Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Summary of the Judgment — N. Paul Vasanthakumar, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a writ appeal against the order of the learned single Judge in W.P. No. 6975 of 2000 dated 27.11.2001, which upheld proceedings initiated under the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling & Regulation) Act, 1978 (the Act) against the appellants.

The material facts as stated in the opinion are:

  • The third respondent originally owned two acres (S.F. No. 130/21, later renumbered S.F. No. 158/21) and converted it into house plots which were sold to various persons.
  • The first appellant purchased a plot of 5.51 cents by a document dated 11.9.1991; the second appellant (wife of the first appellant) purchased two plots (5.55 and 4.79 cents) by documents in 1994 and 1995; the third appellant (a cousin sister) purchased 5.51 cents in 1993.
  • The second respondent (authority under the Act) determined that the third respondent held 6,590 sq. metres in excess of the ceiling limit of 1,500 sq. metres and published a notification under section 11(3) vesting the excess land in the Government. The appellants' holdings (total 21.36 cents / 868.52 sq. metres) fall within that declared excess extent.
  • The appellants assert they were not given notice of the proceedings and received the impugned orders only after the sales; they rely on absence of notice under provisions including section 11(5) of the Act. Copies of an order dated 14.7.1992 under section 9(5) and a final statement dated 30.6.1996 under section 10(1) were referenced.
  • The Act was repealed by the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling & Regulation) Repeal Act, 1999 with effect from 16.9.1999; the appellants allege this repeal prevented their filing an appeal before the Commissioner of Land Reforms, thus pursuing the writ remedy.
  • The learned single Judge had dismissed the writ petition on the grounds (a) that the appellants acquired after the Act's commencement and so had no grievance as to ceiling fixation, and (b) that possession had already been taken and therefore the writ could not be entertained.
  • The instant bench examined the file, heard parties, and determined that no proof existed that the appellants (persons in possession) had been given notice under section 11(5) before taking possession on 30.4.1999; the bench concluded that non-compliance could not be rectified after repeal and therefore allowed the writ appeal, quashing the impugned orders dated 14.7.1992 and 30.6.1996 and setting aside the single Judge's order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the authorities' failure to serve the appellants (persons in possession) with notice under section 11(5) of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling & Regulation) Act, 1978 vitiates the proceedings and the taking of possession.
  2. Whether proceedings initiated and notices issued only to the third respondent (the erstwhile owner) satisfy the statutory requirement when the appellants were persons in possession and purchasers.
  3. Whether the repeal of the Act (effective 16.9.1999) precludes the authorities from remedying any non-compliance (including failure to issue notices) and whether that repeal affects the appellants' right to seek writ relief in view of the inability to file the statutory appeal.
  4. Whether the fact that the appellants purchased the plots after the Act's commencement prevents them from challenging the vesting/possession taken under the Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The appellants are purchasers and persons in possession of the specified plots and therefore are "interested persons" who should have been given notice and an opportunity to be heard under the Act, particularly section 11(5).
  • The second respondent's proceedings were initiated on the basis of statements in Form-13 from the Sub-Registrar; the officials relied on those entries and proceeded largely against the third respondent but failed to issue notices to the actual possessors (the appellants).
  • The character of the land changed only in 1992 from agricultural to vacant/house plots; prior to that it remained agricultural and so the ceiling provisions were not attracted until the stated change. Action initiated after 1992 should still have complied with the statutory notice requirements.
  • Possession was taken (the appellants assert) on 30.4.1999 after their purchases (1991–1995); non-issuance of the statutory notice vitiates the vesting of the lands in Government under section 11(5).
  • Because the Act was repealed effective 16.9.1999, the appellants could not pursue the alternate statutory appeal remedy, making writ relief maintainable.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The learned Government Advocate / Special Government Pleader submitted that possession had already been taken pursuant to the proceedings (possession recorded as taken on 30.4.1999) and that, at this stage, the writ petition could not be entertained.
  • The learned single Judge earlier recorded that the appellants purchased property after the Act came into force and therefore had no grievance regarding steps taken under the Act, because the extent of the ceiling should be fixed on commencement of the Act.
  • The respondents also relied on the fact that possession was taken before repeal, suggesting that challenge after possession may not be permissible (as argued to the Court), though the bench found no proof that the appellants had been given the required notices under section 11(5).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Vijay Foundation (P) Ltd. v. The Principal Commissioner and Commissioner of Land Reforms, 2006 (5) CTC 52 = 2006 4 L.W. 159 Where acquisition/vesting proceedings were initiated against a person who was not the owner or the real person in possession, and mandatory statutory conditions (Sections 7 to 12) were not followed, the possession taken is vitiated; proceedings initiated against the wrong person cannot validly result in acquisition/vesting. The court cited and expressly agreed with this decision, using it to reinforce the conclusion that proceedings initiated against the third respondent (not the actual possessors) and the consequent possession are vitiated for failure to comply with mandatory statutory requirements, supporting quashing of the impugned orders.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's reasoning proceeded as follows:

  1. Examination of the file showed that proceedings under the Act were initiated against the third respondent, the erstwhile owner, but the appellants were purchasers and in possession of the plots at the relevant times.
  2. Section 11(5) of the Act imposes a mandatory duty on the competent authority to issue a written notice to any person who may be in possession of land vested in the State under subsection (3), ordering surrender or delivery of possession within thirty days of service of the notice. The opinion reproduces section 11(5) and treats it as a mandatory compliance requirement.
  3. The court found no proof in the record that any notice under section 11(5) was issued to the appellants before taking possession on 30.4.1999. Although a section 11(5) notice was issued to the third respondent, he was not the real owner/possessor of the affected plots at the time.
  4. Following the principle in Vijay Foundation (P) Ltd. (cited by the court), proceedings initiated against the wrong person and without fulfillment of mandatory statutory conditions vitiate the acquisition/vesting and the taking of possession is invalid.
  5. The court observed that because the Act was repealed effective 16.9.1999, the authorities cannot now proceed to rectify the earlier non-compliance (for instance, by reissuing notices or redoing statutory steps), and therefore the non-compliance stands as a fatal flaw.
  6. Finally, the court accepted that the appellants could not pursue an appeal under section 33 of the Act because of the repeal, which made the writ petition a maintainable remedy in the circumstances.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The writ appeal is allowed. The order of the learned single Judge dated 27.11.2001 in W.P. No. 6975 of 2000 is set aside. The impugned orders of the second respondent dated 14.7.1992 and 30.6.1996 are quashed. No costs. Connected miscellaneous petition closed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The orders vesting the specified excess land (as declared in the impugned notifications) in the Government (dated 14.7.1992 and 30.6.1996) have been quashed, restoring relief to the appellants as against those impugned actions.
  • The court relied on precedent to hold that non-compliance with mandatory notice requirements to persons in possession vitiates the proceedings and the taking of possession.
  • The court did not purport to lay down a novel legal principle beyond applying existing precedent; the decision's consequence is to invalidate the specific impugned actions for failure to comply with the statutory notice requirement and because the Act's repeal prevents corrective action by the authorities. The opinion does not announce any broader new precedent beyond its application of cited case law.

If additional procedural documents or arguments were referenced in the full file, they were not reproduced in the opinion and therefore are not summarized here.

    V. Somasundaram v. Nityakalyani 3. V. Sugandhi

    Judgment — N. Paul Vasanthakumar, J.

    This writ appeal is directed against the order passed by the learned single Judge in W.P No. 6975 of 2000 dated 27.11.2001 in and by which the proceedings under the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling & Regulation) Act, 1978, initiated against the appellants were upheld.

    2. The brief facts necessary for disposal of the writ appeal are as follows,

    (a) The third respondent, who owns two acres of dry land in S.F No. 130/21 at Piratiyur village, Srirangam Taluk, converted the said land into house plots and sold the same. The first appellant purchased a plot measuring 5.51 cents as per document No. 4235/1991 dated 11.9.1991 The second appellant, who is the wife of the first appellant, purchased two plots one measuring 5.55 cents and another 4.79 cents from the third respondent as per the document Nos. 4310/94 and 768/95. The first appellant's cousin sister, the third appellant herein also purchased one plot measuring 5.51 cents under document No. 573/1993. All the four plots situate in S.F No. 130/21 of Piratiyur Village and the same has been later on renumbered as S.F No. 158/21 in the updating survey.

    (b) The case of the appellants is that when they have taken steps to put up live fencing around the plots, the Village Administrative Officer (Thalayari) of the village informed that the officials from the Srirangam Taluk Office came to the land and took measurement of the lands owned by the third respondent, two to three months ago. Thereafter the first appellant contacted the third respondent, who in turn informed that the second respondent had initiated proceedings on the land under the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling & Regulation) Act, 1978 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’) and handed over the copy of the order dated 14.7.1992 under section 9(5) of the Act and the final statement dated 30.6.1996 issued under section 10(1) of the Act.

    (c) Thereafter the first appellant enquired in the office of the second respondent and came to know that after determining a fact that the third respondent was holding vacant land to the extent of 6590 sq.mtrs in excess over the Ceiling limit of 1500 sq.mtrs, had passed orders and issued notification under section 11(3) of the Act, published in the Tamil Nadu Government Gazettee, vesting the excess land with the Government. The appellants' land measuring 21.36 cents falls within the said extent of 6590 sq.mtrs of land declared as excess by the second respondent, which was previously owned by the third respondent.

    (d) The case of the appellants is that they were not informed of this proceedings at any point of time either by the second respondent or by the third respondent and the impugned orders have been sent only to the third respondent and not to the appellants. It is further stated in the affidavit that the second respondent in his order dated 14.7.1992 stated that he had initiated proceedings under the Act only on the basis of the statement he received from the Sub-Registrar in Form-13 under section 27(1) of the Act read with Rule 19 of the Rules framed under the Act in respect of the lands sold by the third respondent to the appellants and others. Therefore it is contended that the second respondent, who is fully aware of the appellants landholds in S.F No. 130/21 has failed to issue notices to the appellants.

    (e) It is the further case of the appellant that the second respondent had issued the final statement under section 10(1) of the Act, determining the extent of vacant land held by the third respondent in excess of the ceiling limit only on 30.6.1996, that is after the purchase of the lands by the appellants in the years 1991, 1993, 1994 and 1995. The appellants are interested persons over an extent of 868.52 sq.mtrs of land in S.F No. 130/21 (new No. 15 8/21) in terms of ownership and possession. However, no notice was issued by the second respondent before taking over the said lands owned by the appellant and no opportunity was given to them and therefore the impugned orders are in violation of the principles of natural justice, particularly section 11(5) of the Act.

    (f) It is also stated by the appellants that the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling & Regulation) Act, 1978, was repealed with effect from 16.9.1999 by enacting the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling & Regulation) Repeal Act, 1999 (Act 20 of 1999) by the Government of Tamil Nadu and therefore the appellants were unable to prefer appeal before the Commissioner of Land Reforms.

    3. Even though the writ petition was admitted as early as on 3.6.2002, no counter affidavit was filed by the respondents.

    4. The learned single Judge dismissed the writ petition on two grounds. Firstly, the appellants purchased the property only after the Act came into force and therefore they cannot have any grievance with reference to the steps taken by the authorities under the Act as the extent of the ceiling should be fixed on commencement of the Act. The second reason stated for dismissing the writ petition was that the learned Government Advocate on instructions submitted that the possession has already been taken pursuant to the proceedings taken against the land owners and therefore at this stage the writ petition cannot be entertained.

    5. The learned counsel for the appellants argued that the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling & Regulation) Act, 1978, came into force on 3.8.1978 and as per section 3(p) of the Act, ‘vacant land’ is defined as the lands, which would not include agricultural land and as per section 3(o) and 3(c)(iii) read with Section 7, Ceiling Act would get attracted if they were ‘vacant land’ at the commencement of the Act i.e, 3.8.1978 or from the time of the land became vacant, ceasing to be agricultural land. The learned counsel further argued that insofar as the appellants' lands are concerned, it were continued to be agricultural lands before and after the commencement of the Act, that is, from 3.8.1978 till 1992 and therefore the provisions of the Act are not attracted and that is why from 1978 no action was initiated by the second respondent against the third respondent. Learned counsel further argued that the character of the land having been changed only in the year 1992, the second respondent initiated action against the third respondent and issued draft statement under section 9(1) and issued notice for enquiry under section 9(4) of the Act and called for objection, if any. Since the third respondent sold out the land, he did not respond and therefore the second respondent treated the third respondent as ex-parte and proceeded further and issued order dated 14.7.1992 under section 9(5) of the Act stating that the third respondent was holding excess lands than the ceiling limits and after four years on 30.6.1996 final notification under section 11(3) of the Act was published in the Tamil Nadu Government Gazettee, thereby vesting the excess lands to the Government.

    6. The main contention urged by the learned counsel for the appellants is that the appellants are interested persons as they have purchased the lands from the third respondent and are in possession of their respective extent of land and hence the second respondent ought to have issued notice to the appellants, who are the real owners and therefore the action of the respondents are in violation of sections 9(4), 10(1) and 11(2) of the Act. The learned counsel ultimately argued that the vesting of the lands in question with the Government cannot be accepted in view of the non-compliance of the specific provisions contained in section 11(5) of the Act, which reads as follows,

    “Section 11 (5) Where any vacant land is vested in the State Government under sub-section (3), the competent authority may, by notice in writing, order any person who may be in possession of it to surrender or deliver possession thereof to the State Government or to any person duly authorised by the State Government in this behalf within thirty days of the service of the notice.”

    Citing the said provision of the Act, the learned counsel argued that even according to the respondents, possession was taken only on 30.4.1999 i.e, long after purchase of the land by the appellants from 1991 to 1995 and nonissuance of the notice to the appellants vitiates the entire proceedings of vesting of lands with the Government.

    7. Heard the learned Special Government Pleader for the respondents 1 and 2, who also produced the entire file and submitted that the possession was taken on 30.4.1999 We have perused the file and we find that there is no proof that notice was given to the appellants before taking possession under section 11(5) of the Act. The learned Special Government Pleader submitted that the possession having been taken before the repeal of the Act, the appellants are not entitled to challenge the orders of the respondents.

    8. We have considered the rival contentions of the learned counsel for the appellants as well as the learned Special Government Pleader for the respondents 1 and 2.

    9. From the perusal of the file it is clear that proceedings were initiated against the third respondent, who is the erstwhile owner of the lands in question, in respect of transfer of his land to the appellants herein. Section 11(5) notice was also issued to the third respondent, who was not the real owner. As per section 11(5) of the Act, the competent authority is bound to issue notice in writing to any person, who may be in possession of the land, to surrender and delivery possession thereof, to the State Government or to any person duly authorised by the State Government, within thirty days time. No notice having been issued against the appellants, who are in possession of the lands as stated supra, taking possession of lands on 30.4.1999 by the second respondent is non-est. It is to be noted that due to the repealing of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling & Regulation) Act, 1978, with effect from 16.9.1999, it is not open to the authorities to proceed against the appellants at this stage to rectify the non-compliance of section 11(5) of the Act.

    10. Similar issue was considered by a learned single Judge of this Court (A. Kulasekaran, J.) in the decision reported in 2006 (5) CTC 52 = 2006 4 L.W 159 (Vijay Foundation (P) Ltd. v. The Principal Commissioner and Commissioner of Land Reforms) and in para 7 the learned Judge held as follows,

    “7. The respondents herein have initiated acquisition proceedings against the person who is not at all owner of the lands. The above quoted mandatory conditions mentioned in Section 7 to 12 were not followed by the respondents. The statutory conditions for the purpose of acquiring the lands has not been followed at all in this case, hence, the alleged possession taken by the respondents is vitiated. The Ceiling Act is not like Land Acquisition Proceedings where the authorities are required to serve notice upon the owner or occupier of the land and on such person known or believed to be interested thereon to show cause within 30 days from the date of service of notice as to why the lands should not be acquired, hence, based on the entries in the mutation proceedings, the opportunity be given to the owner or occupier or person interested in the land be sufficient because the Notification specifies the intention of the Government to acquire the land for public purpose, which is mandatory. So, the defence that mutation proceedings contain only name of Krishnan, hence, the proceedings were not initiated against the petitioner is not a valid ground. Based on the proceedings initiated against the wrong person, the lands of the petitioner cannot be acquired by the respondents.”

    We are in entire agreement with the said decision of the learned Judge.

    11. As rightly contended by the learned counsel for the appellants, the appellants were not entitled to file appeal due to enactment of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling & Regulation) Repeal Act, 1999, from 16.9.1999 Hence the writ petition filed without availing the alternate remedy of filing appeal under section 33 of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling & Regulation) Act, 1978, is maintainable.

    12. In view of our above finding, the writ appeal is allowed. The order of the learned single Judge dated 27.1 1.2001 in W.P No. 6975 of 2000 is set aside. Consequently, the impugned orders of the second respondent dated 14.7.1992 and 30.6.1996 are quashed. No costs. Connected miscellaneous petition is closed.

    VCJ/VCS

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    V. Somasundaram v. Nityakalyani 3. V. Sugandhi
    (Jan 12, 2007)