additional Government Advocate would invite our attention to an order in STRP No. 34/2003 dated 12.08.2004 and she would say that a Division Bench of this Court has considered similar pleas and accepted the case of the revenue. She, therefore, says that same order may be passed in the case on hand.

    5. Per contra, Smt. Vani. H, learned Counsel for the assessee would oppose the revision petition and contend that the impugned order does not require our interference on the facte of this case.

    6. After hearing, we have carefully perused the material on record.

    7. The Tribunal has chosen to frame the following question of law at paragraph 5 of page 16, which reads as under:-

    “Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case the disallowance of the claim of deduction on the purchase of iron & steel and consumables from local registered dealers which were used in the execution of works contract of fabricated doors frame, windows and frames, grills etc., is in accordance with law?”

    8. Thereafter the Tribunal has chosen to answer the said question of the assessee in terms of the impugned order. A Division Bench of this High Court, after noticing the Judgment of the Supreme Court, reported in (1993) 88 STC 204, has chosen to consider a similar plea in STRP No. 34/2003 dated 12.08.2004 A Division Bench of this Court has ruled that iron & steel were purchased and the same were utilised for the purpose of construction of the bridge. The Division Bench also noticed that the said iron & steel purchased were used not in the same form as iron & steel but were used for the purpose of construction of a bridge. After noticing this aspect of the matter, the Division Bench would hold that liability of the dealer would squarely come under Entry No. 6 of the sixth schedule to the Act. The said order is equally applicable to the facts of the case. The Tribunal in our view, is not right in answering the question against the State in the light of the binding order of the Division Bench in STRP No. 34/2003 dated 12.08.2004 In the circumstances, despite a strong plea made by Smt. Vani.H, learned Counsel for the assessee, we are not persuaded to take a different view than that of the finding given by a Division Bench of this High Court in STRP No. 34/2003.

    9. Respectfully following the order passed in STRP No. 34/2003 dated 12.08.2004, this revision petition stands allowed. Questions of law are answered in favour of the Government and against the assessee. Ordered accordingly. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    The State Of Karnata... v. M/S. Anant Engineeri...
    (Oct 26, 2006)