The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
Pratap Kumar Ray, J.:— Heard the learned advocate appearing for the applicant of this contempt application.
2. On perusal of the application it appears that in the cause title and in the prayer portion there is no identification detailing the contemptu ous act and conduct of the respective alleged contemners who are three in numbers herein. Contempt proceeding is a quasi criminal proceeding in view of the reason that order directing imprisonment to jail and/or fine could be imposed to the alleged contemners on finding him guilty of the charges. Reliance is placed to the judgment passed in the case Mrityunjoy Das v. Sayed Hasibur Rahaman,1 wherein on issue of burden of proof in contempt proceeding and degree of proof, the Court relied upon the observation of Lord Denning in paragraph 14, which reads such:
“The common English phrase “he who asserts must prove” has its due application in the matter of proof of the allegations said to be constituting the act of contempt. As regard “standard of proof”, as it is a proceeding under the extraordinary jurisdiction of the Court in terms of the provisions of the Contempt of Courts Act is quasi-criminal, and as such, the standard of proof required is that of a criminal proceeding and the breach shall have to be established beyond reasonable doubt.”
3. In the case Re Bramblevale Limited,2 the Court held to this effect: “A Contempt of Court is an offence of a criminal character. A man may be sent to prison for it must be proved “beyond reasonable doubt”. The Calcutta High Court Contempt of Courts Rules, 1975 framed by the High Court of Calcutta in exercise of the powers conferred by section 23 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 by Article 215 of the Constitution of India. In Rule 4 it is provided that in the cause title, the particular contemptuous act and conduct must be mentioned identifying the individual action of the alleged contemners to that effect and in Rule 7 it is stipulated that in the prayer portion, the contemptuous conduct distinctly to be stated for which rule is prayed for. Rules 4 and 7 of the said Rule aforesaid reads such:
“Rule 4.—Every petition and affidavit in connection therewith (suitably modified where necessary) shall be entitled:
In the matter of Contempt of Court
In the matter of (state briefly the nature of contumacious conduct complained of)
In the matter of (state the name and other particulars required as in a plaint, of the petitioner and each of the petitioners)-Petitioner
Versus
(State the name and other particulars required, as in a plaint, of the respondent or each of the respondents)-Respondents.
Rule 7.—The prayer to the petition shall distinctly state the particular contumacious conduct alleged for which the rule is prayed for.”
4. Besides such, in the pleading also it requires to be categorized. The object of the aforesaid rule having a jurisdictional concept to this ef fect that in a contempt proceeding as it is a quasi-criminal proceeding, the alleged contemners should know the specific charge as levelled against him for his proper defence, if any.
5. In the instant case it appears that in the prayer portion as well as in the cause title there is no identification of the particular contemptuous conduct by the respective individual alleged contemners therein, but a general statement has been made that concerned alleged contemners violative the Court's order, which is not sufficient to frame a charge against the alleged contemners, which the Court will take cognizance by issuing a rule or directing them to file respective opposition.
6. Beside such, natural justice principle mandates that a person must know the allegation as made against him with specific foundation.
7. In that view of the matter, we have no other alternative but to reject this contempt application as it has not identified the alleged contemptuous act and conduct of the respective alleged contemners by specifying the same in the manner aforesaid.
8. Already on the aforesaid point one of us (Pratap Kumar Ray, J.) sitting singly passed a judgment in the case Sri Sheoram v. Sri Bho???der Singh.
9. Application is rejected accordingly. However, rejection of this application will not debar the applicant to move afresh. Xerox plain copy of this order duly countersigned by the Assistant Registrar (Court be given to the learned advocates appearing for the parties on usual undertakings.
Tapas Kumar Giri, J.:— I agree.
10. Application Rejected.